Her??? Whom Would U Like To See In The American AbFab????

Filed under: TV News > Anglophilia

wenn52334993.jpg

As we previously mentioned, Fox is butchering making an American version of beloved British sitcom Absolutely Fabulous, the gay classic telling the sordid tales of Patsy and Edina.

Well, now Variety is reporting that Kristen Johnston is close to signing on to star in the show.

Is that a good thing or a bad thing????

The actress has won Emmys for her role on '90s sitcom 3rd Rock From the Sun.

Johnston table-read for the Fox execs on Friday. Shortly after they decided to pick up the American AbFab for a pilot. That doesn't guarantee the show will make it to the air or that Kristen will be in it.

Oh, yeah, and we buried the lead! Johnston would be playing the part of Edina (Jennifer Saunders' character).

Thoughts?????

Whom would U like to see playing those iconic roles?????

We vote for Megan Mulally (Edie) and Faye Dunaway (Pats)!!!!!!!

[Image via WENN.]

    Posted: Jan 28, 2009 at 9:00 am / Email this  »

    126 comments to “Her??? Whom Would U Like To See In The American AbFab????”

    More comments: [1] 2 »



    1. 1

      I vote the skip the whole fucking idea AND COME UP WITH SOMETHING NEW.



    2. 2

      Nice rack………. :o ) (((((((((((MOON KISS)))))))))))



    3. 3

      ( . )( . )'s! ;)



    4. 4

      A 'gay classic' ??? Which 'Absolutely Fabulous' have you been watching?



    5. 5

      Oh no! They can't ruin another great British comedy.
      Seriously.
      I don't wanna see anyone doing those roles, but if I did Megan Mulally for Edit IS a great choice, Perez.
      I don't know about Pats. Who can play that vapid a blond?



    6. 6

      Re: Long Dong Connery – Guten Tag! Wie Geht's schatz?!



    7. 7

      survey says - Hell NO

      leave this classic alone - it cannot be duplicated



    8. 8

      LOVE! LOVE! LOVE! Everyone listed would be great women for consideration. Megan Mulally…does it get any better?!?!?!



    9. 9

      Re: _Alice_ – I see your ( . )( . ) and raise you a pair of ( ° )( ° )



    10. 10

      EW WHO WOULD WATCH ANYHTING WITH HER IN IT CAN SHE HAVE ANY MORE BOTOX IN HER UGLY OLD FACE?

    11. LSD says – reply to this


      11

      ACTUALLY I PICTURED HER MORE AS PATSY RATHER THAN EDIE. I MISS ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS! THAT WAS ONE OF THE FUNNIEST SHOWS EVER!



    12. 12

      I vote for no remake, ESPECIALLY if it involves Megan Mulally as Edina. Seriously. Some things you just DON'T TOUCH.



    13. 13

      Nice tits! 2nd!



    14. 14

      WTF!!!



    15. 15

      wowww..perez, you took back your .perezhilton screen name..
      kool, coz that shit was fukin with me…
      I luved fukin Sally..she was such a fukin bitch..and the bigg Giant Head use to make me laugh..heheheeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
      dingdong..hehehehe
      I'm back baybay..shitfukshit..go back to bart simpson and look at my last 2 comment..fuked up..



    16. 16

      Way to be a journalist. It's spelled "lede" not "lead." You buried the lede.

      I also second M*I*A*R's motion to come up with something new.



    17. 17

      Re: _Alice_ – mornin frauline!!



    18. 18

      The last BBC season sucked bad enough now it's gonna go the way of the American version of Coupling. But I could see either Kristen or Faye as Pats



    19. 19

      No one should be playing these roles. Absolutely Fabulous worked because its humor is so fantastically British and Jennifer Saunders is simply awesome. Come up with your own ideas, stop stealing British shows!!

    20. Glen says – reply to this


      20

      what they need to do is re-invent it. Rather than do some fox schlocky shit they should take it to HBO so they can do it right and make it Eddie and Pats - two gay older dudes - leave saffron as the daugther and go from there. I would say Colin Furth as Eddie Monsoon, Rupert Everett as Patrick Stone - nothing says struggling to be young as two gay older men - :P



    21. 21

      Re: Long Dong Connery
      (((((( dingdong kisss hehehee)))))))))))))))



    22. 22

      fresh



    23. 23

      next



    24. 24

      Megan Mullaly is the only american actress I can actually picture in the role of either Edwina or Patsy.. I really hope its somewhat entertaining at least. I doubt Jennifer Saunders would let it be bad.



    25. 25


    26. 26

      Re: Sensitivity – Afternoon;)

    27. Glen says – reply to this


      27

      They need to lose Fox, go with HBO - and change it - Two gay men - Eddie Monsoon and Patrick Stone - played by Colin Furth an Rupert Everett - that way they can do it right - with all the drugs, fucking and language.. and it would play funnier in the US with gay guys.



    28. 28

      Hey peeps.



    29. 29

      Re: _Alice_ – Wie Gates Alice…..Long time no see ( . ) ( . ) ..
      How is Letty doing??? say hi form the Dong…..Re: SheriMoonZombie – Thanks….. you might have to go back to bart as well……… :o )



    30. 30

      ….she'd be better as Patsy…..it could happen….Megan Mulally already played a lush….plus she is too old for that part now….



    31. 31

      Re: harrybalsac – Hey Bossman……… Fucking 25cm of fucking snow today…..



    32. 32

      Re: _Alice_ – #25 Nahh! I was bluffing!



    33. 33

      I absolutely love her goof ability. I loved her on 3rd Rock From the Sun.



    34. 34

      NO NO NO NOT Faye Dunaway…she would piss everyone on the set off..including the cast and the show would fall apart by the 3rd episode

      I adore Megan Mulally, but she's already done this kinda role….



    35. 35

      Oh GOD!!! Everything but Megan Mullaly!!
      Kristen would be great!
      although Im a huge Jennifer fan and no one could be as good as her



    36. 36

      tits



    37. 37

      Re: _Alice_ – goudin abent!!



    38. 38

      I vote they leave it alone… They could never come close to Edina & Patsy. I'd rather see reruns of the real Ab Fab then have them ruin it by copying it.



    39. 39

      haha. Perez! Your picks are hilarious! I would LOVE to see Megan Mulally play Edie. She does drunk and snobby very well.



    40. 40

      Mornin Harry!!



    41. 41

      WTF



    42. 42

      Well…. She does look great!!!



    43. 43

      Re: zarrafakt Hates Perez – He doesn't realize that not everyone is a homo.



    44. 44

      Re: Long Dong Connery – Convert that to inches for this stupid American.



    45. 45

      This has got to be stopped, and then burned!



    46. 46

      She'd be OK as Edie - not great, but OK



    47. 47

      Okay, hold the phone: American TV networks have already massacered Kath and Kim and The Office. Please leave Ab/Fab alone!



    48. 48

      Kristen hasn't got the chops to do it, her comedy's too American, but maybe that'll play here! She's seriously funny, but needs a better vehicle that's more suited to what she's good at!



    49. 49

      They should keep the original series. With the exception of The Office I haven't heard of any british TV shows being successfully transfered to american TV.



    50. 50

      I would love to see Megan Mulally play Edie. She will do the role justice.



    51. 51

      I vote no one, because they should leave Absolutely Fabulous the fuck alone! I don't mind remakes, but I don't think this one will work at all.

      Though Megan Mulally would be a good choice.



    52. 52

      Re: harrybalsac – 12 subway sandwich………



    53. 53

      She would be perfect - I would absolutely love to see her - Kristen Johnson - be in that sit com. She is hilarious! I love her.



    54. 54

      next fruitcake



    55. 55

      Honestly, NO ONE! They shouldn't trash this iconic show with crappy actors trying to imitate the greatness that is Jennifer Saunders and Joanna Lumley and crew!



    56. 56

      Some things you don't touch. AF is one of them.

      Let it be, Fox.



    57. 57

      No one could duplicate the original.

    58. Pike says – reply to this


      58

      Absolutely Fabulous has nothing to do with gays. I hope the sue your home ass, Mario……………….



    59. 59

      I think Roseanne Barr (or whatever her last name is now)……owns the rights to this show so dont get your hopes up…..this has been up in the air for about 10 years now….
      .
      ABFAB is the funniest show ever to be on television…..I hope it happens….but i dont see it any time soons…….



    60. 60

      Alice………….. miss ya



    61. 61

      What's wrong with our version?!



    62. 62

      Sorry Perez, This one will fail horribly. Nothing and i mean NOTHING will make it as good as the original.



    63. 63

      i can guarantee that after the first few episodes, this show will tank. there is no messing with the original ab fab…



    64. 64

      i can see her as patsy, but not edina. i love this show and i hope they don't screw it up by making an american version.



    65. 65

      I can't imagine anyone else playing edina and patsy - what a waste!



    66. 66

      wtf………..



    67. 67

      Kristen Johnson is perfect for the Edina role.



    68. 68

      Ab fab is my favorite show in this world. I hope they don't butcher it trying to make it palatable for mid America. (not that Canada is a whole lot better) Johnston would be better suited as Pats and yes I agree Mulally as Eddie would be perfect.



    69. 69

      They should just not make it at all. Why do they have to remake things? They could just give those involved in original some $$ and credit by re-airing the amazingly great originials! They'd save some money not making a stinker.



    70. 70

      Didn't they try to bring AbFab to the States before? It was a FAILURE!!
      This is awful. Leave classic British comedies alone!



    71. 71

      Re: Obnoxious Joe – The only other Brit comedies that translated well were "All in the Family" and "Three's Company". The rest bombed!



    72. 72

      Kristen would make a great Patsy!



    73. 73

      Megan Mulally would be hilarious.



    74. 74

      Megan Mulally as Edina? No. And the only reason you think she'd be good in the part is because she played Karen on 'Will and Grace', who was also a drug/addict alcoholic with money. A fabulous character, and one of my favourites, but she's not right for Edina.

      As for you, Perez, you're fat, and stupid, and ugly.



    75. 75

      Christine Baranski as Pats



    76. 76

      LEAVE ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS ALONE! Dont ruin a iconic tv-show, please!



    77. 77

      That is so stupid…a remake of that show is impossible…it is classic and great…and Americans do not get that kind of humor…will be ruined…kath & kim anyone?



    78. 78

      WHY AMERICANS HAVE TO REMAKE EVERYTHING???

      The original version is awesome and I'm sure that american version will suck. Like ALL American remakes.



    79. 79

      it cannot be done!!! don't touch it!!
      the only people who might find it slightly funny would be those who've never seen the real thing.

      its like bacon and soja bacon….just can't replicate it…



    80. 80

      NOOOOOOO!!
      you have already slaughtered The Office…
      leave AbFab alone!



    81. 81

      Why remake Ab Fab, leave it alone! But if I had to pick US versions of the characters:

      Edina: Molly Shannon
      Patsy: Amy Sedaris

    82. Leto says – reply to this


      82

      I totally agree with YOUR cast Perez, Megan Mullaly has everything it takes to be an american Edina, and Faye would be suuuuch a great Patsy (I can totally figure her being as trashy-classy as Johanna Lumley lol)



    83. 83

      OMG she would be hilarious! She was awesome in Music and Lyrics, and she was recently in bride wars. She obviously wasn't the lead, but I think she deserves to be! This would be the perfect role for her….I've seen a few episodes of AbFab in the past, and that would be a perfect show for her.



    84. 84

      I also agree it should be re-booted with two middle aged gay men. gays are into celebs, drugs, booze and staying young. I'm not sure if the same can be said for american women.



    85. 85

      Nobody should ever, ever remake Ab Fab. The US version can never compare to the original……..to pc here…….drug use on primetime……drinking out of a vodka bottle… Selling your daughter for some pot while on vacation/holiday…..I think the fcc would actually step in. The US is too uptight when it comes to this stuff. And you wonder why British comedy is awesome!!

    86. D. says – reply to this


      86

      DO NOT DO IT… they butchered Kath & Kim and now they are going to butcher AbFab. Is there no one left in Tvland with some creative integrity of their own.

      Although we like Perez's choice.

      HANDS OF ORGINALS!



    87. 87

      I won't even consider it!!!! There's only ONE Absolutely Fabulous in the world… I'm Absolutely Fucking apalled at the insanely shiteous idea of an American version. What a bunch of wankers!!



    88. 88

      NO ONE! Look what american tv did to Kath & Kim!

    89. h311o says – reply to this


      89

      Nope. After watching Mamma Mia I really think the hilarious Christine Baranski should be Patsy. I don't see anyone else who could give Joanna Lumley a run for her money. Megan Mulally for Edie could work.

      Really. Apart from Christine Baranski for the role of Patsy I don't see how its going to work. Ab Fab is part of British culture as much as Dr Who is (and I hope to god the US don't want that one reinvented) and the first is always the best. Jennifer Saunders absolutely owns that role. As do Joanna Lumley and Julia Sawalha as Patsy and Saffy respectively. I'm not comfortable with America fucking it up. Leave it alone! Watch it the way it is! We do!



    90. 90

      NOOOOO…DONT TAKE A GENIUS SHOW AND MAKE IT SHIT!!!!!
      IM NOT BEING OFFENCIVE TO AMERICANS, US BRITS CANT TAKE A GOOD AMERICAN SHOW AND MAKE IT WELL IN BRITAIN, NO ONE SHOULD EVEN TRY!!!!!
      IF YOU WANT TO WATCH AB FAB…WATCH THE ORIGINAL…!!!!!!!!!!!



    91. 91

      Wouldn't make more sense for Kristen to play Patsy? I do not see her as Edina at all! I LOVE the idea of Megan Mulally as Edie!



    92. 92

      No way American TV will do any justice to AbFab. That said, Kristen Johnson is one of the better choices they could find. Megan M would be great, too, but it would be a rehash of her "Karen" character from Will & Grace so she may not be interested.



    93. 93

      It's not a classic you MORON!



    94. 94

      why do americans feel the need to fuck up everyone elses shows?



    95. 95

      Re: Monkey Claw – theres gonna be an american gavin and stacey too! sacreligious!!



    96. 96

      one of the best shows! don't mess it up!



    97. 97

      kristen fits the idea of being pats than eddie. eddie has to be petit. i do so agree that meagan mulally play eddie. megan is the american version on jennifer saunders. they are both completely wonderful. but it will be hard to redo a fantastic show like ab fab.



    98. 98

      Why mess with a classic? I still watch it on you tube. They are fabulously hilarious. Kristen would make a better Patsy than Eddie.



    99. 99

      I can totally see her doing Patsy, but never Edina. Part of Edina's thing is she perceives herself as Fat and does have a bit of extra weight. I can't see Kristen getting into character to play that. That is, IF they MUST bother redoing the show. The original was wonderful (at least the first 2 or 3 seasons) and best left as is.



    100. 100

      OH PLEASE DO NOT RE-MAKE THE SHOW!!
      .
      The original was so good, and there's no way to even come close…
      .
      Can American TV come up with its own ideas for once!?!? Almost every show is based on a British version!

    More comments: [1] 2 »