Separated At Birth

Filed under: Anglophilia > Separated At Birth > Mariah Carey > Leona Lewis

Left: the cover for Mariah Carey's first CD. Right: the cover of Leona Lewis' upcoming debut album.

Posted: Oct 23, 2007 at 1:38 am / Email this »

See All 165 Comments

165 comments to “Separated At Birth”

More comments: « 1 [2]

Carla says – reply to this

101

Mariah's looks were much more natural back then. She still looks natural even when she steps out.

Mariah was much more attractive back then, and she's much more attractive nowadays. Excuse my french, but Leona is FUGLY.
epitome of imperfection says – reply to this

102

FUCK ME SIDEWAYS, CAUSE I'M NEVER FIRST.
Both artists are amazing singers. I'll take Leona over Mariah anyday. Mariah can sing her heart out but she's a horrible performer.
I saw Mariah in concert at Jones Beach theater in NY, and I was so disappointed at myself for wasting $120 to see the bloated bitch. She wasted a good 10 minutes talking about her broken nail. (I kid you not) she's a complete waste of time. I liked Mariah once, but now I can't stand her. She seems like the type of bitch that goes around telling herself she's the prettiest of them all, while eating boxes of twinkies.
Juliette says – reply to this

103

Oh,please….theres no comparison,Mariah wishes she was that beautiful!!!!!!!!!!! one is hot and the other (Carey) is FAT and UGLY!!!!!!!!
both ugly yikes! says – reply to this

104

They are both UGLY…one has a year round puffy face, and the other has a puffy gonzo nose.
"another MixedChick" says – reply to this

105

oh so what.
they are both beautiful;
they are both talented;
they are both biracial (which RULES btw); and
they both can sing their asses off!
THEY SHOULD DO A DUET — with Halle Berry as a backup dancer!
(fyi… biracial people don't hate on each other!)
chinamina says – reply to this

106

Ummmmmmmmmm, NO YOU DUMB ASS…why do they look alike because they are both biracial….that is the only fucking comparison. As for the vocals ummmmmmmm NO, LEONA HAS A NICE VOICE BUT SHE ISN'T FUCKING WITH MARIAH…AT LEAST MARIAH HAS A BIT OF SOUL IN HER VOICE.
 says – reply to this

107

Mariah and Leona are living their lives and gettin' paid.
You are writing about their lives and gettin' acid reflux. fools.
Honey says – reply to this

108

Biracial people are the BEST! (Black & White ONLY.)
Uhhh... says – reply to this

109

Perez, ya kinda missed the mark here.
lily says – reply to this

110

Everybody is copyin Mariah!!!! This never ends!!!!!!
pr guru says – reply to this

111

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE………………………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

112

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE………………………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

113

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE………………………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EASTiENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

114

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE……………jj…………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EASTiENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

115

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE……………jj…………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTHH EASTiENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

116

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE……………jj…………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…//
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTHH EASTiENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

117

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE……………jj…………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE.-
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTHH EASTiENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
pr guru says – reply to this

118

leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE……………jj…………..
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EeAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE.-
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTHHH EASTiENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
leona GIVES THE BEST BLOW JOB IN SOUTH EAST ENGLAND,,,TYPICAL HORE…
oliver says – reply to this

119

leona looks better in evry way ! fuck mariah kill yourself
chimp says – reply to this

120

Leona has way too much makeup on. Skin looks blotchy, unnatural.
gaby says – reply to this

121

mariah just looks like a fukin' monkey, really….
leona is gorgeous.
meghan says – reply to this

122

no, they dont really look that much alike
serbian girl says – reply to this

123

leona is beautiful. i hope she will not become crazy like mariah…
PC says – reply to this

124

They don't look a thing alike. Are you kidding?
kerrigwen says – reply to this

125

They don't look anything at all alike.
Mookey says – reply to this

126

MARIAH is THE REAL ARTIST!!!!
me says – reply to this

127

you americans are fucking wierd. who gives a shit if they look/sound the same?! they are both good singers and are pretty so shut the fuck up and get on with your own lives instead of talkin aload of shit about what race they are !!
FrankieLamb#1 says – reply to this

128

I strongly disagree. Aside from the covers having face shot close-ups, they are nothing alike. At all. Mariah is Fierce and this newer girl is definitely not Mariah. Sorry P-dawg….
Qu4ntik says – reply to this

129

uuuuhhhh NOT! I really really don't think mimi looks like Leona… Leona is way too much prettier than mariah.
paranel says – reply to this

130

They couldn't be more different. Where is the similarities ?
Raki says – reply to this

131

At least Mariah's pretty - Leona looks like a farkin' horse with a wig!! Ew
Tara says – reply to this

132

You've GOT to be kidding! These two have nothing in common! That Leona thing is much uglier than Mariah. God, her face is just square! And although Mariah Carey is an arrogant diva nowadays… You just can't deny that she has a incredible voice, and made fantastic song. I haven't even heard of that Leona Lewis before this horrible wrong "separated at birth".
Sherelle says – reply to this

133

What u should have done is compare Leona's cover to a horse ass..lol…
Perez, you can still suck my cock says – reply to this

134

The covers are similar - they both feature screaming, vacant whores who have become (in)famous for their vocal warbling.

Leona looks especially dense. The nose job makes her look less fat in the face, but otherwise you couldn't fuck that even with a paper bag on its head. There is nothing behind the eyes…she's just a bland, unimaginative whoreanus.

I can only who she fades as quickly back into obscurity. She disgusts me with her simpering, whining, nasal screeching. The shy school-girl act doesn't wash with anyone with half a brain, but since most of the people who post here are just as thick as Perez (you know, thick as shit), it really doesn't surprise me half of the stupid cunts below buy into it.
jp says – reply to this

135

yes both ugly but they dont look alike, not even close
Carol C says – reply to this

136

Nice nose job, Leona!
I Absolutly Love Mariah Carey says – reply to this

137

Ok people!!! How can you hate on the one person that can hit a z note and stay there? She has accomplished a lot in life and supports and loves her fans for making her who she is today. Both of these woman are beautiful and yes Perez I can see it. I absolutly love Mariah and if I had all that money I would be exactly like her. And dont try and say you wouldnt bittches…. Everyone that hates Mariah are just jelious… U STUPID DUMB ASS BITTCHES
sweetpetite says – reply to this

138

Artists have come and gone. Mariah is still here.
Leona has a pretty voice but her new video and song are both, forgettable.
rod says – reply to this

139

Noone ever comes close to Mariah!The woman is teh absolute best and she's beautiful and radiant, too!
me says – reply to this

140

Leona looks like a tranny!
juicygirl says – reply to this

141

oh ya but when mariah does something slightly similar to anyone else you wont shut your big fat mouth but when someone copies mariah its no big deal! your too sad!
Leeny says – reply to this

142

Perez, nice try but no. These two look nothing alike. This ridiculous comparison between Leona and Mariah is laughable. If we compare them vocally, there's no match. Mariah is hands down the winner there. But really, it is about talent and that is where Mariah excels. She can not only sang her a$$ off, but also writes AND produces and has from the beginning. No way Leona will be around nor make the impact Mariah has. Again, nice try Perez but NO!
jingles says – reply to this

143

moo moo wishes she was even as close to fine as miss Leona.
Annah says – reply to this

144

I LOOOOVE Leona!!!!! She's so beautiful, and amazing singer and seems like SUCH an absolute sweetheart! LOVE LOVE LOVE you LEONA!!!!
XXXX
katie says – reply to this

145

leona is a poor mans impression of mariah to the sad beat of a celine 90's album track on a whitneys non crack day. good effort but like the album cover the song aint orig and she lacks personality. she shoulda stuck with the sugary r'n'b she recorded before x factor, leona was a cheat she already had a deal!

no one will ever steal mariahs crown!
robin says – reply to this

146

I wonder how Mariah would look now if she'd kept her original looks - she musta had a lot of work done cuz she doesn't remotely resemble the younger her - and Leona is drop dead gorj, in your (surgically reconstructed) face M!
Perez, you can still suck my cock says – reply to this

147

Re: Annah –

Stupid fucking Annah - you fancunts make me sick.
Fuck you the fancunts says – reply to this

148

Re: rebecca –

Another fancunt. Time to close comments, Perez. Maybe you and Leona could hook up and snort something together - oh wait, she can't, because the nose job means she no longer breathes. Hence the reason for all the breathless whining on her album.
Starla says – reply to this

149

THAT is the Mariah Carey that I miss! My how her facial features have transformed over time.
vensal says – reply to this

150

Mariah wishes. Mariah looks like a chipmunck.
Stu says – reply to this

151

Are you fuckin' blind as well as fat and ugly? They look nothing like each other, you must be running out of shit to say. Pratt!
perez is an ass says – reply to this

152

two mixed race women….stop trying to create hate
Meggy says – reply to this

153

Leona is far better talented and beautiful. I watched her on X Factor and she's incredible, Simon was even amazed.
mariah2003 says – reply to this

154

Mariah is beautiful…Leona is terrible!!!
foxtrot says – reply to this

155

first
The honest truth says – reply to this

156

Leona has a nice voice, that is it. If she wanted to make her mark she should have released a debut song to blow all of her peers out of the water. Think Beyonce with "Crazy in Love". Hate her or love her, Beyonce shut down the music industry with a song that people are still jamming to and she has never stopped.

Leona's song is very forgettable. The worse thing is that she is boring and has no personality. If she thinks having Simon's name behind her will propel her to worldwide fame then she has a rude awaekening coming her way. Everyone knows that to make it big, you have to make it in America and you only get one chance to prove yourself. She'll be another Mica Paris and Gabrielle in a heartbeat. She will never get another chance and if Bleeding Love is the best track then the album will tank.

I wish her the very best. She's a sweet girl but sadly I don't think she has what it takes to be a true star. No passion, grit or determination just another boring chick from Hackney
Nada says – reply to this

157

Both amazing! looks and vocal wise.
good for you Leona! wish you all the best! your new video is wicked too!
andj says – reply to this

158

Leona is not pretty. Her picture has been photoshopped.
I saw her on the X factor.
In real life her nose is a bit too big and her face is not symmetrical enough to be called beautiful. She is average looking made to look better with makeup and stylists. Mariah is way better looking - her face has a sweetness or cuteness about it.
misaas says – reply to this

159

YOU KNOW, I FIND IT FUCKING HILARIOUS HOW MARIAH CAREY HAS POSPONED HER ALBUM AND HER FANS AND FELLOW YANKS HAVE NO IDEA WHY!!! OHH COULD IT BE BECAUSE SHE'S SHITTING HERSELF ALONG WITH HER RECORD COMPANY?? SHE DOESNT WANT TO BE SHOWN UP BY LEONA AND HER NEW ALBUM, MARIAH CLEARLY WANTS TO STUDY IT BECAUSE HER ALBUM RUNS THE RISK OF LOOKING LIKE UTTER GARBAGE NEXT TO HERS, SHE WANTS TO SEE IT BEFORE RELEASING HERS!.

THATS RIGHT MARIAH..SHIT YOUR PANTS, YOU SAW LEONA SINGING WITHOUT YOU AND YOU WERE BLOWN AWAY BY IT, LEONA IS YOUNG, HOT, AMAZING LIVE AND ON CD..

THE BRITISH HAVE A HABIT OF SPOTTING HUGE WORDWIDE STARS LONG BEFORE THE YANKS DO,,WE AREN'T THAT DIFFERENT TO YOU..YOU TEND TO LIKE WHAT WE LIKE WHEN IT COMES TO WORLDCLASS SINGERS.
hey says – reply to this

160

i think leona lewis has a great voice, i dont know if she will be a mega superstar cause she might get shit songs to sing, i really hope she makes it big cause she as good as mariah
MrsLV says – reply to this

161

ummmm…i don't see it
JS says – reply to this

162

Leona is an english rose.. with an amazing voice.. their both in totally different legues Leona is british, Mariah is american so thats a big enough difference right there, oh and by the way Clive Owen who is american rang Simon Cowell to ask if he could work with her so.. its you americans who are trying to steal our talent x
eejhay says – reply to this

163

Re: chumbura – ur so wrong……… it sold over 9,000,000 copies in the US alone!
madi says – reply to this

164

I love Mariah (I bought all her albums) but Leona also has a similar voice - a combination of Mariah and Whitney - listen to her song 'A Moment Like This" and see if you agree. Leona seems a shy person and not aware of her talent (unlike Mariah!)
buzz says – reply to this

165

Re: pr guru – its whore you thick moron in your sad ass pathetic dreams………… as if