Which Will It Be: Rachel McAdams or Anne Hathaway?

We mentioned earlier that Sony Pictures was looking to cast Rachel McAdams in the starring villainess role in Spider-Man 4. We were cool with this decision, if for no other reason to have some actual TALENT grace the screen.
But now we're hearing another star's name being thrown around for the role of The Black Cat. Sources are suggesting that Anne Hathaway is also being considered!
Heavy hitters!
They are really trying to compensate for the fact that Kirsten Dunst is still in this franchise.
Who would U rather see in the role?
[Image via WENN.]






























































Rachel McAdams please, cause she's the pretty one..
Rachel, I think Anne Hathaway would have a hard time shaking off her nice-girl image. I still think she's a great actress though.
I say not "The Mouth" go with Rachel McAdams!!
check out the latest on campus gossip here: www.thecampusqueen.com
Um hello, are you the only one that doesn't know that Rachel turned them down?
Why do you hate Dunst so much and when will you post about the settlement with B.E.P.'s management?
rachel
I can't believe anyone would consider watching a fourth one of these after the horrific shitfest 3 turned out to be.
Rachel McAdams for sure.
Kristen Bell please
rachel mcadams pulls off a bad girl better… i still see anne hathaway as the girl from the princess diaries
I'd rather see GaGa!
rachel all the way!
i love both but i think racehl mccadams would be better
Anne Hathaway all the way!!!
rachel mcadams. def.
RACHEL!!! I love her
rachey rach
Rachel McAdams!!!!
since BOTH are great actresses, I don't mind. ^ That there is real talent.
Rachel should replace Kirsten and Anne should get the role of The Black Cat.
RACHEl MCADAMS
Rachel McAdams for sure! I adore her!
NEITHER
Rachel McAdams > Anne Hathaway
Surely you know by now that Rachel McAdams is NOT being considered for the Sp4 role so why do you continue to try to propagate this false information, Perez?
I like them both but Rachel Mcadams seems to suit the role better…I mean shes used to playing evil roles !! Who remembers Mean Girls ?
rachellll for sure…anne is just blah
i love both but i think rachel mcadams is better at being a bad girl.
Rachel McAdams.
God, that's a tough one! We've seen Rachel do mean. But Anne has really shown her range in "Havoc", "Rachel getting Married" and "Brokeback mtn". So I dunno
Rachel! Anne is too horsy.
- R E E S E W H I T H E R S P O O N - (instead)
Kristen Dunst is Fugly. get rid of her. Rachel is better for the part than anne.
Definitely McAdams…she has way more potential to be sexy. Hathaway is not sexy AT ALL
kirsten dunst is very talented, so up your perez.
Rachel McAdams please!! I don't like Anne Hathaway and I think Rachel could play crazy/mean/villain better than Anne.
Rachel PLEASE. Anne Hathaway could not be more overrated.
Rachel hands down
The black cat is my favorite marvel caracter, and I don't think anne hathaway have what it takes to be felicia hardy!
I vote for rachel
I think Rachel McAdams, I believe Anne Hataway is too soft for the role
I saw the first Spiderman several years ago, but only because it was one of the films United Airlines showed on a flight to China (so I coudn't walk out). It was the most retarded crap I've ever had to sit through… at least until another flight overseas a few years later played the Fantastic Four.
Anne Hathaway for sure she way diverse and would be amazing ..Rachel ius good but Anne is just better
omg, rachel most definitely, fo'sho(:
Def rachel!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
rooting for Anne…
Anne Hathaway, my fav
Either would be great. They are both fantastic choices.
rachel mcadam.. duh. hope she reconsiders the part.
Scratch all of these losers and give it to Lindsay Lohan. She would bring crazy villain to a whole new level.
Rachel McAdams!!!!!!!!!
Rachel ofcourse!
I'd take either one! But I thought Rachel said no?
they could do better than either for a villainess role
We all know Rachel McAdams would rock it. But it'd be interesting for Anne Hathaway to do it because she has not done much (if any) characters like this. Either way, both are great actresses!
i would much rather see rachal mcadams!!! she would fit in better then ann!!
Mmm I think Blake Lively has the perfect look to play Felicia Hardy (the Black Cat) I always imagine the Black Cat the way Britney looks in the Toxic video
hope rachel, i don't like anne.
Team Rachel!!!!
Re: Carrierocks – rachel is 1000 more times talented and prettier than anne.
rachel mcadams. i love anne hathaway, but i'd like to see rachel in a feature… it has been a while.
Re: mystatusisbaddest.com – haha lindsay is the biggest loser in hollywood u dumb bitch
None of them!! I go for Blake Lively
Rachel is way prettier and a way better actress. Anne can't play a villain.
Rachel McAdams…cause i think she could do a good job of being evil yet still sexy.
Here's a thought, how about boot Kirsten Dunst, hire McAdams to play Mary Jane, and Ann Hathaway to play The Black Cat.
anne hathaway hasn't got it in her to be mean
who cares,the movie will probably suck anyways
Rachel all the way!!!! Anne's eyes are too buggy.
i'm so sick of Spider Man. Can't Tobey Maguire find another job? btw, a skinny, short ass poop face is NOT superhero material
Re: BRITNEYSPEARSXXX – Boo. You whore.
Rachael Mcadams definately i hate anne hathaway
Rachel turned it down? I like Reese too loverboy.
Definitely Rachel McAdams!!! I love her!
RACHEL !!!!
rachel said it was just a rumor and that she hasn't auditioned or had any correspondence with sony, perez! update this so your facts are right!
Rachel can play a villain much better I think, but they're both talented actresses. Either one of them would be great.
Rachel McAdams is more talented and much prettier. Anne Hathaway sucks.
I would prefer Rachel… both are good choices, but I like Rachel a lot more.
anne hathaway. she's darker and has the edgy side the roll needs. rachel may seem like a nice girl but she's a princess……..
I love Anne but Rachel is definitely better for the part

I really swould not like to see Anne being a villain.. it wuld feel so phony but who knowss
whoops I just read some comments that say Rachel wont be apart of it
awwwwww man
GAGA, I say! Perfect breakout role. I bet she'd love to play a superhero-flick villainess. Up against the rest of the ensemble, she'd be a much better actOR - guaranteed.
I LOVE Rachel but I think Ann would be better for the role of villian!!!
McAdams…HANDS DOWN.
omg yes lindsay lohan PERFECT xD
Re: AliciaMay – Have you seen Havoc? Any good girl image she had was gone after that. lol…
I personally would like to see Anne Hathaway in Spider-Man four
rachael all the way! annes to goody goody!
Rachel!! cuz she was a good bitch in mean girls way back
anne ftw! mcadams way to cute…
Rachel McAdams!
I love Anne, but she's no villain… McAdams needs to take this one.
id rather rachael id like to see her take on a villian role
BLACK CAT IS A BLOND VERY SEXY WOMAN, AND SORRY BUT NEITHER HAVE THIS.
WHAT ABOUT ERICA DURANCE?
McAdams
RACHEL. bc anything other than the princess diaries…she acts the same in every movie (speaking about anne_
either - both great
Re: didntneedtoseethat –
Oh God NOOOOO Watching gaga on the big screen is just too much!! she is overrated, overexposed and over everything!!!
Anne - she shed her Disney tag alright in "The Devil Wears Prada"
RACHEL FTW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Rachel - definitely
Whatever Dunst may be in reality, she is pretty good in this franchise. She does a very good Mary Jane.