Kelly, Is That You?

Filed under: Kelly Clarkson > Music Minute > American Idol

On Wednesday, the first ever American Idol winner, Kelly Clarkson, was spotted in Hong Kong meeting fans and promoting her music.

The singer, who's been known to fluctuate in weight, was looking rather, uhmmm…healthy!

Maybe she shouldn't have posed next to her overly Photoshoped album cover?

Just sayin'!

[Image via AP Images.]

Posted: May 28, 2009 at 4:30 pm / Email this »

See All 197 Comments

197 comments to “Kelly, Is That You?”

More comments: [1] 2 »

aLiCiaXo says – reply to this

1

holy ..cow
pakowwww says – reply to this

2

thats a very unflattering shirt
Cali40 says – reply to this

3

You can take the girl out of the trailer but can't take the trailer out of the girl……..
truth in life says – reply to this

4

Oh your not going to Bully her to about if she is GAY or not
charmaineager says – reply to this

5

WOW, you really are a pathetic BITCH mario
Desert Latina Gal says – reply to this

6

well…you know how it goes….maybe she has thyroid problems. She's coming to the desert…can't wait to see her!! Gordita or not!!
mizzgypsy says – reply to this

7

Re: aLiCiaXo – oh shut up you whore kelly looks fine
Larizza says – reply to this

8

I like how she looks homely and obviously doesn't give a shit. It's nice to see someone concentrated on their music, then on any other aspect that makes other entertainers plastic.
NiKiRoLLeRbLaDeS says – reply to this

9

OMG POOR THING NEEDS TO WEAR LONGER SLEEVES!!

You are right Perez… she shouldn't have done that. I'm not saying I'm perfect but I wouldn't be caught out looking like that- ESPECIALLY in that industry!
madgesboi82 says – reply to this

10

Bet she still weighs less than you perez!
dr2000girl says – reply to this

11

she needs to do something about her weight its not healthy that she goes up and down
heyimarn says – reply to this

12

i still heart kelly.
silverfoxx says – reply to this

13

Who cares if she gained some weight jeezus!
Laura_S23 says – reply to this

14

wow.
Kanye's a Gay Fish says – reply to this

15

Re: eatmejerkwad –
OLIVER_deez_NUTZ says – reply to this

16

Wtf is up with her arms? her arms have fat rolls also just like you perez
livelovetwilight says – reply to this

17

either way Perez, she's still slimmer than you!
just because shes not a size 00 and weights 20 pounds doesn't mean she's fat.
she looks great!
erinzorz says – reply to this

18

I love kelly clarkson but the girl really needs to get a better stylist….
cherrymuffinlove says – reply to this

19

She's pretty but she doesn't try. At least put some make up on girl.
tily80 says – reply to this

20

like the fat you recently shed will be gone forever
just sayin
Duckie says – reply to this

21

so…let s see….she s had a serious eating disorder for some time and you make fun of it by commenting on her non-skinny figure now? Low…rather LOW…imo.
ianlandry says – reply to this

22

please you are a courageous person kelly you can loose some weight!!!! …. you are still young, you do not want to be fat forever!!! … pay yourself a good trainer!!! love you
77777 says – reply to this

23

Man you are a useless asshole. People suffer from body images problems that cause so much pain and suffering. How can you perpetuate stereotypes that keep women at a size zero? Should she strive for an eating disorder so she can please you. The image you portray is so negative and wrong. Shame on you!
baloneytits says – reply to this

24

wow- girl needs to lose some weight-
shes looking almost as fat as LADY GAGGING O THE COVER OF ROLLING STONE!!!
AND THATS FUCKING GROSS!!!!
WriterGirl says – reply to this

25

leave her alone! it's not her fault that she was photoshopped! NO ONE LOOKS LIKE THAT IN REAL LIFE!
rocckkssy says – reply to this

26

Perez Jesus, you've battled a bit with this. Don't be such a meany. What's the bet this one post will have her hiding for a few months and returning stick thin…
simmys says – reply to this

27

whoaa
JessHolmes says – reply to this

28

I don't get it, what's wrong with her?
JERJER says – reply to this

29

So she gained weight. Yes she needs to lose it. But in the meantime, learn how to dress for it! Do your hair & make & get a great stylist! Jordan Sparks is a "healthy" girl and always looks FLAWLESS at appearances.
crazybeautifulstella says – reply to this

30

I love her music, Im not worrying about what she is wearing when i listen
STEFFANlE says – reply to this

31

I love the way she is sooo natural
Kateedid didn't says – reply to this

32

YOU'RE (THERE YOU GO TO THE PERSON WHO CALLED ME ILLITERATE FOR BEING LAZY AND USING YOUR) ONE TO TALK FATTY! MAYBE WHEN YOU HAVE 10% BODY FAT, THEN YOU CAN THROW STONES BUT IN THE MEANTIME, UMMM, WELL JUST KEEP LOOKING IN THE MIRROR AND DOING THOSE AFFIRMATIONS: I AM NOT A BABY FATTY PANTS WITH THE BIGGEST CHIN IN THE WORLD! THERE YA GO, ALMOST THERE (EXCEPT I GUESS YOU CAN LOOSE THE CHIN LIKE YOU DO THE WEIGHT, BETTER GO TO THE PLASTIC SURGEON ASAP!)
Bufffan says – reply to this

33

Wow her arms have cellulite!Maybe she shouldn't wear sleeveless tops. Those don't even look like the same person, like the pretty girl and her ugly fatter sister. I mean shes not fat but shes not in shape either, its ok to be big but not flabby. And her face is all fat, even her nose looks fatter than in the picture.
Samantha07 says – reply to this

34

You should speak Perez, you look great in the H8 picture then on other pics wearing all white yuck!
Kateedid didn't says – reply to this

35

Re: Cali40 – Re: Cali40 – You would know wouldn't you honey!
ho_reely says – reply to this

36

good for her
Sizza says – reply to this

37

She looks lovely. So what if she is not a size 00. Too bad you have turned into a self-righteous former fat person, Perez.
Jamiii says – reply to this

38

She looks like a normal person. Good for her for not weighing 80 pounds.
TicTacTic says – reply to this

39

Considering how much the average American weighs, she looks just fine. It's by making mean comments like that, Mario, that so many girls have serious body issues. Way to be an asshole. I know being bitchy is your job, but sometimes you take it too far. I doubt you'd take it very well if anyone started making such comments about you.
jujube85 says – reply to this

40

Leave Kelly alone. She looks great and happy. Don't be a hypocrite!
krazygreen11-26 says – reply to this

41

Wow Perez, then you've been "healthy" your whole life?
Kathagr says – reply to this

42

She's beautiful!! Every album cover is photoshopped these days. I guess she might have gained a bit weight, but she's also a great person, with awesome vocals!
lovelyS says – reply to this

43

Aw leave her alone. kelly rocks. i love you kelly ignore this fatass. hes just jealous.
Stefnilove says – reply to this

44

UMMMMM WHO the EFF is that and WHY did she eat Kelly?
pawinmouth says – reply to this

45

…or maybe they should just stop photoshoping her altogether. Why do they have to fake already pretty people?!?! They minimize already small waists, buts in extentions in already beatiful hair, puts on fake lashes on naturally thick and long ones. it kills me how FAKE this world is.
MEMEME4 says – reply to this

46

Damn perez, lose a couple pounds and you call someone who actually has a reason to be famous, fat.
c00kiem0nster says – reply to this

47

Leave Kelly alone! She looks fine! You would be giving her shit if she was skinny too! You're not one to talk about weight either you fat fuck.
WildOrchid1298 says – reply to this

48

Hmm well they shouldn't have over done the photo shop. She could use some toning up, but otherwise she's looking good. As for the shirt it's not helping it makes her look boxy…anything would have been better than that top.
xoxo_anonymous says – reply to this

49

she wears alot of unflattering clothes, it doesnt really help her out. but i see nother wrong with her. i mean the pic in the back is photoshopped to shit & she has make up on in it. but there she has no make up, her hairs not all done, she looks normal, get over it.
Theo says – reply to this

50

OMG! I would not even know that was her……..
cute_puppy says – reply to this

51

Did she nick that blouse from her grandma?
Could she possibly look any frumpier?
Marmoseta says – reply to this

52

she's been pumping iron. Look at the guns on her.
jham says – reply to this

53

she seeems genuinely happy which is always attractive.
donichka says – reply to this

54

whatever who cares how much she weighs, she has an amazing voice!
bananaballerina says – reply to this

55

Re: dr2000girl – but really… how the fuck is it your place to say that?

Leave her alone. Far out. Most of you are waaaay bigger than she is, I'm sure.
Kevyn says – reply to this

56

Its funny how you think you can call people fat Mario when you are the size of a whale
The Original Gossip Girl says – reply to this

57

mmm.. just look at that sexy armpit fat.
RennyRen says – reply to this

58

Where's the problem? She looks fine to me.
Firehouse713 says – reply to this

59

HOLY CRAP… what happened…
AZchick says – reply to this

60

Wow. Not good.
allykisskiss says – reply to this

61

Kelly is GORGEOUS! SHUT UP PEOPLE!!
and Perez, hypocrite much?! YES! Get a bloody grip!
baloneytits says – reply to this

62

MARIO YOU WEIGH TWO OF HER SO SHUT THE FUCK UP- MAYBE FOUR ACTUALLY!!!
Scottsdale_Sun says – reply to this

63

I think she looks beautiful, and she has an amazing voice.
Leave her alone Perez, you have no room to be talking about anyone's weight.
redmond says – reply to this

64

I feel bad for her. She obviously really struggles with her weight. It must suck dealing with it in the public eye. Then again, she's rich and can afford a home gym!
Madeline11 says – reply to this

65

It's more the shirt than her…she still looks pretty good
Debbie89 says – reply to this

66

STFU perez,,she's looking a thousand times better then you.
Go stare in a mirror!!!

Kelly is my rolemodel,love her!
xcalibur says – reply to this

67

SHE'S FATTTT!!!!!!!!!!! DAYUM SHE NEEDS TO DROP 50 - POUNDS THAT IS..
britsbiotch says – reply to this

68

wow she needs to like tone or something because her arms r just narsty
goodtasteishardtofind says – reply to this

69

If her fans are buying her albums and doing their part, they deserve to see a beautiful and fit pop star, not a frumpy fat ass cow…All Kelly Clarkson fans should be mad that she just sits around eating food and recording songs getting rich and fat. I would be pissed…that's why I love Madonna, she always looks good for her fans, that why we appreciate her and adore her, she works hard, unlike other lazy pop stars who get a free meal ticket.
goodtasteishardtofind says – reply to this

70

Re: Marmoseta – Guns? I'm saying tons. She DOES look genuinely happy tho…fuck it! Go Kelly.
WMariah says – reply to this

71

Perez..just curious…do you ever think the weight will creep back on you? It seems you forgotten your chubby days. Don't get cocky baby…might come back and bite you in the ass.
UGLY DONKEY FACE = PEREZ says – reply to this

72

Perez, your pic above on the right looks like a homo Shrek.
loismustdie says – reply to this

73

You know what Perez, you are not a very nice person!! I'll bet when you were large (fat), you didn't like other people talking ugly about you did you? You are a PIG!!!!!!!
jd9805 says – reply to this

74

she looks absolutely horrible, just like her music
chillgirl76 says – reply to this

75

Yeah, everyone is talking about this lately..poor kelly, it was on the cover of in touch magazine and I notice on the "My life would suck without you" video that they don't really show her body very much…she has so much hair thats all you can see…anyway, who really cares? i'm a fatty too. I love to eat!! I would rather sing like kelly than be a bag of bones any day!!
WMariah says – reply to this

76

Re: goodtasteishardtofind – I actually go to her concerts to hear her sing…..can care less about her looks. But I guess REAL TALENT IS NOT IMPORTANT TO EVERYONE.
Debbie89 says – reply to this

77

Re: goodtasteishardtofind –

Thats the dummest thing i ever heard!:|

I am one of her biggest fans and as long as kelly is happy with herself,
then why wouldnt i be happy for her??It is NOT about what the rest of the world thinks about her body,its what she thinks about it herself.I think she looks great either way.Zero is NOT a size people!!!

And its not like her music is different when her weight changes..
REAL fans dont stop liking their idols just bc their looks change.
missiowa24 says – reply to this

78

LOL
MaggyMay says – reply to this

79

Her main problem is that she does not dress very flattering. She never has.
Big Gulp says – reply to this

80

Why are you such a hater?
The Mancunian Candidate says – reply to this

81

at least she admitted they airbrush her senseless
dreamattack says – reply to this

82

poor kelly, she looked great in 2005.
Peter 97624 says – reply to this

83

Rule #1 in Show Biz: DO NOT GET FAT ! Everyone, but everyone will HOUND YOU GIRL ! She's looks very different from here Photoshopped photo behind her………..maybe she's pregnant !! She's not wearing any makeup or anything…….we DEMAND GLAMOUR, MISS CLARKSON ! GLAM-MOOOOOOOOUR !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lobster no says – reply to this

84

she needs to cover her arms and get some bigger hair
cherry.girl23 says – reply to this

85

She looks like a hideous pile of goat's cheese. Kelly is a fugly ass.
scissor says – reply to this

86

Well, Mrs. Holton, two words (again):
.
glasshouse, stones
.
pose next to your prop8 pic, let the readers compare with Kelly´s pic and you will see that most of the people will say that Kelly wins this competition…
.
maybe you can photoshop Kelly thinner but you can´t photoshop Lady Caca into a good looking person!
.
okay, Kelly gained some weight, what´s the big deal? she looks good (hello Beth Ditto!) and her album is great - at least she can sing (Mrs. Hilton, what about your sales on iTunes? - just asking)
.
lover her, hate you
.
Oceannia420 says – reply to this

87

She owes her public to stay at a decent weight. No one wants to be known as "FAT"…….
Put the twinkies down and pick up a pencil and start writing some songs then!! HOLLA!!
krazysexikewl says – reply to this

88

Re: aLiCiaXo – my words exactly !!!
Illise says – reply to this

89

The shirt is not good for her but she looks great
myboo2 says – reply to this

90

You know, it was overly-critical, smart-assed dicks like you making harsh, baseless comments like this that pushed her to the edge of a nervous breakdown. Keep it up. Maybe you can do it again, you jerk.
peace_and_THCx420 says – reply to this

91

she looks FINE!
Debbie89 says – reply to this

92

Re: scissor –
AMEN! =P
topper says – reply to this

93

So you call Kelly Clarkson "healthy" and Jessica Simpson "fat". You need to have your head or eyes checked out Perez.
sctyeahuknowme says – reply to this

94

Finally, someone who is able to make it in the industry based on TRUE talent, not some stupid chick who is all image(up in the studio workin' on sythn's, not vocals) and no pipes! I will admit that everyone in the public eye is warned not to go sleeveless unless you ARE perfect. So she could find something more flattering but I think she just doesn't give a hoot what we think anymore.
illmuffin says – reply to this

95

nice arms kelly.
htownboy says – reply to this

96

wow. thats the ugliest shirt ive ever seen. he hair is tottaly washing her face out, and she needs some makeup. on top of everything, she needs to tone up a bit… i like her to be a little healthy, not uh,, cowish.
Beach Babe says – reply to this

97

yikes….she has money she should be working out in a gym
Glambert says – reply to this

98

Stop being such a dick Mario. Especially since you obviously have a weight problem too. (Referencing your anti h8 protest pic) Kelly is a beautiful girl and a great singer… She's accomplished a lot more and has waay more talents and looks than your lard ass has.
Belle de Jour says – reply to this

99

She looks pretty normal to me Perez. The girl didn't become famous because of her looks she became famous because she could sing. Who gives a crap about how she looks or how much she weighs? Don't you remember what you said about Susan Boyle? You're being a hypocrite. I think it's great to see a natural looking celebs today, so many them are turning plastic.
dbabygirl81 says – reply to this

100

her boobs bother me