Who Did It Better????

Filed under: Celebrity Feuds > Miley Cyrus > Katy Perry

While Miley Cyrus and Katy Perry are currently engaged in a friendly war of words, we thought we'd let their music do the talking and have you do the picking.

The Disney star covered Breakout, a song Perry recorded years ago, for her new album, and Miley even chose that as the title of her record.

So, which version do you like best: Katy's or Miley's?????

Check them both out below (Perry is on top, Cyrus is below).

Which version do you like better???

Miley Cyrus's! (58%)
Katy Perry's! (42%)

Total Votes: 223,420

Loading …

[Images via WENN.]

Posted: Jul 30, 2008 at 3:45 pm / Email this »

See All 933 Comments

933 comments to “Who Did It Better????”

More comments: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »

She S says – reply to this

1

First fuckers
Kevin says – reply to this

2

I think overall Katy is better, but this song goes to Miley
funky says – reply to this

3

erm like 10th yeh?
oisin says – reply to this

4

first!
getba says – reply to this

5

first
BRITT says – reply to this

6

KATY PERRY'S SOUNDS BETTER TO MEEEEEEEEE!!!
ALLIE says – reply to this

7

katys is better… but just by a little.
sunda says – reply to this

8

i vote katy perry, because miley cyrus's version sounds exactly like the original, only with crappier vocals. what happened to adding your own personal touch?
tbags says – reply to this

9

both sound the same….besides the 15 yr old voice to the sex-ness of katy perry!
rebec says – reply to this

10

that kate perrys got a better voice; it suits the song more
hey says – reply to this

11

mileyyssss is so much better
tdigg says – reply to this

12

neither. stupid song.
chara says – reply to this

13

FIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIRST!!! FUCK MILEY U SUCK BITCH
Nic says – reply to this

14

miley's voice is better
Caiti says – reply to this

15

FIRST!!!

Miley is ANNOYING! Go Katy!
rufus says – reply to this

16

first
kb says – reply to this

17

katy perry has more talent than miley ever will
moi says – reply to this

18

first?
joejo says – reply to this

19

MILEY!
Chels says – reply to this

20

Team perry on this one.
erin says – reply to this

21

Miley's voice is like nails on a chalkboard - pure, annoying crap.
court says – reply to this

22

They both suck
GUAM1 says – reply to this

23

OYE! choices… choices… choices… What to do… I tell ya!
Dani says – reply to this

24

Firsttt
Kate says – reply to this

25

First!
HSW says – reply to this

26

Grow up, Miley! Stop acting like such a little diva brat. Your 15 minutes are over!
willi says – reply to this

27

katy perry is so much better…first
miley says – reply to this

28

Miley forever!
jfn,m says – reply to this

29

miley is a slut
BRITT says – reply to this

30

MILEYY
deb says – reply to this

31

FIRST
laur says – reply to this

32

FIRST.

they both suck.
spiri says – reply to this

33

Katy is soooooooooooooo much MORE original!!!!! Not so POP TARTish…..
chell says – reply to this

34

KATY PERRY!
dnice says – reply to this

35

FIRST!!! BITCHES
Gidge says – reply to this

36

Miley gets on my nerves more and more every day.
ida says – reply to this

37

I'd have to choose Perry, seeing as Montana's screechy voice gives me a headache.
blah says – reply to this

38

katy perry hands down.. her version is way better.. plus she doesnt sound lik an idiot
Phoen says – reply to this

39

Miley's is better.
Hands down.

Katy should stick to doing backup for her.
Check the liner notes.

Her fifteen minutes of fame are up.
ss says – reply to this

40

FUCK THSUI SHIT
Pure says – reply to this

41

rum
overi says – reply to this

42

where is Miley's publicist? Someone needs to sit this girl down and tell her to shut up!
What is the big allure of Miley? She talks like a boy too.
SHUT UP MILEY! you make yourself look like a brat with all your stupid comments to the press.
erin says – reply to this

43

fuck slutty cyrus
lo says – reply to this

44

i like katy. mileys just annoying
pryro says – reply to this

45

leave miley alone
addy says – reply to this

46

im just used to the miley version cause of her cd, it seems like the lyrics dont fit katy perry
xoxo
kel says – reply to this

47

Mileys is better. i love katy perry, but i think mileys sounds better.
bee says – reply to this

48

i love them both.
gmail says – reply to this

49

first
Jessi says – reply to this

50

Hate to say it but Miley's is better.
jessy says – reply to this

51

Miley's is AMAZING! Plus, Miley wrote the song.
Buckwheat says – reply to this

52

Who be singin that Achey Breaky Heart song? I lub dat song. Who of dey ladies used to hab that mullett hair? I lub dat mullet hair.
krist says – reply to this

53

First!
haha says – reply to this

54

katy perry!!!!!
Bren says – reply to this

55

Katty is soo much better!!!
Kyle says – reply to this

56

Miley is such a skank it makes me sick - I swear in her version I can actually hear the sound of her vagina crying from all the abuse. Katy is fabulous. I'd do her. And I'm gay.
Erica says – reply to this

57

Miley is really getting annoying!
frand says – reply to this

58

miley is so lame… katy perry rocks!!
jessi says – reply to this

59

katy
sara says – reply to this

60

ewww miley sucks!
Yali3 says – reply to this

61

I LOVE KATY PERRY>>>

xoxoxoxxo
KT says – reply to this

62

first!
linds says – reply to this

63

first
ISSA says – reply to this

64

KATY!!!
loveg says – reply to this

65

MILEY!
Scooo says – reply to this

66

Miley's better!
miley says – reply to this

67

miley sucks
woo says – reply to this

68

katy perry deffo
Britt says – reply to this

69

TEAM KATY!!!
amy says – reply to this

70

they sound pretty much the same except Katies voice
is not annoying
grly2 says – reply to this

71

Both suck
haha! says – reply to this

72

1st!
Ashle says – reply to this

73

first! i love miley!
HH says – reply to this

74

Miley SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Danie says – reply to this

75

First, and def. Katy!!
louis says – reply to this

76

katy clearly has the better version.miley sounds like a chipmunk on drugs.
kayce. says – reply to this

77

dayum! i am glad perez said whose was whose b/c miley didn't even ATTEMPT to do somet diff w/ the song, LOL.
demi says – reply to this

78

miley's for sure!
ashle says – reply to this

79

miley's is much better! but they're both whores.
aimee says – reply to this

80

i actually like miley's better….not a huge fan of katy perry. her voice just sounds strange to me..
Danni says – reply to this

81

Katy's a better singer
scott says – reply to this

82

they're both lame. really lame. i don't get the katy thing. i don't get the miley thing. hate them both.
erin says – reply to this

83

i actually like miley's more .
kaile says – reply to this

84

Perry's better…
Whole says – reply to this

85

FIRST
Alice says – reply to this

86

Miley's is easily better.
Hewsk says – reply to this

87

who gives a shit?
vanes says – reply to this

88

cyrus sucks shes such a hypocrite! katy mouth is where her money is
rose says – reply to this

89

gotta admit, they sound wicked similar
Lau says – reply to this

90

FIRST!!!!! MILEY SUCKS
katie says – reply to this

91

definitely katy perry's! miley sucks, i hate her and i wish she would go away….. along with her washed up dad
Jayme says – reply to this

92

Im sorry but Im sick of Miley Cyrus. My 11 year old daughter adores her. I dont have the heart to let her in on what a little slut she is. KATY Perry is amazing. Her original is way better. Why? Because it's Katy Fucking Perry. 6 Weeks Number 1.
2nd t says – reply to this

93

2nd!
jelly says – reply to this

94

unfortunatley miley's cover was better.
ayjay says – reply to this

95

KATY ROCKS

MILEYS A WHORE
nugge says – reply to this

96

nugget for miley she eats them
hey says – reply to this

97

miley sux
click says – reply to this

98

i hate miley soooooooooo much
Emi says – reply to this

99

Neither!!
Gen says – reply to this

100

Miley's voice sounds digitally enhanced. Yuck.