Kelly, Is That You?

Filed under: Kelly Clarkson > Music Minute > American Idol

On Wednesday, the first ever American Idol winner, Kelly Clarkson, was spotted in Hong Kong meeting fans and promoting her music.

The singer, who's been known to fluctuate in weight, was looking rather, uhmmm…healthy!

Maybe she shouldn't have posed next to her overly Photoshoped album cover?

Just sayin'!

[Image via AP Images.]

Posted: May 28, 2009 at 4:30 pm / Email this »

See All 197 Comments

197 comments to “Kelly, Is That You?”

More comments: « 1 [2]

Blindmag says – reply to this

101

either some one is too fat or too thin.. make u your fucking minds. news flash peeps not everyone is fucking skinny . if yall got probs with how she looks DONT FUCKING LOOK AT HER.
Kdonald says – reply to this

102

bitch is fat, who really gives 2 shits.
MaggyMay says – reply to this

103

Re: goodtasteishardtofind –

Yes, Madonna. I only listen to "singers" who look like veiny and muscular old men.
ashwill says – reply to this

104

Why do talk like your skinny???
anniegirl says – reply to this

105

No, she doesn't look fine. She looks like shit. She has never dressed well, and certainly doesn't dress to flatter her size. She should have never let that album art come out with her 60 lbs fatter.
halifaxperezer says – reply to this

106

wow she has cellulite on her arms, who'da thunk it
halifaxperezer says – reply to this

107

Re: dbabygirl81 – LMFAO!!!
ScarletOHara says – reply to this

108

So why is this girl gaining some weight the subject of catty remarks and yet you nonstop gush over how fabu Beth Ditto is? Since when is being a morbidly obese singer who likes to run around naked preferable to a singer who has gained 15lbs and wears terrible shirts? I guess Kelly better gain another 200lbs and become an exhibitionist to be ok.
BrookeC says – reply to this

109

YOU PIECE OF SHIT, MARIO!!!! She is not fat.
grammar police says – reply to this

110

Her photo has heavy dramatic make-up. I like the lighter look for spring/summer–more natural is in, right now.
Lisa12 says – reply to this

111

PEREZ THERE YOU GO AGAIN, YOU KNOW YOU REALLY NEED TO SHUT THE FUCK UP, YOU ARE SICK, FAT ASS. YOU KNOW, YOU CAN LOSE ALL THE WEIGHT YOU WANT, BUT THE TRUTH IS YOU WILL ALWAYS BE UGLY, SAD BUT TRUE. SO "JUST SAYING" YOU NEED TO SHUT THE FUCK UP
dreamygrl says – reply to this

112

Re: aLiCiaXo – I love how you call her a cow… but have you ever looked at how ugly your face is hunny
BabyMeg says – reply to this

113

Shut up perez. She still looks gorgeous, and at least she can sing!
I cant stand them says – reply to this

114

Leave Kelly alone, Perez. If she doesn't want to spend her life in a fucking gym and live more like the average person… what is the problem? Kelly has a great voice. If lady Caca was fat she would have never had a contract!
britbrit07 says – reply to this

115

omgee who cares if she gained some weight…Perez you shouldn't even talk…c'mon…at least she's not embarrased by it…i'm proud of her
mcdon4748 says – reply to this

116

she is the ONLY Idol as far as i'm concerned. can we stop with season after season of losers?
mikeandsteph23 says – reply to this

117

leave the poor girl alone!
LoladeLI says – reply to this

118

looks like an absolutely normal. healthy. beautiful. TALENTED. girl. you ppl are sooooo warped….that is not what fat looks like…it's what the average woman looks like….not like an anorexic coke binging whore….aka basically every female in hollywood nowadays….

and lady GaGa does NOT look fat on the cover of rollin stone…she's just got an hourglass figure. NOT ALL WOMEN LOOK LIKE 12 YEAR OLD BOYS HOMO!!!!
Whathefuck says – reply to this

119

Damn she's HUGE!!!! I hope they pay the photoshopper well as they are putting in some overtime fixing that mess.
rosabelle says – reply to this

120

i think she looks beautiful…
MasterClass says – reply to this

121

Adam Lambert has bigger breasts!
vixposh says – reply to this

122

theres healthyand then there's just plain FAT!!! eww kelly, go to the gym
JohnnyD says – reply to this

123

She has cellulite on her arms! Can you imagine how fat that girl would be if she was a housewife rather than a celebrity?
Yellow Peeps says – reply to this

124

Love her regardless
Elliebug2 says – reply to this

125

yuck!!! shes fat
ju_cybebe says – reply to this

126

That blouse would actually look really nice on a person who wasn't as big as she was.
maneet says – reply to this

127

ur a fucked up asshole perez. i used to love your site and think you were hilarious. but now u jump on every freaking person and twist around their words for the stupidest reasons. now ur making fun of people and their weight? u talk about equality and being a good person, but u say the evilest, rudest shit like this. aren't u listening to all these comments and how everyones getting pissed at u? is getting site hits all u care about now? u fucking suck perez.
geez_louise says – reply to this

128

perez, the only difference between her body and yours is that she has a slight bit less of a farmers tan on those flabby-ass arms
QuinneVengeance says – reply to this

129

wow perez, thats a low fucking blow.
she looks absolutely GORGEOUS and is very healthy looking.
just because shes not fucking skinny like Lindsay Lohan doesn't mean she's fat.
ALSO she used to have an eating disorder, so how DARE you say she's fat.
its people like you, you fucktard, who give girls eating disorders cause they cant live up to YOUR expectations.
fuck you perez.
dancedjkaraoke says – reply to this

130

Put down the hoho's Kelly
mollers says – reply to this

131

doesn't matter what anyone says, she's amazing no matter what she weighs!!!

and at least she's honest about it. i think she's even moreso relateable to sending a message out to all females about positive body image. REAL WOMEN HAVE CURVES!! REAL WOMEN have some body fat because they are meant to have babies!

who cares if she's gained and lost. haven't we all?
Paris Hilton Looks Like A Flamingo says – reply to this

132

Damn, she grew up to be very ugly. She used to be cute and spunky. Now she has too much upper arm fat… and why oh why did she never consider a nose job?
Sabrina S says – reply to this

133

Oh my God, that's depressing.
How can that happen in that short amount of time.
No wonder why she loves being single; It's because no one wants that.

I get a gay vibe from her. Anyone else agree?
THA_SHIZNIT says – reply to this

134

Fat ass!
the-truth-hurts says – reply to this

135

Perez…you have no right to be calling anyone out on their weight…if I remember correctly not too long ago (a certainly very much still) are "healthy" yourself. Kelly is famous because she is talented which is something you certainly can't say. She looks like a normal human being. Considering the U.S.A is the Obese capital of the world she looks quite normal in comparison to half the people that walk by you on the street. She can sing her ass off and thats all that matters, she had an eating disorder for a long time too so the media making comments about her gaining some weight are repulsive to me. The media has absolutely no couth, respect, or class what-so-ever. You have even less.
Just sayin'!
the-truth-hurts says – reply to this

136

Re: Paris Hilton Looks Like A Flamingo – why don't you post a picture of yourself or your mother on here. You have an awful lot to say about everyone elses appearance!
exBFF says – reply to this

137

sweetie, you dissing someone for being heavy is akin to heidi montag criticizing someone for being a vapid, talentless whore. just don't.
Almondjoy says – reply to this

138

she looks awesome and her weight is none of our business. her music still kicks some serious ass and thats all that matters matey.
Almondjoy says – reply to this

139

she is the most perfect example to girls in the world. she got her start by sticking to something she loved and was good at. she was a regular girl. and now, because she has chosen not to stick her finger down her throat, use illegal drugs or get her excess sucked out of her body, little girls around the world can see that a star can be a regular size too. i love her now, i think she rocks!
Almondjoy says – reply to this

140

so how bout you just let her be that example of healthy to little girls and dont make fun of her for it?? pick one person that you will praise for NOT using coke or whatever the "stars" use besides their fingers to keep their weight off and show the world that healthy is a good thing.
Almondjoy says – reply to this

141

Re: Almondjoy – and that its normal to go back and forth, that we all do it and youre not better when youre at your thinnest, youre just thinner.
Grandpa Lou says – reply to this

142

leave that poor girl alone! it's very painful when your weight fluctuates!! There's nothing that can ruin a day more than putting on a pair of your favorite jeans and they're tight!!
pandamax says – reply to this

143

Kelly.. girl… you gotta get yourself a better stylist.. LOVE THE SMILE THO!… Mario is just bein a self-hating, jealous fat asshole. you should tottally not worry about any of it cuz u're ridiculiciously talented
Rabbit23 says – reply to this

144

W
brittymachine says – reply to this

145

ewwwwww….
fuck photoshopping album covers haha. this is pathetic. her arms are cellulite farms..she looks 40
Photographer1956 says – reply to this

146

Isnt this similar to the photoshopped picture of Perez where he TRIES to look hot??? Reality bites Perez. She still looks good!!
kcurbzzz says – reply to this

147

awhh i love kelly!
bitchtitsaurus says – reply to this

148

PEOPLE! Shut the fuck up! She's alright! She's normal! It's just an unflattering shirt. She doesn't look so bad and not every single damn famous girl has to be "skinny" all the time. She looks fine, cut her some slack,gosh!
Kitty386 says – reply to this

149

Perez…. you obviously didn't see the pictures of Kelly's performance on Wango Tango. She actually looks really good on this picture compare to those.
bitchtitsaurus says – reply to this

150

Re: goodtasteishardtofind –

Idiot
Rabbit23 says – reply to this

151

We went months with you sort talking alot about your weight on the site. And every time u talk about Lohan anymore your talking about how underweight -you- think she is. And now your hating on Clarkson because she's "uhmmm…healthy looking" so guessing by your humor means fat fucking cow.
So I'm personaly just trying to get this straight, Lohans who's about 110lbs too skinny, Kelly Clarkson about guessing on her height 150.
I would really really like to know your personal opinion on what size Perez Hilton thinks a woman is supposed to be, because it's driving me crazy.
Odviously Clakrson's needs to think twice and look in the mirror before leaving home, and hire a stylist asap, I agree!!
Your words affect, I guess is what I'm trying to say.
k-lee says – reply to this

152

She looks beautiful to me.
ohyeahbabyohyeah says – reply to this

153

She looks like Fiona from "Shrek"
smartypants79 says – reply to this

154

Perez, why are you hating on people when they gain weight? did you know that you're fat? Leave peopel alone. Someone flashes their crotch at paparazzi, go to town. Some is a normal human being, leave them alone.
chowchilla says – reply to this

155

she looks adorable
whysoserious says – reply to this

156

poor thing.
wildjkster says – reply to this

157

if she's goanna b fat, dont photoshop the shit outta her pics to be someone else. be someoneelse that resembles the possibly skinny version of herself!
TheRen says – reply to this

158

wth? Because shes fat shes healthy? wow.
Marianne Chitter Chatter says – reply to this

159

I love Kelly, but when she appeared on Idol this year, she looked horrible. I'm about her size, but I'm pushing sixty. When I was her age, I was about a size 4. It only gets harder kiddies. If she's this gigantic at 25, can you imagine how big she'll be at 55.
FayeRiffic says – reply to this

160

Whoa …..
shittin_condoms says – reply to this

161

she looks like a fat elderly woman
igetsooocbaby says – reply to this

162

Like it or not, she's still the most successful American Idol.
itsk4yl4duh says – reply to this

163

HI HYPOCRITE.
YOU'RE FAT TOO.
you think you're OH SO THIN.
you're not.
you weigh more than my car.
DutchCow says – reply to this

164

OH MY GOD!!!! She looks so……… Normal! But the shirt is ugly and doesn't flatter her at all…..
cherrymuffinlove says – reply to this

165

Re: ballsdeep88 – lol
DoutzenKroes<3 says – reply to this

166

idk about you guys but her face looks diffrent too if you look at all of her album covers she looks diffrent in ALL of them, stop with the photoshop!
old men are gross says – reply to this

167

Love her. Love her voice and style. Leave her alone. She is gorgeous!
ilracnella says – reply to this

168

You know she may not be as skinny as all these other girls that claim they can sing and have horrific albums out but she is a damn good vocalist…who gives a fuck if she isn't a size 2…no guy really likes that anyway.
Ilaria says – reply to this

169

she has all the money in the world to have somebody on her ass to make her workout…why doesn't she do that. I don't like working out either but it's not something you can avoid for too long. can't super fit Reba give her some advice?
ASDFjkL2 says – reply to this

170

perez… YOUR FAT.
Snapodile. says – reply to this

171

Perez, as someone who has struggled with their weight in the past, you should know to not be so insensitive.
Personally, I think Kelly is a tremendous role model for all tenage girls purely for the fact she doesn't obsess about her weight because of how the rest of the industry believe she should look. She's keeping it about the music, make her a musician, not a "pop star." Believe it or not, there's a difference.
Besides, she's not even fat! It's sooo good to see somebody with a realistic waistband instead of someone who is width of a pencil.

Definitely not a fan of that shirt, though…
Re Dani says – reply to this

172

Wow there are truly some judgmental people out there who need to take a look in the mirror. Nobody's perfect NO1 !. Shes a musician not a model..
Re Dani says – reply to this

173

Re: eishatl – To the bitch that says white women are fugly! is only a simple sign of jelousy hunny. dont hate cus you cant run your fingers through your hair darlin! ha!!!
Nickster50 says – reply to this

174

She's such a cute girl and makes great music but she needs to get a stylist and head to the gym and get in shape because that's not healthy. Her hair is looking very mousy too.
JonzeyWTF says – reply to this

175

She is no doubt, the biggest she's ever been. I heard an interview with her the other day, talking about how '[she] doesn't care about the weight issue any more, and [she] eats what she wants.' By all means, do that. But do it in smaller portions!
PEEKALICIOUS says – reply to this

176

PEREZ ~ WHY THE HELL ARE YOU ALWAYS SLAMMING PEOPLE ABOUT THEIR WEIGHT???
WHO GIVES A FLYING PHUCK HOW MUCH SOMEONE WEIGHS…
ehann! says – reply to this

177

okay she has alot of money invest in a trainer! not that she is overly fat but for the music industry honey that aint gona cut it!
Velly Boo says – reply to this

178

This is why we shouldn't use photoshop so effing much. Wow.
bethanne558 says – reply to this

179

She's still pretty.
Stev says – reply to this

180

Leave Kelly alone.. the girl has so much talent and she seems like such a genuine person… Slim or Thick I like her.. her music speaks for itself
SportyGal says – reply to this

181

Like it really matters!!! She's a great singer in my book!
Txgirl80 says – reply to this

182

Kelly look nice it the shirt it got to go that style dont suit anyone, Perez she looks fine.
Cullen Girl987 says – reply to this

183

OH MY GOD! THEY ATE KELLY!
YOU BASTARDS!
GoPeReZ says – reply to this

184

WOW!! Im sorry but i am not a fan of kelly but holy shit, she is fucking fat!!! And btw whores, perez lost the lard
-3mm!!!!- says – reply to this

185

that cant be Kelly!
catalin says – reply to this

186

I think she looks good. I'm so sick of anorexic stars.
lindseyyyyyy says – reply to this

187

Oh, come on MARIO. Leave her alone. You're an asshole. If she was 30 lbs lighter you would have a problem with that too!
Plus, you are one to talk. YOU could stand to lose a few pounds.
morgan17 says – reply to this

188

Re: mizzgypsy – no she doesnt , thats nasty .
OceanBabe says – reply to this

189

i say you should leave kelly alone.sheseems to be happy with the way she looks,and the fans like her no matter what she looks like and her album is doing great,so why bother posting this,it's not worth my time to read about kelly looking a little on the chubby side,and i think she looks great.i say post something that people will actually want to read.
**rocky** says – reply to this

190

don't find this pretty at all
THE JOKER says – reply to this

191

you guys can lick my ass i fuking love kelly
portugues-princess@hotmail.com says – reply to this

192

She has got a great voice and thats all that matters…..hasnt stopped her yet!
knowitall says – reply to this

193

Re: MaggyMay – Madonna is awesome and you should look so good at any age.
knowitall says – reply to this

194

Re: BrookeC – You know if Mccain had picked a normal person for vp instead of that militant freak Palin,he might have not lost by such a huge margin.
KCsilleLOVER says – reply to this

195

okay that's so unfair, she looked gorgeous when she was on Ellen Degeneres Show, and in I Do Not Hook Up music video, and THAT IS NOT LONG TIME AGO !! she was just unlucky with this dress !!
ashywashy says – reply to this

196

shes confident!
shes tilll got a great voice.
PickleSurprise says – reply to this

197

You, of all people, should not be at the forefront of fat shaming.