The First Reviews Are In

Filed under: Whitney Houston

76990132_10.jpg

Miz Whitney Houston performed her big comeback concert at the Live & Loud music festival in Malaysia this weekend, and lucky PerezHilton.com reader Kyle was able to attend.

Here are his thoughts on the show:

"Hey P!

My name's Kyle and I just came back from the Live&Loud Music Festival in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia on Saturday where Whitney Houston performed and made one of her first comeback shows. I could tell, the people went there just to see Whitney and even my partner and I forked out around USD$900 for the tickets. We were all up to see Whitney and arrived around 7.00pm when Elliot Yamin was performing. We waited and waited and finally Whitney came in around midnight with a silver top, matching pants and white trench coat. She sounded ok but her voice got husky and apparently she couldn't hit all the high notes in her top songs. She even sounded like Amy Winehouse at times! She told the audience she's dropping a new album soon and during rendering 'My Love is Your Love', her daughter joined her on stage to sing a duet. Overall, the performance was great but the voice was just ok. In fact, thousands who waited patiently since afternoon to see Whitney, sort of disappointed with that and left after she sang 3-4 songs. As much as I enjoyed the show, I must admit that I expect more of her. Perhaps she'll get better with time!

Cheers,
Kyle
Kuala Lumpur

PS: I'm sorry I couldn't attach any video of the performance because the organizer warned the audience [3 times] that no recording or photographing is allowed during her performance. This didn't apply when Shaggy, Elliot Yamin and others were performing prior to her! Seems like she's still a diva after all!"

[Photo via Getty Images.]

    Posted: Dec 1, 2007 at 3:49 pm / Email this  »

    141 comments to “The First Reviews Are In”

    More comments: « 1 [2]

    1. The Emperor says – reply to this


      101

      Well, she was a messed last night !! It was a disaster!! She appeared with all matching silver colour and she looked like she is pregnant (you will never believe it, she look like those British men with the beer belly!) Second apprearence with the purple dress and she kept on stepped on the dress!! My fellow friends agreed that she kinda losing plot and she doesnt look that confident anymore still Whitney thanks for coming …

      PS : I prefer Shaggy performance than yours though, at least they communicate with the audiences

    2. Wake Up Call says – reply to this


      102

      Re: Amanda – hello

    3. jenbunny says – reply to this


      103

      whitney's appearance on american dad really spoke to me.

    4. Pinche Cagon says – reply to this


      104

      First! I'm first you dirty bitches! Now bend over and take it like a Catholic! Cause I'm first!

    5. robert says – reply to this


      105

      Good show. Definitely the best on the bill. Everyone was good but she was just in a different league. Her voice was really better than any singer I have heard live especially recently. And I was really listening. There's so much crap I wanted to see and hear for myself. The notes were controlled and full. She seemed to sing lower than her records but this girl is definitely one of the best. Saw a few other "divas" this year and she was better than all of them. Liked the way she didn't have the backup singers drown her out on the difficult parts of the song. If she missed a note you heard it. That's what I pay my money for. She looked good but with all the recent pictures that was expected. I will definitely buy her new cd

    6. skim says – reply to this


      106

      Re: clinton – FUCK U. DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHERE MALAYSIA IS YOU RETARDED AMERICAN

    7. malaysia is better than singapore! says – reply to this


      107

      whitney was ok. I was just glad to see her perform again after all these years and it was a pity she started too late in the evening (12.30am for god's sake), I think more people would've stayed on. I agree with what daniel ali aman said. don't judge. thanks.

    8. audrey says – reply to this


      108

      i was there, too. and we were all cheering for her. its the first time she's here, so we were really psyched. the crowd was chanting her name, and singing along to all her songs. she even came back for an encore. her purple dress was magnificent, while her first outfit did not do her body much justice. its great to see her up and healthy again, though she put on quite abit of weight. i enjoyed it very much, as her voice is just gorgeous. whitney rocked last night.

    9. citizenx says – reply to this


      109

      I just wanted her to come back STRONG

      .. still hoping
      for a US blowout

    10. who? says – reply to this


      110

      its not even her own concert, thrs elliot yamin, shaggy etc. and the tickets is not really 900 bucks per tickets! maybe she brought alot of frenz…..TAKE NOTE! the tickets are not really that expensive….(for seeing 3 or 4 international artists in one concert)!

    11. franc says – reply to this


      111

      I saw her live a few times before she was married. Had a great voice, a nice persona, but was not a good performer. Some can sing and perform (Celine), some can't do both.

    12. Liana says – reply to this


      112

      I was there and I left after Heartbreak hotel…I was there since 3pm and left around 1. The setup was reallllyyyy slow….more then 30 mins for Whitney's performance…Despite waiting so long, i was dissapointed enough to leave :D ..she looked unfit too..spotted a tummy like britney's during the VMA'S…oh but the tickets were RM260…which is around USD 68….

    13. Cym says – reply to this


      113

      I was there, and I felt bad for Kyle too… USD 900 for tickets? The normal pass was selling at MYR 262 which is approx USD 78 and the elite pass was at MYR 500 (approx 150) so how did the figure USD 900 came about?

      Anyway, the overall it was great, Shaggy was da BOMB! Whitney was alright. The fans expect her to sing lots of the songs that she was best known for (eg: I will always love you, where do broken hearts go, one moment in time, saving all my love for you) but she did sing some of those but she also did songs like heartbreak hotel and it's not right but it's ok… which arent her trademark songs. And that was when people start to leave. But she closed the show with a bang with I will always love you and im every woman.

    14. nadine says – reply to this


      114

      hey, im from sydney and i was there in KL to catch whitney. i got the vip pass which was MYR1200 and approx USD800-900…pretty much like kyle said. i kinda agree with kyle..although she still can sing, it wasnt a great performance after all..elliot n shaggy did better..but i like KL very much! xoxo

    15. Michelle says – reply to this


      115

      Good for her to get up there and try it again! We will have to wait to get the rest of th reviews to actually get the full story. But I think it's fantastic she is trying to make a comeback, and she's doing it smll and working upwards… hopefully! I know someone who should have a lot more class like Whitney.

    16. Marianne says – reply to this


      116

      Sh looks beautiful, she seems to have come a long way. But some of Whitney's newly conquered demons are pretty tough on the voice, lets hope with time…………..( okay, a girl can dream)

    17. Mike says – reply to this


      117

      The Woman is the greatest VOICE of our time, Welcome Back Whitney, this is pnly the begining…

    18. fake! says – reply to this


      118

      that review is not real, she sung about 15 songs including Step By Step, Its Not Right But Its Okay, I Will Always Love You, Greatest Love Of All, I Wanna Dance With Somebody, How Will I Know etc…

      that "kyle" is talking shit!! i have the audio and so do many other people!!!

      REMOVE IT!

    19. she's fat says – reply to this


      119

      it's a little known secret that whitney houston has been a chain smoker of cigarettes since the 80's. of course she's going to sounds like crap after all the years of smoking cigarettes, and the weed she smoked. i don't know if she smoked crack but she got busted with weed so i'm assuming she was smoking it. smoking is lame.

    20. Lesa says – reply to this


      120

      Her problem was too much money and DRUGS!! She has ruined her vocal chords and will never sing well again.

    21. Chino says – reply to this


      121

      Too sad to hear that Witney's voice is in such disrepair. This was truly one of the best voices to come along in the 80's; smooth, velvety with a glorious golden sheen. I used to sing and know for a fact that voices perish if you (as I did) do not take good care of your health. There are other reasons, too. Even if her range has become shorter, she could coach with an excellent vocal coach and maybe, maybe get something back. Do not chastise her for what she went through. WE ALL MAKE MISTAKES.

    22. shutup! says – reply to this


      122

      Re: The Emperor

      shutup u ideot, learn to speak english, and learn to give a proper review, thats a load of crap. ive listened to all the audio and she wasnt bad at all!!! she looked good, and she wasnt wearing all silver, she wore a white coat with silver top and leather trousers, then she came out in a purple dress… she was good!!!!!! no ones voice stays the same forever!!!! WHITNEY WE LOVE YOU

    23. hates retarded people like dawn davenport (i'm sure they used a fake name and is probably a hick) says – reply to this


      123

      Re: DAWN DAVENPORT

      Fuck you!! I'm no Whitney fan, I don't even listen to that kind of music nor care AT ALL about her. But your stupid ass rantings about Jesus go way too far. No one is impressed and could give a shit about your retarded comments. Hell, I don't even go to church, but was highly offended by what you said. You are nothing but a sorry sack of shit that probably worships Marilyn Manson and his queer ass music (no offense to the gay and lesbian people, that's just how people from massachusetts call something stupid). I bet you are one of those retarded EMO people that cuts themselves, too. LOSER! I hate people who preach, but NEVER….NEVER do I disrespect ANYONES religion and beliefs, unless ofcourse its a fucking flamer like you. I hope that EVERY SINGLE born again christian and johovahs witness in the world knocks on your door three times a day for the rest of your sorry life and BEATS YOU WITH THEIR JESUS STICK!!

    24. kimberlycun says – reply to this


      124

      the usd 900 bucks are designated seats for the cushy rich at the back of the free standing section. of course it got boring after a while! i had the freestanding tix, right in front of the stage, so i was prolly 10 feet away from her. she was amazing! true, her voice wasnt how it used to be, but it's far from a shabby debut after such a difficult time…she was great and professional.

    25. crazymommylady says – reply to this


      125

      This is why I want to raise my children to hate those lazy crack smoking blacks like whitney. I am half black and it doesn't seem to matter how much I scrub, it just won't come off.

    26. tonadachi says – reply to this


      126

      c'mon Whitney, girl! Keep 'er goin! You're comin from behind and making momentum. I'm on your side. You're a class act who got in with some bad people. Straighten the ship and full steam ahead!

    27. Sugar Nips says – reply to this


      127

      Anyone notice her HUGE Adam's apple in that pictures? Holy tits!

    28. Sugar Nips says – reply to this


      128

      Anyone notice her HUGE Adam's apple in that picture? Holy tits!

    29. Sugar Nips says – reply to this


      129

      Anyone notice her HUGE Adam's apple in that picture? Holy tits!

    30. hanibuns says – reply to this


      130

      Love her to bits! I was there as well, watched her performed..but i agree with Kyle..she couldnt hit any high notes. OMG! seriously..she looked like she was trippin' on something! Anyway i will give her credit for trying!

    31. JM says – reply to this


      131

      leave whitney alone

    32. lulz says – reply to this


      132

      Most expensive tickets were RM 1,500 each. That's approx USD 450
      My ticket cost RM 500, approx USD 150 and I got it for FREEEEEEEEEE
      Shaggy rocked.

    33. Ayesha says – reply to this


      133

      It was 450USD perperson… for the whole festival pass. thats for 10 days. With Dionne Warwick and James Morrison + some other Motown artist.

      The whitney show (top of pops) was actually only 300 Ringgit which is like 90usd

    34. allene says – reply to this


      134

      she's the original Unfitney

    35. Another Nobody says – reply to this


      135

      Love Whitney. Always have, always will!

    36. Carla says – reply to this


      136

      Whitney is a singing legend but her voice isn't what it used to be. Still wish her well in her comeback as she is still probably better than some of today's so-called "stars". Elliott Yamin has the best sounding voice I've heard since Whitney was at her peak and that's been awhile! And he sings just as good or better live than recorded–quite possibly one of the best voices of all time. I expect we'll be seeing and hearing him all over creation.

    37. ME says – reply to this


      137

      Well, I hope she gets better. The last time she was in Hawai‘i (early 90s, I think), my mom and her friends went to the sold-out concert. My mom said that Whitney was stinking up the place. She couldn't reach her notes, was huffing and puffing on stage… Then, Bobby Brown came out (my mom had NO IDEA who he was) and started performing. According to everyone who went, he saved the show and Whitney's face. How ironic…

    38. joeyOh says – reply to this


      138

      They did a great job on her teeth, cause they were all gone before from the crystal and crack. Amazin'

    39. joeyOh says – reply to this


      139

      They did a great job on her teeth, cause they were all gone before from the crystal and crack. Amazin'

    40. Raymond says – reply to this


      140

      Re: Whitney forums? Get the fuck outta here! – The last 2 years for Whitney has hardly been rest. Have we forgot that she has gone through a divorce. As much as you people trash her, you forget love is love. She loved the man and its over. Shes now back on her own. You dont just jump back into the groove that easily. I listened. She is definitely on her way back. It will take time and a new cd. Some of these comments are heartless and you all talk as if you know her. Some of you are sick and god forbid that the trials of life come knocking at your door. Lets see how you do! lol.

    41. Bill says – reply to this


      141

      Re: Liana

      Liar! Of course you were there. Some of you will resort to anything to spread negativity on this woman.

    More comments: « 1 [2]