Welcome to PerezHilton.com
Welcome to PerezHilton.com - Hollywood's Most-Hated Web Site!
Celebrity Scoop Goes Here
E-mail Perez@PerezHilton.com

Other technical problems.


Contact us to advertise on PerezHilton.com



Wear it, share it, give it, get it! Represent!

Jump to your favorite celebrity

The Publicity Didn't Pay Off

Filed under: Music Minute > Mariah Carey

75519999__opt1.jpg

Despite the insane media attention that followed her surprise wedding to Nick Cannon last week, Mariah Carey's new single, Bye Bye, has plummeted on this week's Soundscan singles chart in America.

The song drops from #22 to #41.

Sucks for her!

People may be interested in her wedding, but it seems like they don't care about her single!

Madonna, on the other hand, is doing quite well on the chart.

4 Minutes is currently at #3 this week and her second single, Give It 2 Me, debuted at #21.

Congrats, Madge.

Mariah can go cry on Nick's shoulder now!

[Photo via Getty Images.]



Leave your comment

157 comments to “The Publicity Didn't Pay Off” (RSS feed

More comments: [1] 2 »

  1. #1 - D says – reply to this

    first?!

  2. #2 - D says – reply to this

    wil check dan ik was first!!!

  3. #3 - Alex thefuckingprincess A. says – reply to this

    Poor Mariah Carey! Sucks to be beaten by someone who probably has to eat soft food and wear some extra padding in case her bowels release. Oh well, at least you married a Nick Cannon…who…is…pretty…coo-hahaha. Sorry I couldn't help it.

    Go Madge! Fierce!

  4. #4 - Shannan says – reply to this

    My Dear Perez,

    Why do you always hate on Mariah? Her album has done tremendously well (best selling first week numbers of her career) and outsold Madonna's album in the US by over 200,000 copies.

    I enjoy reading your blog but sometimes you come across as a hater. I think you should try to stop putting people down and concentrate on the positive aspects of their careers.

    Best,
    Shannan

  5. #5 - D says – reply to this

    miiaaauuwww

  6. #6 - DH says – reply to this

    Well maybe if her music didn't fucking suck…

  7. #7 - Furby says – reply to this

    I give this marriage 6 months tops….

    some heavy humping could end it sooner.

  8. #8 - hater says – reply to this

    HATE HER !!! CAN'T BELIEVE PEOPLE "CRY" WHEN THEY SEE HER !!
    GET OVER IT !!!

  9. #9 - Caitlyn says – reply to this

    He looks like her son. I'm sorry, I'm all for happiness but this is not going to end well.

  10. #10 - amara says – reply to this

    haha

  11. #11 - Mileia says – reply to this

    PEREZ = PHILIP SEYMOUR HOFFMAN W/ OVERLY TWEEZED EYEBROWS.
    Fat-ass fag.

  12. #12 - Lisa says – reply to this

    PEREZ, why are you such an asshole??? leave people alone and get a life

  13. #13 - NEED MORE PROOF says – reply to this

    I BLEW UP THE PIC ON PEOPLE MAG'S COVER AND THEN WENT TO MARIAHDAILY.COM AND BLEW UP THE OTHER WEDDING PHOTO THEY HAVE. IS IT ME, OR DOES NICK'S SUIT LOOKS DIFF? I SWEAR, THE ONE ON MARIAH'S SITE IS A SATIN SUIT AND TIE. THE ONE ON PEOPLE'S MAG IS CLOTH. CHECK THIS OUT, IT'S PLAIN AS DAY IF YOU INCREASE THE SIZE.

  14. #14 - luke says – reply to this

    the single's not even been released yet! give it a chance!

  15. #15 - tt says – reply to this

    MIMI is Awesome every email Perez@PerezHilton.com and tell him to shut it about Mariah and he needs to Lose some weight

  16. #16 - Sloan says – reply to this

    does anyone know where to view this weeks soundscan numbers????

  17. #17 - Kirsten says – reply to this

    E=MC2 rocks - just as good as last CD - your review of it is what SUCKS!! Seriously…

  18. #18 - dpaled says – reply to this

    Perez…did you mention how Mariah's album is dropping like a stone as well.

  19. #19 - rabs says – reply to this

    Mariah looks like a momomonkey.

  20. #20 - Both are talentless, ugly whores... says – reply to this

    Anyone who buys either of their shit are inbred piles of cumfuck….

  21. #21 - NIKKI says – reply to this

    THE ONLY REASON HER SONG "4MINUTES" IS DOING SO WELL ON THE CHARTS IS BECAUSE JUSTIN AND TIMBALAND ARE SINGING ON IT!!!!!!!!! =)

  22. #22 - tt says – reply to this

    Perez SUCKS ..email him at Perez@PerezHilton.com and flood his inbox tell him to STOP HATIN ON MARIAH

  23. #23 - Nicki says – reply to this

    Girl dont get too comfortable with those belly shirts! You lost wieght but not that much! IIIVayyy!

  24. #24 - Jen says – reply to this

    Re: Alex thefuckingprincess A.

    I can tell that you are the kind of person I would PUNCH IN THE FACE if I was ever to meet your retarded ass. Do the World a favor and look into suicide

  25. #25 - Krystal says – reply to this

    Well if she got Justin on her songs that would make them top the charts too! It is not just her on that song!

  26. #26 - Your mom says – reply to this

    Re: Shannan

    Dear dumb cunt,

    If Perez listened to your retareded ass, his page would die within a week. Now eat a dick and STFU.

    kthxbye

  27. #27 - Lollypop says – reply to this

    This is really gross… Mariah looks like she could be his mother, she should have found herself a more masculine looking man….. he looks like a 15 year old and she looks well into her 40's

  28. #28 - pandrew79 says – reply to this

    I like a lot of Mariah's music, but "Bye Bye" is not a good song. It's generic and not very original. I loved "Touch My Body", but this song just doesn't make the mark. Nor does the video, which is poorly made.

    Maybe the next single will be better?

  29. #29 - tt is a inbred twat says – reply to this

    That cunt is a fat whore who sucks, if Perez wants to talk mad shit about her all day long, he sure can. LOVES IT that you would waste time emailing him about negitive statements on the site…that is what this site is ALL about! Die!

  30. #30 - katy says – reply to this

    Who gives a shit. She is retarted. Nick is to good for her. I met him last year and he is the most down to earth guy. She is too needy for him. He needs someone simple and that is far fetched from Mariah's vocabuary.

  31. #31 - Laury says – reply to this

    It would help if the song didn't suck. It's so boring, it's impossible to listen to it without falling asleep halfway through.

  32. #32 - A says – reply to this

    I hate all these stupid comments on Mariah. She has some monster singles coming out soon.

    I think Perez's making these comments because Mimi doesn't give a shit about him. But come on, face it, she's a super star. And you're a wannabe celebrity.

    And although I like Madonna, her new album sucks a big time, she'll choke on it. let's see how many copies she can sell.

  33. #33 - Look at Nick's gace says – reply to this

    Re: katy
    Oh yeah this picture sux

  34. #34 - alex says – reply to this

    im starting not to you like you, im finding danasdirt alot better really. could you get off madonnas dick? 4 mintues will never be a #1 song in american, byebye will. you all will get mad - mariah will, madonna loses like always!

  35. #35 - KEVIN says – reply to this

    WELL UR MADGE DIDNT SELL 463,OOO COPIES AND UR MADGES 4 MINUTES AINT GOING TO #1 AND GIVE IT TO ME WILL FALL NEXT WEEK BC IT HAS NO AIRPLAY, IT DEBUT HIGH BC OF SALES NEXT WEEK IT WILL FALL…SO FAR MARIAH HAS WONT THIS BATTLE STILL!! SOLD MORE RECORDS AND A #1 SONG, SORRY MADONNA FANS TRY HARDER!!

  36. #36 - heather says – reply to this

    Publicity marriage and sucky music.

  37. #37 - jesse says – reply to this

    Her album is really really boring…. its basically "Migrate" and rest of the songs sound the same… even the same as last album….
    I think an artist that can call themselves artis should bring new stuff everytime instead of showing the same painting over and over… Shes playing her finger on american people with lots of promo on TV.
    Because shes "Hot now"…. come on people…. though you were smarter.
    She cant make new music… thats why her album is droping like stone.
    I bet shes gonna have to make tons of remixes so she can sell more…. cause the original songs are seriously bad.
    Re release = corrections to the album.
    and now… the "marriage stunt"….. come on people… wake up!!

  38. #38 - LOL HOW STUPID ARE YOU PEREZ says – reply to this

    well at least mariah got dignity unlike the half century old grandma kissing young girls and drinking champagne HOW TACKY IS THAT HAHAHA

  39. #39 - WILLVENEZUELA says – reply to this

    PEREZITA YOU ARE SO BAD WITH MARIAH, THE VIDEO JUST YESTERDAY WAS RELEASED AND THE SINGLE IS BETTER THAN MADONNA JAJAJA YOU ARE SO SAD BECAUSE OLDONNA JUST MAKE A POOR DEBUT JAJAJA MARIAH RULES YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH MARIAH I LOVE FROM VENEZUELA

  40. #40 - cass says – reply to this

    I AM SOOOO SICK OF MARIAH CAREY. NO ONE CARES ABOUT HER! AND YOU'VE BEEN REPORTING JUST THAT. PEREZ . . .DARLING. . .YOU GOTTA STOP MAKING EVERY 5TH BLOG ABOUT HER - ITS DRIVING ME BONKERS!!!

  41. #41 - Kymm says – reply to this

    Don't care about her wedding or her music - it all sounds the same. I am amazed she is still around and still sells any albums at all. You are just buying the same album over and over again.

  42. #42 - el mikey de S.F says – reply to this

    I LOVE YOU PEREZ. Long live the queen.

  43. #43 - Kevin says – reply to this

    Madonnas Hard Candy is No 1 in 25 countries!!! INCLUDING USA!
    Mariah was No 1 in the USA only….. she knows how to dumb american people but not the rest of the world…. lol.
    and now the marriage… lol…. you gotta be kidding me.

  44. #44 - 1up4fun says – reply to this

    You have to know why she is plumenting. She got married. To NICK CANNON. He's so gross!!! What a down grade Mariah. Tsk Tsk

  45. #45 - num says – reply to this

    shut up perez.. madonna looks all sucked out any way.. B*tch needs to quit.. ppl are tired of seeing her 40 yr old dried up ass.. lol

  46. #46 - Joey says – reply to this

    I feel as though there is no longer any need to compare these two, at least for now… both have had extremely successful careers, but despite that, their styles are completely different. Both albums have proven to be succesful one way or the other… there really isn't any "loser" in this situation.

  47. #47 - Mariah is OLD says – reply to this

    Belly shirt that shows plastic fake cleavage: $162

    Injections that turn me into a plastic robot: $2300

    Marry boy I've known 6 weeks who looks like my son and is young enough to be: Priceless

  48. #48 - Annie says – reply to this

    Mariah concerts are boring as hell and so her records….
    American people should be really sad people to buy her music.

    And talking about Madonna I admire how good she looks at 50. you americans should be proud of having such a legend, a 100 years from now Madonna will be remembered and no one else.

  49. #49 - Roxy says – reply to this

    I used to like Mariah but now its too obvious that shes just selling out, all this publicity on TV, the marriage… "her No 1s on american radio"…..its just enough… I think those No 1 are arrangements between business people.
    Besides, she acts like a diva wannabe…..
    Im done with this girl.

  50. #50 - Perezerator says – reply to this

    What a crock of shit. Madonna is holding up on her own quite well but by NO STRETCH of the imagination is she doing better in the U.S. than Mariah. Madonna's first single didn't even hit #1 but Mariah's did. Sweet perezerita FAILED to mention that part. Bye Bye isn't even released as an official single yet. I guess it hurts poor little perezilla that Mariah out sold Madonna by over 200,000 copies of her album when it came out. Madonna is an entertainer who gets by "singing" or should I say LIPSYNCHING (see MSN's madonna concert for proof) and where Mariah is a SINGER, not someone who needs to rely on dancing and flashy concerts to keep the audience attention. Mariah's voice does that on its own. They are in two completely different classes. Mariah is in the same league with Celine Dion, Whitney Houston, Barbra Streisand and other great SINGERS for GODS SAKE. Madonna however is a great entertainer and is in the same class as the Britney's and other pop showcase artists who have to dazzle on the stage to distract from their mediocre singing. I wish Perez would just stop putting them together as if they are even remotely similar in artestry. Your continued persuit for Madonna to trump Mariah speaks to your ignorance about the music industry and doesn't make you look good at all. Give it a rest already Perez and realize these are two amazing women who cannot be compared to each other - period.

  51. #51 - Jennifer says – reply to this

    So Perez, how do you feel about Hillary doing so poorly last night & having absolutely no chance at the nomination now?

  52. #52 - Tom says – reply to this

    SURE THERE IS NO COMPARISION BETWEEN MADONNA AND MARIAH..
    Madonna - A Legend, musician, performer, dancer, business woman.
    Mariah - She sells records in USA and buy airplay for living.

  53. #53 - rgz says – reply to this

    There is no need to compare.
    They are completely differente artists.
    Strong women on top, I love it.

  54. #54 - madonnasass says – reply to this

    Being that she didn't promote the single or the video, that should be EXPECTED.

  55. #55 - marwin says – reply to this

    the single dropped down the charts because it's not available to buy from itunes anymore. Get your facts str8 Perez. You're so not a real journalist!

  56. #56 - Mimi says – reply to this

    I REALLY don't like Mariah- but Madonna said that she "liked Mimi's new album"..so there can't be much of a diva battle going on. Or if there is..Madonna aint playing along..

  57. #57 - Fun I tells yea! says – reply to this

    It's fun! Fun to knock someone who thinks she farts out the very best perfume and craps out gold bullion. I'll bet she doesn't have a single real friend, not one. Reason being is she is a self absorbed, high maintenance, neurotic bitch.

  58. #58 - WHO CARES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! says – reply to this

    PEREZ NOBODY CARES ABOUT MARIAH MARRYING THAT CORNBALL NICK CANNON BUT U SO SAD!

  59. #59 - Madonna Makes Mariah Orange with white hands! says – reply to this

    IT'S BECAUSE THE SINGLE BYE-BYE DIDN"T HAVE A CONTEST ATTACHED TO IT WHEN IT WAS RELEASED LIKE Touch My White Hands.
    THE ONLY REASON E=MC2 DID WELL IN IT'S FIRST WEEK WERE BECAUSE OF THE FANS WHO BOUGHT MULTIPLE COPIES!
    Mariah fans can bash Madonna all they want but the true desperate skank in the business is Mariah!
    MARIAH IS TO MUSIC WHAT STEROIDS ARE TO BASEBALL.
    If her voice is her talent ……why the implants? Why the Skimpy clothes?
    Why the spray Tan? Why the sham marriages to Tommy & Nick? Because she is no different than the next person & outside her voice ain't sh.it. AS she goes thru her 40's & radio gives up on her (like they are now) What is she gonna do?
    She can't tour like Madonna cause she has no stage presence. We'll see where Mariah is when she is 50…….and people when you pass her….Please give her your spare change.

  60. #60 - Sinead is a dyke! says – reply to this

    I think both Vadge and Mooriah suck monster cock, but I have to hand it to Miss Fatty…she outsold the Old Whore by a landslide on the album charts! 650k compared to 250k is HUGE. Like Moomi's ass. Both albums completely suck though. Mooriah with the same old ni**er shit and Madonna with amatuerish lyrics and sounds.

  61. #61 - Dita's Bitch says – reply to this

    plz dont act like Mariah is a concert draw cause she aint. her last show she couldnt even sell tixs at $10.00. and dont hate on Madonna cause she gets more press for a promo tour (NYC and Paris) than Mariah gets for marrying a child. also, Madonna was NOT lip-syncing and she sounded great. hate all you want….but CLEARLY you were drawn in and watched Madonna's show. i would watch Mariah for all the money in the world. i HATE her that much.

  62. #62 - Mama says – reply to this

    The song is soooooooo bad and so corny–why in the world would anyone download it to hear again and again? "One Sweet Day" was enough!! Such a depressing topic, and such a silly lyric "bye-bye bye-bye" — even if I had just lost someone close to me I wouldn't want to hear that over and over again.

  63. #63 - Dana says – reply to this

    haha sucks for her, we all kno madonna is the best!

  64. #64 - Luisa says – reply to this

    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.
    uh, M-A-D-O-N-N-A, is a legend…what else would you expect.

  65. #65 - Riccccccck! says – reply to this

    VIVA MADONNA! she prevails again…don't underestimate MADGE, lambs! VIVA MADONNA! she prevails again…don't underestimate MADGE, lambs! VIVA MADONNA! she prevails again…don't underestimate MADGE, lambs!

  66. #66 - haha says – reply to this

    awww poor mariah and her poor lambs..BUMMER!!

  67. #67 - _phunkey_ says – reply to this

    wow…quit hating on madonna. peace, y'all …by the way, her album is dope…mimi's was alright.

  68. #68 - Jen says – reply to this

    Does Nick Cannon ALWAYS look like a fucking retard?

  69. #69 - US-UK Expat says – reply to this

    Why do all the Mariah Carey fans type in all CAPS?! Oh, and don't get me started on the typing errors. One or two are okay, but when riddled with them, it gets annoying.

    Note: Before you hit the 'Submit Comment' button, please review what is being sent.

    'Bye Bye' has been released as a single. Check iTunes.

    Also note that '4 Minutes' has out sold 'Touch My Body'. Billboard Top 100 is based mainly on airplay, not sales. Mariah held back the single 48 days to create her latest chart topper. Prior to that the single was stagnate.

  70. #70 - Sara luvs Mariah says – reply to this

    Perez-
    Stop comparing Mariah and Madonna. Madonna is old, nasty and looks like a dude. No one likes that dumb song she has out. It's dumb as hell. I would puke if i saw Madonna naked and her music makes my ears bleed!
    Soooo STFU Perez…

  71. #71 - JJ says – reply to this

    what a waste of time whoreshiping the fat pig!

  72. #72 - mariah's bitch says – reply to this

    HI!
    MY NAME IS MARIAH
    I'M A FAT PIGGY IN A BLANKET.

    I ACT LIKE A FUCKING CUNT BECAUSE I'M THE ONLY ONE WHO THINKS I'M A SOMEBODY.
    
I SELL PERFUME MADE OF BUTTERFLY PISS AND USE THE MONEY TO BUY MY $5 HOOKER SPANDEX MINI'S AND CHA CHA TRANNY HEELS.
    
I TRY AND TRY TO ACT BUT I KNOW I'LL WIN ANOTHER RAZZIE
    I LIP SYNCED ON IDOL AND YES I STILL CRACKED MY VOICE AND SHIT MY PANTIES TRYING TO HIT THE HIGH NOTES.
    
I'M A TRASHY DIRTY HOOKER. AND YES I HAVE CRABS…

  73. #73 - daniel says – reply to this

    Mariah stop dressing like a Las Vegas crack whore.
This cunt has absolutely no class what so ever.
Start doing something to make this a better world you fake bitch.
Mariah is Gutter Trash.

  74. #74 - kim says – reply to this

    Mimi, You're going to be 40 years old, would you please stop dressing like a hootchie???

  75. #75 - La Reina says – reply to this

    Madonna needs to retire - her old ass should be taking care of her kids instead of actin like she is still stuck in the 80's. She didn't have class then and she sure doesn't have class now. But it's worse now since she is so old. And Mariah, granted she is also pushing it. She looks ridiculous dressing the way she does. How stupid are u that u dress like that even in the dead of winter. But if I had to choose between them I'd say Mariah since she has by far the best voice. Sorry Madge be a mother to your kids instead of being a whore to the world.

  76. #76 - E=M(essy)C(unt)2 says – reply to this

    Mariah just really needs to suck it: E=M(essy)C(unt)2

  77. #77 - Madonna Makes Mariah Spray Tan says – reply to this

    Re: madonnasass
    "Being that she didn't promote the single or the video, that should be EXPECTED"

    The same could be said when you compare the first week sales of Hard Candy and E=MCSkank…..right? But it's a different story when it comes to Mariah, huh?

  78. #78 - american dream************* says – reply to this

    why is there so much negative shit out there? appreciate these two divas for their successes and relevance all these years…and for all you haters on both of them — keep your piehole shut and get on with life! no one wants to hear your negative comments. why don't you try and figure out the american dream like these two ladies have instead of wasting your time writing bullshit.

  79. #79 - gina says – reply to this

    Madonna Leads 200 With 7th No. 1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    CONGRATS MADONNA!!!!

  80. #80 - willbill says – reply to this

    what is all this shit… Mariah is better blah blah blah REMEMBER WHY 4 minutes didnt hit number 1? can anyone guess? She started selling the single shortly after it came out on the radio!!! 4 minutes BY NO MEANS was at its radio peak, and in fact, it still isnt. Had Madonna released 4 minutes on Itunes etc 2 weeks ago.. IT most definitely would b number 1. the billboard hot 100 is a 50/50 split of sales/airplay the sales of the single went to #1 while airplay was relatively low. Airplay is up now.. and the sales are slowing down a bit. Touch MY BUTTHOLE was released as a digital single at TOUCH MY BUTTHOLES airplay PEAk. exactly what Hooriah is known for doing. and now where is it?? dropping like stone in BOTH CATEGORIES. while 4 Minutes is still selling strong and INCREASING on AIRPLAY

    All you madonna haters need to stop ….Mariah can have her 1 chart statistic of most number 1's but any logical human being knows madonna OWNS almost EVERY OTHER RECORD.

  81. #81 - Kyle says – reply to this

    Ha Ha! Don't get your knickers in a twist because Mariah almost sold DOUBLE of what Madonna's album sold. Always tryin to bring someone down….

  82. #82 - DITA says – reply to this

    HAHAHAHA MADONNA'S #1

  83. #83 - FOX NEWS says – reply to this

    BILLBOARD:
    MADONNA’S HARD CANDY DEBUTS AT #1 AROUND THE WORLD
    It seems that the entire world has quite an appetite for Madonna’s new album, Hard Candy, with the record debuting at number one in no fewer than 27 countries. In addition to debuting at the top of the chart in Canada and the United States in North America, the album has also entered at number one in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Australia, Germany, Italy, France, Japan, Holland, South Africa, Sweden, Finland and Slovakia, to name just a few.

  84. #84 - Kara says – reply to this

    mimi is a whore, madge rules

  85. #85 - wayne says – reply to this

    Re: Sara luvs Mariah

    go suck on a horse's testicles. i disagree, bitch.

  86. #86 - china says – reply to this

    LOVE you madonna

  87. #87 - michael says – reply to this

    Miriah should stop dressing like a slut!

  88. #88 - california angel says – reply to this

    Go Madonna!
    yay. Give it 2 Me is my favorite one on the album. Get the deluxe version and it comes with cool remixes of both 4 minutes and Give it 2 Me (remixed by paul oakenfold!)

  89. #89 - Adam says – reply to this

    Love the battle of the Divas, ups! let me refrase there's only one true Grandiose, Expectacular Diva of the all………………Madonna ofcourse!

  90. #90 - haho says – reply to this

    Madonna forever!! Mariah should just keep chasing butterflies with her baby brother, I mean husband…….

  91. #91 - Music Chart Experts say: says – reply to this

    • For those chart watchers (and diva enthusiasts) who are trying to draw comparisons between "Hard Candy's" 280,000 bow and Mariah Carey's 463,000 start with her new "E=MC2," hold your horses. During "E=MC2's" release week, Carey pulled out all the stops and performed on "American Idol," "The Oprah Winfrey Show" and "Good Morning America." During "Hard Candy's" release week, Madonna did not perform on TV. In fact, she has yet to perform on American TV to promote this album. Last week, the only chat show she visited was BET's "106 and Park" (May 2).

    • Madonna did, however, stage a well-publicized club show at the Roseland Ballroom in New York on April 30, which was streamed online via MSN. But a club show — no matter how hot — can't compare with the impact "American Idol" and Oprah Winfrey has. And, keep in mind that Carey was returning with her first album since her comeback set, "The Emancipation of Mimi," which also happens to be the biggest selling album of 2005.

  92. #92 - Andrew says – reply to this

    Does anyone forget to notice that mariah sold nearly 200,000 more cds in the US on her debut and her album received much higher marks in nearly every trade pub.

    Perez is so biased its absurd. Pretty funny how a tricky stewart/dream produced song in Touch My Body held up pretty well against a Timbaland/Timberlake Collabo.

  93. #93 - q says – reply to this

    she has not got a nice face

  94. #94 - MANDY says – reply to this

    CONGRATS TO BOTH DIVAS!!! HOWEVER, I HAVE TO GIVE UP TO MADONNA FOR DELIVERING ANOTHER KICK-ASSSSS ALBUM. HER STUFF IS KILLER!

  95. #95 - trish says – reply to this

    Who cares what # on the chart she's at.. That song is very pretty!!

  96. #96 - Madonna MANIA on U.S. Soundscan chart!!! says – reply to this

    Madonna is ALL OVER the new Soundscan digital singles chart released today! Check out the amazing numbers!

    4 MINUTES comes in at # 3, selling an additional 150,000 downloads this week

    GIVE IT TO ME comes in at # 21, selling around 37,000 downloads

    CANDY SHOP & BEAT GOES ON also were on the Top 200 Downloads chart ….

  97. #97 - JC says – reply to this

    OK..LOL…Thats great! There must be something wrong with her to get married after 6 weeks? Hmmm do I smell another breakdown???????? GO MADONNA!

  98. #98 - I LOVE IT!!!! says – reply to this

    Shannan, Perez hates on EVERYONE, even Madonna, so get over it.
    Perez has been creaming over Mariah for the past 2 weeks.
    Mariah can't have #1's every single time, people, so just relax.

    The only reason I was happy to read this post, is I'm tired of all Mariah's
    fans hating on Madonna. What purpose does that serve? They don't even have the same music buying audience!!

    WHO CARES if Mariah had 173,000 or so (not over 200k as falsely claimed by
    Shannan) sales more than Madonna in the first week? Both of these ladies have staying power. More power to BOTH of them! Why do Mariah's fans have to try and downplay every postive Madonna song and Album? It's stupid.

    I'm sure they are going to go back and forth with numbers and popular singles, during the next 6 months or so. Let EACH of them enjoy their
    chart successes and stop acting like 12 year olds, when one does better than
    the other!

    I'm so over this stupid site, with the 'so called' feud between Madonna and Mariah. Madonna actually said she liked Mariah's album last week in an interview, but Diva Mariah couldn't bring herself to say anything nice about Madonna, who paved the way for her career?? It's just a testament to who
    has more class between "M" and Mariah (and their fans). Peace out!

  99. #99 - jc says – reply to this

    I just downloaded Hard Candy and it SUCKS. I have loved every Madonna album from Like a Prayer to Confessions (yes, I even thought American Life was well done) but this album is shite. some good beats but her lyrics are horrible and the vocal melodies are flat. The songs mostly sound like her B-side bomb tracks from the 80's like Physical Attraciton and White Heat…remember them? OF COURSE YOU DON"T CAUSE THEY SUCKED

  100. #100 - IS IT ME?!!! says – reply to this

    Duh!! which way did he go? slow clothing; slow hair; She just looks slow in this pic. like she's having difficulty trying to be intelligent and young at the same time.

More comments: [1] 2 »