Not So Blind Item

Filed under: Gay Gay Gay > Not So Blind Item

What closeted American Idol alum has finally got a boyfriend!

The repressed homo is dating another Broadway queen.

We know who he is and what show the new guy's in. But, it's more fun if you guess!

CLICK HERE to leave your speculation in the comments section.

Posted: May 5, 2008 at 6:05 pm / Email this »

See All 763 Comments

763 comments to “Not So Blind Item”

More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8]

Casey says – reply to this

701

Clay is too easy of a target…. David Hernandez is not playing in RENT, So my guess is Josh Strickland.
MeanyJeanne says – reply to this

702

Gay Clay, of course!
LaLa says – reply to this

703

Justin Guarini
jbyrd says – reply to this

704

justin guarini?? fo sho
Christine says – reply to this

705

Obviously its Clay Aiken!
melissa m says – reply to this

706

Clay (I'm Not) Aiken
Dmac says – reply to this

707

How about that superqueer bitchy transvestite Daniella Noriega?
Dmac says – reply to this

708

How About that superqueer, bitchy, transvestite, Daniella Noriega?
cyn_d_sin says – reply to this

709

Clay Aiken
bridget says – reply to this

710

clay aiken
Darla says – reply to this

711

Clay!!!!!!!
Toni says – reply to this

712

Clay Aiken!!!!!!!
Wendy O Koopa says – reply to this

713

Clay Aiken..
Lydia says – reply to this

714

Probably either Danny or Clay
Paula says – reply to this

715

Clay Aiken
Gracie says – reply to this

716

Who else but Clay (you make closet organizers shutter) Aikens
Danielle/FL says – reply to this

717

CLAY AIKEN, Of course!
molly says – reply to this

718

either Clay Aiken(the obvious choice) or David Hernandez. possibly.?
Allyn says – reply to this

719

clay fuck me in the ass aiken
kristen says – reply to this

720

obvi, CLAY AIKEN!!
Wilma says – reply to this

721

homolicious fools
justin t. says – reply to this

722

brittany spears is sooooo HOTT
justin t. says – reply to this

723

brittany spears is sooo HOT
katie says – reply to this

724

it's so obvious it doesn't even need to be said
Bubaliscious says – reply to this

725

WELL its either clay aiken or that gross gay strip club guy david fernandez who looks unnaturally oily and greasy all the time
Teri says – reply to this

726

Clay Gayken
chelsey says – reply to this

727

Its not Clay. It would have been headlining news and we would have heard by now. Its probably some 8th place reject from season 1 that no one remembers.
SweetPea says – reply to this

728

it has to be Aiken!
kk says – reply to this

729

THE GAYKEN?!?!?!
Jainie says – reply to this

730

It's most definitely Gay Aiken. Duh.
jessica says – reply to this

731

gay aiken
JG says – reply to this

732

Clay Aiken!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Terry says – reply to this

733

Is it Dave Tobin from Valero in Benicia, CA?
Fran says – reply to this

734

Re: Terry – It Is!!! I knew it!
steve says – reply to this

735

Clay Aching for cock!!!!
luvperez says – reply to this

736

Very clever, Perezzzzz! You are a smart cookie….one little blurb and TONS of hits. I'm kinda agreeing with Chelsey….we would of heard by now…so, when we gonna hear the answer for real?
Me says – reply to this

737

Re: Porterville CA –
guess what … NOBODY CARES BESIDES YOU !!!!
lindsay like lohan 'cept sober says – reply to this

738

that creep-a-licious ginger Clay Aiken!
pook says – reply to this

739

David Hernandez- I saw him at HERE in West Hollywood and he introduced me to his "friend"! He's pretty cute!
Delores M says – reply to this

740

Clay Aiken???? Please he needs to come out already.
cntspel says – reply to this

741

clay clay
Ceddy says – reply to this

742

Clay Aiken and Mario Lopez….shut up…jealous!!!
judyjudy says – reply to this

743

clay is married to what ex major falcon porn star…
Leandra says – reply to this

744

It should be Ryan Seacrest……but oh well
Stephanie says – reply to this

745

It's gotta be Clay!
freddie fendz says – reply to this

746

YOU KNOW ITS GOTTA BE THE GAYKEN!!!!
Shelley says – reply to this

747

SOMEBODY WASN'T LIKIN IT!!!
awesome_sauce says – reply to this

748

gAIKEN
n says – reply to this

749

HERE HE GOES OUTING PEOPLE AND HURTING THE GAY MOVEMENT.
then he'll bash someone else for saying something negative about a gay person.
you fat hippocrite
steph0205 says – reply to this

750

It's Gay Aiken, of course!
hahahha says – reply to this

751

Its got to be ACE YOUNG!
ashamedthat Icare says – reply to this

752

the cute guy that is in Tarzan on Broadway (I think his last nane is like Strickland or something)
Em says – reply to this

753

CLAY!!!
caleb says – reply to this

754

BLAKE LEWIS!!!!
Shindee says – reply to this

755

Who is it?
I MUST know!
T_T
donna says – reply to this

756

it's gotta be clay aiken . he's so gay its not funny .
julie says – reply to this

757

mai-mai kennedy
julie says – reply to this

758

julie holland????!!!
&*(_) says – reply to this

759

Clay Aiken
sco says – reply to this

760

clay aiken he sooooo gay
Insideguy says – reply to this

761

If it is Clay (What a shocker) Aiken, it surely isn't Cheyenne Jackson, that man has taste. David Hyde Pierce is very married to his long time lover, so that's out. Are you sure it isn't a lady-in-waiting among the world of Broadway queens.
nykettia says – reply to this

762

Its clay aiken finally coming out with that dude from Justin timberlake old group!
Raul says – reply to this

763

Ummm? Could it be Clay Aiken? Could his boyfriend be Mario Lopez? Thats an interesting combo.
Clay=Bottom , Mario=Top

More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8]

Beyonce SHINES At Revel! WERKS Single Ladies & Halo! Watch!!

Sparkle it up, gurl!! Let us see that seXXy shine!!

Still thrilled from Beyonce's intimate behind-the-scenes video, we're ready to DANCE after watching this Single Ladies performance!!

The crowd was WILD for Bey when she made her first stage debut since giving birth to beautiful Blue Ivy. And from the looks of this performance, she gave 'em their money's worth and then some!

But don't even get us started on Halo (below)! She even tributes Whitney Houston with

Advertising info