This Breaks Our Heart

Filed under: Exclusives!

Our favorite Pussycat Doll, the tranny, has left the group!

Sources reveal exclusively to PerezHilton.com that Carmit Bachar of the PCD has "gone on to pursue other projects."

Devastating!

They are not going to find another tranny to replace her. It will just be five girls from now on.

We miss you already Carmit!

[Image via WENN.]

Posted: Feb 29, 2008 at 12:30 am / Email this »

See All 171 Comments

171 comments to “This Breaks Our Heart”

More comments: « 1 [2]

TX Perez Fan says – reply to this

101

oh boo. She was actually my favorite and one who had been there the longest.
They were a fun group of gals for that last album but that "thing" Nicole put out was really awful.
She aways has been a female she's just not your typical Hollywood look.
Jay says – reply to this

102

She may look like a tranny,but she is more friendly than Shytesinger will ever be.Anyway,Shytesinger looks like a tranny these days too.
Cristina mmm says – reply to this

103

Ah thats a horrible foto of her, she's usually gorgeous!
hayden says – reply to this

104

You need to lay off the transgender community, bro. You are a powerful voice among the younger people of today, and that hatemongering will only make it harder on the 'trannies.'
Laury says – reply to this

105

Whatever. She was just a backup dancer anyway, and probably the ugliest one of the bunch.
Rk says – reply to this

106

Ugly
Chrissy says – reply to this

107

I LOVE how people take this shit sooooo seriously!! Reading these pathetic comments is what makes my day. It's called a JOKE people!! Learn to lighten up!! And if you don't like Perez so much, why the fuck are you even going to his website? BTW…..I'm glad someone finally said it, cause that chick DEF looks like a man!! Who gives a flying FUCK if she has a cleft pallet?? Dumb asses!!!
whatevamingas says – reply to this

108

for everybody who is so stupid and dont know anything..

1. asia QUIT pcd for a solo career
2. shes not a tranny
3. shes 34 not in her mid 20s
4. shes the nicest person EVER
kathryn says – reply to this

109

what ever happened to asia, who won the search for the next doll, will she be in the group?
Nefertiti78 says – reply to this

110

This sucks, she was one of my favorites…I loved what her tone of singing voice added to the group. Damn man…well I'm glad I got to see them all in concert before she left.
Me says – reply to this

111

Can I just ask a question, wtf ever happened to Asia who won "The search for the next doll"?!
who cares???? says – reply to this

112

it was too many girls in the group anyway
v-kidd says – reply to this

113

are you kidding me??? she was one of my favorites!!
Cranky says – reply to this

114

I saw PCD in concert cus some friends forced me to go and SERIOUSLY Carmit and Melody are the best singers in the group. If Carmit has gone then only Melody and Nicole will sing, Nicole's voice is mediocre shes not a great singer at all.

They should have kept Asia in the group cus she has a good voice. Nicole is not the best singer its a shame that they promoted her over everyone else in the band.
miley's tampon says – reply to this

115

..she's got the joker face
LoveTheRedheads says – reply to this

116

She's my favorite too!!! I love redheads and she is the sexiest PCD by far. But is she really a tranny??
mega says – reply to this

117

Re: Me – Bitches kicked her out of the Group - they wouldn' tlet her stay.
iza says – reply to this

118

fake
fuck perez
Alley says – reply to this

119

why her right boob looks weird?????surgery gone wrong!
malary says – reply to this

120

isnt that why they found another doll ?? lol … now they have 6… whats her name anyways ??? lol asia ?? or something
Mean Willie Green says – reply to this

121

Joker face; fake tits; less talent than Paula Abdul

WGAS?
UGH!!! says – reply to this

122

well what im wondering is what happened to that girl that won the competition thing she was on tv it took up WAAAY to much air time and now i dont see her anymore, wasnt her name like "asia" or something?
Kat says – reply to this

123

RE: ASIA- WINNER OF SEARCH FOR THE NEXT PCD
after she won she actually never joined the group. she was offered a spot and turned it down for a solo career… technically she was not legally obligated to join after she won.
sophieeeee says – reply to this

124

is she actually a tranny????? or does everyone say that coz she looks like one
will some let me know please??
Ashley says – reply to this

125

No one cares.. she was HELLA ugly anyways
JONATHAN ANTIN says – reply to this

126

she is almost as fugly as my sister robin
emma says – reply to this

127

She competed in the olympics BEFORE transgendered were permitted to do so. She was born a female but has had multiple surgeries to fix her cleft palate giving her that tranny-look,
??? says – reply to this

128

Was she really a man?
blah says – reply to this

129

#100…Chelsea was my favorite too…I wish she had won.
katyaldridge says – reply to this

130

She is certainly a tranny and for those of you who don't see that, or disagree, are naive and ignorant.

Whether she's beautiful or ugly, who knows. But is she a tranny? certainly yes.
lisaaaa says – reply to this

131

HEY what happen to that ASIA girl???? she just disappeared
open says – reply to this

132

Very implanted and plastic looking. Not human.
Miry says – reply to this

133

Re: katyaldridge – You're a complete idiot. She had a fucking cleft and had to have surgeries on her face. If you look closely you can see the scars above her lip where the cleft was. She can't help what her face looks like and tons of women have more of a masculine look. She's probably a lot more successful and talented then you will ever be. People are so cruel nowadays that it's ridiculous, we're all going to end up killing eachother for our differences at the the rate we're going.
pixiebdg says – reply to this

134

Nice meth fingers Carmit.
twinklinstarr99 says – reply to this

135

It's the human version of Disney's Cheshire Cat from Alice in Wonderlang!
violets says – reply to this

136

Re: pillow –

Um, actually Andy Warhol never photographed Twiggy. You probably confused her for Edie Sedgewick.

Anyway, for some reason I remember reading in a magazine (or something) that carmit was born with facial defects, and that's why she's well…sorta messed up looking.
Anna says – reply to this

137

She's NOT really a tranny. Good for her, she's successful in her own right (look her up on Wiki if you don't know).
tranny says – reply to this

138

all this anti trans talk is really disgusting.
transsexuality is a medical condition so y'know..fuck off
Mah says – reply to this

139

OH NO!!!
AND?
THE PCD , WITHOUT CARMIT??
¬¬
Mah says – reply to this

140

IT'S HER FACE!

HER BODY IT'S PERFECT!!!
SHE'S THE BEST DANCER OF PCD!
Ily says – reply to this

141

She kills it when she dances, tranny or not… SHe used to dance with Youdontsay aka BeYaki before she joined PCD.
stef says – reply to this

142

I went to Bancroft JHS with her…This girl has overcome a lot in her life and is far more successful the most you "pretty" bitches. To be a PSD, that speaks alot for her talent and sex appeal. Show some respect.
SKiNNY BiTCH says – reply to this

143

That's really cruel. Don't make fun of her looks - she was born with a disability! She also seems like a nice person too.
Kreeza says – reply to this

144

I loved Carmit!!! She also did a lot of work for children and people who have cleft lips and pallettes. She was also a founding member bitches so stop ragging on her! lol
Lucy says – reply to this

145

SHE AIN'T UGLY! We're not all gonna be as good looking as we were in our young years. Let me see you guys in 10/20 years and let's see who looks better, Carmit or you. I think Carmit has an amazing voice and I love her dance skills. Too bad she's going. That's kinda weird though because I thought Nicole, Carmit and Melody had the lead vocals on PCDs 2nd album :0
holl says – reply to this

146

is she really a tranny
ewww says – reply to this

147

She's disgusting.
LehLeh says – reply to this

148

good. she looked out of place.
paris whitford says – reply to this

149

she was a tranny? and i find this out now!!!!
junjun says – reply to this

150

well, no worries, this tranny can easily be replaced by another tranny… PARIS HILTON ring any bells? she obviously won't be able to dance as well as this one but if a tranny is required, you know who to call! herpes and tantrums included!
OMFG! says – reply to this

151

Nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!! WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS TO ME?
katt says – reply to this

152

SHES NOT A TRANNY U IDOT! THEY RAN AN ARTICLE ABOUT HER IN SEVENTEEN LAST YEAR AND EVEN SHOWED PICS OF HER FROM WHEN SHE WAS LITTLE!
Bridget says – reply to this

153

She has been quoted on Wikipediastating that she was born with a cleft lip and that she has intentions of opening a charity devoted to helping other born with cleft lips.
set it right says – reply to this

154

Can you say anything nice about anyone? Do you have a decent bone in your body? That you can make up such garbage about a person with such a sweet spirit shows just how little character you have. What you put out will come back and knock you flat! Karmas a bitch. Good luck with that!
Mike says – reply to this

155

Actually Ashley is a singer as well. On their new CD they all atleast have a song or a duet type kind of song laid out for them. Plus Nicole isn't the one that matters the group makes her. She sucks on her own.
seth says – reply to this

156

trannies have the best tuna!
trace says – reply to this

157

you fat fag… PCD are 2005.. move on freck fuk
PR says – reply to this

158

What??????

I thought this band…. i mean musical act …. I mean hired dancers had at least 3 or 4 trannies!!!
kay says – reply to this

159

I had no idea who this bitch was, but I thought you were serious about her being a tranny.
Nicolas4fun says – reply to this

160

CARMIT WAS ONE OF THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! with MELODY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
KIck out that NICOLE tirant BIAAATCH! with capital B!
meeks says – reply to this

161

I went to high school with Carmit and she is awesome- always was a fantastic dancer and just a very nice person. Good luck Cami!!!!
Lara says – reply to this

162

No she was not a tranny, stop being a bunch of dicks. PCD are not trannies.

She's not in her mid twenties, she is 31. She is doing work for charity.

She's been in the group for 12 years, she's having a break for herself now.

What a bunch of ignorant pricks.
me says – reply to this

163

Re: me –

I agree, what the hell?Re: acid –

someone's immature.
josie896 says – reply to this

164

her mom teaches dance classes at bancroft middle school in l.a. i know, she was my teacher…..
G-Suss says – reply to this

165

Effing Ancient!!
OliZ says – reply to this

166

it's not fair! i used to like her & her voice…i wish her best of luck for her career
mig says – reply to this

167

who cares??!! she'll be back!! just like nicole!
katie says – reply to this

168

Speaking of talent, they have none.
I may however, plug in Danity Kane as actually HAVING talent. God these girls cannot sing. (They can dance though) I'll give them credit for that.
a friend says – reply to this

169

Carmit was born with a cleft palate and had to have a lot of surgery to look at all normal. She is an amazing dancer with a lot of talent, and that's why they brought on someone who looks a little different. It's really cruel to insult her like that when she's fought so hard against prejudice.
LFD says – reply to this

170

First of all NO Carmit was not a tranny.. if you were a fan you'd know the reason behind her (what some people would call) defined looks and if you're not a fan well don't spread rubbish about her. Personally I think Carmit looks AMAZING she's a beautiful person both inside and out. Also she's not old or really young looking old. I'd be here all day replying to the crap some people have posted so all i'll say is I wish Carmit all the luck in the future and I hope whatever she does is a great success because she deserves it.

Oh and one more thing, Carmit does loads of things during the PCD concerts she is not boring and uneventful if you really think that I do believe you were watching the wrong show.

That's It..

WE LOVE YOU CARMIT!!!

BTW.. Thanks to the people who stuck up for her, I'm sure Carmit will appreciate it

xoxo
hh says – reply to this

171

i love carmit…seriously

More comments: « 1 [2]

Beyonce SHINES At Revel! WERKS Single Ladies & Halo! Watch!!

Sparkle it up, gurl!! Let us see that seXXy shine!!

Still thrilled from Beyonce's intimate behind-the-scenes video, we're ready to DANCE after watching this Single Ladies performance!!

The crowd was WILD for Bey when she made her first stage debut since giving birth to beautiful Blue Ivy. And from the looks of this performance, she gave 'em their money's worth and then some!

But don't even get us started on Halo (below)! She even tributes Whitney Houston with

Advertising info