Separated At Birth

Filed under: Separated At Birth > Mariah Carey > Celine Dion

Left: the cover of Mariah Carey's 1995 Fantasy single. Right: the cover of Celine Dion's new album, out in November.

Posted: Aug 31, 2007 at 6:41 pm / Email this »

See All 170 Comments

170 comments to “Separated At Birth”

More comments: « 1 [2]

hayden55 says – reply to this

101

mariah does it better. and the songs from fantasy are also better
jimmy says – reply to this

102

Celine is way better than that slut!
wats up says – reply to this

103

LOOKS ALOT LIKE AN OLD CHRISTINA AGUERILA POSE ON THE COVER OF HER STRIPPED ALBUM
anna says – reply to this

104

Celine's the best!
jbonz says – reply to this

105

Celine Dion is horrible. How did that horse-faced sadsack ever come to be thought of as a great chanteuse?
LauraLuvsMariah says – reply to this

106

Mariah's looks w—-ay better… Nice Try Celine's People….
whitney says – reply to this

107

at least Celine can sing live! Mariah on the other hand is constantly lipsynching!
Chris says – reply to this

108

Maybe Celine's problem stems to the fact that when she was little she had all those ear infections and all the towns people called her stupid little retarded girl. Maybe she does have a slight case of mental retardation. She looks like a transexual on this cover. OH and she's even trying to copy Janet with this photo, that right boob is about to pop out. Can somebody say wardrobe malfunction? Next celine will be wearing bandannas and getting out of her car panty-less at Britney's next kegger.
fags says – reply to this

109

mariah is way better
kyle says – reply to this

110

the only thing mariah is better at is lipsynching! Celine's way better!
Jey says – reply to this

111

it's fantasy style from the neck down, and it's one of mariah's later albums with the big hair later for the neck up. it's different for celine though, so i guess that's some credit there.
Jackkk says – reply to this

112

Who honestly cares about the album cover?

They're both incredible artists with amazing voices.

Long live the divas!
camille says – reply to this

113

the first one sucked & the second one sucks even more for copying something that was bullshit to begin with.
MARIA'S COVER IS TIMELESS AND CELINE LOOKS LIKE SHES TRYING TO TAKE A SHIZ IN HER DEPENDS!!!! says – reply to this

114

AND SHE NEEDS TO TAKE THAT DEAD BUFFALO OFF HER HEAD
winnie says – reply to this

115

Celine's so much classier than that lipsynching fraud! Celine's the best!
CARLA says – reply to this

116

I called it to myself that Celeine was looking like mariah, but atleast these two have talent
Ale says – reply to this

117

Who is mariah?
lexi says – reply to this

118

maybe she's payin homage to the comback queen
walla says – reply to this

119

Did I miss something? Are the 80's coming back?? I knew I shouldn't have gotten rid of my slutty disco clothes.
GardenMimine says – reply to this

120

Celine gets lost in translation. Even though she speaks decent English, she is French Canadian and tends to do word to word translation of French so, I admit, she does sound bizarre sometimes BUT she is the sweetest ever human being you could ever meet…and as mentioned before, a giving loving person who never forgot where she came from. No temper tantrums, no drugs, no sleeping around and, she not only did ballads, in the 90's, her first English album was definitely dance. The song Unisson was a dance floor hit. As for looks, well, let's say she makes the best of what she got. Je t'aime Céline et bonne chance!
MIKE says – reply to this

121

CELINE IS WAAAYYYY BETTER THAN THIS SLUT !! Celine IS a Diva even she's inspired by the others…..40 years old! C'mon she looks great
Mariah SUCKS
Boyblackuk says – reply to this

122

Celine Looks 100 times sexier.

For those of you that dont know, gone are the big ballads and this album is going to be more rock orientated like her french albums, check out the french albums before you comment…they are very credible and fantastic
Ash says – reply to this

123

Wow that's awful.
Maylee says – reply to this

124

Celine Dion took a chance on copying on Mariah's album and tries not to be sued. Nice job ^^”
Laila says – reply to this

125

love me some celine dion….but seriously?? ridiculous! Id pitch a fit to change it if I were her
Juju bunny says – reply to this

126

Celine doesn't have tits&ass or it would maybe look 1/2 as good as mariah's in the first place.
toni says – reply to this

127

Soo…where are all of your snotty comments about Celine Dion…you know…the kind you can't wait to make about Beyonce???? I Celine's not brown enough for you to hate on her.
J says – reply to this

128

#34 she's no longer Canadian u can have her
pedro says – reply to this

129

mariah has a more beautifull voice and is far prettier. celines also has an amazing voice but i prefer mariahs.
miss michele says – reply to this

130

Seperated at birth, perhaps. However Celine makes her crazy sound so much more interesting with a Pepe Le Pew accent.
nikki says – reply to this

131

wow very origanal………………………………
Wesley Angel Dion says – reply to this

132

CELINE ESTA PERFEITA…e ela voltou arrasando!!!!
J-P says – reply to this

133

oh, mc has done this like 12 years ago!! hello!! mc is so head of time!!!
memememe says – reply to this

134

thats exactly what i was thinking when celines cover photo was first posted..
looks just like mariah carey's. where's everyones creativity? jeez, shes rich enough, hire someone to be creative!
lattygirl says – reply to this

135

jeez, she's the walking dead.
LaBreea says – reply to this

136

yea celine dion is way way way tp pale
LaBreea says – reply to this

137

yea celine dion is way way way to pale
michael says – reply to this

138

mariah is better
QueenCarey says – reply to this

139

MIMI: OFTEN IMITATED, NEVER DUPLICATED.
Matt says – reply to this

140

Mariah has sold more records than Celine. And Celine lipcyncs, too.

She has a decent voice, but she is boring as hell. Mariah's voice has layers, and texture. So, I prefer hers.
Jayson says – reply to this

141

I think it's ironic that her album title is called "Taking Chances" when the cover shot is blatantly copied. LOL. Anyway, Celine can only pray that her next album will garner the critical acclaim and success of Mariah's Daydream.
sara-canadian says – reply to this

142

I love Celine's figure, hair and suit!

I also like her songs; I'll be happy to add this album to my CD rack. There's no question about it having massive sales. The video airplay here in Canada alone will be pretty much eternal!
Mimi says – reply to this

143

It is pretty dam obvious that the new Celine's album cover looks like Mariah's 1990's day dream cover the black shirt black pants Mariah pulled the look over better.
lefty says – reply to this

144

That can't be Mariah she has too many clothes on…
Pauline says – reply to this

145

Yay Mariah!!! Love.
Celine, respect for her - I'll comment when I hear the music.
Jared says – reply to this

146

Celine is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much better then Mariah Scarey! Sexy Momma!
FO says – reply to this

147

Mariah looks way more BETTER!!!!!
AMN says – reply to this

148

Leave Celine alone unless you can sing like she can. Although I am not so sure about this new album…
jpm3 says – reply to this

149

someone fucked with celine- and got her good. the 1995 mariah cover was HUGE, everyone has seen it. the similarities are so similar that its almost impossible for that not to have been done on purpose. SOMEone in celines camp has HAD to have noticed that|(and failed to point it to celine) before the photo made the cover. i feel bad for celine. that was a total set up. she probably fucked over her art director now this is what he has done. good bitch! at least he a good job. mariah rules.
jpm3 says – reply to this

150

im beside myself noticing that celine put more tittie in it.
sam says – reply to this

151

that was maybe mariah's best albums. why shouldn't celine take inspiration from it. ps…both look hot in a black suit wooooooohhhoooo
Holli says – reply to this

152

I have a separated at birth for ya! Christian Bale and Adam Levine. Am I the only person that has ever thought this?
not that old says – reply to this

153

omg mimoo!! lookit that! talk about extreme photoshopping! geesus.
fawaz says – reply to this

154

MARIAH CAREY ,,,LOVER HER SOO MUCh ..EVERYBODY is COPYING Miss Mariah ..But at the END ..MY MARIAH ALWAYS WIN …Cant wait for New ALBUM ..:)
Colby says – reply to this

155

OMG….Celine Scared me so much…
MARIAH definitely has more class and originality than her.
Doug says – reply to this

156

Celine Dion is the best selling female artist of all time. There's not question of that. She also is one of the biggest artists of all time - this was further demonstrated by the fact that she had the MOST consecutive sold-out concerts ever. She's a mega star. And while Mariah is good, she's not in the same league. Personally, I have been waiting for this CD for years now. I can't wait.
rocco says – reply to this

157

omg, i can't take that biaatch… she's fugly.
i mean, i don't wanna say she's a bad human beeing. not personally. but for the image of her, the star-persona, the "music" and the appearence.. i hate her!
btw. whoriah scarey sucks, too.
peter says – reply to this

158

mariah is bitch

CELINE IS GOD
jealous stupid american people who like mariah fatty scarey
dreamWeaver says – reply to this

159

I wonder why they would ape a picture from a Mariah single that came out like 12 years ago?
Lars says – reply to this

160

Mariah is always duplicated, but never imitated,, they can't do the things mariah can do.. have a life celine dion fans.
Anonymous says – reply to this

161

put in Sara Silverman's Gap ad and you've got a tryptic.
mickey says – reply to this

162

don't really care about this stupid fight of who's the best, but really before writing all those stupid comments, some of you should get your facts right: Dion is the female artist who sold the most album in the world…so forget Carey on this one…Celine is french canadian, yes, but she doesn't represent all of the french canadians..she is weird in english but in french too! and contrary to what a fellow canadian right about leaving the country if everyone was like her, I would say: we need more french canadian in Canada…if not, it is so uptight and boring!
Marki says – reply to this

163

BLAME CANADA!
Mj says – reply to this

164

Please, Celine looks way better than that sloughed up creamballed hoe.
Jason says – reply to this

165

Mariah is better! although i like Celine too!!
isabellle says – reply to this

166

photo
Vanessa says – reply to this

167

I hope SNL gets a hold of this! I can't wait to see the skits they can create from this still dramatic.. yet amazing diva.. but nontheless fun to make fun of.. I met her tho.. and she's a sweeeet heart!
ej says – reply to this

168

celine is imitating mariah! hahaha
ashlee says – reply to this

169

i am glad that they changed the album cover to a closer shot.. the closer shot looks a lot better!
yomama says – reply to this

170

Re: philipppineslovemariahcarey –

Celine Dion is MORE SUCCESSFUL than Mariah Carey so get you bullshit out of here.

More comments: « 1 [2]

Britney Spears & Demi Lovato's First X Factor Critique! Listen Here!

Girls are on fire!!!

We won't get to see how the ladies did until the fall, but today in Austin, Britney Spears and Demi Lovato took their seats as the new judges on The X Factor. Someone had the foresight of smuggling in a recording device to the Texas auditions and we've got the audio from the ladies' first critique!

And you know what? They sound like old pros!

Check out the video (above) to hear Brit Brit and Darling Demi give their thoughts on the first contestant of season two!

They both sound so GOOD! Strong and confident; it doesn't sound like either of them were nervous at all!

Bravo, ladies! We can't wait to see you in action!

Advertising info