Who Did It Better????

mileykatie__opt1.jpg

While Miley Cyrus and Katy Perry are currently engaged in a friendly war of words, we thought we'd let their music do the talking and have you do the picking.

The Disney star covered Breakout, a song Perry recorded years ago, for her new album, and Miley even chose that as the title of her record.

So, which version do you like best: Katy's or Miley's?????

Check them both out below (Perry is on top, Cyrus is below).

Which version do you like better???

  • Miley Cyrus's! (58%)
  • Katy Perry's! (42%)

Total Votes: 223,420

Loading ... Loading …

[Images via WENN.]

    Posted: Jul 30, 2008 at 3:45 pm / Email this  »

    933 comments to “Who Did It Better????”

    More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 [10]

    1. LEX says – reply to this


      901

      Miley has more emotion in her voice… i think Katy's voice just sounds very flat. Plus, you know that Disney put way more work into Miley's single than who ever did Katy's. Don't get me wrong… i LOVE Katy Perry. But, I just think that Miley's is better. :)

    2. ashle says – reply to this


      902

      dude…..
      the song sounds better with miley,mostly because the lyrics sound more realistic with miley because miley is 15 and STILL GOES to school and kate is 23! its more of a pre-teen song. so yes.miley did it better.

    3. Miley says – reply to this


      903

      MILEY IS SOOOOOO MUCH BETTER!! SND DOES KATY PERRY SING THAT SONG I KISSED A GIRL?

    4. pauna says – reply to this


      904

      mileys better

    5. Jilly says – reply to this


      905

      mileys is wayyyyy better

    6. anna says – reply to this


      906

      this song is mileys song katy just sung it as a demo for a record deal then the song was sent to mileys label and they wanted to put it on the first miley cyrus cd but it was too late so they put it on the newest album so miley isn't a bitch and hasnt stolen the song it belongs 100% to miley cyrus. the songwriters are Gina Schock,Ted Bruner& Trey Vittetoe so katy didn't wrote it and katy just want to damage miley cause she didn't wanted to kiss her !!! and that sucks !

    7. jjfro says – reply to this


      907

      i don't like the song at all no matter who sings it.

    8. Franc says – reply to this


      908

      Katy Perry has the most manly voice ever she cant sing seriously when i ehard her gay song i kissed a girl i thought it was a guy then i heard something bout boyfriend and im like huh?

    9. kia says – reply to this


      909

      Miley!!!!!!!!!! all the way

    10. kit says – reply to this


      910

      Ok i think Miley Did WAY Better.I Think it was more fun to dance to.But their Both Amazing Singers.

    11. Selen says – reply to this


      911

      Ok i think uhh MILEY! KATYS SOUNDS LIKE CRAP!

    12. jasmi says – reply to this


      912

      miley is just another avril shes claiming to write these songs yet clearly she didnt she needs to stop she doesnt even know how to sing

    13. Selen says – reply to this


      913

      Ok i think uhh MILEY! KATYS SOUNDS LIKE CRAP!

    14. Selen says – reply to this


      914

      Ok i think uhh MILEY! KATYS SOUNDS LIKE CRAP!

    15. MiLEY says – reply to this


      915

      MILEY IS A COPY KAT AnD REaLLY NEEDS TO STOP SO WHAT iFF IS SOUNds A LITTlE BEtteER SHE stil COPYED aND its stupid how YO U CAN do IT
      GO KATY!! Miley SUKS!!! deal w// it @#%*! her

    16. mdb says – reply to this


      916

      it seems as though miley can't write her own songs… she has to steal others songs frist cheyenne now katy perry….
      thats jut not right

    17. Aimee says – reply to this


      917

      Katy's is better!
      I agree with Sunda: If you're gonna sing someone else's song, at least add your own personal touch to it.

    18. becca says – reply to this


      918

      HAHA, youuu jealous bitch, perez, mile yfucking worte that song GO AWAY RETARDDD



    19. 919

      Miley is a cuuuuunt who needs to come up with her own stuff :)

    20. Chris says – reply to this


      920

      KATY!!! IS WAY. MILEY BE MORE ORIGINAL NEXTIME YOU SUCK! YOUR VOICE IS ANNOYING.

    21. Karin says – reply to this


      921

      Miley sucks monkey balls and Katy rules, but Miley's voice goes better with this song.

    22. PEREZ says – reply to this


      922

      PEREZ IS JUST A HATER YA KNOW?
      HIS GAY A$S LAME REMARKS ABOUT PEOPLE.
      HIS GAY A$S LOOKING HAIR COLOR CHANGING
      NO LIVE HAVING GOSSSIP TALKING
      WISHIN HE WAS A GIRL
      MOTHAFUCK3R.
      YOU NEED TO GET LOST FORREAL
      YOU FAT FREAK



    23. 923

      Katy perry. her voice is MUCH more unique. its different in a good way. in a way that makes u want more. miley cyrus voice is much more… well…



    24. 924

      MILEY IS WAY A BETTER SINGER THAN PERRY! I CAN TELL



    25. 925

      i just hate slutty cyrus!! and i think katy's song its a lot much better!



    26. 926

      miley sucks .(not sure what gender she DOES suck though)
      used to think she was good .
      until i found out what a slut/bitch she is .

      katy perry is WAY better .



    27. 927

      katy's is wayyyy better than slutty cyrus!



    28. 928

      Katy is a millionkajillion times better and so is all her songs :)

      TEAM KATY!!

      www.katyperryblog.com



    29. 929

      i hate to say it, but mileys version IS better. :(
      But i like katy perry lots better!!!
      i cant believe miley copied her song!!!
      grrr.



    30. 930

      I think Miley's sound better. A teen sing it sounds better than an adult singing it. Sorry Katy Perry.

    31. Toria says – reply to this


      931

      Id have to say Miley even tho Katy is 1 hot chica ..



    32. 932

      Katy Perry is AWSOME~~ And Miley Cyrus…NOT! But the song has to go to Miley though.



    33. 933

      Katy Perry is better. She's better in everything : song, voice, talent, looks, personality, reputation, and I can just keep going.
      The only reason people are voting Miley is because they heard her version first. It is everywhere.
      But still. Katy will always win!!!

    More comments: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 [10]