Separated At Birth

Filed under: Separated At Birth > American Idol > Johnny Depp

Left: American Idol contestant Amanda Overmyer. Right: Johnny Depp as Sweeney Todd.

Posted: Feb 28, 2008 at 10:50 am / Email this »

See All 128 Comments

128 comments to “Separated At Birth”

More comments: [1] 2 »

jules says – reply to this

1

1st
virginia says – reply to this

2

that's what I call a match!
adsda says – reply to this

3

first
Betty says – reply to this

4

First?!
jo bunny bebe says – reply to this

5

4th bitches! yum..i love mr. depp
boo says – reply to this

6

1st!
Phillip says – reply to this

7

i love you perez nooo doubt
GRRR says – reply to this

8

WOOF!
eww says – reply to this

9

woah! nasty!
niccix85 says – reply to this

10

ahhh!! johnny !!
J says – reply to this

11

FIRST!
SHESDIFFERENTBUTNOTSOGOOD says – reply to this

12

Her hairstyle is unusual. She's okay I guess but she doesn't thrill me.
amanda says – reply to this

13

she looks like a lion. why would they do that.
jo says – reply to this

14

lmFao
J says – reply to this

15

Okay, not first lol but this chick looks like a fat, ugly beast. I hope she gets voted off.
Jon says – reply to this

16

Nope bad comparison. You should have compared her to Sindel from Mortal Kombat. Find a picture of her and look at it. It is way closer than sweeny todd. I don't know if you do redos but you should for this one. It will be so much sweeter!
karrah says – reply to this

17

thats my grandma!
Sabrina says – reply to this

18

i think she looks like an electrocuted skunk!!!!!!!!!!!
Anna says – reply to this

19

Um yeah. The hair turned me off last night. And the song she sang….well….how come no one sang Donna Summers or Ricky Lee Jones?
Emma London says – reply to this

20

Also looks like that woman from that Halloween show that was in black and white. And Lisa Presley.
I'D BANG THEM BOTH!! says – reply to this

21

AT THE SAME TIME!!

Ooh, and what's with all this excitement about being first about..??

…FuCKING ReTArDs.
Chelsea says – reply to this

22

WTF. Her hair looks awful. LOVE PEREZ MUCHLY!
Amy says – reply to this

23

BADDD CHOICE of hair.
Allison says – reply to this

24

She was fucking awful, it was embarassing to watch. She sang her way off the show last night.
Dekay says – reply to this

25

But only one of them can sing.
Kait says – reply to this

26

I think she looks more like a cracked out Rosie O'Donnell
Candy says – reply to this

27

Johnny Depp is soooo hot!!!!! Yummy! I Love You Johnny !!! That girl sucks. She should go home.
Asta says – reply to this

28

Silvia Night the icelandic artist should be there instead of Johnny Depp!
toenis says – reply to this

29

shalalalala
Birdy says – reply to this

30

Her hair was almost as bad as her sound last night. I really like her voice usually.
Flowerbomb says – reply to this

31

So glad to see AI has the obligatory "rebel girl with bad hair color" again this season. They have the no talent gay sangina boy, the cute dorky boy who can actually sing, The rocker dude, the big black guy…Sounds like they are sticking with a formula
mangoout says – reply to this

32

I would still tap that.
E says – reply to this

33

She looks like Silvia Night.
YuckYuckYuck says – reply to this

34

My first thought on seeing that clip of her last night was…DYKE!
CheckthisOut.. says – reply to this

35

Want another switched at birth. How about Mike Huckabee and the Campbell's soup guy??? Freaky..
Heather says – reply to this

36

that is soo eww!!! lol
Stacey says – reply to this

37

She looks so much better with very little makeup and he hair pulled back! Not loving this hairstyle at all…. not on anyone!!
TXMOM says – reply to this

38

She looks like that villan on 101 dalmations
{itz hillary bitchez] says – reply to this

39

zzz”””””' now thatz funny coz my zizter liked her the bezt///

zzzzzzzzzzzzzezpecially the hair….but my Johnny Depp…

[[[[[ no one comparez to that hott babe..I luv him ♥♥]]]]]]]
Buckeyefan1 says – reply to this

40

Personally, I think she is one of the best they have ever had - for setting herself apart from the competition. She will make the top 10 and I think she will outsell many of the other top finalists. She has a great quality to her voice - provided she is not trying to growl her way through the song. I want to see her do something that shows off more of her voice (without being a Janis Joplin song).
tt says – reply to this

41

She is normaly fantastic! I hope she stays another week
mmm says – reply to this

42

cruella deville
Chabelly says – reply to this

43

LMFAO !! can't blame u perez te queremos en republica dominicana !!!
foxygirl says – reply to this

44

CRUELLA D'VILLE?
Christine says – reply to this

45

Her hair is NASTY, and she needs to go home. She SUCKED last night, and was off key 1/2 the song…

BYE BYE!
Amanda Sucks!! says – reply to this

46

She's the Bride of Chucky!!!
nicole says – reply to this

47

ew who the fuck is that? cruella deville? someone vote her off, she's fucking hideous, i don't want to see her on fuse, mtv, mtv 2, mtv tres, vh1, cmt…gross.
Sam says – reply to this

48

omg i cant stand this girl!!! she looked like cruella deville!!! shes only good for one genre which means shes gonna be so awful 4 this show since u have to sing different songs from different genres. i hope she gets sent home tonite!!!
Kyle says – reply to this

49

Re: Buckeyefan1 – LOL!! $20 says her skunk ass is going home tonight!! She's outta there!
natalie says – reply to this

50

LOLS!!!!!
julie says – reply to this

51

i wish we could vote 4 who we want to leave cuz im gettin really pissed that the people that i hate can stay and i have no control over it.
sam says – reply to this

52

omg she was charged with a dui in october 2006 and she was on probation until august of 2007. wow wat a role model and american idol!!!!
Kat says – reply to this

53

Coif by Cruella Deville!
CJ says – reply to this

54

I would have matched her with tracy turnblad personally…
He he says – reply to this

55

kudos to her for being diff, but just a bit much on the hair.
URSILA from Little Mermaid says – reply to this

56

I thought she looked more like Ursila (sp) from The Little Mermaid. I could not bear to watch her perform last night - she really sucked!!!
Rebecca says – reply to this

57

She looks more like Tracy Turnblad in Hairspray.
wooda says – reply to this

58

i think she looks more like cruella
racheal says – reply to this

59

she looks JUST like DJ TANNER from Full House…they could be TWINS!
*** says – reply to this

60

http://votefortheworst.com/
anjhest says – reply to this

61

She always looks so OLD, but she's only 23 or so!
Jeanette says – reply to this

62

Now i was thinking she looked more like mortisha from the Adams Family! Theres a match! lol
Nicole says – reply to this

63

You forgot to show her pants…her hair matched her pants! Her look was so unflattering last night! I don't like her.
Buckeyefan1 says – reply to this

64

www.dialidol.com has Amanda listed first. Note that votefortheworst.com chose her this year as their contestant to throw the voting off, so who knows how much it will effect the final votes.
BROoke says – reply to this

65

atleast super hot johnny depp WORKED it.!! this girl is sad.
tammy says – reply to this

66

what about cruella deville?
mellymel says – reply to this

67

LOL You are so not right in the head that is hillarious
kasha says – reply to this

68

hahaha, perfect for eachother in every sense of the word
meschell says – reply to this

69

SHE WISHES!
SuzieQ says – reply to this

70

She sucked last night, and the hair was horrifying. I bet she goes home tonight!
ManaPonj says – reply to this

71

That has to be a wig. Yuck!
me says – reply to this

72

Separated at birth with Lilly Munster would be more accurate !
Paula says – reply to this

73

I THINK SHE LOOKS LIKE THE BRIDE OF CHUCKIE DOLL!!!!!!!!!!
BEV says – reply to this

74

She's so outta there. Loose the hair honey, and the acid washed jeans…they make your thighs look huge!
porodika says – reply to this

75

Did you see her last night? She WAS under the influence. Drugs or Booze. A BIG MISTAKE !!! She looks fat and older than 22 or 23. But I like her pretty face and her attitude. You go girl !!!
Julie says – reply to this

76

She looks like Lillian Munster too
no way says – reply to this

77

Oh no, this one isn't a good one. That chick only wishes she could look just a tiny tiny micro tiny bit as good as Johnny Depp. Poor Johnny, the comparison is insulting to him.
yuck says – reply to this

78

In last night's show she looked absolutely ridiculous, like she had a costume on, and she sang horribly. That said, I do believe that this girl is 'the real thing' in the rock world. Too bad TPTB at American Idol are trying to turn her into a faux rocker babe. Not that authenticity bothers them - look at their pet fake rocker Daughtry! Where in this century do real rockers still wear leather wristbands and wallet chains and act like morons on the stage?
I hope that Amanda is kicked off tonight so she can go home and shake off all the nasty influences of American Idol.
DH says – reply to this

79

wow, she's an idiot to think that her hair looks good… And if anyone told her that it looks good, well they are an idiot too.
sarah wall says – reply to this

80

She is a serious joke…I hope she gets voted off tonight!
katie says – reply to this

81

she looks like that news lady with the bad hair
Sweetface says – reply to this

82

Her hairstyle is a complete ripoff of SILVIA NIGHT. I wonder why SILVIA NIGHT has not been mentioned by Perez. Maybe she has but she had almost the exact same hair 2 years ago
LaurenM says – reply to this

83

I LOLD SO FUCKING HARD. i'm now gonna call her Sweeney

she looks like DJ from Full House. her face, i mean.
OMG says – reply to this

84

I like this chick but last night WOW she looked bizzare.. I couldnt stop looking at how the pants matched her hair, her shirt her make up .. She looked crazy. I like her voice but WOW tone it down baby
KKD says – reply to this

85

Re: porodika – I have to agree with you. She looked like she was a bit fucked up almost out of it.. And I think her hair made her face look HUGE.. SHE looked like she had a helmet on. Im shocked that the other girls didnt tell her she looked crazy.
Chuck says – reply to this

86

She sucked, but i would love to give her a free
sample of my love juice….
nice fat ass…
bulldogmama says – reply to this

87

I told my husband last night she looked like Cruella De Vil. She needs to go, she can't sing only scream.
snowbunny says – reply to this

88

more like the bride of chucky
Bernadette says – reply to this

89

looks more like that star who played in 101 dalmatians movie….ha ha ha
niha says – reply to this

90

she looks awful. johnny is sexy
xoxo says – reply to this

91

Perez,where you seperated at birth from Courtney Love?
Rach says – reply to this

92

Freaky!
Johnny Depp Fan says – reply to this

93

They are both talented. She can really sing and put on a show and he is one of the best actors, let alone writers and musicians alive.
Candi says – reply to this

94

My first thought was Sindel from Mortal Kombat!
Don't flatter her! says – reply to this

95

Ohhhh that it soooooooooooo mean —– to Johnny! HE can sing and HE rocks the do. But her = bloody dreadful!!!
John says – reply to this

96

Two words: LION KING
Joyce says – reply to this

97

one of these is just like the other lol….either him or cruela de Vil…lol
STUPID FUCKING FAGS! says – reply to this

98

why dont you all just shut the fuck up! i personally know her and have heard her sing since she was in middle school. she is pretty fucking awesome. so she might have had a bad night…i dont see all you lame ass fucks out there on national tv. nope–you are here on gay ass fucking perez hilton just sitting there making fun of people that actually have talent.
grow the fuck up and go out and find a new hobby.
Katie says – reply to this

99

She will be the next contestant to go (home).
lucy bowels says – reply to this

100

Since when did they allow 40 year-old's on American Idol? No wonder I stopped watching.

More comments: [1] 2 »

Beyonce SHINES At Revel! WERKS Single Ladies & Halo! Watch!!

Sparkle it up, gurl!! Let us see that seXXy shine!!

Still thrilled from Beyonce's intimate behind-the-scenes video, we're ready to DANCE after watching this Single Ladies performance!!

The crowd was WILD for Bey when she made her first stage debut since giving birth to beautiful Blue Ivy. And from the looks of this performance, she gave 'em their money's worth and then some!

But don't even get us started on Halo (below)! She even tributes Whitney Houston with

Advertising info