Home Videos Photos
Home >> American Idol >> Remember Her?

Remember Her?

Filed under: American Idol

dianaaaaa.jpg

Hey, remember Diana DeGarmo from the third season of American Idol?

At a tender 16-years-old she was the second youngest AI contestant and narrowly lost the competition to Fantasia.

All grown up and sporting a new dark 'do we hardly recognized the singer at the CMAs on Wednesday nght!

Which Diana do U prefer?

[Photos via Getty Images.]

    Posted: Nov 13, 2008 at 5:45 pm / Email this  »
    « Previous story
    Wowie Wow Wonder Woman!
    Next story »
    Whoopi Goes Global - Keeps Busy!
    See All 74 Comments

    74 comments to “Remember Her?”



    1. 1

      I always loved Diana! I wanted her to win, not fan-terrible.



    2. 2

      black hair!! nicer more mature too defently



    3. 3

      P.S. I think she looks great both ways.



    4. 4

      The dark hair Diana!!



    5. 5

      no thats not the same person, thats a white girl and an asian girl two different people

      sorry perez dont believe this one…

      who the eff cares about diana degarmo aanyway?



    6. 6

      i like the newer one…..



    7. 7

      neither.



    8. 8

      where's the pooch?!



    9. 9

      Watch those hyphens! This should be "16 years old."



    10. 10

      i love her either way



    11. 11

      She looks way better now.



    12. 12

      Wow, would not have recogized her. Looks better with the dark do



    13. 13

      I like it dark. She looks so much older.



    14. 14

      why was she even there?!



    15. 15

      Sarahaha wake up dumb ass!!! Ofcourse that is Diana, don't forget the picture on the left was taken a few years ago



    16. 16

      The new look, is MUCH better. Something about her old look back then always bugged me. The highlighted hair was much too light for her complexion, it washed her out.



    17. 17

      The Big Titty Blonde Piggy.



    18. 18

      Re: SBFREAKSgirl925 – Hey Hot Stuff!



    19. 19

      She looks like a typical Long Islander woman.



    20. 20

      look at her eyes and eybrows…yep its her…wow she has matured, I wonder if her voice has also…



    21. 21

      I love the dark look - it looks more like she embraces her ethnicity, instead of trying to cover it up.



    22. 22

      She is awesome and a very good singer



    23. 23

      EW It's Diana DeGarbage! I always hated her!



    24. 24

      i like the old one.



    25. 25

      She looks great both ways but the darker do looks more mature and more natural. She is a beautiful girl.



    26. 26

      Definitely the dark-haired. It makes her look more sophisticated.



    27. 27

      they dont even look like the same person….wow



    28. 28

      SHE LOOKS
      BETTER NOW..
      PUBERTY WAS
      KIND TO HER ! ! !



    29. 29

      sustuhhh lookin guudd.
      haha naw I like the one with black hair, She looks great.



    30. 30

      Darker! she looks chic and polished! who is she again??



    31. 31

      She look cute when she was sixteen, and she looks beautiful now!



    32. 32

      i love diana! she was my favorite that season of american idol, and i saw her when she played penny in hairspray on broadway :) she really has mutured with age and she looks amazing!



    33. 33

      duh…thats a no brainer…..the new one



    34. 34

      the one on the left looks great;;o by the way perez is she a s@lt or a tramp tell me cause only you know!!!



    35. 35

      Wow, she looks fantastic! She should have won AI that season instead of that screeching Fantasia person who made my ears bleed every time she sang.

    36. ajbwb says – reply to this


      36

      SHE LOOKS GREAT HOT HOT HOT LOVE HER



    37. 37

      we have friends in common….hung out with her at a bar downtown atlanta…

      BITCH

      I have pictures if you want them



    38. 38

      Darker….with the blonde she was just too pageanty.



    39. 39

      dark hair all the way! she looks fab!



    40. 40

      Well, the dark hair is a bit extreme, but she is amazing!!! I got to see her do Penny Pingleton in HAIRSPRAY on Broadway and she was AWESOME! She turned that role upside down!
      I hope she gets more roles on Broadway!!!



    41. 41

      Ewwwwww….on both pics.



    42. 42

      dark is better for sure



    43. 43

      She looks hard, not like a 20 year old. When will young girls get it: Trying too hard makes them look old, not sophisticated.

    44. evw93 says – reply to this


      44

      i wanted her to win when she was on. her record wasnt too shabby. why did she dissapear?



    45. 45

      Is she Asian?



    46. 46

      She looks SO much better.

    47. exBFF says – reply to this


      47

      is there an option for D: None of the above?



    48. 48

      Does anyone else notice her eyebrows in the right picture? It is the better picture of course, but her right eyebrow looks…hmmm…shall we say interesting?

    49. Bumpy says – reply to this


      49

      Re: ShereenGeorges –
      I couldn't believe nobody mentioned that before. That was the first thing I saw.



    50. 50

      the 'After'



    51. 51

      did you guys know, that she was asked to try out for high school musical when it first came out???

      who's regreting that now!



    52. 52

      She is looking much better now. Basic black is always a good bet. I always thought she was quite hideous, but this is a step in the right direction. Wow. That sounded like I actually care.



    53. 53

      i still don't like her
      anyway u made a spelling mistake
      sorry im just like that



    54. 54

      I prefer the one that shuts her pie hole and gets off my TV screen. She's been blabbing all over about Jennifer's Hudson family tragedy. UGH! Get a life, Diana!



    55. 55

      Dark



    56. 56

      When I saw that pic on People.com and it said "Diana DeGarmo" I was like 'Oh, whoops, typo! Seriously though, who is that?' Heh, I still can't believe it!



    57. 57

      I thought the person in black was Lucy Lui!



    58. 58

      New!



    59. 59

      I prefer the invisible one, you know, the one where i don't have to look at her ugly face. yeah, that one!



    60. 60

      looking great!
      she looks hot as a brunette!
      another 10 lbs n she will be a knockout!!

    61. tetzy says – reply to this


      61

      She's still jailbait so no, I wont comment.



    62. 62

      WHO CARES?????



    63. 63

      She probably feels more natural with the dark hair - i seem to remember her mentioning somewhere (is that vague enough for you? LOL) that she wasn't really feelin' the blonde! She look s really exotic on the right! Is she still singing??



    64. 64

      dark hiarr

    65. Daxie says – reply to this


      65

      What a classic beauty! She was fantastic then and will always be fantastic!



    66. 66

      Diana looks great with the darker hair. If anyone has Howard-TV. Check out Diana when she came on Howard b/c Eric the Midget showed up for his first in studio appearance. She was so cute. Great body!!!!



    67. 67

      i actually like the chunky version go figure



    68. 68

      I saw her in New York, she plays "Penny" in Hairspray on broadway. She was really amazing and definately made a funnier penny than Amanda Bynes!



    69. 69

      Wow, she looks nothing like she used to. Crazy. I think she looks great either way.



    70. 70

      She looks much better now! A whole lot slimmer, and the hair looks classier. No more schoolgirl hair!



    71. 71

      dark haired diana 100% improvement!



    72. 72

      darker hair. she looks less of a bimbo.



    73. 73

      I prefer whichever one is the first to GET NAKED!!



    74. 74

      Dark Hair, more mature definitly. I liked her better than fantasia or whatever! but the best idol rarely wins so…