Welcome to PerezHilton.com
Welcome to PerezHilton.com - Hollywood's Most-Hated Web Site!
Celebrity Scoop Goes Here
E-mail Perez@PerezHilton.com

Report technical problems.
Perez Posse signup FAQ

Contact us to advertise on PerezHilton.com



Wear it, share it, give it, get it! Represent!

Jump to your favorite celebrity

Articles by date

Who Won????

Filed under: Baby Blabber > Nicole Richie > Christina Aguilera

xtinavsnicole.jpg

It was the war of the dueling babies!

Christina Aguilera and Nicole Richie both recently debuted their new infants to the world.

But which cover sold more????

Nicole's! By a lot!

Richie's cover is on track to sell 1.8 million copies. That's about 500,000 more than Aguilera's!

It would be safe to say that Xtina is a bigger star, but…

So, why did her pics sell less copies???

Why does there seem to be more interest in Harlow Winter Kate Madden? One magazine insider said part of it could come down to the moms’ fan bases. “Christina historically doesn’t do that well on covers,” said the source, who cites poor sales of her wedding photo issue in OK!, and less-than-stellar sales of her nude photo shoot in the January 2008 Marie Claire.

That might be true, but Nicole Richie doesn’t seem like an obvious home run on the cover, either. “There’s also a greater element of curiosity with Nicole,” the source conceded. “She’s gone public about being a heroin addict. Her boyfriend is covered in tattoos. By default, she’s got the more interesting baby. People want to see how she settles down. They want to see what kind of baby someone with her background has.”

Also, Christina married a "regular" fella.

Nicole, meanwhile, made sure her babydaddy was a celebrity, Joel Madden.

There's just more interest there!



215 comments to “Who Won????”

More comments: [1] 2 3 »

  1. laura says – reply to this
    1

    first

  2. Luis says – reply to this
    2

    First! Go Hillary

  3. susie says – reply to this
    3

    first!!

  4. susie says – reply to this
    4

    dang hehe.

  5. slashONmyCOCK says – reply to this
    5

    FUCK ME HARD CHRISTINA
    damn i want ur sweet lil pusSSSY
    let me shit on ur tits and vomIT IN UR mouth
    JUSt like i did to MY Grand DADDY
    daMN he luVed it wen i sucked he CoCK
    swaLLowed he sweet CREAMY juiCESS

    FUCK YA Y"allllL!!

  6. jenn says – reply to this
    6

    who cares?

  7. Emily says – reply to this
    7

    FIRST

  8. slashONmyCOCK says – reply to this
    8

    Susie I WANT UR SWEETNESS

  9. cat says – reply to this
    9

    firt

  10. kelly says – reply to this
    10

    first!

  11. arty says – reply to this
    11

    not first

  12. Molly says – reply to this
    12

    Plus, let's not forget that many people buy magazines for reasons other than the main cover story. Nicole's issue was also the OSCAR FASHION ISSUE…what else did Christina's have?? Maybe it was just a slow week with other news when Christina's cover came out.

  13. AndyMatronic says – reply to this
    13

    Meh, Nicole is a bitch. She's famous for nothing, that talentless skank means nothing

    Christina's an absolute legend. She isn't a faker and truthfully loves her partner and will be a great parent and should be a role model for us all.
    She's 100% genuine, unlike that slag Nicole.

    KTHXBAI

  14. mbt says – reply to this
    14

    FUGLY XTINA + FUGLY HUSBAND = FUGLY BABY = POOR SALES

    AND MORE, SHE'S ABSOLUTELY BORING, TRYING TO SELL A IMAGE OF PERFECT LADY.. PERFECT WIFE… BOOOORING!!!!!

    LET'S NOT FORGET ABOUT HER LAST ALBUM: A COMMERCIAL DISASTER.

    BETTER STOP YELLING NON STOP ON ALL SONGS AND START STRIPPING OFF AGAIN!!!

  15. Sandy BoO says – reply to this
    15

    NICOLE RICHIE rocks my socks and Joels tats are HOT!

  16. Dawn Day says – reply to this
    16

    Since when did they start conducting breast implants during labor?

    Christina's new rack is just that…new! And that ain't all milk. Unfortunately milk glands aren't shaped like half a bowling ball!!

  17. duh says – reply to this
    17

    who fricken cares!

  18. chelsea says – reply to this
    18

    first

  19. mbt says – reply to this
    19

    FUGLY XTINA + FUGLY HUSBAND = FUGLY BABY = POOR SALES

    AND MORE, SHE'S ABSOLUTELY BORING, TRYING TO SELL A IMAGE OF PERFECT LADY.. PERFECT WIFE… BOOOORING!!!!!

    LET'S NOT FORGET ABOUT HER LAST ALBUM: A COMMERCIAL DISASTER.

    BETTER STOP YELLING NON STOP ON ALL SONGS AND START STRIPPING OFF AGAIN!!!

  20. superv says – reply to this
    20

    I bought the one with Christina NOT Nicole, XTina looks hotter anyways…

  21. jenn mark says – reply to this
    21

    i just think the look of the cover for nicoles was more nicely done. christinas cover didnt have a flattering angle shot of the baby plus there were more side bars of other stories taking away from her spotlight.

  22. Natalie says – reply to this
    22

    Plus Nic's baby is cuter!

  23. AndyMatronic says – reply to this
    23

    Oh yeah, and Xtina is hot. And is wayyyy talented.

    Nicole's just some ugly bimbo who's dad is a famous has-been, like her.

  24. MBT says – reply to this
    24

    FUGLY XTINA + FUGLY HUSBAND = FUGLY BABY = POOR SALES
    AND MORE, SHE'S ABSOLUTELY BORING, TRYING TO SELL A IMAGE OF PERFECT LADY.. PERFECT WIFE… BOOOORING!!!!!
    LET'S NOT FORGET ABOUT HER LAST ALBUM: A COMMERCIAL DISASTER.
    BETTER STOP YELLING NON STOP ON ALL SONGS AND START STRIPPING OFF AGAIN!!!!

  25. Andy says – reply to this
    25

    first

  26. salina says – reply to this
    26

    Nicole is black and people are curious what color the baby is. That's why she'll sell more copies!

  27. jb says – reply to this
    27

    Fifth? Nicole's issue was also an Oscar special "double issue", so that probably was a factor.

  28. mbt says – reply to this
    28

    FUGLY XTINA + FUGLY HUSBAND = FUGLY BABY = POOR SALES
    AND MORE, SHE'S ABSOLUTELY BORING, TRYING TO SELL A IMAGE OF PERFECT LADY.. PERFECT WIFE… BOOOOORING!!!!!
    LET'S NOT FORGET ABOUT HER LAST ALBUM: A COMMERCIAL DISASTER.
    BETTER STOP YELLING NON STOP ON ALL SONGS AND START STRIPPING OFF AGAIN!!!

  29. Amanda says – reply to this
    29

    True. True. Love Xtina more, though.

  30. Grammar Queen says – reply to this
    30

    "why did her pics sell less copies?"

    She didn't.
    She sold FEWER copies.

  31. Natalie says – reply to this
    31

    Nicole Richie is cuter than Xtina and has a better (perceived) personality. She's girlfriendy, where Xtina is someone who would be your jealous enemy or something. She's cold. Let's face it, choice between the two us girls would rather look and dress like Nic over Xtina, and fuck Nic's boyfriend over Xtina's husband anyday.

  32. loren says – reply to this
    32

    I FUCKING LOVE XTINA

  33. OMG says – reply to this
    33

    Re: slashONmyCOCK – Perez, get this shit off of here!

    Slash, did Mommy write you a note to get out of school today?? Grow up idiot!

  34. Justine says – reply to this
    34

    Dont forget… Christina's hubbie is butt ugly - who wants to look at an ugly baby? Eww that nose and those jug-head ears….

  35. jaclyn says – reply to this
    35

    First!

  36. lez says – reply to this
    36

    nice tits christina,i dont thinks christinas baby lost,any1 who gets to suck on those tits is a winner!!yumyum

  37. CC_99 says – reply to this
    37

    HAHA Joel Madden isn't a celebrity

  38. lefty lady says – reply to this
    38

    Eh….Xtina is still prettier. And she got the bigger post-baby boobies!! I'm jealous!

  39. KA says – reply to this
    39

    it could also be that nicole's cover sold more because it was the issue that followed the oscars! not as many people care about the grammy parties which was on christina's cover! just an observation.

  40. ryan says – reply to this
    40

    xtina is sooo much better.. AND Max is cuter

  41. Ana says – reply to this
    41

    ALSO NICOLE'S PEOPLE MAGAZINE WAS A DOUBLE MAGAZINE. SO OF COURSE MORE PEOPLE ARE GOING TO BUY A MAGAZINE WITH MORE MAGAZINE.

  42. LUVSJOELANDNICOLEANDHARLOW says – reply to this
    42

    Congrads to both of these women who had babies and look so awesome soon after! But one reason why Nicole's mag sold more in my opinion is that Nicole's was about the family more then what the home looked like (Aguilera's expensive nursery, huge waterfall in the background..). Plus there was an interview. Just my opinion……

  43. Girl Next Door says – reply to this
    43

    Re: AndyMatronic – "Meh, Nicole is a bitch. She's famous for nothing, that talentless skank means nothing
    Christina's an absolute legend. She isn't a faker and truthfully loves her partner and will be a great parent and should be a role model for us all.
    She's 100% genuine, unlike that slag Nicole.
    KTHXBAI "

    Yup, as 100%genuine as those titis on her chest

  44. fussler says – reply to this
    44

    I only bought nicole's baby pics mag because i wanted to see if the kid would turn out retarded after its mom was a heroin addict… it did look a little abnormal, it was worth the four dollars

  45. Girl Next Door says – reply to this
    45

    Rleax people, dont get your panties in a twist, its not who is a better celeb but whos mag offered more, and nicole 's did thus her mag sold more.

  46. jane says – reply to this
    46

    And they want to know if Nicole is going back to anorexic now.

  47. slashONmyCOCK says – reply to this
    47

    Re: OMG
    HeyyYYYY gurrrrlll
    wannAAA taste off my MUDDY lil fingerss
    mmmmAHHHHH u want em' inside dontcha biiaaTTCCHHH

  48. alvarup says – reply to this
    48

    YEEEEEAH NICOLE IS A BITCH.. CHRISTINA IS A LEGEND GOOOOOOOO CHRISTINA I LOVE UUU!!!

  49. whateva says – reply to this
    49

    Maybe b/c Christina tries to damn hard, she's never herself. Just look at the picture and the way she acts, she wants to be Marilyn Monroe — and GOD knows she not. She's an annoying twit

  50. Megan says – reply to this
    50

    I Love Christina, she's beautiful and a absolute legend!

  51. Candy says – reply to this
    51

    Another reason is that X-tina tamed down too. Hollywood kind of forgot about her until she got pregnant.

  52. dee says – reply to this
    52

    Plus, other stories on the cover of Nicole's edition were more interesting…Angelina was on the cover in a small side pic…unveiling her bump…that had to count for something!

  53. Rachael says – reply to this
    53

    Christina's hotter and better but less interesting. She's never done anything too stupid and we're all sure she'll make a great mother. Nicole on the other hand? I dunno something about her being a COKE FIEND and an idiot makes the idea of her having a baby all the more interesting. I think it's a positive reflection on Christina.

  54. thisismyname says – reply to this
    54

    Simply put, Nicole's baby is a hell of a lot cuter.

  55. dee says – reply to this
    55

    btw…Xtina looks a little like Anna Nicole Smith in that pic of her you showed…all huge boobs and flowing blue tent dress hiding her enormous ass…for a little girl she certainly ballooned during her pregnancy…well you know what they say…if you want to see what a girl will look like after a few kids, just look at her mother! lol..even though she had that planned c-section so she wouldn't have "vaginal tearing"…like having a baby cut from your gut isn't at all drastic and major surgery…idiot.

  56. Stephanie says – reply to this
    56

    maybe because Harlow is cuter

  57. crystal says – reply to this
    57

    I bought the mag for the Oscar fashion

  58. bighair_mini says – reply to this
    58

    The only reason why the Nicole issue sold more is that it's a double issue covering the Oscars as well. Also, Angie's on the cover with her new baby bump. I bought that particular issue and not because of Nicole, but because of the Oscar coverage. I'm sure a lot of other people were like me.

  59. RAE4KMA says – reply to this
    59

    THE OSCAR ISSUE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BIG DIFFERENCE. I bought them both, but I buy it regardless of who is on it.

  60. NY says – reply to this
    60

    OF COURSE! CHRISTINA IS SO UGLY AND BORING!!!!!!!!!! CHRISTINA IS A BITCH WHILE PEOPLE SAY NICOLE IS VERY, VERY NICE!

  61. NY says – reply to this
    61

    Re: mbt – I TOTALLY AGREE WITH U!

  62. nj says – reply to this
    62

    it was also a double issue with oscar coverage AND had angelina's pregnancy on the cover — not a reasonable comparison.

  63. Josh says – reply to this
    63

    Christina is by far more talented and settled than Nicole! Nicole has a higher level of spectacle. It is the same reason Britney Spears will oversell almost anyone else right now on a cover. She is a train wreck! No one can look away. Christina has a very strong and loyal fan base, but we are more interested in her music and her Back to Basics DVD that just came out (which has been number one for some time now) than her baby pictures and her undramatic life! I wish her the best with her beautiful baby and her happy marriage, but people seem to be more interested in seeing the chaotic and unstable stars than a star doing well and living a normal lifestyle. It is sad. Christina, you are awesome and these numbers are just numbers. Your fans stand behind you and know that you have no rival when it comes to talent and beauty. Time will be your testimony, just keep up to what you're doing and they will all see.

  64. {if itz not hillary..then u bitchez zuck az momz says – reply to this
    64

    zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

    theze r both of my bitchezzzzz I have ♥

    4/them equally….vote hillary bitchezzzzzzzzzzzz

    zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz◘♥♥◘

  65. Vince says – reply to this
    65

    Christina is ugly. Nicole is someone you want to root for.

  66. pretty girl says – reply to this
    66

    i bought a copy yesterday, haven't even flipped thru the pages yet. but for some odd reason i love nicole way more than christina…don't know y…but i do!

  67. lauren says – reply to this
    67

    could it have something to do with the fact that nicole's issue of people also was a double issue with oscar coverage?

  68. Chop sticks says – reply to this
    68

    Christina has a clown face. Look at that big mouth!

  69. Mr. Hat says – reply to this
    69

    God, is Christina A. UGLY.

  70. Templeton says – reply to this
    70

    I agree. UGLY

  71. Cindy says – reply to this
    71

    For some reason people love Nicole more than Christina, there is something so humble about Nicole that makes us go "aww" .. she melts our heart… Nicole's baby was much cuter than Christani's by miles and miles!

  72. Ozzie says – reply to this
    72

    Look at the 2 pictures. Nicole has grace. Christina is a cartoon character.

  73. jeff says – reply to this
    73

    Who really cares which cover sold more, what about those tits on Christina!

  74. Janel says – reply to this
    74

    Or is it because Angelina was also on the Nicole cover at the same time?

  75. susie says – reply to this
    75

    Nicoles pic was way cuter. you could actually see the baby and her facial expressions were adorable. Nicole looked very serene and her makeup was done well..very simple. Christina's cover pic was not flaterring to her and you couldnt even see the babys face..he was sleeping!

  76. Jason says – reply to this
    76

    They wasted 2millions on Christina.. no one cares about her, she is ugly… Nicole on the other hand got it all, she is so gorgeous man it hurts - Nicole's baby was so cute, the cutest Kid of 2008.. Go Nicole we luv ya :)

  77. stephanie says – reply to this
    77

    Nicole sold more because it was an Oscar double-issue.

  78. Sloane says – reply to this
    78

    I think it's because Nicole is a bigger tabloid star.

  79. pamela says – reply to this
    79

    Nah….I don't think it's joel madden (the "famous" boyfriend) we're interested in….I think it's cause we're STILL in shock that this nearly anorexic girl, with all her other probs, was able to conceive a healthy baby and look damn good after it.

  80. kim says – reply to this
    80

    Christina seems like she's all about herself. She seems to even pretend to herself too much that she's soo special. Tina looks stuck-up. Now her newest dumb move is flaunting her nasty milk filled breasts. Keep those tucked away tina….then you look much prettier, with some class.