Separated At Birth

Filed under: Separated At Birth > Mariah Carey > Celine Dion

Left: the cover of Mariah Carey's 1995 Fantasy single. Right: the cover of Celine Dion's new album, out in November.

Posted: Aug 31, 2007 at 6:41 pm / Email this »

See All 170 Comments

170 comments to “Separated At Birth”

More comments: [1] 2 »

P1ll says – reply to this

1

they are running out of ideas
ana l. says – reply to this

2

soooo creative.
pffft.
Eric Kane says – reply to this

3

Perez, you'll find there is very little truly original things in hollywood anymore. You could take countless pics and do the same thing, who give a shit.
HH says – reply to this

4

was I 1st??!..or at least in the top 10??!
amanda says – reply to this

5

4th
amanda says – reply to this

6

6th?
vag says – reply to this

7

FIRST and gross
amanda says – reply to this

8

4th?
Joanna [Poland] says – reply to this

9

HAHA! ALMOST THE SAME PIC!
Daniel John Hardy. says – reply to this

10

WOW. THATS AMAZING.
it wasn't even a hot cover to begin with!
mach says – reply to this

11

Don't forget that they both are copying a Calvin Klein ad that Brooke Shields did in the early 80's!!!!!
Steven Thomsin says – reply to this

12

whoa
Collin says – reply to this

13

Wayyy lame
commentkiller says – reply to this

14

Twin Mimi
Jessica says – reply to this

15

Celine Dion looks WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY Better!!!!
dfhfg says – reply to this

16

MARIAH RULES!!!!
linder says – reply to this

17

ohhh 4….not so bad…..smae old ass stylist working with her….ughh
LOL says – reply to this

18

who give a shit hahahahaha
Mariah Fan says – reply to this

19

I think Celine's album will bomb big time. She only knows how to sing ballads, and on this album she worked with Timbaland on more up-tempo songs. She should just stick to what she is good at.
PEREZHASISSUES says – reply to this

20

I BET IF THIS WAS BEYONCE SHE WAS BE A COPY CAT, BUT B/C IT CELINE ITS OK!!! INTERESTING
UKer says – reply to this

21

sweetie none of us care about these two hasbeens.
commentkiller says – reply to this

22

is that an old Mimi look alike
lemyou says – reply to this

23

haha
ramona says – reply to this

24

how sad, you would think she could pick some classier to copycat. How about a Britney topless strangulating myself pose
Christine says – reply to this

25

Really freakin original. That's one ugly woman!
Daisy says – reply to this

26

If they photoshopped Celine Dion any more, she would disappear. Hmmmm. On second thought, not a bad idea….
St.F says – reply to this

27

I prefer Mariah!
Celinealicious says – reply to this

28

My pants are bigger, loser!!!
Olga says – reply to this

29

Mariah Fan - You obviously have no clue what you are talking about if you say Celine can only sing ballads. Get your head out of your ass and if you are going to make statements, make sure that they are based in reality.
maral says – reply to this

30

geez, i didnt realise how skinny and hawt mariah used 2 be!!
olga says – reply to this

31

And for the rest of you, why are there so many haters out there? People love to talk shit. How many of you have done a tenth of what Celine has done for charity? Get out there and do something productive with your lives instead of just trying to trash other people!
Sherry says – reply to this

32

No matter how much they photoshop, Celine Dion still looks ugly.
bmazz says – reply to this

33

Thats spot the hell on. Silly canadian.
marjan says – reply to this

34

its funny. mariah looks 100 times better though. celine looks crazy. and you can hardly see her damn face!! i cant wait for the mimi album though. that should be amazing.
V Head says – reply to this

35

I love Celine but she needs to get the F real.. I buy every one of her CD's.. but I may skip on this shit.. burrr
Matt says – reply to this

36

There's a new Sarah Silverman ad for GAP that looks almost identical too. Google it.
jaded says – reply to this

37

so true…aww celine what happened? i luv her so much….but this is so wrong….
u rock p-nasty! belize luvs ya! smooches from jul and migz….p.s. migz thinks ur hott!!!!!!!!
lily says – reply to this

38

Not only the cover for the sigle but the cover of the DAYDREAM album Perez!! Mariah's better!!!
Kathleen says – reply to this

39

Holy Shit! I thought Celine was Shakira!

She's the best selling female artist of all time. Whoever said she will bomb, check your facts. Not only that, she just broke records in Vegas these past few years. Looking forward to it!
Leilani says – reply to this

40

YESSSS! Thanks for noticing that Perez
Tiff says – reply to this

41

Its becos they were both managed by tommy mottola
CELINE DION says – reply to this

42

BRITNEY WHO? (stick to being a trainwreck, bitch!)
Thank the rappers and the producers expertise with Pro Tools… otherwise all you'd have left is a croaking, whining Britney. Millions can buy you anything people… anything except a music career for K-Fed… he's so completely devoid of talentl even her dough couldn't help him. ahh-ha-haaa!!!
celestial says – reply to this

43

Haha, Mimi is the hottest betch everrrrrrr!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I hope Celine didn't pay someone too much to direct that photo shoot, cuz it's so unbelievably been done before!!!
Canberry says – reply to this

44

Celine is more sexy than Whoriah Scarey! End of the story.
ldk says – reply to this

45

what is growing on celine's head?
PerezEATSshit! says – reply to this

46

Fat pez in a good for nothing morbidly obese pig/clown! I hope you overdose on all that shit you like to eat and drop dead!!!
jess says – reply to this

47

It didn't look so great the first time.
philipppineslovemariahcarey says – reply to this

48

Celine dion said to her record label, "lets copy mariah carey's fantasy album cover so that people will mistaken bought my album intead of hers, they might tought thats its mariah's but its mine, coz my sales of album tracks is poor not like mariah's album". CELION DION DIFFINITELY LOOKING UPTO MARIAH CAREYS TRACKS SO THAT SHE CAN BE SUCCESSFUL AS MARIAH DOES.
ck says – reply to this

49

Who cares? Both bitches swiped it from 'Mama Said' by Lenny Kravitz.
mimifan says – reply to this

50

mariah is a bad bitch! just the fact that people can remember this album cover from 12 years ago is proof of how fucking awesome she is. stop hating on my girl mimi
hthahff says – reply to this

51

FIRST

ha
4dbling says – reply to this

52

i love you perez i want to do you

www.myspace.com/4dbling

check out my music
SpadeAShovel. says – reply to this

53

Mariah put on a few.
They both sing like canaries.
Whoreanus says – reply to this

54

Mariah > Celine
Carissa says – reply to this

55

How Unoriginal! and please don't insult Mrs. SJP by saying that this hot mess looks like her. Diva my ass you couldn't pay me to watch her or listen to her lol
;ldfad says – reply to this

56

this is for comments not what fucking order you commented in no one fucking cares what number you are leave a comment or nothingg !!!!!!
Allan says – reply to this

57

Celine is such a has-been. And in all honestly I've always thought she's been slightly mentally retarded. Like any time I've seen her on tv or something, she seems not to be playing with a full deck of cards. But maybe that's how all Canadians are. I don't know.
Monkey Turd a.k.a. Perez The Turdster says – reply to this

58

Damn. That shit is hilarious!!!! Still it's not as good as the Britney and Chyna separated at birth. That shit had me crying.
Speaking of tears, I smell a turd. Is that you Perez?
bruno oliveira says – reply to this

59

I DONT CARE
i love celine…
i love mariah…

but i hate the designer…
the cover is beautiful really
but he/she didnt check the past cover arts…
hahah

BUT I LOVED ANYWAY
the princess says – reply to this

60

whats rong with celine's hair PLZ tell me its not her new style or something.eww.anyway i really like celine's music better than mariah's but i garra admit that mariah look better, and she woold look much better if she were warring the clothes that celine is warring now.YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY THEY ARE SO ALIKE.THAT IS JUST SILLY.
Angie From Chicago says – reply to this

61

THEIF!!!! No really……its just a black shirt and pants, its hard to end up with the same damn thing. I mean what's so original about artists with their faces taking up a whole album or them sitting down with their best side forward, its whatever
jj says – reply to this

62

yuck. who would copy fuckin' mariah carey?
GetRealJobs says – reply to this

63

LA has SOOO many losers that they are trying to keep rich, they just keep recycling movies and music…..and obviously album covers too.

Nuke LA.
v says – reply to this

64

How can you say anything BAD about Celine????? Let's look at the 'values'!
Fearless says – reply to this

65

#61 Allan - no, we only had a few retards in the whole country and they are now AMERICAN citizens! You poor saps.
Yup. says – reply to this

66

Celine > Mariah.
Canadian. says – reply to this

67

Allan - No. It's that she's from Quebec, plus there's a cultural gap that doesn't translate well verbally from french to english speaking. Plus she is a different bird. Artistic and eccentric. If all Canadians were like that, I'd move.
crystal says – reply to this

68

eh- i think theyre both hot. funny, tho
ben says – reply to this

69

#60 not all!! just most!
astro says – reply to this

70

bwahahaha, that woman is just a f**** copy cat
mariah says – reply to this

71

hola MARIAH and CELINE are both great, though I prefer MARIAH CAREEEEY YAAALL
Angela Marie says – reply to this

72

i guess there are only so many "looks" that work
Silverdude says – reply to this

73

Or Sarah Silverman in her new ads?
I never liked her. says – reply to this

74

She is such a fake. Remember when she had her babies and she dramatically said "I'm going to stay home and take care of my babies". Yeah, that lasted about a year. She's a phoney baloney. Oh! and remember when she was sympathized with the Katrina looters? Yeah, we should have invited them to her home. What a hypocrite.
JT says – reply to this

75

Celine Dion is looking loverly with her big hair! i love it Hunny!!!
mikemuscles21 in Winnipeg says – reply to this

76

Well, Celine Dion may not be original but she does it better. Ashamed to say that as a gay guy, I never really liked her music although I wish the best for her. The only song I like was one of her first songs that she did in French and I also liked one english song, "Candle in the Water". She is great, but just not for me.
Australia says – reply to this

77

GO CELINE !!!
Rajan says – reply to this

78

She looks like Kelly Clarkson from her first return to American Idol when she sang "Miss Independant"
brenda says – reply to this

79

#19 Safetoy
I just want to thank you, that IS a very important matter. Make sure your kids toys are safe / Brenda
ONT I love Celines pants , the suit is fantastic! But still booring copycat!
Britney..b***ch! says – reply to this

80

Celine looks diva-ier than Mariah!
Unkown says – reply to this

81

Even Celine is inspired by mariah!!! Tat proves who is the greatest of all.
DEAR PEREZ READ THIS says – reply to this

82

GO TO NOWLIVE.COM Adrianne Curry show and there is a REPLAY of her show from AUGUST 30th.

Perez you have to report on this!! Adrianne Curry wants to hire a maid and bitches about how all the candidates thus far were hispanics, she mocks their accent and continues to bash Mexicans, particularly illegals.

Very bigotted comments. Who knew Peter Brady married a racist?!

How does this stoner get away with this shiz?????
READ THIS says – reply to this

83

Why does Adrianne Curry racist against Mexicans? Listen to her show on nowlive and hear for yourself. August 30th show replaying right now.
DRB says – reply to this

84

Most of you are such hypocrites. If it looked like Mariah was copying most of you would be calling her every name in the book b/c you are set on hating her for no reason. But since it isn't Mariah copying, you change the subject
svet says – reply to this

85

uuuughhhhhhhh! i'm going to hang myself, celine is the pitts.
adriana says – reply to this

86

mariah's cover is 100 times better
celine is a fucken biter
her comeback will not be as great as mariah's
Hollaback says – reply to this

87

Celene Dion's face looks like it got slammed between her husbands ass cheeks. ANd what the fuck is with her hair? If I have to hear another one of those sappy ass Titianic like crap songs from her again on the radio, Im gonna fucking hurl.
ECO says – reply to this

88

Also looks like that Calvin Klein ad with Brook Shields from the 80's.
emmerson says – reply to this

89

HAHAH dope
Rochelle says – reply to this

90

I knew I seen some thing like that before… when I saw the Celine album first…It felt like deja-vu. Now I see why!
aj80 says – reply to this

91

@ least Mariah didn't marry her grandpa.lol
Michelle says – reply to this

92

It's pretty much the same picture only Celine looks freakishly weird.
LovesIt says – reply to this

93

Bonjour! I am zee greatest singer in zee world!
Now, I would like you to meet my father, I mean my husband, Rene!
Jason says – reply to this

94

Mariah's cover is waaaaay better….
maemae says – reply to this

95

that cover of celine looks like the same cover as chritina aguilera stripped
danni says – reply to this

96

i don't even care!! Celine Dion is fabulous and looks amazing for her age! Not to mention she's not a lunatic like ms. mariah! She's a crazy bitch. I mean who gets in the bathtub with lingerie on. Seriously people!
cake says – reply to this

97

Mariah looked so much better without the fake boobs and fake hair and the whole fake Mimi thing…
Celine always looks weird in an alien kind of way. Is she a Scientologist or what.?
Gwen says – reply to this

98

I hate both of these bitches. Celine makes me embarrassed to be Canadian… wish that bitch had never touched Roy Orbison/Cyndi Lauper's I Drove All Night. God, what a mess that was!
jogaagora says – reply to this

99

We like Celine's version better, but what's with the title? She better be taking chances with this CD, otherwise she'll start becoming a has been with a great voice and large fan base.
Turtle says – reply to this

100

One of Mariah's best songs.

More comments: [1] 2 »

Britney Spears & Demi Lovato's First X Factor Critique! Listen Here!

Girls are on fire!!!

We won't get to see how the ladies did until the fall, but today in Austin, Britney Spears and Demi Lovato took their seats as the new judges on The X Factor. Someone had the foresight of smuggling in a recording device to the Texas auditions and we've got the audio from the ladies' first critique!

And you know what? They sound like old pros!

Check out the video (above) to hear Brit Brit and Darling Demi give their thoughts on the first contestant of season two!

They both sound so GOOD! Strong and confident; it doesn't sound like either of them were nervous at all!

Bravo, ladies! We can't wait to see you in action!

Advertising info