Who Worked It Better????

Filed under: Madonna > Janet Jackson > Celebrity Feuds

Left: The cover of Janet Jackson's new album, Discipline. Right: Madonna on the cover of Pop magazine, circa 2002.

Posted: Jan 17, 2008 at 5:14 pm / Email this »

See All 1030 Comments

1030 comments to “Who Worked It Better????”

More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 »

Trilly says – reply to this

801

Janet sucks and looks like an old snake
Terry says – reply to this

802

Music duo Goldfrapp slammed Madonna and they have a right to be upset. She ripped off their music for "Confessions On A Dance Floor" as well. Several critics noticed the Goldfrapp knock off…and so did Goldfrapp.

"The singer continued her outburst by suggesting that Madonna lacks creativity. 'I think it's quite clever, but I don't know if that's creative,' said Allison Goldfrapp." - Virgin Music News
Dutchie says – reply to this

803

MADONNA
Bibi says – reply to this

804

JANET….defintely JANET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
arnold divine says – reply to this

805

Madonna !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FFS
tit says – reply to this

806

Madonna of course!
jenny says – reply to this

807

and the winner is - MADONNA
It's Barbie, Bitch says – reply to this

808

okay, so noone is going to read the 900th comment. I don't care, I'll make it anyway.

Madonna IS the granny you could teach to suck eggs. She's too old, too pretentious and too talentless. And she has no soul.

Janet owns that shot.
clodagh! says – reply to this

809

Madonna looks way better!I hate janice!
linis says – reply to this

810

seriously, janet looks like an alien…as has been the case for the last ten years.. JUST QUIT GIRL! Go home
Katita says – reply to this

811

They're both so fierce in different ways - too close to call!
Krys says – reply to this

812

Madge definitly!!!, she looks so much more model, while janet just looks like a cartoon!
GO MADONNA!!! says – reply to this

813

MADONNA! MADONNA! MADONNA!
brittneyy says – reply to this

814

madonna definatlyyy! janet looks so ugly
kleatusmg says – reply to this

815

Madonna looks like Iggy Pop!
~mandy says – reply to this

816

madonna
freakin says – reply to this

817

madonna wins so freakin clearly
kathiiiiii says – reply to this

818

def. madonna
those hair….greeaaaat
JUNIOR says – reply to this

819

COM CERTEZA A MADONNA, ELA É MIL VEZES MELHOR QUE A JANET…I LOVE MADONNA, ELA É A MELHOR, THE BESTE, LINDA E MARAVILHOSA.
PEREZ, VC É MARAVILHOSO TAMBÉM…(PEREZ, YOU IS THE BEST)
olivia says – reply to this

820

Madonna rules! Janet is nice too, but she obviously abused of the photoshop…
R&B Junkie says – reply to this

821

JANET! (she already do this on Janet Cover 1993)
Michael says – reply to this

822

Madonna does it better.
jb says – reply to this

823

MADONNA. She's the one.
Joe says – reply to this

824

MADONNA ofcourse!

LONG LIVE THE QUEEN!
Denise says – reply to this

825

MAdonna totally rocked it!
MAGGIE..UK says – reply to this

826

MADONNA
Sandy says – reply to this

827

Janet has an alien-looking kind of like of her brother mike.. scary! Madonna looks awesome, she takes the medal
Lola says – reply to this

828

No contest!!!
MADONNA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LAV says – reply to this

829

MADONNA!!!
superstar says – reply to this

830

janet looks much better and can actually dance and is talented
Liz says – reply to this

831

Maddie rules as always!!!
varsh says – reply to this

832

madonna def- but it makes me sad to her like that coz she never does anything risque anymore!!
granny pearl says – reply to this

833

Mariah… Hello!
Herman Munster says – reply to this

834

Madonna. Look at Janet, she looks like Herman Munster in drag
madonna fucks says – reply to this

835

madonna makes janet look like a plastic goose
Susan says – reply to this

836

Oh, be for real…. Madonna, of course… although Janet's not too slouchy, either!
Zadie says – reply to this

837

Madonna..obviously… no contest. They all frigging ape Madonna from some ere or another.
dunk247 says – reply to this

838

janet
cauchy la pute says – reply to this

839

Jnaet & Madonna
Luck12 says – reply to this

840

In Madonna's photo there is attitude + she looks hot. She looks far better than Janet and she doesn't have to resort to diet pills to keep her weight down.
Lara Croft Mac N' Cheese says – reply to this

841

That's some serious Photoshop going on in both photos, but I'd have to say Madonna looks better. She looks like a sea-hag now but 5 years ago she was still looking pretty good (the Photoshop helped).
isaac says – reply to this

842

They are both fucking hott as hell. But if i have to choose it would be JANET
sexy bitch says – reply to this

843

Re: lauren – you're #49 dumbass!!!
cassandra says – reply to this

844

definitely Madonna
Encyclopedia Dramatica says – reply to this

845

MADONNA, by FAR! I'll never forgive Janet for calling Madonna a classless whore! Fuck you, Janet! At least Madonna pushed buttons…you flashed your saggy boob at the Super Bowl to try to one up her…FAIL. Madonna will kick your ass any day…you probably wouldn't even BE if it weren't for Madonna.
bush sucks says – reply to this

846

MADONNA! Hands down!
Fatdavid says – reply to this

847

Madonna for sure - that pic of her was also taken very shortly after givign birth to Rocco. Impressive
Jes says – reply to this

848

Janet baby!!
SanneFromHoland says – reply to this

849

I'm sorry but janet looks soo creepy!
Madge rockt it totally!
Well luff ya perez soo much
Kiss from holland
Garbanzo says – reply to this

850

Janet's surgery is awful. Makes her look like a common tranny!
superbomb says – reply to this

851

…definitly janet……big fan of both tho…
VJeter says – reply to this

852

that doesnt even look like madonna !!!!!
aeryl says – reply to this

853

madonna is way hotter than michael duh
Quel says – reply to this

854

niether, they're both too old for how young they think they are, grow up. the 80s were 20 years ago. ya both had a good hay day. look back fondly and move on.
MISSAYYY says – reply to this

855

hands down madonna
RudeDude says – reply to this

856

I love both artist, but I hate both pictures. They've both done way better!!!
Dee Tee'z says – reply to this

857

Re: yeahok – First of all, Janet Jackson has been out WAAAAAY Before Madonna! Before Madonna Headed To NY, became homeless, and started fucking ALL the producers for a record deal! So janet aint copying NO ONE!! Janet is the TRUE QUEEN OF POP! yes her last couple of albums SUCKED ASS! but honey, she is back, and is by far a WAY BETTER performer than Madonna! Hands down to Janet!! (Even though i love them both)! LOL!
Dee Tee'z says – reply to this

858

They are both AMAZING artist, but i have to say neither one of those pictures are hot! but if it came down to it, I have to give it to janet! she should have used the "Feedback" photo instead for her album cover!
Marisa says – reply to this

859

Madonna, of course!
andy says – reply to this

860

definantly madonna, i love you janet but what on earth is going on! you look scarey!
amytoby00 says – reply to this

861

MADONNA KILLED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AMO says – reply to this

862

I'm really lovin Madonna's 'do in that pic. I might have to cop that! To answer your question; Madonna looks way better. Janet looks like total shit. I can't believe she even approved that cover.
madjunky says – reply to this

863

how can you ask my dear Madonna of course …. Janet follows the queen and try to make it better what a pity it doesn't work as always
Dusty says – reply to this

864

They don't even look that similar! What's with everyone compairing everything that Janet or Madonna do with the other one?! They are both great artist & both look great! I can't wait for both of their new CD's this year!
ROMMEL says – reply to this

865

MADONNA. I can't put my finger on it, but there's something about Janet's face that doesn't look soooo, ho hummm, natural.
miesh says – reply to this

866

madaonna all the way!
Kira says – reply to this

867

Madonna all the way, she looks amazing, organic. I love Janet, but she looks extremely digitaly/surgicaly inhanced, her face looks fake(if you know what I am saying!!!)
Jenn says – reply to this

868

Janet works it
Brandy says – reply to this

869

Definitely Madonna!
TURDLICIOUS says – reply to this

870

Janet has a pig face
Jen says – reply to this

871

Michael…I mean Janet doesn't even come close.
MADGE WINS BY A BICEP.
Mandy says – reply to this

872

MADONNA WILL ALWAYS DO IT BETTER!
doc says – reply to this

873

janet is WAY better.
Oliver nome says – reply to this

874

Madonna of course!
Candi says – reply to this

875

Definitely Madonna. Janet looks like a fucking alien!
ss says – reply to this

876

JANET JACKSON you have no taste madonna is a total ho.
Mary K says – reply to this

877

I say Madonna!!!!!! She looks way better and less touched up. Janet doesn't even look human to me in her pic.
MY says – reply to this

878

Janet of course.
emily says – reply to this

879

definately madonna
Ketty says – reply to this

880

Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna
Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna Definitely Madonna

Madonna is the queen of pop!
charlotte says – reply to this

881

are you kidding?
first, Janet's wig looks greasy.
second, its too busy,
third, she looks like a drive in movie swamp monster.

Madge, defiantly. i don't even think Janet could spell "s&m"
Mona says – reply to this

882

Madonna for sureeee!

but Janet still looks hot.
dalipardon says – reply to this

883

Madonna, without a doubt! Her pose looks more 'natural' than Janet. Janet's hair is fug and so is her mug on top of that, she it just looks awkward. Madonna wins this one hands down.
Kat says – reply to this

884

Janet!!!!!
Jason says – reply to this

885

I LOVE MADONNA! SHE ALWAYS DOES IT BETTER!!!
piiimpcess says – reply to this

886

uhh Madonna. so hot. Janet just kills the picture.
Chris Ryan says – reply to this

887

uhh…Madonna…HELLO!!
Chris says – reply to this

888

As a professional retoucher…they are both retouched WAAAY too much.
But I would have to go with Janet
Raul says – reply to this

889

Madonna of course
Janet Cambell vs. Madonna Pheifer says – reply to this

890

Janet has the Naomi Campbell look while Madonna looks likes Michele Pheifer. Madonna's is a 100% safe make me look beautiful cover while Janet pushes the envelope. Safety does not rock in music. Funny it's normally Madonna that has the edginess, but here clearly Janet wins.
JJ says – reply to this

891

Both!
Two different looks and two different themes
Desiree says – reply to this

892

Madonna blows Janet away. Always has always will.
bee-bee says – reply to this

893

definatley maddona
KAT says – reply to this

894

IT'S CALLED *PHOTOSHOP* PEOPLE! THEY BOTH NEED ALL THE HELP THEY CAN GET - IT'S TIME EMBRACE YOUR AGE LADIES!
KAT says – reply to this

895

IT'S CALLED *PHOTOSHOP* PEOPLE! THEY BOTH NEED ALL THE HELP THEY CAN GET - IT'S TIME TO EMBRACE YOUR AGE LADIES!
MATERIAL BOY says – reply to this

896

MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
MADONNA
Kahlil says – reply to this

897

this proves that

JANET IS A PASTIC COPY CAT

MADONNA IS THE TRUE FASHION ICON

suck it haters
kahlil says – reply to this

898

Proving that

JANET IS A PLASTIC COPY CAT

MADONNA IS THE TRUE FASHION ICON
Lisa says – reply to this

899

Is that picture of Janet from 20 or 25 years ago? Tell me Perez.
Madonna looks like a stoned super model.. its hot
Blair says – reply to this

900

for MADONNA this look is soooooo 2002 but of course JANET had to copy it as usual

MADONNA ROCKED IT BETTER of course !!!!!!!!!!