Which Will It Be: Rachel McAdams or Anne Hathaway?

We mentioned earlier that Sony Pictures was looking to cast Rachel McAdams in the starring villainess role in Spider-Man 4. We were cool with this decision, if for no other reason to have some actual TALENT grace the screen.
But now we're hearing another star's name being thrown around for the role of The Black Cat. Sources are suggesting that Anne Hathaway is also being considered!
Heavy hitters!
They are really trying to compensate for the fact that Kirsten Dunst is still in this franchise.
Who would U rather see in the role?
[Image via WENN.]















































Rachel would be awsome… but it would be awesome to seee someone like megan fox or reese witherspoon!
rach
RACHEL!!! Anne is gross
well Anne is definitely a more distinguished and bigger actress and name in hollywood. that is a fact
rachel!
rachel is definitely better by far, but she seems too classy for the role
I'm with Rachel McAdams on this. Anne is a great actress but this is not for her.
Neither, Christina Aguilera (Look wise and personality wise) would make the perfect Black Cat. Maybe if the director opened up a comic book every once in a while he'd know that.
While for some reason I will continue to watch the spider man movies even though they have boring as hell plot lines and sub-par acting, you have actually given me a hard question because these are two of my fave actresses, so lets be creative since all villians are mostly male, lets have two women who kick ass….and hopefully win too because we all know that the bad guy loses…..
or, just as good BRING BACK JAMES FRANCO!!!! HIS CHARACTER DID NOT HAVE TO DIE!!
i lobe them both, but i'd stick with rachel
Rachel McAdams is one of the most beautiful and talented actresses out there right now. She definitely needs to be in more things.
AWW! i LOVE THEM BOTH!
Definitely Rachel McAdams! She is so beautiful and talented!
McAdams for sure.
Both would be great, but it would be interesting to see Anne Hathaway do it. She can do drama…watch "Rachael Getting Married". Would be cool for her to play a bad girl again.
MCADAMS - HANDS DOWN!
this is a though one !!!!!!!! but i think i have to go with rachel on this one !!!!!
Anne Hathaway is a horse-faced bitch. Rachel is the clear choice and better! DUH?!
RACHEL MCADAMS!!!!….all the way
Anne Hathaway all the way. If you ppl don't know she has played dark roles before people. She does a wonderful job at it.
I vote for Rachel McAdams!
Olivia Wilde
definately the jew
I love Anne, but Rachel all the way!!
Rachel McAdams - DEFINITELY!
Definitely McAdams!!
Anne is talented aswell, but Rachel just has more of an edge to her
Rachel McAdams please! Shes beautiful and a GREAT actress
RACHEL MCADAMS!!!
Felicia Hardy/Black Cat isnt a villian, dumb ass.
Rachel McAdams all the way!! I love her!
Re: AynRandy – PERFECT
..anne is great but rachel is an amazing actress!!!
Rachel but Anne could be interesting.
Rachel McAdams, she is amazing!
Rachel definitely. Anne doesnt have that certain edginess about her like McAdams does.
RACHEL ! I adore Rachel and would actually go see the movie if she were in it. Without Rachel, zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz………..