She Said/He Said

Filed under: Lindsay Lohan

743-1131.jpg

Who are we going to believe????

Us Weekly is reporting that Riley Giles, Lindsay Lohan's new boyfriend, was engaged to someone else (Bree Tierney) when he began dating the actress after they met in rehab.

The mag even spoke to the girl's mother, who says she is "destroyed" and only found out about her fiance's relationship after seeing pictures of him and Lohan.

Now, Riley is fighting back!

Speaking exclusively to In Touch Weekly, the snowboarder says, "I broke up with Bree a week before I started dating Lindsay. We had dated for almost two years, but it’s not like we were engaged or anything.”

She said/he said.

    Posted: Oct 17, 2007 at 11:51 am / Email this  »

    94 comments to “She Said/He Said”

    1. becca says – reply to this


      1

      Hater!!!! Perez is a hater!!!!

    2. first says – reply to this


      2

      1rst

    3. jmesrevenge says – reply to this


      3

      thank god lohan is back.

    4. me says – reply to this


      4

      yawn

    5. Someone! says – reply to this


      5

      Boo!!!!!!!!!! He sucks!

    6. teresa says – reply to this


      6

      1st? she should go back to rehab; i'm sick of her

    7. tish says – reply to this


      7

      Oh well, Lindsay will tire of him soon and he will be back with the ex fiance.

    8. OUCH says – reply to this


      8

      A PILE OF SHIT > PEREZ HILTON

    9. PGH` says – reply to this


      9

      fake ass hoes……..first!

    10. Kara says – reply to this


      10

      well dude.. shes a fag and hes a fuckin queer

    11. jstarr91177@yahoo.com says – reply to this


      11

      I LOVE THIS HOT MESS FOR SOME REASON!!! hmmm… I am closer to the top of the list this time and not like after 50

    12. ROX says – reply to this


      12

      LIES….

    13. snowhore says – reply to this


      13

      he can slide his board in me!!!!!

    14. Dumbass says – reply to this


      14

      Ummm..errr I broke up with my girlfriend like a week before I started dating Lindsey. Oh yeah right please dude… you think we really believe your b.s. excuse. Everyone knows you started banging Lindsey in rehab and then decided to dump your poor girlfriend. What a lying putz!

    15. Fuck my mom says – reply to this


      15

      Hell Yeah I would Tap Lindsay too !

    16. LiL-MiZZ-BoSSy says – reply to this


      16

      WhatevErrrr

    17. stace says – reply to this


      17

      both are weirdos.

    18. christine says – reply to this


      18

      MEOW!!

    19. Erica McD says – reply to this


      19

      It seems as though Lindsay could fuck up a free lunch!

    20. stphie says – reply to this


      20

      4th

    21. RLV says – reply to this


      21

      Did she get some work done in "Rehab" or what. She looks totally different!

    22. sade says – reply to this


      22

      he's pretty fugly, i'm not gonna lie

    23. Mo-joe says – reply to this


      23

      Uh! WHAT? Thats still BAD DUDE! You broke up with your girlfriend a week before you started dating someone new! CLASSY. And in rehab? Sheesh.

      Lindsay needs to get herself a good guy. Not this trash. He must have a big dong or something, hes OBVs an idiot and he is not cute. BLEGH!

    24. whoo dun it says – reply to this


      24

      What a tool.

    25. CHINA LUV says – reply to this


      25

      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      BITE MY SHINY,YELLOW ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    26. Bel says – reply to this


      26

      People are not REQUIRED to stay w/ someone they are no longer attracted to or in love with. The jilted girl AND her mom need to just get over it ! It looks needy & pathetic when women do this after they are dumped.

    27. POS says – reply to this


      27

      Lindsay Lohan is such a piece of shit.

    28. Rash Manly says – reply to this


      28

      Oscar Wilde says that
      "When a man marries his mistress
      he leaves a vacancy in that position."
      .
      Marry him, Lindsay! :lol:

    29. Rooo says – reply to this


      29

      I HATE FAGS THAT REPOST THE SAME MESSAGE

    30. dd says – reply to this


      30

      go loose "some" weight

    31. Jaime says – reply to this


      31

      Does this remind anyone else of Britney/Kevin Federline/Shar Jackson thing? Only the fiancee isn't pregnant.

    32. EmilyJ says – reply to this


      32

      What an asshole. He's a fat loser. Lindsay can't possibly live her life without a guy in it and they're just enabling eachother to be dirty stupid losers. BREE, trust me you are much better off! You don't want him back after this. Before, he was just a fat, ugly, bad-dressing shitty snowboarder. NOW, he'll be a fat, ugly, bad-dressing shitty snowboarder with herpes and genital warts. THANK GOD YOU'RE RID OF HIM!

    33. whoo dun it says – reply to this


      33

      I smell the bullshit oozing. Wow, what a guy "I broke up with her a WEEK before I started dating Lindsay."
      At least we can comment on something OTHER than B.S.
      I thank you Perez for that.

    34. Gay Man says – reply to this


      34

      I would fuck the shit out of Lindsay too !

    35. Hey Losers Fuck You!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! says – reply to this


      35

      The people on these boards are disgusting. Nothing but bored lazy haters that live their life through celebs. Nothing but ugly chicks, fags, and hating bitches that have an opinion about everything. Of course you wouldnt do any of these things that celebs do. Your not the one people want to be around, your not the one who is rich, your not the one who is attractive in Hollywood, and your not the one who is young and can do whatever. Fuck off losers.

    36. whoo dun it says – reply to this


      36

      Re: Mo-joe – Yeah, god didn't "spare the rod" when the UGLY STICK came out!
      I wouldn't fuck that guy with a STOLEN PUSSY.

    37. WTF says – reply to this


      37

      WTF

    38. yo momma says – reply to this


      38

      lol

    39. irishprincess says – reply to this


      39

      Regardless, if they were dating for two years with no ring at his age……he's a commitmentphob loser!

      Run Lindsay! Run!

    40. EmilyJ says – reply to this


      40

      Re: Bel – You think he's in love with Lindsay?? Yeah fucking right. Guys who get an opportunity to bang a famous whore and don't have the balls to say no are the ones who are pathetic and needy. She'll be bored with him soon enough and he'll go crying back to his ex, new herpes sores and all. Exposing these guys for the scumbags they are is NOT pathetic. This guy is a FAT popeye-faced loser and he wants to get his 15 minutes.

    41. elizabeth says – reply to this


      41

      did you see him wearing that brand spanking new Wu-Tang shirt in the other picture? Bwah-ha-ha-ha-ha! What a loser! And he's busted! Way to go, Lindsay! While you were gone, all the hot sluts that can keep it together were making out with Josh Harnett.

    42. wtf says – reply to this


      42

      hl

    43. T-Money says – reply to this


      43

      i think i'll believe his girlfriend, a normal person, over a coked-out rehabbed loser who hangs out with lindsay lohan any day. they should just stay in rehab, you know they'll be back in a flash any way

    44. scott A says – reply to this


      44

      Can someone please "dig" my site at the link below?

      digg.com/offbeat_news/Shadow_Daily_now_ delivering_Serialized_stories_from_up_and_coming_authors

    45. catty says – reply to this


      45

      Riley looks like he is thinking "Hey dude, I though the drugs were crazy until I meet this bitch inrehab. Lindsay says unless you are married everyone is fair game. Fuck the olw woman, I am going toride this train wrech out of rehab to Hollywood." Who does Lindsay think she is, Liz Taylor picking up relationship trach in rebab? Lindsay will fuck anything with some kinda dick.

    46. Elisabitchsuxdix says – reply to this


      46

      Re: its a clinger…..
      Look perezie LaBlowhan reads your bloggie blog!
      Woooooooooo WOOOOOOOOO
      You celebucocksuckers are so pathetic and worthless and shoud just really go to college and maybe some where along the line realize that who ever told you flashing your cha cha for the cameras is NOT a lady like thing to do and ultimately will ruin your career when you realize no one wants to buy tickets to see your full feature film with your first authorized full frontal shot in it CAUSE WE ALREADY DONE SEEN YO SNATCH YOU CHILDISH BRAT!
      And p.s. you look like you are on ocke in these pictures. GO TO THERAPY CHILD!

    47. 25beerbelly says – reply to this


      47

      why aren't my fellow homos leaving erotic comments on the can't stand it hotness on models and actors on thequeerofallmedia.com ?

    48. sillyme says – reply to this


      48

      Even if they were still dating, or even engaged, they WEREN'T married. AS usual, the media is making a big deal out of nothing, just to make headlines.

    49. HEB says – reply to this


      49

      K-Fed!

    50. Kelly says – reply to this


      50

      Shouldn't she be trying to get a boyfriend OUT of rehab?? Crazy bitch…

    51. beantown babe says – reply to this


      51

      he looks like corey feldman????

    52. gibblebitch says – reply to this


      52

      isn't there a "rule" in rehab and the 12th step program that it isn't a good idea to become romantically involved with anyone while you are seeking treatment??

    53. Fuck you says – reply to this


      53

      Re: Elisabitchsuxdix

      Fuck off no one want to pary with you or be around your ugly ass that why you talk like that. Your a loser and will be that way forever even your kids will be losers because of you STFU

    54. Kathleen says – reply to this


      54

      Kind of reminds me of federline who left Starr for Britney

    55. Kacky says – reply to this


      55

      wow, a whole week. That's sincere.

    56. Kate says – reply to this


      56

      NEW BRITNEY & KEVIN?????? After the Fries, Frapuccinos & Cheetos….the Lohan babies!!!!! We'll check this later!!!

    57. KML says – reply to this


      57

      I actually believe him… if he was in rehab, chances are… his x-fiance' or what ever she was… could very well have a crazy bitch! He said he was with her for 2 years… and that has to mean she was with him while he was a drug addict! So, in turn, that most likely means that she was a drug addict as well… and it doesn't say anything about her being in rehab with him! So, she is probably a crazy drug addict still!!!

      Just my theory!

    58. LK says – reply to this


      58

      Wow…what a douche! Breaks up with his girlfriend of TWO YEARS and starts dating Lindsay a week later?! She really knows how to pick em.

    59. Elisabitchsuxdix says – reply to this


      59

      Re: Fuck you
      Life is not a party. I dont like children. Talk like what kid? In complete sentences? Dipshit.

      Oh shit, i bet this is little Allie or her brother ist it?
      You guys are too young to be on this site mmm k?
      Ask your mommy to stop looking at herslef in the mirror and take you to school.

      Tell her orange is not a skin color OR a way of life.

    60. camp kitsch says – reply to this


      60

      yeah, and he started dating Lindsay two weeks after he started effing her!Q Ha

    61. Lor says – reply to this


      61

      She is attracted to losers. She needs therapy to find out why (maybe her daddy has something to do with that). He's an unattractive, chunky man who dropped the dime on his 2 year relationship when he met his lottery ticket.

    62. lauren says – reply to this


      62

      That guy looks like he just stepped out of an 80's heavy metal video…DUDE! I guess they deserve each other. I saw Lindsey on Jay Leno once and since seeing her on that show I thought she was just an airhead with a pole stuck up her A**. This girl annoys the sh*t out of me.

    63. kat says – reply to this


      63

      He is fugly.. you cant be a asshole and fugly because then the world will hate you. Only good looking people can be assholes… So fugly boyfriend of lawhorelohan (i cant remember your name your so forgettable) your 15 mins will be up soon. Think about it.

    64. Matt says – reply to this


      64

      Why do all these guys want to "fuck the shit" out of Linsday? I want to beat the shit out of her. Homewrecker.

    65. bottums up says – reply to this


      65

      I need my Lohan drunkity drunk. Cmon girl………. you be sooooooo boring now..

    66. cplusg says – reply to this


      66

      WOW. What a sensitive guy. She sure picked a winner.

    67. ENUOGH ALREADY says – reply to this


      67

      The perfect 'worm' for that vulture….

    68. Katie says – reply to this


      68

      This guy is a FUCKING TOOL! He'll go running back to the other woman as soon as Lindsay dumps him…you watch.

    69. blondjane says – reply to this


      69

      Oh great, just what she needs, a USER AND A LOSER! Hes a dopey mf, was engaged and I just read he gave his ex girl and fake diamond! N I C E!
      Lindsey better get smart and ditch this guy, hes after her fame and her fortune! Hope shes sees thru it all. Your not even supposed to have a relationship during recovery and shes just beginning. Linds, if u read this, ditch the guy, hes trouble! Bree is lucky she found this out now, before she married him! Linds, your can do better too! Fly solo for a while till your get your balance.

    70. Fuck you says – reply to this


      70

      Re: Elisabitchsuxdix

      Your over 30 and commenting about teen pop culture..Hmm.. What a fuckin loser you are. Just because your ugly and no one wants you doesnt give you the right to talk shit.haha bitch

    71. AshtheSmash says – reply to this


      71

      what can you say, the bitch can pick'em.

      now they can sniff coke off eachother's belly's and roll in all her dwindling dough.

      lindsay's a champ. i tell you.

    72. Elisabitchsuxdix says – reply to this


      72

      Re: Fuck you
      Under 30. Calling someone you cant see ugly seems like something a dumb fucken kid would say.
      Make sure you dont forget to fasten your chin strap before you get on the short bus you little retart.
      Anything else?
      I hereby declare you burned in the state of New York.

    73. holly says – reply to this


      73

      what does first mean??

    74. T in the OC says – reply to this


      74

      Not to worry, Linds will dump him a in a few weeks anyway. It's guaranteed.

    75. Natalie says – reply to this


      75

      ok i think we saw how this turned out with britney spears.

    76. JoeBoo says – reply to this


      76

      A junkie wigger is worse than a homo blogger

    77. looloo says – reply to this


      77

      HE IS PROBABLY ONE OF THE UGLIEST GUYS I HAVE EVER SEEN. those sunglasses are like the ones you put on as a joke at a gas station, and nice fucking clothes. What the fuck is she thinking? She doesnt actually have sex with that does she…???

    78. Kat says – reply to this


      78

      how did perez not comment on this trash heap giving THE SHOCKER sign in the picture?!?!?!?! helllooooooo. oh, lindsay…picking up a dude who bangs you in rehab and then gives the shocker symbol in pictures with you. he REALLY respects you. but then again…we all do.

    79. Kat says – reply to this


      79

      how did perez not comment on this trash heap giving THE SHOCKER sign in the picture?!?!?!?! helllooooooo. oh, lindsay…picking up a dude who bangs you in rehab and then gives the shocker symbol in pictures with you. he REALLY respects you.

    80. LH is slutty says – reply to this


      80

      Re: Hey Losers Fuck You!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! – WOW, this must've been Lindsey herself…

    81. Spliff says – reply to this


      81

      CONGRATS!! Lindsay, YOU have found the man of your dreams ;-) Invite me to your wedding…HAHA, wow, she really snagged a winner this time, or should I say "snatched" a winner with her firecrotch??

      xoxo, Spliff

    82. Ashley says – reply to this


      82

      She shouldnt be mad at Lindsay cause her boyfriend is a cheating asshole…be mad at him. Lindsay has no obligation to this girl unlike the boyfriend so its not really Lindsays fault. so bitch should back off. if anyone knows how i can tell her please contact me at levy_ashley@yahoo.com so i can tell her.

    83. bree is FUG- can you blame him? says – reply to this


      83

      The Girl is FUG can you blame him? Really? Please examine the pictures once again- AND she doesn't seem sweet, or kind or dignified. She's one fugly bitch!!

    84. PAtrick says – reply to this


      84

      I love her and I am glad she is doing better. Perez is a fat whore

    85. EmJ says – reply to this


      85

      Re: looloo – A joke at a gas station…hahahaha!

    86. :-) says – reply to this


      86

      She's pregger's…….Just watch!

    87. confused says – reply to this


      87

      what does it mean to say first?

    88. aneurysm says – reply to this


      88

      she busted up one marriage while in there. then riley. so, she steals 'friends' clothes, why not steal women's men. she's vile. & she looks like hell for her age.

    89. Wow says – reply to this


      89

      What a neanderthal, plus he looks retarded in that picture. Look at his face, I don't know if he's laughing or trying to make a weird expression. Either way, he's an ugly bitch.

    90. Tiffany says – reply to this


      90

      He is just using her to become famous. Lindsay is stupid.

    91. marie says – reply to this


      91

      RiLEY IS A ROYAL SCUMBAGGGG

    92. Mysterie says – reply to this


      92

      He's such a f/in liar. The National Enquirer always scoops the other weeklies and I totally believe the guy was engaged and dumped his girl for a ride at the celeb pony farm. The last thing Lindsay needs is to be in a relationship. Focus on urself girl cuz if this boy did this to his fiancee, imagine what's he's going 2 do 2 u. Karma's a bitch and so is Linds!

    93. KHill says – reply to this


      93

      Thank god for Lohan… no more Britney! Also.. I think LL's new bf is lookin for some papparazo attn!

    94. Bitch! says – reply to this


      94

      Ugh, hes so fugly.
      I don't like Lindsay, but seriously? THIS GUY??!
      Hope they have fun makin' ugly babies.