Welcome to PerezHilton.com
Welcome to PerezHilton.com - Hollywood's Most-Hated Web Site!
Celebrity Scoop Goes Here
E-mail Perez@PerezHilton.com

Report technical problems.
Perez Posse signup FAQ

Contact us to advertise on PerezHilton.com



Wear it, share it, give it, get it! Represent!

Jump to your favorite celebrity

Articles by date
« Fergie Hearts Hookers
Ed McMahon's Life Sucks Even More »

Who Did It Better????

Filed under: Celebrity Feuds > Miley Cyrus > Katy Perry

mileykatie__opt1.jpg

While Miley Cyrus and Katy Perry are currently engaged in a friendly war of words, we thought we'd let their music do the talking and have you do the picking.

The Disney star covered Breakout, a song Perry recorded years ago, for her new album, and Miley even chose that as the title of her record.

So, which version do you like best: Katy's or Miley's?????

Check them both out below (Perry is on top, Cyrus is below).

Which version do you like better???

  • Miley Cyrus's! (58%)
  • Katy Perry's! (42%)

Total Votes: 223,420

Loading ... Loading …

[Images via WENN.]

Posted: July 30, 2008 at 3:45 pm


933 comments to “Who Did It Better????”

More comments: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »

  1. She S says – reply to this
    1

    First fuckers

  2. Kevin says – reply to this
    2

    I think overall Katy is better, but this song goes to Miley

  3. funky says – reply to this
    3

    erm like 10th yeh?

  4. oisin says – reply to this
    4

    first!

  5. getba says – reply to this
    5

    first

  6. BRITT says – reply to this
    6

    KATY PERRY'S SOUNDS BETTER TO MEEEEEEEEE!!!

  7. ALLIE says – reply to this
    7

    katys is better… but just by a little.

  8. sunda says – reply to this
    8

    i vote katy perry, because miley cyrus's version sounds exactly like the original, only with crappier vocals. what happened to adding your own personal touch?

  9. tbags says – reply to this
    9

    both sound the same….besides the 15 yr old voice to the sex-ness of katy perry!

  10. rebec says – reply to this
    10

    that kate perrys got a better voice; it suits the song more

  11. hey says – reply to this
    11

    mileyyssss is so much better

  12. tdigg says – reply to this
    12

    neither. stupid song.

  13. chara says – reply to this
    13

    FIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIRST!!! FUCK MILEY U SUCK BITCH

  14. Nic says – reply to this
    14

    miley's voice is better

  15. Caiti says – reply to this
    15

    FIRST!!!

    Miley is ANNOYING! Go Katy!

  16. rufus says – reply to this
    16

    first

  17. kb says – reply to this
    17

    katy perry has more talent than miley ever will

  18. moi says – reply to this
    18

    first?

  19. joejo says – reply to this
    19

    MILEY!

  20. Chels says – reply to this
    20

    Team perry on this one.

  21. erin says – reply to this
    21

    Miley's voice is like nails on a chalkboard - pure, annoying crap.

  22. court says – reply to this
    22

    They both suck

  23. GUAM1 says – reply to this
    23

    OYE! choices… choices… choices… What to do… I tell ya!

  24. Dani says – reply to this
    24

    Firsttt

  25. Kate says – reply to this
    25

    First!

  26. HSW says – reply to this
    26

    Grow up, Miley! Stop acting like such a little diva brat. Your 15 minutes are over!

  27. willi says – reply to this
    27

    katy perry is so much better…first

  28. miley says – reply to this
    28

    Miley forever!

  29. jfn,m says – reply to this
    29

    miley is a slut

  30. BRITT says – reply to this
    30

    MILEYY

  31. deb says – reply to this
    31

    FIRST

  32. laur says – reply to this
    32

    FIRST.

    they both suck.

  33. spiri says – reply to this
    33

    Katy is soooooooooooooo much MORE original!!!!! Not so POP TARTish…..

  34. chell says – reply to this
    34

    KATY PERRY!

  35. dnice says – reply to this
    35

    FIRST!!! BITCHES

  36. Gidge says – reply to this
    36

    Miley gets on my nerves more and more every day.

  37. ida says – reply to this
    37

    I'd have to choose Perry, seeing as Montana's screechy voice gives me a headache.

  38. blah says – reply to this
    38

    katy perry hands down.. her version is way better.. plus she doesnt sound lik an idiot :)

  39. Phoen says – reply to this
    39

    Miley's is better.
    Hands down.

    Katy should stick to doing backup for her.
    Check the liner notes.

    Her fifteen minutes of fame are up.

  40. ss says – reply to this
    40

    FUCK THSUI SHIT

  41. Pure says – reply to this
    41

    rum

  42. overi says – reply to this
    42

    where is Miley's publicist? Someone needs to sit this girl down and tell her to shut up!
    What is the big allure of Miley? She talks like a boy too.
    SHUT UP MILEY! you make yourself look like a brat with all your stupid comments to the press.

  43. erin says – reply to this
    43

    fuck slutty cyrus

  44. lo says – reply to this
    44

    i like katy. mileys just annoying

  45. pryro says – reply to this
    45

    leave miley alone

  46. addy says – reply to this
    46

    im just used to the miley version cause of her cd, it seems like the lyrics dont fit katy perry
    xoxo

  47. kel says – reply to this
    47

    Mileys is better. i love katy perry, but i think mileys sounds better.

  48. bee says – reply to this
    48

    i love them both.

  49. gmail says – reply to this
    49

    first

  50. Jessi says – reply to this
    50

    Hate to say it but Miley's is better.

  51. jessy says – reply to this
    51

    Miley's is AMAZING! Plus, Miley wrote the song.

  52. 52

    Who be singin that Achey Breaky Heart song? I lub dat song. Who of dey ladies used to hab that mullett hair? I lub dat mullet hair.

  53. krist says – reply to this
    53

    First!

  54. haha says – reply to this
    54

    katy perry!!!!!

  55. Bren says – reply to this
    55

    Katty is soo much better!!!

  56. Kyle says – reply to this
    56

    Miley is such a skank it makes me sick - I swear in her version I can actually hear the sound of her vagina crying from all the abuse. Katy is fabulous. I'd do her. And I'm gay.

  57. Erica says – reply to this
    57

    Miley is really getting annoying!

  58. frand says – reply to this
    58

    miley is so lame… katy perry rocks!!

  59. jessi says – reply to this
    59

    katy

  60. sara says – reply to this
    60

    ewww miley sucks!

  61. Yali3 says – reply to this
    61

    I LOVE KATY PERRY>>>

    xoxoxoxxo

  62. KT says – reply to this
    62

    first!

  63. linds says – reply to this
    63

    first

  64. ISSA says – reply to this
    64

    KATY!!!

  65. loveg says – reply to this
    65

    MILEY!

  66. Scooo says – reply to this
    66

    Miley's better!

  67. miley says – reply to this
    67

    miley sucks

  68. woo says – reply to this
    68

    katy perry deffo

  69. Britt says – reply to this
    69

    TEAM KATY!!!

  70. amy says – reply to this
    70

    they sound pretty much the same except Katies voice
    is not annoying

  71. grly2 says – reply to this
    71

    Both suck

  72. haha! says – reply to this
    72

    1st!

  73. Ashle says – reply to this
    73

    first! :) i love miley!

  74. HH says – reply to this
    74

    Miley SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  75. Danie says – reply to this
    75

    First, and def. Katy!!

  76. louis says – reply to this
    76

    katy clearly has the better version.miley sounds like a chipmunk on drugs.

  77. 77

    dayum! i am glad perez said whose was whose b/c miley didn't even ATTEMPT to do somet diff w/ the song, LOL.

  78. demi says – reply to this
    78

    miley's for sure!

  79. ashle says – reply to this
    79

    miley's is much better! but they're both whores.

  80. aimee says – reply to this
    80

    i actually like miley's better….not a huge fan of katy perry. her voice just sounds strange to me..

  81. Danni says – reply to this
    81

    Katy's a better singer

  82. scott says – reply to this
    82

    they're both lame. really lame. i don't get the katy thing. i don't get the miley thing. hate them both.