Home Videos Photos

Judge Kara DioGuardi May Not Return To Idol!!

| Filed under: TV NewsPaula AbdulAmerican IdolSimon Cowell

wenn2349853kara.jpg

Oh, Kara… We hardly knew ya!

The odds of American Idol's newest judge, Kara DioGuardi, sticking around once this season ends are looking slim!

What…. a…. surprise!

"I’m only here for one season," DioGuardi told reporters on Friday. "That’s what we’ve discussed. So we’ll see what happens."

There has been tons of speculation that DioGuardi was brought onto Idol to allow Paula Abdrool's exit from the show as smooth as possible, but boy, did that plan backfire!

Says Idol judge Simon Cowell, "The only say I have is about Ryan, Randy and Paula… I’ve always made it clear that I wouldn’t like to do the show without them. So that’s all I’m really concerned about."

So if Paula's out, Simon walks too???

Looks like the execs over at FOX didn't map out their Abdrool-solution too well, now did they?

[Image via WENN.]

59 comments to “Judge Kara DioGuardi May Not Return To Idol!!”



  1. 1

    WOW no one saw that coming Mario…



  2. 2

    what were they thinking adding her anyways



  3. 3

    Kara is OK but she needs to go, the rest stay.



  4. 4

    She should just leave now! She is so freaking annoying!



  5. 5

    They should go back to the idiodic guest judges. At least you could make fun of someone different every week.



  6. 6

    i like her. she is a wayyyyyyyyy better judge then paula. i will miss her if she leaves



  7. 7

    Well, seeing as how I've never watched the show, I don't think I'll miss her.



  8. 8

    Fuck FOX. Those bible thumpin assholes..What are they gonna do with a gay idol ??? I can't wait.



  9. 9

    Pleas the show is nothing without crazy Paula. Kara sucks and adds nothing to it.



  10. 10

    DOESNT THE BITCH MAKE MORE MONEY DOING MUSIC ANYWAY?? A DRUNKEN PAULA IS WAAAY BETTER FOR THE RATINGS. WE CAN GUESS WHAT DRUGS SHE'S ON EACH WEEK - AND HER DENIALS AFTER THE SHOW! NOTHING MORE KOOLER!!!!!!!



  11. 11

    Get rid of Paula and Kara.
    I bet Simon would stay if they could get Janet Jackson.
    After all…. Paula owes her music career to Janet.
    So who better to replace her.

    Yeah, like that will ever happen. Janet would loose her shit under the pressure of daily appearances.



  12. 12

    I like Kara, but I have found the 4 judge format awkward. Although I think Paula is a space cadet, she works.



  13. 13

    Re: LizardKinG – FOR REAL….HE IS SUCH A FUCKING AMAZING BLOGGER……



  14. 14

    Just curious. Who is she anyway? I have to assume that she is a singer or at least a song-writer. I'd hope that any judge they'd have on the show at least had some talent of their own.
    Oh, and another question. Has anyone ugly ever won the show and gone on to do anything?



  15. 15

    No, Perez. If Paula were FIRED, Simon would throw a bitch fit and she'd be brought back. Same for Randy and Ryan. But if Paula leaves on her own, I doubt Simon will walk away from the last year on his contract.

    That said, I doubt Paula will leave, and I think Kara will be gone and replaced with a younger and more glamorous fourth judge. Perhaps Cheryl Cole(barf)? But maybe an American version of her. Like Nicole whatsherfeaturedface…from PCD.



  16. 16

    Kinda glad to see her go.



  17. 17

    good she sucks



  18. 18

    I HOPE ITS TRUE, I DONT LIKE HER…



  19. 19

    The big surprise is that Randy is leaving. He is B-O-R-E-D and it shows!!!



  20. 20

    It was a bad move bringing her in, now get her out….As idiotic as Paula can be and as offbase as Randy can be, we need them. Simon, well he is really the only one who knows his shit!Excuse me Stuff….



  21. 21

    Re: COCO17 – Nicole What'shername? I doubt it….it's a family friendly show, and they wouldn't want to whore it up.



  22. 22

    GOOD! No offense but AI is best with just THREE judges.

  23. @v@ says – reply to this


    23

    Kara has other, better skillz. She's been there, done that. No worries there.



  24. 24

    Bitch don't when to shut that piehole ( like most bitches).



  25. 25

    cannot stand the show, but why mess with a good thing. 3 judges seemed to work, who the hell is she anyway?



  26. 26

    What they really need to do is get rid of Ryan Seacrest. He's getting TOO big for his britches!!



  27. 27

    SHE ADDS ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO THE SHOW…GET RID OF HER!!!!! PUT KATHY GRIFFIN IN KARA'S PLACE. NOW "THAT" WOULD AT LEAST PROVIDE SOME ENTERTAINMENT.



  28. 28

    Re: Oceannia420 – WONDERFUL IDEA DEAR….. I'M BORED SHITLESS BY THAT CLOSET QUEEN, SEACRUST!!!!!



  29. 29

    kara knows what she is talking about, but, it looks like no one cares. And no one does-it is all a popularity contest. Randy says maybe one sentence that makes sense in the middle of Dog, you know, when I hung with, etc. etc., Paula takes about 2 minutes to get out 1 sentence, like she needs a jump start to get going or she comments on their outfit. Simon will comment on their performance and get booed. SO-THE AUDIENCE DOES NOT WANT THE TRUTH



  30. 30

    Oceannia420, can you not read? If Idol got rid of Ryan, Simon would also threaten to walk. He wants Ryan, Paula, and Randy. And at this critical stage, Idol is going to give Simon all he wants to stay.

    Deal with it.



  31. 31

    Paula is great and funny and makes me happy !

    Paula

    Paula

    Paula

    Paula

    Paula

    Paula

    Paula



  32. 32

    show would be very boring without PAULA ABDUL. shes helped keep this show #1 for 8 years

    PAULAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
    PAULAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA



  33. 33

    THE RADICAL QUEEN:

    Simon luuurves himself some "Seacrust".

    SUCK ON A FAT ONE, HATER!



  34. 34

    Paula is just awesome! interesting character she's like everybody a lil sane a lil cuckoo…love crazy Paula!



  35. 35

    And she was the only one trusting Adam fro the beginning



  36. 36

    GOOD. Send that damn bitch packing!



  37. 37

    That's sad if she doesn't come back. I really like her. She's the female Simon Cowell without being mean. She speaks the truth. Abdul just tells everyone they are great and Randy cannot express himself too well. I really like her. I always understand what she says. The only thing she did wrong was compete in singing with that bikini girl. But since then, she's been great.



  38. 38

    Good she sux, and Paula is awesome.

  39. 29 says – reply to this


    39

    bye kara



  40. 40

    Since ealier this week I keep thinking aifayttwji. You don't deserve to be in your situation. I want to change that so bad! And I can if you will let me. ywlmstwi. Make you feel happy, safe and loved! There is light at the end of the tunnel and that is where I am standing. bmwbc 46 hmaw



  41. 41

    Please let her leave already ! I've never missed a year, but I could not make myself watch this season, and if they get rid of the unwanted 4th judge I might tune in again.



  42. 42

    www.stdsincolor.com



  43. 43

    ah
    i dun agree with that
    i want her to stays and Paula should leave now
    cuz i think she is over-acting sometimes
    so dun go Kara
    and by the way I dun love and hate anyone of them



  44. 44

    i dun want her to leave !!! she is new.
    i want Paula to leave cuz i think she's over-acting sometimes while listening to the contestants singing.
    (by the way i dun love or hate anyone of them).
    i'm just telling the truth



  45. 45

    and again she's better than Paula in every way.
    listen to the songs she sings and read the songs she writes ,,,
    every single thing about her is better than her…



  46. 46

    i love u 02badgirl!
    i can c only u kno the exact truth
    wat do u think if Paula,Simon and Randy is replaced by MiMi,George Michael and Bob Geldof?????



  47. 47

    god I hope they get rid of Kara Can'tCount-di. Not gonna miss her. at all.



  48. 48

    I love her. Hope they keep her.

    Four judges works ok for me, although I could do without Randy.



  49. 49

    That would be a dream come true - Kara is the MOST annoying thing about AI right now. And you can tell how annoyed the other judges are with her. She's got canned opinions, and she adds nothing positive to the show



  50. 50

    Good, she needs to leave. Four judges are too many.

    She cuts into the amount of time we have for Paula's drunken ramblings.



  51. 51

    See ya, Don't let the door hit you in the butt Kara.



  52. 52

    she has to go, no one likes her



  53. 53

    She should never have been brought onto the show anyways… :(



  54. 54

    Good. She is NOT needed! 4 judges is too many!



  55. 55

    i love kara though, she makes so much sense.. her comments are really valuable, i'm a fan of her music too!



  56. 56

    I don't have a problem with her but if anyone goes, it should be her.



  57. 57

    Paula is the only judge that FEELS the music from her heart it is not only the tears but her facial reactions in general are deep .. I love her and I love how she reacts with songs and with contestants .. And she is the only one of the judges who performed on stage and with top 1 songs .. yes she is a lil crazy but actually this adds to her personality charm .. and she always makes me smile .. I think people who talk **** about her are jealous of her fame and huge fan base .. It is so awful and sad how they disrespect her in the media cause she is a nice person ..



  58. 58

    She has that way of saying exactly what is correct, especially from a songwriters point of view, and a great and legendary songwriter at that which she is. American Idol is a tired old show with a diving audience and market share. Fox needs to swallow it and invent something new and better. Todays kids have lost interest in these kind of talent shows 4 seasons ago and have moved on to other things like computer gaming networks. Next big hit for Fox… Computer Gaming Competitions, placing the audience right in the game between contestants. Kia could write the theme song.



  59. 59

    Kia? Meaning Kara DioGuardi, of course.