Who Worked It Better???

Filed under: Separated At Birth > Britney Spears > Mariah Carey

Left: Mariah Carey. Right: Shitney.

Posted: Sep 11, 2007 at 12:27 pm / Email this »

See All 1046 Comments

1046 comments to “Who Worked It Better???”

More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 »

Mary says – reply to this

801

They are BOTH sexy curvy women! I am NOT a fan of Brits music but damn she isn't fat, she just doesn't have the body she had before the boys!
anna says – reply to this

802

Britney did it better,
I dont know why ppl hated her performance so much.
It wasnt amazing. But it wasnt like she fell off the stage either.
Dan O says – reply to this

803

At least put up a flattering photo of Mariah. This picture is the worst possible photo you could drag up? Don't be such a hater. I have some super fly photos of MC in that outfit, and she looked fierce.
Britney's not getting credit for looking good, but she doesn't deserve the attention she gets. She didn't even rehearse for such a huge event; she was out partying. Loser!
Victoria says – reply to this

804

Britney worked it better. Even though her performance could've been better.
Dom L says – reply to this

805

B R I T N E Y .
carrie says – reply to this

806

BRITNEY!! Mariah is fatter and she doesn't have babies!
kitty says – reply to this

807

britney is way better than mariah. she is in good shape after having 2 kids.
Kirsti says – reply to this

808

Britney worked it waaay better
Maky says – reply to this

809

BRITNEY ALL THE WAY..
Mariah its mo0re crazy than bit bit
Halle says – reply to this

810

Pot bellied girls!!
Brook says – reply to this

811

I think they are both hot, but Mariah is definitely hands down way better. i mean common now…..shes the female artist with more # 1 hits !!! She even beat the Beatles !!!! Plus , just take a listen to Mariahs voice, its out of this world man !!!
jeana says – reply to this

812

i mist say both of these bytches make me want to puke, not going to lie! but if i had to choose i'd have to say mariah. shitney is a disgrace to females. i'm sorry, if you look like that, don't wear something to revealing! AND if you're going to lip sunc, at least stay on time with the music. at least mariah sings as crazy as she is. shitneys pretty much a waste. XO
gmommy2NOLA says – reply to this

813

Re: Tinkerbell –

That is funny. LMAO.
Lee says – reply to this

814

Frik and Frak, - not much difference.
Samantha says – reply to this

815

Britney looks better in this little get up, but Mariah can outsing Britney. Neither are fat, though. They have average, womanly bodies. That's sexy!
gmommy2NOLA says – reply to this

816

Re: Maky –
Mariah its mo0re crazy than bit bit

Are you stupid?
tristenn says – reply to this

817

however fucked up, fat, and crazy maiah can ever get she can still sing even if she has to be suspended on a belt like shamu after an all you can eat binge at the olivegarden!
Steve says – reply to this

818

Britney did it better. Mariah looks absolutely awful… it's probably the angle, though. Britney just didn't look "into" her performance at the VMAs. She looked like she couldn't handle the crowd… I mean, would YOU be able to? She's only talked shit about, she probably choked knowing that everyone in the room was probably talking crap about her after they announced her. Fortunately, "Gimme More" is a wicked catchy track and if anything will bring her sales, it will be a song like this.
yaya says – reply to this

819

Ouch! MOO-riah makes Brit look good!
EMILIO says – reply to this

820

They both are great!!! These 2 gals paved the way for a lot of artist today!!! LOVE
sumi says – reply to this

821

at least i dont see no crotch shots of mariah thank god,

anyways they both are not fat, mariah has lost some weight recently and seriously if u call them fat, at least 100 million ppl should die now including perez coz they are nowhere near better than them.

btw, perez put on a bikini and do you and brit again….PEREZ ON A BIKINI!! DO IT
FanofM says – reply to this

822

neither are bad, neither are fat. neither should be wearing those outfits. but i prefer mariah of course.
yomammasofatshelookatthemenuandsayok says – reply to this

823

why dont u, perez, wear a similar outfit and then ask us who looks better? neither of them are fat, but you… that's another story!
kellie says – reply to this

824

Mariah looks bloated. Britney looks good, especially after having 2 kids in the last 3 years. Jesus, leave her alone, I wish I looked that good. She totally sucks as a singer though. But she looks good sucking.
fliparoo says – reply to this

825

Neither one of them is fat outside of Freakywood, but both of them have needed some serious clothing for a long time. Both are obviously so desperate in the body image area.
kellie says – reply to this

826

Re: Xmimi –
Right the fuck on!
robert says – reply to this

827

Britney hands down
LaLaLaxatives says – reply to this

828

Mariah looks like a beached whale. She's got the real life body of Homer Simpson. Britney on the other hand is not fat…she just doesn't have the slammin bod that she used to. But for someone who popped out two babies in two years and went through a very public divorce Britney looks like a fucking rockstar. GO BRITNEY. Mariah needs to cover her fugly ass up and quit eating altogether.
eee says – reply to this

829

perez u ake to much shit fatboy
joy says – reply to this

830

HOLY CRAP THEY BOTH LOOK SHITEOUS TO ME! WHATS UP WITH THE WHOLE PRANCING YOUR FAT AROUND THE STAGE THING??? IS THIS WHAT HOLLYWOOD WANTS NOWADAYS????
jenny/someone who love her says – reply to this

831

BRITNEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY.
look at mariah belly:::is plastic surgery! now we can confirm that britney never did plastic surgery.

MARIAH LIPO!
Shane says – reply to this

832

Re: cristal –

I totally agree with you: Mariah has man belly for days!!!!!!
jenny says – reply to this

833

BRITNEY LOOKS BETTER! SHE IS NOT FAT, I´T´S THAT SHE ISN´T ANOREXIC, AND WE CAN NOTICE MARIAH´S PLASCIT SURGERY IN THE STOMACH.
buttcrack says – reply to this

834

I would say Brit looks better in the picture, but when mooriah did it, she looked totally comfortable and owned her big fat body, while Brit looked embarassed that she looked like a heffer…

i give it to Mooriah
monilove77 says – reply to this

835

PLLEEAASSEE…..that's like comparing a flawless diamond (Mariah) to a big heaping pile of s*%#. Mariah is a queen and they don't come any higher. Shame on you Perez….
Lucy says – reply to this

836

britney. hands down.
ASB says – reply to this

837

MARIAH CAREY has had WAYYYYYYYY more success than Shitney.
First of all Mariah is just a little older people, she started her amazing career earlier. Her music is soulfull, meaningful, & actually makes sense compared to Britney's bubblegum piece of shit lyrics
Granted this is a HORRIBLE pic of Mariah, She has never had a horrible performance & check out that amazing hair!…She may have had a nervous breakdown but so did Britney! At a stand point Mariah Owns and is way over that immiture "I cant get my shit together" Crap.

MARIAH WINS!
skim says – reply to this

838

shitney. mariah is fat
ambermadic says – reply to this

839

Mariah has no reason to be fat!!!!! Britney looks good who wants to look at skin a bones. EWWWWW sorry i think Mariah looks like a trannie
MARIAH says – reply to this

840

Re: christy –

No, that's why I say she should stay at home and give herself and all of us a break…until she kills herself.
MARIAH says – reply to this

841

LOVE MARIAH! She's got the TALENT, Shitney Beers got nothing but 2 poor Kiddies!
valival says – reply to this

842

MOORIAH, at least the skeezer can sing!!!
robin says – reply to this

843

Mariah needs to dress like a grown woman instead of a I don't know what - it's really old! Try something new, you got the bucks!! As for Britney, ditto. Good lord she set herself up for it.
noelan says – reply to this

844

OK SO THAT IS NOT THE BEST PIC OF MARIAH…..SHIT PEREZ WHY DONT U PUT A BETTER PIC OF BOTH OF THEM…..I SAW OTHER PICS OF BRITNEY WEN SHE WAS SINGING AT THE VMA'S AND THERE WERE BETTER ONES. SO YEA AND MARIAH IS JUS SEXY AS HELL…..AND SHE DOESNT LOOK LIKE THAT ANYMORE ANYWAY…..HAVENT U SEEN NEW PIX OF HER??? YEA SHE LOOKS GOOD NOW. U SHULD POST THOSE PIX UP…MAYBE IT WILL SHUT U THE HELL UP. AND BRITNEY ALSO…..AND IM EXCITED FOR MARIAH'S NEW ALBUM!!!!! IM NOT A BRITNEY FAN BUT I HOPE SHE DOES GOOD CUZ SHE HAS BEEN THRU SUM SHIT SO SHE DESERVES A HIGH POINT IN LIFE! SO YEA BUT I LOVE MARIAH! FOREVER!!!!
Doubledees says – reply to this

845

Look I am a heavy gal myself. I also will tell you I can cover mysef up and that is how it should be. Perez, I love how you tell it the way it is. Some people just don't have the balls to do so. Your new show is great also! Loving it! Unlike Justin who is probably glad he doesn't have it anymore. Lol
CAPTAIN says – reply to this

846

MARIAH LOOKS BETTER AND I THINK THAT IT IS A BAD PICTURE OF HER. I SAW HER TWICE ON TOUR AND SHE LOOKED NO WHERE NEAR THAT WEIGHT AND THERE R PICS OUT THERE TO PROVE IT. NEITHER OF THEM ARE FAT THOUGH. ONLY DOGS WANT A BONE.
Adrian says – reply to this

847

They're both fat and fake…fake boobs,fake hair…Get real! They can both sing but need to find cloths that suit them…I mean really..No mirrors?
Ms.G, Da Gossip Queen :) says – reply to this

848

well peepz Ms Mariah has like 10 years on Brit! Dont u guys be too cruel to her. At least she has the best comeback ever in the history. (That's only if Brit can top it off,which I really doubt it). Beside, Miss M. can sing, actually she's one of the best singers out there. Brit needs to get her cracked-up head together and focus on her career. You cant keep disappointing your fans like this!!! Shame on u!
sallyxmander says – reply to this

849

britney looks way hotter. fuck mariah. she sucks.
karen says – reply to this

850

thank god, my 46 year old body (today is my birthday) is better than shittaney's…..my gut is less obtrusive than hers!
katie says – reply to this

851

britney.. she's much prettier. shes not fat, that was just a poor choice on costume!
Nathalie, belgium says – reply to this

852

I don't think Britney is fat, she has a realistic model. Marilyn monroe is the biggest sexsymbol of all times and she was a size 42!! Don't forget that is isn't 16 anymore, she is now a woman with curves
Kam!! says – reply to this

853

mariah dose'nt look to good here but she can SING and she is more good looking then brit so MARIAH!!
amelia says – reply to this

854

britney spears!!! ok her performance was shit house but she looks way hotter then mariah and considering she just popped out 2 kids she looks pretty fucken awesome!!!
KRISTEN says – reply to this

855

OMG IS THAT REALLY A QUESTION? OF COURSE MARIAH…. LOL
KRISTEN says – reply to this

856

Re: amelia – MARIAH IS FUCKING 40 YRS OLD, AND SHE LOOKS AS GOOD IF NOT BETTER THAN BRITNEY SO SHUT THE FUCK UP. MARIAH ALSO ACTUALLY GIVES A SHIT ABOUT HER FANS!!!
KRISTEN says – reply to this

857

Re: LISA – SHE LOOKS HELLA GOOD FOR HER AGE!! WHAT R U TALKING ABOUT???
aky says – reply to this

858

where's mariah's neck?
Private Slovak says – reply to this

859

Britney, Paris, and Lindsay Rule!
Chelsea says – reply to this

860

Anyone else notice that Britney is missing two of her fake finger nails in this picture????? Poor trashy Shitney……
Jessica says – reply to this

861

I love them both, But I think Britney deff worked it better…
Carla says – reply to this

862

In my point of view, MC is better than Britney in everything, except dancing. Brit is all about the show's visual and Mariah is always about the voice. she does Playback? of course, but everybody does 8don't tell me britney doesn't). but MC still can deliver a good show.
You are comparing a 20 and something years old girl to a 37 year old women… please…

AND IT'S BRITNEY NOT SHITNEY
ben says – reply to this

863

ARE YOU KILLING ME ?!?! YOU COMPARE SHITNEY WITH THE GODDES OF MUSIC ?!?! O.o FUCK YOU
MC 4ever&longer ♥♥
Sean Cochran says – reply to this

864

regarding britney. Id still hit it.
Adam says – reply to this

865

How can you compare Brit to Mariah? Come one Perez…..seriously…..have you seen Mariah lately?? HOT!!!
Jen2 says – reply to this

866

DOUBLE WIDE. The only thing that prevents Britney from living in a double wide trailer is her early Disney exposure, and clever handling and marketing. She is trailer trash.

Mariah Carey is a talented singer. You can take away the "control room" and Mariah Carey can still sing.
JEN says – reply to this

867

NEVER THOUGHT I WOULD SEE BRIT LARGER THAN MARIAH. MARIAH CAN PULL IT OFF. BRIT SUCKS
debbie says – reply to this

868

Britney looks FAR better than freakin Mimi… lol. Mariah always looked portley, but everyone says how fab she looks. She looks more like a skank in Joyce Leslie clothes. Brit may have bombed on stage, but her bod rocks more than crazy moomoo's… err, I mean Mimi's
Alaina says – reply to this

869

At least Mariah has all of her Lee press on's secured.

And I sort of hate the fact that everyone says Britney is fat. If being a normal size 4 or 6 is fat, than there is seriously something wrong w/ this country. Its really no wonder 15 year old girls are being sent to rehab for eating disorders.

However, Brit should have chosen a better outfit. She needs to realize that she is performing literally for millions of people on camera- and all those flaws you wouldn't normally notice are greatly magnified…

All in all- CLASS UP, BRIT!
LOOL says – reply to this

870

OK BRITNEY IS NOT SOO FAT BUT SHE BECAME A SHIT
I KNEW THAT WHEN SHE HAD STOPPED SINGING
JCB says – reply to this

871

Who has given birth too 2 children….?
Jenn says – reply to this

872

both are gross!!!
Boss says – reply to this

873

Brittney of course!!!! neither one of them are fat but Brit Brit has kids….. whats Mariah excuse!!! Anyway lay off Brit…….. i still and always will be ah fan, and who cares what shes doing with her life right now! She accomplished a lot of things some artist to cant and wont do!! PLUS shes still rich as hell!!!! She can live care free, not work, get fat, travel, do girls, guys, drugs, sex, club and STILL be a BOSS, because not many could do what shes done in here career in a lifetime!!! HATERS!!! IT'S BRITTNEY BITCH!!! GET THE NEXT ALBUM!!!!
eva says – reply to this

874

I THINK THEY BOTH LOOK RIDICULOUS! They crave attention so much and the only way to obtain it is to get undressed. Who needs to prance around, in public, in such skanky outfits, other than ditsy and insecure women. We all know, you can look sexy and classy at the same time. This is simply trashy!
Lauren says – reply to this

875

I'm gonna have to say Mariah, even though she looks like crap too.. I pretty much think anything /anyone can win over the train wreck formally known as Britney Spears.
Rachel says – reply to this

876

at least brit or shitney haha doesnt have a double chin eww both are gross though like y wear sumthing like that wen u have a body like that
Sparksy says – reply to this

877

Re: german Nº1 FAN –

Hate to break this to you young buck but Mariah holds the record for most hits in her almost 20 years of working compared to Brit's 5-6 year hits…plus Mariah has fuckin grammys sooo shut the fuck up retard and read some books and mags on entertainment before commenting on a subject you kno nothing about. Mariah is a singer, Shitney is a performer…there's a huge difference in the two…Mariah may have some weight, she's older and she is a fucking woman not a girl struggling to become a woman. Having kids doesn't make you a woman, taking care of them and yourself is what makes you a woman something that Shitney obviously knows nothing about. Perez can say what he wants…this is his shit….if you don't like go elsewhere!!!! fuckers!
Eve says – reply to this

878

At least Britney doesn't have a monkey face.
Alex' says – reply to this

879

Mariah worked it better than Brit did Hey, I'm sorry but it's true
cc says – reply to this

880

Perez, you are a big fat jerk.
Fallon Arenaz says – reply to this

881

They are both utterly ridiculous, so much so, it's glorious!
KBH says – reply to this

882

They are both fucking disgusting
Sasou says – reply to this

883

too close to call…
kimo says – reply to this

884

MARIAH!!!
CoUrTnEy says – reply to this

885

BRITNEY WORKED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
JUST NOT ON THE SONG
Ken says – reply to this

886

Non of them are really fat, they're a bit curvy. Mariah is 12 years older than britney and there are pictures way more flattering of her than this one. Mariahs hair looks way better and her teint as well. They are so different, one can't dance but sure can sing (mariah) the other used to be a good dancer but she's worth nothing as a singer (britney). They both had public breakdowns though :d but mariah handled it more like a lady I must say.
loverski says – reply to this

887

why is perez posting this when he's pretty much mariah carey and shitney put together?
shut up says – reply to this

888

Perez you fat f**k, they both look better than you. Maybe you should stop calling everyone fat after you lose about 150 pounds big ass.
shut up says – reply to this

889

Re: Ken – Mariah handled it better??????????? by stripping on total request live, how quickly they forget.
Anthonymcxxx says – reply to this

890

Mariah is well the best!!! It is not even a question to be asked - however I do still believe Britney looks ok, people need to cut the girl a break now. At the end of the day 'they' are quick to attack yet when do good forget to praise!!
Either support the music which is their job/career or leave them alone!!!!!!!
gaby says – reply to this

891

people! mariah can be 800lbs. & the bitch can still sing beautifully!
AS 4 BRIT EVERYONE HAS 2 GET OVER THE PERFECT/BRITNEY FANTASY THAT WAS A LONG TIME AGO SHE IS A REAL PERSON WHO HAD 2 BABIES .. SHE IS TRYING …HELLLOOOOOOO?????
ALEXIS ONE says – reply to this

892

THEY'RE BOTH FAT!
Cinderella says – reply to this

893

Its time these big bitches put some CLOTHES on!!! They BOTH need to GROW UP ALREADY! I weigh less than they do and I would not be caught DEAD in shit like this!
oliver ... says – reply to this

894

oh yes the double " oin oin" effect…two fat pigs !!!!
but i decide for Britney. because she makes me laughing…
kkiikk says – reply to this

895

can you say Whoria. she is so gross why do people like her. and yeah it is momma baby fat, so why wear that and show it off. put some clothes on
Lulu says – reply to this

896

Britney is an amazing singer and she looks great. Leave Britney alone! She worked this outfit and her voice was flawless.
Sike!
You fools, Mariah needs to have clothes on at all times. She is a pretty vocalists. Stripping down is not required. Britney on the other hand needs to put her cunt in your face for you to buy her album. Did it work? She sucks, she always sucked. People are just recognizing her bullshit for what it is these days. Ashanti is next!
Lisalisanthecultjam says – reply to this

897

yeah,i'm done with your pathetic comments on brit, perez!You act shes suppose to stay the "same" brit in a timecapsule for the the rest of her life.She's older now and had two kids by c-section!Do you even know how serious emergency c-sections are?And how epidural shots mess up ur spine?I know cause I have 2 kids as well and could never do what she has done… and I was a professional dancer for 10 years!From my emergency c-section I was crippled from 3 bad epidural shots,so it makes me happy to see brit at least trying…I mean if you are the" queen of all media?"Didn't you know she twisted her ankle practicing behind stage…duh..thats why the dancers were helping her up….and she still did the show with the twisted ankle why..CAUSE THE SHOW MUST GO ON…and that perez is a performer…I would know because I was.Besides like who did any better at the VMA'S…LOL!
OH WELL PEREZ YOU DON'T KNOW REAL LIFE ISSUES CAUSE YOU ARE HEARTLESS!BYE——–
julie says – reply to this

898

i think shitney looks great, for having 2 kids & not having a body that looks like a road map…..shes hott! mariah looks aweful esp. in this pic her stomache looks old & fat, i think SHE looks like miss piggy not brit…….she also has some fat roles hanhing over her halter top wtf!
Lilja says – reply to this

899

eeew I've always hated Mariah Carey. She looks like a fat monkey on that picture. See the boobs! They are uuugly. Go Britney
mariah sucks says – reply to this

900

britney the other shit is sooooooo much FAAAATTTTTEEEERRRRRRR.

More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 »

Britney Spears & Demi Lovato's First X Factor Critique! Listen Here!

Girls are on fire!!!

We won't get to see how the ladies did until the fall, but today in Austin, Britney Spears and Demi Lovato took their seats as the new judges on The X Factor. Someone had the foresight of smuggling in a recording device to the Texas auditions and we've got the audio from the ladies' first critique!

And you know what? They sound like old pros!

Check out the video (above) to hear Brit Brit and Darling Demi give their thoughts on the first contestant of season two!

They both sound so GOOD! Strong and confident; it doesn't sound like either of them were nervous at all!

Bravo, ladies! We can't wait to see you in action!

Advertising info