The New Hilary & Haylie

Filed under: Disney > Ashley Tisdale > YOU Decide!

Disney star Ashley Tisdale took her actor sibling Jennifer to the premiere of High School Musical on ice this weekend in LA.

Ignore what they're wearing.

The real question is….

Which one is Hilary and which one is Haylie?????!!!

[Photo via Getty Images.]

Posted: Oct 6, 2007 at 10:26 pm / Email this »

See All 256 Comments

256 comments to “The New Hilary & Haylie”

More comments: [1] 2 3 »

Emily says – reply to this

1

Ashley is Haylie and Jennifer is Hilary.
Shaun says – reply to this

2

they are both fug - who cares?
KASEYBABY! says – reply to this

3

you prob wont be FIRST…so dont even say it lol.!
HAHA says – reply to this

4

ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
ASHLEY IS HILARY
gomer says – reply to this

5

first
SEE YA says – reply to this

6

FUCK OFF ASSHOLES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
leah says – reply to this

7

who cares?
Troll Patrol says – reply to this

8

you aint first
Camia says – reply to this

9

First? xD
cynthia says – reply to this

10

it's so obvious, Ashley is the blonde
nicoline says – reply to this

11

clearly ashely's hilary!
sarah says – reply to this

12

losers
corrin says – reply to this

13

ashley is totally going to be hilary, she's already a pretty big star, unlike her sister.
slammer says – reply to this

14

More brainwashing for american youth
Alicia says – reply to this

15

Hillary is on the right…Haylie is on the left!
molldoll says – reply to this

16

both gross
KAY says – reply to this

17

bitch on the left is hils, bitch on the right haylie
EJROCKSU says – reply to this

18

Jennifer looks wayyy better than her sister. Ashley looks like a dog -_-
manpreet says – reply to this

19

ASHLEYS IS HILARY!
KIMUCHURRI says – reply to this

20

HEY!!!!! CINDY N.D.
Helgi says – reply to this

21

Obviously Ashley is Haylie…
Val says – reply to this

22

Ash is Hilary and her sis is Haylie!!!
EJROCKSU says – reply to this

23

in other words….ashley is hilary lol
that_girl says – reply to this

24

Jennifer - Haylie
Ashley - Hilary
MissMichele says – reply to this

25

both these girlies ugly…i kno ashley tidesdale is from some disney bullshit. uh this sister thing in hollywood is getting so annoying….
saruhh says – reply to this

26

first?
Peace n Love says – reply to this

27

Ashley is so Hilary right now….
She looks so cute like a muffin
MATN says – reply to this

28

who fucking cares
monica says – reply to this

29

so obvi, the slutty one on the right is "haylie". look at those eyes she's ready to bone.
anonymous says – reply to this

30

l1ke omgz first!!
jealousy says – reply to this

31

FIRST BITCH!
jd says – reply to this

32

first
Susan says – reply to this

33

first? booya.
ashley = hilary
maria says – reply to this

34

umm they are both but ugly…
kayla says – reply to this

35

firstttttttt
Natali says – reply to this

36

Perez,
Physically, Jennifer is Hilary and Ashley is Haylie but other than physically, Jennifer is Haylie since she has to live in her sister's shadow and Ashley is Hilary, the star.
Natali
peg says – reply to this

37

ashley is haylie definitely! 3rrrrd!!!!!
manpreet says – reply to this

38

ashley is hilary!
Jesse says – reply to this

39

Ashley = Hilary… she's the hotter sister… no question about that one.
Yawn says – reply to this

40

Ummm….no. The real question is, who cares?
jasmin says – reply to this

41

DEF not the next..
the duffs are better in my opininon
BLACK MAN says – reply to this

42

DID U HEAR? HIP HOP IS OVER!!! RAP SALES PLUMMETTING!
your mom says – reply to this

43

first?
okay says – reply to this

44

NO NO NO
ASHLEY IS DEFFINATLY HAYLIE
brothabill says – reply to this

45

They look like they have about five brain cells in their heads between the two of them.
Looking into their eyes is like staring into an eye of a chicken. Nothing really there it seems. Such is the life and brain of poptarts and wannabe poptarts.
sandy says – reply to this

46

ashley is haylie and jennifer is hilary
meltz911 says – reply to this

47

There both hotter than the Duffs.
meltz911 says – reply to this

48

Re: BLACK MAN – Thank God! That shit was getting more tired than Metal.
Jules says – reply to this

49

Ashley is definitely Hilary… the famous sister who's fame Jennifer/ Haylie is gunna use to make it big… kind of.
Jen says – reply to this

50

Ashley's not bigger enough to be hilary yet, the only person that actually got real fame from HSM was unfortunately Zac
MC! says – reply to this

51

ashley started on the disney channel and was first to get her name out there, so she's obviously hilary…jennifer is just latching on to her sister to have a remote chance at fame much like haylie did, but we all know she's not gonna make it after her sister's high school musical fame
BLACK MAN says – reply to this

52

H
I
P
H
O
P
–
I
S
–
O
V
E
R
–
T
E
L
L
–
T
H
E
–
W
O
R
L
D
–
B
I
T
C
H
E
S
–
NO MORE MAKING BLACK PEOPLE LOOK LIKE UNEDUCATED MORONS!!! WE'RE SICK OF IT!!! WE'RE GOING TO COLLEGE!!! LEARNING HOW TO READ AND WRITE!!! SPEAKING PROPERLY!!! NO MORE RACISM!!! IT'S OVER!!! NO MORE OF THESE HIP HOP MORONS MAKING US LOOK BAD WITH PANTYHOSE ON THEIR HEADS AND GARBAGE OUTFITS. GOOGLE "RAP IS DEAD" STATISTICALLY EVERYONE IS SICK OF HIP HOP AND SALES ARE FALLING. R&B/DANCE/COUNTRY/POP/ROCK MUSIC SALES ARE ALL UP. HIP HOP IS OVER!!! MARTIN LUTHER KING DID NOT FIGHT FOR US TO ALLOW OURSELVES TO BE THE JOKE OF AMERICA. THANK GOD HIP HOP IS DYING FAST!!!
MARIELA says – reply to this

53

DUH! ASHLEY IS HILARY! AND THE OTHER IS HAYLIE. JENNIFER SHOULD ALSO GET HER TEETH WHITENED!
musica says – reply to this

54

wat SHIT are they wearing?
jacqueline says – reply to this

55

ash is hailey
cause her sis is prettier then her

lol

wtf….?? what am i? 13? why the fuck do i care? hahahah…still….her sister is better looking then her…
kerry says – reply to this

56

Haylie on the LEFT.
I literally thought it WAS a picture of HILARY AND HER SISTER, Ashley looks a lot like Hilary (at least from where I'm sitting)
I thought Haylie had got work done but I was like what the f… ? How could she have changed her whole face lol.
Even if it was Haylie after surgery, she'd still be fug.
Though Ashley Tisdale isn't much better especially up close she is really scary, talk about horse face.
meltz911 says – reply to this

57

Re: BLACK MAN – I hear you my brother in knowledge! Pimps and hoes down, education and self respect up.
Oceantownshit Highschool Student says – reply to this

58

I went to highschool with Jennifer. Her legacy is real shit, and I mean that literally. She crapped her pants in my freinds car and ran into her house to throw out her shitty underwear. She got some poop on her hands and left a partial shitprint on the door. Jennifer "shits her pants" Tisdale. Peace OUT!!!!
marie says – reply to this

59

Re: brothabill –
lmao staring into the eye of a chicken

Hey I wish I had a famous brother or sister so I can get lots of free shit and fame and be rich without doing fuck all.
Hailey says – reply to this

60

Ashley is definitely Haylie
kate says – reply to this

61

The both look like biscuits in a can. Looks good. Tastes good.

Mass produced.
Neither! says – reply to this

62

They both look like child whores….and dress like whores too.
b says – reply to this

63

girlfriend on the left needs a teeth whitening…
b says – reply to this

64

girlfriend on the left needs a teeth whitening…
..... says – reply to this

65

clearly, ashley is hilary. hands down.
not shocked says – reply to this

66

why do all these little girls want to look like Vivid Video Whores?
chacha says – reply to this

67

high school musical should always be filed under gay gay gay
rewre says – reply to this

68

EEW. THey're just as ugly as Haylie and HIlary. Haylie Duff thinks she's famous when she's not, and she wears crap all the time! Hilary duff is a long faced skank with horrible taste.

Love Ashley, but she looks fug in this pic!
ashley says – reply to this

69

um…..fyi i went to school in Ocean Township, NJ with both of them…jen was the popular all star cheerleader and ashley was the frizzy fro-ed dorky loser who no one blinked an eye at….and the way she looks now is NOT WHAT SHE REALLY LOOKS LIKE….its amazing what a good team can do…
BrandonS says – reply to this

70

Neither of them are of Duff's stature.
roo says – reply to this

71

i hate ashley tisdale. go fall in a hole and die.
CarLa says – reply to this

72

WTF is up with both of their noses?
Jen's looks like she needs it done and Ashley's looks like she's had 2 operations too many and gets inspiration from Michael Jackson.
Can someone reply telling me if Ashley has had a nose job because I don't care enough about her to search myself but I am really interested as to how a persons nose looks that stupid by nature, doesn't seem possible?
Pat says – reply to this

73

I LOVE THE ASH. SHE IS A GREAT ACTRESS AND POSITIVE ROLE MODEL FOR THE KIDDOS
I'll Take The One On The Right says – reply to this

74

she has the fuck me in the ass look, in her eyes.
quagmire says – reply to this

75

Wonder if these girls have been penetrated yet?
MrsBurt says – reply to this

76

I must be old. I don't know who is who.
LMAO says – reply to this

77

um their both ugly gay and retarded so why does it matter anyways whoever likes high school musical or like ashley tisdail or whatever her name is has serious fuckin issues.. i flipped the channel to it for like 2 minutes and all i saw was a whole bunch of fruity guys and retarded girls 'singing' not really singing though.. hmm i can see how it may appeal to like 5 yr olds but… a whole lotta people needa grow the fuck up. lmao .. if your over the age of 10.. honestly.. and like it.. whoa holy fuckk
sam says says – reply to this

78

umm… have u ever heard of teeth whitening?? that goes for jennifer. i dont know about ashley … maybe thats why she's not showing her teeth
humpy says – reply to this

79

I'd bang the hell out both of them
POO says – reply to this

80

HILARY IS HOT, HALEY IS NOT…………THESE TWO ARE BOTH SUPER FUG!!!!!!!!!!!
tdot says – reply to this

81

ash's sis needs 2 have her teeth cleaned!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! come on ash, SHARE THE WEALTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jillian says – reply to this

82

do doubt that ashley is hillary and jennifer is hayle… who the hell is jennifer anyway
Crystal says – reply to this

83

NASTY! Those teefs need some attention in a big way. They look dead. Girlfriend, if you are walking the red carpet at least get some whitening done.
Chloe says – reply to this

84

C'mon yall! How can these two trailer park ho's be compared to the Duffsters?! It's like comparing The Bush siters to the Hilton Sisters; Theres no competition. These two ugly vitches need to go back to the trailer park and then return that clothes to the thrift store they bought it from. The smaller one also creeps the shit out of me with that stare…Scary bitch!
A says – reply to this

85

ashley is way hotter than either of the duff chicks.. the duff chicks are both way hotter than ashley's sister.
GummiiBearSam says – reply to this

86

Ashley is Hilary because she is known and the other one… Jennifer is Haylie. The not so famous, but wants to be sibling.

They both look CUTE! love the outfits!
sarah says – reply to this

87

They're not haylie and hilary.

Ashley and her sister are way better than that.
yomama says – reply to this

88

even though i'm probably 89 -91 FIRST!!!!!1111111onetwothree

if it's fame: Ashley - hilary , jennifer - haylie

looks: ashley - haylie , jennifer - hilary
WENDALYNN says – reply to this

89

LOOK AT THE LOOK IN ASHLEY' S EYES, THAT IS NOT A DISNEY LOOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Pezzzz says – reply to this

90

Jennifer is Hillary, Ashley is Haylie. It's all in the nose.
MI says – reply to this

91

The girl on the right looks like Lara Spencer from "The Insider".
Wendy says – reply to this

92

Ashley is……………….

FUGLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!—- thats what she is.

Her sister is soooo much more prettier and less concieted looking.

Ashley looks like a bitch dog in heat.
geny says – reply to this

93

the tall one is haylie and the other hilary
56476 says – reply to this

94

the tall awkward one is clearly haylie
amanda says – reply to this

95

omg. it has nothing to do with what they look like, he's making a joke, that Ashley's sister Jennifer is using her fame to get famous herself, the same way that Hailey did with Hilary. there. I spelled it out for you.
jeffy says – reply to this

96

they are wayyyyy hotter than the Duff sista's. Especially the elder Duff.
Jenni (luv ya perez!) says – reply to this

97

AHLEYS HILARY, JENNIFER IS HAYLIE
KELLYYYYY. says – reply to this

98

does it matter?
the Duff sisters are better than them anyway!
jbonz says – reply to this

99

I'll tell you what, boys. I've watched a shitload of "Sweet Life of Zach and Cody" with my daughter, and Ashley's character always comes across as a sweetie pie. But those eyes are the eyes of a hellcat and that's for sure. Look for our little Miss Tisdale to be popping up in a sex tape that'll curl your shorthairs!
paz says – reply to this

100

WOW! Someone got a new nose! It's about time