Miley Killed Christmas!

Filed under: Icky Icky Poo > Mariah Carey > Miley Cyrus > Jonas Brothers

Miley Cyrus did the worst cover of All I Want For Christmas on Disney's ABC parade special.

Awful, awful, awful!!

How could you do that to Mariah??? And us!

Click here to check out the whoreanusness.

At least the Jonas Brothers gave a lovely (albeit lipsynched) performance.

Click here to watch them do Girl Of My Dreams.

Yay!

Posted: Dec 25, 2007 at 2:10 pm / Email this »

See All 1169 Comments

1169 comments to “Miley Killed Christmas!”

More comments: « 1 … 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 12 »

Christine says – reply to this

801

wow, that was REALLY BAD. if that was the first song you ever heard from miley, i would never listen to her again.

and i really won't because she sucks.
krystal says – reply to this

802

#29 is a fuckinq hater #31 is a jackass she can never be better than the oriqinal singer stupida thatb bitch is probably tina from youtube lol =] love you perez
Marco says – reply to this

803

i loved that cover…it was cool that she didn't sing it like mariah carey b/c sometimes mariah goes way over the top…miley's was clean and simple but good… i like how she sings things the way she wants
aly says – reply to this

804

Miley is awesome.
That wasnt bad.

I think we should critize someone who deserves it.
motherof2girls says – reply to this

805

Re: Lydia – rofl! good one! ur right, it's like comparing perez to brad pitt! Different leagues people!
Puhleeaze says – reply to this

806

She did fine for being Miley Cyrus- no one can cover a Mariah song like Mariah, so cut her some slack. Her fan base doesn't care anyway…
At least she's not knocked up and doesn't have her tits and vajayjay hanging out…
maggie says – reply to this

807

I really thought she did OK.
LadyJane says – reply to this

808

I liked it….she's cute, leave her alone…
kim says – reply to this

809

OOFF that was WAAAACK! I couldn't watch the rest of it, she murdered the song.
hi!? says – reply to this

810

im a huge miley fan.. but uhh, what is this?
Liz says – reply to this

811

Re: getoveryourself –

First of all. You don't even know who the fuck I am, so the fact that you're telling me I'm jealous is a pretty pathetic argument. "I don't see you singing on TV" Yeah this is the internet and you don't know who I am so for all you know you could have. And no, I'm not jealous of a girl that probably got all of her fame from her dad, when i have friends three times as good as her but don't have the connections to sing on TV. Finally, it's not that much to ask for some quality singing in today's world- people like PARIS HILTON can get record deals, that pretty much proves my point. anyone can get a record deal or sing on TV if they have the connections.
a miley fan DUH says – reply to this

812

ok that was a good performance!!
so idk why people r dissin miley!!!!
so is so awesome! i couldnt even tell that she was, and idt that she was.
PEREZ, u got it all wrong!!!!!!!
Gabby says – reply to this

813

There wasn't even anything wrong with it ! .. And I totally love her hair
melanie says – reply to this

814

Aw come on perez it wasnt that bad! I know not many can compare to mariah's voice and she didnt but it wasnt all that bad. she just added some country twang to it. stop being so mean!
Vegas Baby says – reply to this

815

Ummm, just a reminder… the majority of the crowd (kids aged 4-12) don't even know who Mariah Carey is!!! I'm just glad she didn't lip synch!!
iziah ! says – reply to this

816

skank, she finally sings live and she sounds terrible :]
Shelby says – reply to this

817

I mean sure shes no mariah but i thought it was pretty good all though the jonas brothers
Mariah Carey says – reply to this

818

Re: Bee – I totally agree with you. She is a kid singing to kids, and at least she sings live AND she actually is in tune.
fuck you perez says – reply to this

819

She sounds great! Fuck off!
♥CassieLovesJB says – reply to this

820

I have total respect for Miley…

But this is HORRIBLE. She sounds like a chipmunk… ugh.
kaitlin says – reply to this

821

she just has a VERY different voice than mariah so of course its not going to sound the same or as good…it was alrightttt
Cindy says – reply to this

822

I think she is adorable… and a wonderful role model for our youth! LEAVE HER ALONE!!!!!!!!!!! She made the version of the song her own and was keeping it real, just like she is.
h. g. wells says – reply to this

823

I thought she was great. What was wrong with t hat?
polekat says – reply to this

824

ummm she's like 14 I think its probably ok to cut her a little slack even if its not very good
Mest says – reply to this

825

She did a fine job, she just sinks it much lower and more country is all.
Denise says – reply to this

826

I thought she was great. I mean, she's what… 14 years old. She was better that the HSM kids.
rachism says – reply to this

827

c'mon, really…. she sounded mad nasal-y. she canNOT compare to Mariah, why try?
AVA says – reply to this

828

i thought it was goooood!!!
idk what you're talking about…
teri says – reply to this

829

omg she suxx
i can even do better omg
she SUXX
leslie says – reply to this

830

lmafo
the little kids
can see upp her dress her outfits are allways soo short when shes on stage
singing was ok
dress cute
but wear some leggings or something
for the children
tschik tschak says – reply to this

831

Obviously that wasn't as good as Mariah Carey but she did ok. It wasn't "awful awful awful"! Let me guess Perez when you met with Miley she didn't give you an autograph and the Jonas Brothers did!
kerri says – reply to this

832

you are an idiot perez - you are sad and jealous that miley cirus has a real career and you are just a fraud sucking the bottom of the feeder pool that brittany, lindsay & paris reside in…..
K says – reply to this

833

I think she was great!! I hate kids getting bad press. That is what happened to Britney. It's cyber bullying. I thought she did a great job. She is sooo cute. Keep positive Mylie!
Emmalee says – reply to this

834

ya that girls not my favvv but atleast she aint a CRACKKHEAD… yet atleast but as for the song wow NOT good
cameron says – reply to this

835

She's no mariah… but who is?
i think miley was really good!
i got my sister her cd for christmas, and i actually like it a lot!
bored at night says – reply to this

836

She did a great job! Leave her alone! She is the least trasy person to hit hollywood in quite awhile!

You're definatly wrong on this one!
Miley Rocks says – reply to this

837

Whatever.. she sounded awesome!
noemi says – reply to this

838

lol i wonder if people up in the front could see up her dress
thats nasty..she such a whore
Lauraa says – reply to this

839

it wasnt that bad…i mean I HATE HER..but i acceted but it was less than good….JONAS BROTHERS did greaaaatttt!!!!
Amanda says – reply to this

840

I thought she did a good job.
Jenny says – reply to this

841

I think she's great! I don't think she has the best voice for every song, but she always does a good job at doing what she does! We like her!!! And She's Cute!!!

And she's NOT pregnant!
liz says – reply to this

842

My sister had it on and i almost freaked when I heard her tryingot cover Mariah. She is possibly the worse singer out of all the Disney clones. I saw her on Oprah and she did not evne seem grateful for all she has.
Leah says – reply to this

843

Fuck mariah.

Miley fucking ROCKED that shit!!!
hjhgjhv jhv says – reply to this

844

SHUT UP…honestly people i wanna hear you sing that song….lets see if you sound as good as mariah carrey she did good her voice is just different and i think better than mariah carrey
Sandy says – reply to this

845

First of all, most of the people on here can not even spell (except "first") let alone sing, so what makes any of you singing experts? Perez, you stated that she "killed Christmas" because she didn't sing the song like Mariah, well, NO ONE can sing like Mimi that is what makes her special! However, Hannah did a great job singing for "Disney"! She is a good kid who went out there and did her best WITHOUT lipsynching like others do. Have you been to any concerts lately? Most of these singers CAN NOT sing without being in a studio to adjust the sounds. Give the kids a break. She is awesome (for a child)!
Amber says – reply to this

846

I thought that she did a really good job..
Sandy says – reply to this

847

Re: FUCK MILEY CYRUS –

I can NOT believe that Perez and or any staff would allow you to post such a hate filled message without reporting it to the police! I am disgusted and appauled that you would have such hate and venom in you to write such a message about a child! Perez, I am absolutely disguested that you could even post this message no matter how you actually feel about Miley, this is out right wrong and this stupid fuck sounds like he would actually do this to her. This is scary and you should do the right thing by reporting this to the police and then banning this person from EVER posting again! I can tolerate a lot of shit that is said on this board, however, this shit is WAY OVER THE LIMIT and it is scary to think that there is someone out on the streets with such a fucked up mentality and that you actally let him vent his hateful rage on your website! This is disgusting and you should be ashamed!
Kristi says – reply to this

848

you shouldn't pick on kids you dick. first that's fucked up and second it's people like you in the world that give little girls a complex. she was adorable during that performance. you're just jealous fat ass.
Kristi says – reply to this

849

you shouldn't pick on kids you dick. first that's fucked up and second it's people like you in the world that give little girls a complex. she was adorable during that performance. you're just jealous fat ass.
Kristi says – reply to this

850

you shouldn't pick on kids you dick. first that's fucked up and second it's people like you in the world that give little girls a complex. she was adorable during that performance. you're just jealous fat ass.
alexis! says – reply to this

851

why don't you fuckin give her a break shes 15 years old! we finally find a "real" role model for kids and all you do is cut her down? she has more talent and beauty than you will ever possess, your pathetic, and you shoudl just go kill yourself now, thanks.
jaycinco burrito says – reply to this

852

shes a little wench if yew askage meh…but…i dont think shes that baddd
jaycinco burrito says – reply to this

853

shes a little wench if yew askage meh…but…i dont think shes that baddd
melissa says – reply to this

854

dude, back off miley! she's probably the only teen star that's not totally fucked up, and my 3 yr old daughter loves her. if an adult needs to belittle kids, at least stick to the ones with the crack pipe in the diaper bag.
syd says – reply to this

855

I think she was really really good!!!!!!!!!! And yes it was live and she did not lipsync!!!!!! you all are just jealous of a 15 year old girl because shes better lookin that most of yall, has more money, and has no reason to be jealous of anybody!! get over it you jealous freaks
:) says – reply to this

856

perez!!! i usually love you but this time youre so wrong! I THOUGHT SHE DID GREAT!!! And she is so cute too!!! I hope she doesn't turn into a Britney… shes such a great role model! GO MILEY!!!
:) again says – reply to this

857

ALSO– I wish all the little teenyboppers that "hate" her would stop saying so just because of the "Jonas brothers" w/e they are… (I really don't know). I TOTALLY remember "HATING" Britney Spears just because she dated Justin Timberlake when I was in "love" with Nsync…. but I grew out of it! (When she was still good…) so Miley keep your head up!
victoria, yo says – reply to this

858

JB HAD to lipsynch.
they were in a parade.
mmk.
when your riding in a float in a parade you have to.
no speakers can support that, duhh dumbshits.
victoria, yo says – reply to this

859

btw!
ily Perez.
you are my hero.
keep up the love for Jonas.
Perez=hot dirty sex.
I like it... says – reply to this

860

Hey I like it and I am not a fan… I like it more then the one marah did this one is more up beat.
Barbie says – reply to this

861

I loved 'em both! I don't think they were lipsyncing. For once PEREZ doesn't know what he's talking about…
Shawna says – reply to this

862

Performance kinda of lacked vocal talent but she looked great.
hfhfxghj says – reply to this

863

Perez sounds like one of those little groupies
xD
You know, the ones who don't like Miley just because she's affiliated with the Jonas Brothers.
Woooooow, grow up doode.
x]
anonymous says – reply to this

864

So, what exactly makes a singer good? I'm sick and tired of hearing about her, but this could be much worse. She didn't majorly fuck up in a live concert and she's young. Could be waaaay worse.
Kat says – reply to this

865

I actually liked it. Side note, her dress is effing amazing.
mafunzalo says – reply to this

866

SHE tries SOOOO hard.
just look at her squinty made-up face.
she can't hit high notes for shit either.
BLEHHH!
S*A*R*A*H says – reply to this

867

Oh come on she's how old?!!! I think she's talented and did a great job….. absolutely adorable!!!
S*A*R*A*H says – reply to this

868

Re: Sandy – I agree with you 100% It's sadistic to write things like that about Miley or any other minor child. That post was disgusting and I wouldn't be surprised if that person has been profiled on Americas Most wanted….
S*A*R*A*H says – reply to this

869

One more thing to all the haters who shit talked Miley's performance…. How many times has anyone ever done a cover to one of Mariah Carey's songs? Mariah is a hard act to follow and rarely has someone taken her up on that kind of challenge. Kudos to Miley for standing up and believing in herself and doing an excellent job. She is an awesome role model for our kids & with all the Britney's, Lindsay's & Paris's in the world I find it refreshing to have someone like Miley that our little girls can look up too…. how can you hate on that?
Chad says – reply to this

870

SHE WAS AWESOME! THE HAIR THE STYLE! THE MINI DRESS! THE CUTE GOOD GIRL ATTITUDE! THE ENERGY! IT'S FUCKING INFECTIOUS CAND COATED BRAZILLIANCE!!! LOVE HER!!!!!
A says – reply to this

871

Re: OLIVIA JONES – Yo, Olivia, the Chrismas song is NOT a "Mimo" song….She just happened to sing a classic. Stupid.
omaha says – reply to this

872

I don like her but it wasnt that bad
Aly says – reply to this

873

Shes lip synching… She dosen't sing that well live.

Also I cant believe the jonas brothers lip synched! They ususally dont. && It sounds like the record they have out. i'm pretty dissapointed
Tah-Tah-Tah-Tia says – reply to this

874

SHE IS FUCKING HORRIBLE!
dasd says – reply to this

875

she did a great job with that song!
Texasgirl says – reply to this

876

I thought she did just fine.
george lopez says – reply to this

877

She's adorable! Look how much the kids love her. She's a great role model for them. Much better than that idiot Spears sisters!!!!! Shut up with your ugly comments…………
QUINCYGIRL says – reply to this

878

I THINK MILEY DID A GREAT JOB. SHE'S 14, SHE DID A GOOD JOB. DID NOT RUIN IT FOR ME.!!!!!!!! BAH HUMBUG TO THOSE WHO THINKS SHE DID.
frsg says – reply to this

879

okay first of all, all of you that think she did "great" are probably little 10 year olds shes lipsyncing and her voice is STILL horrible

the jonas brothers were great as usual!!!!!!
iosdngfiuusr says – reply to this

880

Re: nikki – deffnitly not live hun
srtguifweriu says – reply to this

881

c'mon perez shes only like 12 years old give her a break before she goes and cries to her dad
harleehonee says – reply to this

882

It thought it was great. UR wrong on this.
jksnfjhs says – reply to this

883

OK, STOP FREAKIN SAYING "PEREZ GIVE HER A BREAK SHES ONLY 15" IT DOESNT MATTER HOW OLD SHE IS, HER SHOW IS REALLY POPULAR SO PEOPLE SHOULD EXPECT HER TO BE AN AMAZING SINGER…WHICH SHE IS NOT!!!! SHE'S SIMPLY MEDIOCRE, I'M NOT SAYING SHES A BAD PERSON BUT SHE DOESN'T DESERVE TO HAVE HER OWN SHOW!
Chloe....x says – reply to this

884

it wasn't that bad..!

leave her alone. I may only be 11 and have a bad taste in music but that is mega good!
jajoie says – reply to this

885

did anyone happen to notice what she is wearing in front of a bunch of 4 year olds…all i was thinking while watching that was what are the people in the front row looking at???…
Ice says – reply to this

886

I have a friend who works on her tour - he tells me she's a total sweetheart, grounded and very genuine. That makes me happy seeing as she's bigger than Jesus right now.

Oh and Jonas Bros aren't completely lyp syncing - they are using Pro-tools
ChittyChitty says – reply to this

887

Miley is freaking better than alot other people who try to sing. She did great. Lets hear Perez try to do it. I think Perez needs to clean his ears out.
Too Old to Be Here says – reply to this

888

Perez, a girl's gotta eat…despite the (many) sour notes, we all watched her performance.
WHY? says – reply to this

889

My ears are bleeding. I bet she took the nude pictures of Vanessa !
saf says – reply to this

890

KRRRRRESMAS!
&_JB says – reply to this

891

i love the jonas brothers!!
they didnt lipsync…
nick reallyy sings that ah-mazinggg lol =)
kristina says – reply to this

892

hick should die.
Allison says – reply to this

893

miley was not bad and neither were the jonas brothers , i lovee themm , they didn't suck and miley didn't lip sync she sings exactly like that live and so do the jonas brothers so shag ye who don't like them other peoiple do so stop saying crap about them .
Pgeen says – reply to this

894

Sounds okay to me.
lala says – reply to this

895

she did a FABULOUS job! you're full of shit sometimes, pnasty
Adam says – reply to this

896

Im SO sick of people remaking this song. NOBODY can ever touch Mariah…..
Sparks says – reply to this

897

I so did not find it that bad at all… She is a great kid and atleast she went live… not like the jonas Bros..
love nick!! says – reply to this

898

Miley did BAD!!!!
Carlyn says – reply to this

899

Ew i feel sorry for her backup singers who clearly would have sang it a hundred times better than her but they have to sit there while she butchers the song..and of all things to try and sing when you can't: Mariah??? no honey
Katelynn says – reply to this

900

I think she did GREAT. It's not like anyone else on here can sing that great at 15 years old. Anyone sho thinks she did bad is retarded!!!