The First Reviews Are In

Filed under: Whitney Houston

76990132_10.jpg

Miz Whitney Houston performed her big comeback concert at the Live & Loud music festival in Malaysia this weekend, and lucky PerezHilton.com reader Kyle was able to attend.

Here are his thoughts on the show:

"Hey P!

My name's Kyle and I just came back from the Live&Loud Music Festival in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia on Saturday where Whitney Houston performed and made one of her first comeback shows. I could tell, the people went there just to see Whitney and even my partner and I forked out around USD$900 for the tickets. We were all up to see Whitney and arrived around 7.00pm when Elliot Yamin was performing. We waited and waited and finally Whitney came in around midnight with a silver top, matching pants and white trench coat. She sounded ok but her voice got husky and apparently she couldn't hit all the high notes in her top songs. She even sounded like Amy Winehouse at times! She told the audience she's dropping a new album soon and during rendering 'My Love is Your Love', her daughter joined her on stage to sing a duet. Overall, the performance was great but the voice was just ok. In fact, thousands who waited patiently since afternoon to see Whitney, sort of disappointed with that and left after she sang 3-4 songs. As much as I enjoyed the show, I must admit that I expect more of her. Perhaps she'll get better with time!

Cheers,
Kyle
Kuala Lumpur

PS: I'm sorry I couldn't attach any video of the performance because the organizer warned the audience [3 times] that no recording or photographing is allowed during her performance. This didn't apply when Shaggy, Elliot Yamin and others were performing prior to her! Seems like she's still a diva after all!"

[Photo via Getty Images.]

    Posted: Dec 1, 2007 at 3:49 pm / Email this  »

    141 comments to “The First Reviews Are In”

    More comments: [1] 2 »

    1. FIRST!!!!@ says – reply to this


      1

      first!

    2. sean who? says – reply to this


      2

      bitch is old and done

    3. ick says – reply to this


      3

      30th

    4. Amanda says – reply to this


      4

      Love Whitney!

    5. sean who? says – reply to this


      5

      she's still a crackwhore

    6. L says – reply to this


      6

      She's looking good

    7. first says – reply to this


      7

      FIRST!

    8. ANDYBEAR says – reply to this


      8

      DANIELLE SMELLS

    9. yvette says – reply to this


      9

      First!

    10. crack anyone?? says – reply to this


      10

      whitney is crackish!!!!

    11. mira says – reply to this


      11

      she is a surviver, she will do it right

    12. Lol says – reply to this


      12

      What a hag.

    13. . says – reply to this


      13

      ??????

    14. lala says – reply to this


      14

      FIRST!?

    15. lala says – reply to this


      15

      FIRST!?

    16. one says – reply to this


      16

      #1

    17. bobby says – reply to this


      17

      much more fun to bust on brit & paris
      hollywoodpizzatshirts com

    18. nat z says – reply to this


      18

      first!

    19. Crackhead says – reply to this


      19

      Sucking on that crack pipe for years ruin her voice…Hey Perez why didnt you scream take her KID away SINCE SHE IS A KNOWN FUCKING CRACKHEAD ….

    20. Meghan says – reply to this


      20

      FIRST
      It's whitney bitch

    21. donnie says – reply to this


      21

      first

    22. JM says – reply to this


      22

      first?

    23. ur whack says – reply to this


      23

      Crack is whack - and so is Whitney.

      Dirty Bobby sucked all the talent, spirit, life, etc out of her - he ruined her career and now he's living out of his car and going to court for alimony. Nice

    24. sasssssha says – reply to this


      24

      Post about Evil Kinevil! Dead at 69 :(

    25. Lovewhitney says – reply to this


      25

      Give her a break, she'll improve in time. Drugs have messed up her voice, but hopefully she'll be back in full swing, she looks awesome!

    26. Anthony says – reply to this


      26

      She'll get better. It's been forever since she's performed. She'll get her groove back!

    27. WhitBrit Connection? says – reply to this


      27

      Re: Meghan – Ha! Good one!!

    28. Jason says – reply to this


      28

      This makes me kind of sad, she might get better with time but will never get her "I Will Always Love You" voice back. She used to be the best, even better than Mariah but now it sounds like she more in Beyonces league

    29. booyah says – reply to this


      29

      She was like that in the eighties, three or four songs, couldn't hit all the notes, or do more than one "run", definitely a disappointment. That is when I learned they fix it in the mix, pull different lines and make one track.

    30. Vageen says – reply to this


      30

      Give it time. Mary J. did a ton of drugs too, and she got a lot of her voice back. Let's hope Whitney can do the same.

      Leaving Bobby and getting clean and sober was a huge first step, and recovery takes time. If she never sang again but lived a happy and clean life, then it's victory in my eyes.

    31. Joy in Virginia says – reply to this


      31

      Forget about Whitney! I want to hear more about that adorable Elliott Yamin! I live near Richmond VA and Elliott is like our local boy all growed up and done good, and his mother is SOOO adorable too! Rooting for Elliott when he was on American Idol really energized our whole town. I have had the pleasure of seeing Elliott perform live three times now and he puts on a terrific live show. He really, sincerely appreciates his fans and is grateful for the opportunity to entertain people and make a living with his music.

    32. geo says – reply to this


      32

      900 bux? who is an idiot??
      pathetic waste of money when there are poor people right next door in indonesia.
      REALLY PATHETIC!!!!!!!!!!!!

    33. Christine says – reply to this


      33

      HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!! Did she honestly think the years of abuse she put her body through wouldn't come at a price! She's a stupid bitch who's career was over a long time ago. I just hope people are not naive enough to shell out their hard earned money on her.

    34. Lisalu says – reply to this


      34

      Aww, keep it up, Whitney! I have hoped for her to clean up and get back to her music for a long time. I am rooting for you, Whitney!!

    35. datahomi says – reply to this


      35

      i was there. and yes people started leaving right after the very first few songs.. apparently people are really dissapointed. Whitney even had a long pause before hitting the last verse of 'i'll always love you'

      there's an encore at the end of the show where she sang 'im every woman'

    36. Soul Music says – reply to this


      36

      I would rather wait until she drops the album before I count her out. Whitney is God's child, She will be back….u wait…

    37. kandykane8816 says – reply to this


      37

      PEREZ HILTON IS A LIAR!

    38. WHITNEY'S A BITCH says – reply to this


      38

      Years ago, I bought tickets for my parents to see her on Fathers Day at Nassau Coliseum In NY. They planned their day around the concert. They went there, got to their seats, only to hear an announcement that she canceled…. ten minutes after the show should have started. WHAT AN UNGRATEFUL, SELFISH GREEDY BITCH!!!! I hope her comeback fails. KARMAS A BITCH WHITNEY!!!!

    39. sexalicouss says – reply to this


      39

      PEREZ..or whatever you real mexican name is !
      Do you actually read the comments people write?!@! all 1 billon… I wonder… Well I love you and hope you see this, cant wait till your sepcial on vh1, why dont they give you your own show already!!? like a weekly one!!! omgggg. it would be too fab.

      Byeee.

    40. Igor says – reply to this


      40

      there are also very positive reviews from people who really was there! im reading Whitney forums now. of course Perez had t post the negative one!

    41. Wendy says – reply to this


      41

      I knew Whitney was making huge mistake when she married Bobby Brown. Can you say "loser", she was slumming for sure. Now that she finally dumped that dead weight, she can get herself together. I hope so I love Whitney! She's still awesome in my book!

    42. rick says – reply to this


      42

      i agree, all that crack did her voice in.

    43. Whitney forums? Get the fuck outta here! says – reply to this


      43

      Re: Igor

      You said it all right there. You are reading the Whitney forums. The very same bullshit people that put their heads in the sand with anything they don't like concerning Whitney. The same folks who said she was never on drugs years ago when everyone knew that she was. You people kill me with that shit. Perez has been doing nothing but elevating this woman for the past three months. Why in the hell would he want to just trash her now? Give me a break. Her voice will never be the same. She has had almost two years of rest and her voice still is questionable. The damage has been done. The damage doesn't just go away. It's sad but it's true. And in the end, no one is to blame, except Whitney herself. I am glad she is clean, but the facts are the facts.

    44. gossipmonger says – reply to this


      44

      Damn, that is so sad, I was really hoping Whitney could get back to her pre-Bobby/pre-crack days, and still bring The Voice. I hope she gets better, but it sounds to me as though hitting the crackpipe cracked her pipes.

    45. CRACK ATTACK says – reply to this


      45

      CRACK IS WACK AND WILL AGE U

    46. piazzasbuttplug says – reply to this


      46

      I'll lube her throat after she gums me and then I'll see if I can get her up an octave while assisting her with her Kegal exercises.

    47. Igor says – reply to this


      47

      Re: Whitney forums? Get the fuck outta here!
      and now listen you! Whitney fans the most Whitney haters in good morning! they are always not happy and expect only perfection from her!!! there are more negative stuff on her primary from her fans than anywhere else! and if some of them who was really there wrote she was great then it could be like this, idiot!!!!

    48. Sarah says – reply to this


      48

      Why would "Kyle", our friend in Malaysia pay $900 USD to see her, think how much crack she could buy for that.
      What a douche…both of them!

    49. yours says – reply to this


      49
    50. Scott R says – reply to this


      50

      She is still my favorite. Maybe she is not as great as she was 10-15 years ago…neither am I!

    51. lovebrad says – reply to this


      51

      I hope she gets her voice back.

    52. $900???? says – reply to this


      52

      $900 to see someone who hasn't had a hit in years??? You must be crazy!

    53. lovebrad says – reply to this


      53

      imagine the horror if they had recorded the whole thing. lol

    54. Jason says – reply to this


      54

      SHE IS BACK AND ITS GOING 2 BE FIERCE

    55. Dina says – reply to this


      55

      Igor, the shit you just posted doesn't even make sense. Try to improve your english skills and refrain from forcing your fanatic opinion down everyone's throats. Fool!

    56. tjollan says – reply to this


      56

      Igor!! Say what? Hello "any one home?"

    57. pa says – reply to this


      57

      viva whitney !!! guapaa!!

    58. "IWANNAFUCKWITHSOMBODY!" says – reply to this


      58

      ………SOMEBODY SAID HER VOICE 'CRACKED' …..HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA..TOO FUCKING FUNNY!
      ……….THE WOMAN ONCE HAD A RARE GIFT, A DAMNED VOICE OF GOD, AND NOW, ALAS, IT IS JUST A GODDAMNED VOICE!!!! TSK TSK!
      ……….GUESS WHITNEY NEEDS BOBBY BACK TO BEAT THE HELL OUT OF HER, GET HER SOME GOOD DRUGS AND WARM THAT SCREAMING VOICE UP…… CAUSE, NOBODY CAN SHOUT "KISS MY ASS!" LIKE WHITNEY! GO GURL!

      ……YA KNOW….WHITNEY CAN ALWAYS SING FOR COCA-COLA, THEIR NEW CAMPAIGN IS "THE COKE SIDE OF LIFE" DOOOOOOOOH!

    59. She's bald says – reply to this


      59

      I was never a fan of hers and after that disgusting reality show she did I can't even look at her without getting all skeeved out. Whitney's music is banal garbage just like Mariah's. Where is the soul? What a pity she ruined her voice with all that crack. Nice wig Whitney.

    60. Hiya says – reply to this


      60

      Elliott Yamin is terrific. If you guys aren't familiar with him go download his song "Movin on"…it's really good.

    61. Sorry Britney, but... says – reply to this


      61

      At least Whitney had the sense to perform her big "comeback" on a small platform, not on National Television. Now hopefully she knows that she isn't quite ready for the cruel American audiences.

    62. Denis H says – reply to this


      62

      I wouldn't walk across the street that hack for free

    63. KD says – reply to this


      63

      Poor Thing,

      She truly TORCHED her vocal cords with that Crack Pipe. For the love of god I do not understand these crazy ass Celebs who have everything anyone could ever ask for and choose to throw it all away for DRUGS!!!!

    64. Lori says – reply to this


      64

      What a terrible waste. I just saw her on "My Grammy Night" (or something) and she was AWESOME! Drugs will destroy your life . . . and your voice.

      I wondered why it was taking so long to get her album out. Now I know.

    65. Lori says – reply to this


      65

      What a terrible waste. I just saw her on "My Grammy Night" (or something) and she was AWESOME! Drugs will destroy your life . . . and your voice.

      I wondered why it was taking so long to get her album out. Now I know.

    66. Shireen says – reply to this


      66

      dude I noticed that here voice had gotten super husky too. years of inhaling cocaine fumes will probably do that to you.
      crack is wack, my friends.

    67. Shireen says – reply to this


      67

      dude I noticed that her voice had gotten super husky too. years of inhaling cocaine fumes will probably do that to you.
      crack is wack, my friends.

    68. Shireen says – reply to this


      68

      dude I noticed that her voice had gotten super husky too. years of inhaling cocaine fumes will probably do that to you.
      crack is wack, my friends.

    69. BobZ says – reply to this


      69

      Umm..Is Kyle hot ? I think that is the only thing that matters.

    70. Linda says – reply to this


      70

      Perez we got a new name 4 ya. Latin Style Perezioso! Cono! Whitney u da mama but ur vocals better be a little sum sum on CHACHO! www.1wpmusic.com

    71. Ephriam says – reply to this


      71

      whitney u ar e the best the dd it and the best that ever will forget these haters tellin them to check your track record

    72. shazzmatazz says – reply to this


      72

      OMG. Whitney tanked BIG TIME.

      I was there are sat (on the grass) throughout the pretty tedious crap from the local Malaysian artistes all evening just so I could see Whitney perform on stage - it's always been a dream on mine to see her live in concert - and when she finally came on AN HOUR after Shaggy said goodbye (HE was great, by the way), we were really disappointed with her voice and performance. My husband, and he should know, pretty much thought she was high on something, just from her gestures, I just thought she'd lost the plot. At one point during her second number, she pulled her trenchcoat aside and started scratching her fat ass tummy (my she got fat!) in an absentminded way and a few people next to me, my husband included, exchanged surprised looks, like 'what the fu-'??!!! Yeah, it was BIZARRE. She kept doing that and we sort of got fed up and left after 5 songs. We felt really sad for WH, because unlike Britney Spears, she actually had a lot of talent and let life on drugs take it over. Britney on the other hand, was a good laugh during her comeback bid and will remain so for a long long time, if not forever, unless she cleans up her act. Poor Whitney.

    73. anonymous says – reply to this


      73

      perez wrote this review himself. Don't believe the hype.

    74. benjamin says – reply to this


      74

      malaysia rock !!!!!!!!!

    75. urworstnightmare says – reply to this


      75

      SHE SMELLS LIKE CRACK

    76. Eric says – reply to this


      76

      Whitney who ???

      The old bag has been gone so long I forget who she is. Oh yeah, the crack head !!

    77. alternate says – reply to this


      77

      I felt bad for Kyle, I got the elite pass tickets for free, and so did the people who sat around us. Thank God I didn't pay for them though, the food and drinks was overpriced and the hour wait in between every segments are a fucking joke. Anywho, back to Whitney's performence. I left after she did 3 songs. The performence itself was BORING, but Whitney herself was great. Eventhough she couldn't hit all the high notes but her voice was still there. She has put on abit of weight on her too! It was definately surreal the first time she came out. Too bad everyone was too exhausted by the time her segments came on.

    78. daniel ali aman says – reply to this


      78

      I think you all have no respect.

      sometimes we are confronted with situations in live which are just to much, therefore we act stupid. But at this point in time it was the only way to act or re-act. WH had a very difficult time (an no, it has nothing to do with money), she was just in love with a man that miss-leaded her all the way…

      What stupid things you did for love…?

      I also think no one in this post knows what it means to be a "crack-head".

      Again, respect for WH, she is trying to get back her live.
      WH knows that she sounds bad but she fights and that is good.

      Never stop fighting.

      And yes i left early too, but not because i was upset or disappointed, it was because i felt very sad and disturbed.

      And again don't judge drug addicts, trust me it can happen to anyone of you…

      There where only a couple of negative things at this openair:

      - no beer
      - no parking (can you believe that a concert is hosted on a Polo field without parking… Malaysia truly Asia… smile)
      - to many malaysian "hotel" singers

      Have a great sunday

      Cheers
      Daniel

    79. anna says – reply to this


      79

      perez is lame for not posting
      check out drunkenstepfather.com

      all kinds of celeb nudes and stuff

    80. WakeUpCall says – reply to this


      80

      people r so critical of whitney. no artist's voice will stay the same forever. she is in her mid forties and she hasn't performed for years. the songs she has sung in here career, no one else can ever duplicate though many have tried. even if she never met bobby brown, her voice will still have changed as she got older. the vocal chords r like any other musle, u don't use them on a regular basis u lose them, but with regular performing she will strengthen them again. at least she is not lip syncing like everyone else.

    81. here's a wake up call for you says – reply to this


      81

      Re: WakeUpCall

      Yeah, her voice would change, but it wouldn't be completely shot. Quit making excuses for her. She destroyed her gift. Plain and simple.

    82. bobby b says – reply to this


      82

      Elliot Y. (snaggletooth) does whitney in the bung hole

    83. tony says – reply to this


      83

      lol so kyle asked each of the 'thousands who waited for her' what they thought??!!

    84. DAWN DAVENPORT says – reply to this


      84

      I HOPE SHE FINDS HER PIPE, HITS IT, PULLS OUT HER TEETH, RIPS OFF HER WIG AND GOES RUNNING THROUGH THE STREETS. THAT IS THE CRACK ASS WHITNEY I LOVE.
      IF THIS COMEBACK FAILS SHE WILL FIND JESUS, RECORD A GOSPEL CD, TELL US HOW GREAT GOD AND JESUS AND BABY JESUS AND JESUS’ MAMA AND PAPA ARE, AND HOW JESUS IS THE MAN, AND HOW MUCH SHE WANTS TO SLEEP WITH JESUS, AND THAT ALL THE GAYS WHO SUPPORTED HER ARE EVIL BECAUSE JESUS TOLD HER WHEN SHE WAS THINKING ABOUT HIM GETTING ALL UP INSIDE HER.
      FUCK WHITNEY AND FUCK JESUS!

    85. kat says – reply to this


      85

      she was the best. Don't know now. When she got together and married BB, I knew it was the beginning of the end for her. I hope her voice improves. At one time, there was none better. So sad if drugs ruined her. Time will tell…

    86. FAT ASS Perez says – reply to this


      86

      Stupid bitch, her days are numbered. Her talent is gone. She didn't appreciate it, thought she could call on it anytime. She should lose her Diva attitude, like she lost her money, teeth and TALENT. Ungrateful Bitch. Didn't realize what a blessing she had!!!

    87. kelly day says – reply to this


      87

      The songs she's known for are hard to sing, you have to belt them out. All singers, over time learn to adjust, lower the key, etc. If you've noticed Celine has 'lightened' up, too. She might surprise us, let's hope so.

    88. TOM CRUISE AND RYAN SEACREST ARE CLOSETED FUDGE PACKERS says – reply to this


      88

      SHE WILL ALWAYS BE A FUCKED-UP CRACK-HEAD TO ME….

    89. TOM CRUISE AND RYAN SEACREST ARE CLOSETED FUDGE PACKERS says – reply to this


      89

      SHE WILL ALWAYS BE A FUCKED-UP CRACK-HEAD TO ME….

    90. -WTF;; says – reply to this


      90

      MMMMM.
      I like her weave..

    91. niki says – reply to this


      91

      it sounds 2 me like this guy who watched the show couldnt make up his mind…i bet she did good but he just wants to give a bad review..but of course i wasnt there and i hate her music n e ways..

    92. SB says – reply to this


      92

      It's going to be a long road back for Whitney, but she can make it. Seriously. Look at Mariah Carey. After she had meltdown, she never sang as well again. Her last album, while wildly popular, showed her higher notes got a whole lot breathier and less stable and those top high notes are pretty much gone. She still had one of the biggest CDs of her career.

    93. Joshua says – reply to this


      93

      I hope Whitney can do it. The gays are rootin' for you!

    94. Aubrey says – reply to this


      94

      Get better with tme? She's like 60 years old now. How much time is really left? She was better before. Before she married Bobby, Before "crack is wack." In essense, before the train wreck. She had an incredible God-given gift in that voice she had the potential to be amazing, she could have had a carreer to rival Strisand's, but she took it for granted, squandered it with her selfish obsession to a no-good-looser of a husband and drugs. I feel sorry for that little girl Bobbi to have grown up in that chaos. Whitney has finally come to her senses, but those years have not been without sacrifice, her looks, her voice, the public opinion and respect. There are some things you throw away and can never get back.

    95. Christina who saw Whitney in Malaysia says – reply to this


      95

      Whitney may not have been able to hit the high notes like she used to, but her voice is still powerful and undeniably "Whitney". She looked beautiful and her performance was flawless. I stayed till the end even though I got in for free. Those who weren't there should be the last to talk about Whitney!! And if you dislike her so much, why do you even want to comment about her voice, her life, her profession…even her right to keep her kid? (who by the way looked very sweet, and both looked like they love each other very much)

      P/S: Some of you are seriously nasty.

    96. pamik27 says – reply to this


      96

      Maybe they should have had Whitney open for Elliott Yamin, instead of the other way around? Elliott may have come out of the American Idol mediocrity machine, but he is a rare talent. His CD is good, but his voice live is even better.

    97. clinton says – reply to this


      97

      I am sure whitney did well .It was not a full concert. and who knows wheter your critic is tone deft or not .. she is in malaysia.. the dont speak ENGRISH very well. i am sure Whitney say as well as she is looking these days. She is the greatest voice of all.. so eat that Celine.

    98. kuala lumpur bitch says – reply to this


      98

      shaggy rocked live & loud way more that whitney!

    99. mar says – reply to this


      99

      did you really expect her to ever have "the voice" after all the drugs she's done??????

    100. mar says – reply to this


      100

      did you really expect her to ever have "the voice" after all the drugs she's done??????

    More comments: [1] 2 »