The New Hilary & Haylie

Filed under: Disney > Ashley Tisdale > YOU Decide!

Disney star Ashley Tisdale took her actor sibling Jennifer to the premiere of High School Musical on ice this weekend in LA.

Ignore what they're wearing.

The real question is….

Which one is Hilary and which one is Haylie?????!!!

[Photo via Getty Images.]

Posted: Oct 6, 2007 at 10:26 pm / Email this »

See All 256 Comments

256 comments to “The New Hilary & Haylie”

More comments: « 1 2 [3]

ASSLEE SIMPSON says – reply to this

201

THATZ ME ON THE RIGHT.
Emily says – reply to this

202

Re: Emily –
I think its the other way around.
rebekah says – reply to this

203

their outfits r definite shit– that jacket on ashley's sis jennifer looks awful!!! it SOOOOO doesnt fit right!
FYI.... says – reply to this

204

Re: mp – Hilary Duff is not a nice person. She recently had a restaurant cleared in the small town I live in just sw of Houston because 2 little girls spoke to her. She hadn't ordered yet and no one else even acknowleged her, so it wasn't like she was being harrassed or anything… she just wanted to throw her weight around to see what it felt like to be important. She'd never get away with that in big cities like NY, LA or even Houston for that matter. She needs to realize that she barely has a career and children are the only reason she does. I mean it was rediculous… it's just a small restaurant that's popular with the locals and seriously, no one even cared that she was there and most didn't even know who she was. Still think she's nice?
tess says – reply to this

205

Is it just me or is Ashley Tisdale really fug? I mean look at this nose. Its so huge. She´s definitely a Haylie or a pre-op Ashley simpson. I give her six months before she runs into a 90210 surgeons office to get her potato fixed.
DZArbonne says – reply to this

206

Get Beautiful Skin Now
Look at my space dzarbonne to learn more.
Apes says – reply to this

207

Holy breast augmentation… am I the only one picking up on that.
Claire says – reply to this

208

Ashley is DEFFENTLY Hilary

I'm mean….Did anyone even Know about The Sister??? Lmao

Sisters 100% Haylie
nobody likes or cares about her…Shes Haylie
Just a bad pic people!!! says – reply to this

209

In this pic her nose looks a little off, but most of the time she looks good. She has mostly good features even if her nose is not perfect, beauty is the total package not just a perfect nose. Lots of ugly girls with good noses.
Chanel says – reply to this

210

I think Ashley Tisdale has a very bright career ahead of her and i wish her all the best, its nice to see some teen actors/actresses who arn't drama queens/divas!!!

Keep up the good work girls
caramel says – reply to this

211

fug girls, call me, i'll be your stylist.
diva says – reply to this

212

Re: DAVID –
lol!
hey,at least they'll probably suck yo dick, hos! just put a paper bag
pharell says – reply to this

213

whoever these ugly chicks are they look like every other girl out there right now. give me a beautiful non blonde chick perez. megan fox??
Kate says – reply to this

214

Who would/could go up to a mirror and say "I think I look great" in that outfit!
emilayyyyy says – reply to this

215

what's up with Ashley's nose? It looks like a plastic surgeon molded it outta play dough and stuck it on her face. Has her nose always looked like that?!?! I'm convinced she had plastic surgery.
YELLOW TEETH says – reply to this

216

UHM….. KOOK AT HER YELLOW TEETH. PERHAPS SOME CREST WHITENING STRIPS WILL HELP HER. IF SHE IS GOING TO WANT TO BE IN 'THE SPOTLIGHT' WITH HER SISTER SHE SHOULD WHITEN THOSE CORN-LIKE TEETH! EWWWWWAH!
by the way says – reply to this

217

There last name is kelly! not tisdale!
k-la says – reply to this

218

ashley is hilary and her sis is um watz her name lol by that i mean no one cares bout the sis !!! why is there always a sister or brother who want to steal their siblings limelight ?!?!
tommyLONDON says – reply to this

219

ashley is gorgeous - she's blonde and pretty. lol, whats not to like?
jennifer is the uglier sister deffinatly.
normslly it's the older sister thats hotter, i thought jennifer was the older one… ahh i don't care.

x
westieNproud says – reply to this

220

Obviously Ashley is Hilary…….
AnA_MexicO says – reply to this

221

is the same thing, the youngest is more famous and the cute one LoL, ashley is like hilary and jennifer is like haylie
emmanuel209 says – reply to this

222

ashley tisdale is hillary and the other girl is ummmmm whoever the fuck the other girl is but yea ashley is hot and i wanna fuck!!!!!
person says – reply to this

223

hilary = the big star helping her failed older sister to get work and exposure so hilary is ashley, and haylie = jennifer because she is using her sisters fame to 'make it' in the industry - she needs to accept the fact she hasn't 'made it' and that ashley has
sara says – reply to this

224

In about a year or two they're going to look back at that picture and be mortified by those shiteous outfits they chose to wear.
MTL says – reply to this

225

ashley tisdale has mad hoe-face.
mariana says – reply to this

226

it hink ashley is haylie and jennifre is hilary becuz i liek ashley and i like better haylie then hilary so yeah ashley is haylie!!!!
I says – reply to this

227

Ashley is Hilary `cause she's minor and most famous than her sister.

The same case that Hilary and Hailey
Michelle says – reply to this

228

ashley and hilary are the prettier, more famous of the duos
whoever and haylie are the lame tag-alongs
jefreyalca says – reply to this

229

Ashley is Hilary!!
They bot had an ugly and unsuccesful sister.
kelly says – reply to this

230

Hell no, they look like the Peldon sisters. Fug and horrible.
natasha says – reply to this

231

ASHLEY IS HILLARY AND JENN IF HAYLIE
OF COURSE
guy from NJ says – reply to this

232

Hilary is Jennifer because they both have zero talent and Hil would give Jennifer some FIERCE competition in a "who can stack more dinner plates on their forehead" competition, it'd be a neck and neck match…
twat stain says – reply to this

233

What an ugly pair of bitches.
Anya says – reply to this

234

Ashley's the younger, more successful - Hilary. Jennifer is the older one I've never heard about - Haylie.
Marley says – reply to this

235

ew what the f i hate ashley.. all these girls, they are teaching little girls how important it is to be blonde and wear make up and tight outfits. it isnt right perez, it isnt right.
quita says – reply to this

236

These two sisters are way cuter than the Duff girls!! Those Duffs are dogs!!
RACHEL says – reply to this

237

OMG! Hilary is the most gorgeous girl ever!! ashely and jennifer are both Haylie!
ally-x says – reply to this

238

Ashley is Hilary
&
Jennifer is Haylie

Ashley Tisdale is getting really popular, when the puck have we ever seen Jennifer?!
AND also the fact that Jennifer is older (like Haylie) and Ashley (just like Hilary) took after he sister
mackenzie says – reply to this

239

ashley is hilary. her sister is fuggo haylie.
ew jesus christ.
gina says – reply to this

240

i know them both from high school. huge tool bag's . jen kellly shit her pants at a party when she was a senior. HA HA HA. no joke. she is a joke though.
both ugly. ashley at least is talented. thats a plus
SESAL says – reply to this

241

hahahahah JEN TISDALE (KELLY) AKA I SHIT MY PANTS IN HIGH SCHOOL. THESE GIRLS ARE BOTH BUSTED. ASHLEY USED TO BE THE UGLIEST GIRL EVER . JEN IS STILL THE UGLIEST GIRL EVER.
ASHLEY IS TALENTED
JEN IS IN THE NEWEST VERSION OF BRING IT ON. THE 89TH SEQUAL.

ASHLEY IS LIKE 25 MAKIGN PRETEND SHES A 17 YEAR OLD DISNEY STAR.
BOTH ARE PATHETIC.
PANTS CRAPPER AND GRANDMA ON DISNEY, BLAH. NEXT SUBJECT
bigtymer32 says – reply to this

242

ashley is hilary. plus shes hot
liz says – reply to this

243

ASHLEY IS HILLARY
IT'S COMMON SENSE!
katie says – reply to this

244

THE REAL QUESTION IS WHO IS THE ONE WITH THE NOSE JOB
irina says – reply to this

245

ashley is hilary!!!
ash says – reply to this

246

WHY DOES IT MATTER?? they are both the people that you want to look up to. i think theyre cool! who should you really talk about, ashley who is on disney…or britney who is just in big trouble? ashley and jen didn't do anything to you. and if you have got the time to look at jens teeth you seriously need a hobby. so chillax already.
ASHFAN says – reply to this

247

ASHLEY IS THE BEST
=
ASHLEY IS NOT HILARY
Beeeee says – reply to this

248

That's obvious. Jennifer is Haylie (the older and less famous sibling) and Ashley is Hilary (The younger and more famous one).
Joanna [Poland] says – reply to this

249

ASHLEY IS THE BEAUTIFUL ONE! BUT I LIKE BOTH OF THEM . THEY LOOK REALLY COOL. I LOVE ASHLEY'S MUSIC.
jfkcnhrith4 says – reply to this

250

obviesly ashley is hilary casue she's younger but she's also haylie because she'e uglier.but i'm still a big fan
Adele says – reply to this

251

lol! no there ashley n jen! woo not hilary n haylie lmao
Lauren says – reply to this

252

ashley tisdale is my role model and i dont want anywun to insult her she has dsone nothing wrong and ISNT copying hilary duff !
Maria says – reply to this

253

ashley is obviously hilary… she is the younger more famous one

hahahahahahah forget what theyre wearing
hahaha i love you perez (sometimes)
torr says – reply to this

254

obviously ashley is hilary, the younger, better looking, more famous one.
and jennifer? i think her name is, yea the one noone cares about like, umm..haylie?

ashley & hilaryyyyyyyyyyy
Aldana says – reply to this

255

Hey! Your web is so cool, I love it!
I don't think Ashley's Hilary, because I know that she doesn't want to look like her. She's Ashley Tisdale, and Just Her… she's perfect like she is
Kisses
jay says – reply to this

256

these 2 will never be like hil & hay. ash wont even be a big star…..