Déjà Vu!

Filed under: Christina Aguilera > Separated At Birth > Lady GaGa

Ain't no denying it!

Posted: Apr 30, 2010 at 1:23 am / Email this »

See All 358 Comments

358 comments to “Déjà Vu!”

More comments: « 1 2 3 [4]

Maple Bunny says – reply to this

301

LOL
I do not know that Gaga had a monopoly off guy in bed, red clothing, white clothing, sunglass, fire and…have eyes??? Please Perez, be serious…
Jack_X says – reply to this

302

Yep, it's almost the same stuff…
ROKN'PA says – reply to this

303

Who really gives a shit if people think Gaga and Aguilera are similar… All of them are gunning for the same audience - Britney, Gaga, Madonna, Aguilera, Pink, all of em. While I like Gaga I also like Aguilera, but do remember, Aguilera HAS been around ALOT longer than Gaga and has proven herself as an artist. I think both of their vids are hot, but Aguilera's is a tad bit hotter!
Yours Truly; says – reply to this

304

Re: BritneyBarnes – Re: BritneyBarnes – Re: BritneyBarnes – haha, amen to that.
gloriaaaaa says – reply to this

305

christina copied madonna, not lady gaga? uhhh i dont think sooo.. she had a decade to be like madonna and NOW she want to? when lady gaga has already done it? uh uh.. total lady gaga wannabe BE ORIGINALLLLL! its not that hard.. lady gaga did it.
loladollyface says – reply to this

306

whatever happened to originality?
:\
loladollyface says – reply to this

307

Re: MisssSaba – then dont come on the site. dont make an account on the site. simple.
nataliejzc says – reply to this

308

No doubt about it.
cozmo says – reply to this

309

Its obvious Gaga's camp give you a kickback.. if not you're an idiot.
mel2t7-lovin lady gaga says – reply to this

310

omg its actually a bit embarassin for christina how similar they are when you see them like this. But perhaps its intentional as everyone loves Gaga and its going to get people talking about her
MAURO! says – reply to this

311

OMG ITS IIGHT DA VIDEO MAKES ME WANNA SEE OVER AND OVER
becbecbec says – reply to this

312

hmm the evidence is clear! :S
Chelsea says – reply to this

313

OMG! HOW DARE CHRISTINA WEAR RED LIPSTICK (which she's being wearing for years), HAVE FIRE IN A VIDEO (last time i checked, a lot of music videos have fire in them), WEAR SUNGLASSES (because we all know "lady" gaga is the only one who can wear sunglasses), AND HAVE A MAN SITTING ON A BED! SHE'S A TOTAL COPY CAT! right perez?
wtf_perez says – reply to this

314

SHUT UP UGLY FAT COW GAY…..I THINK YOU ARE CLONE-ELTHON JHON.
gaga cant sing without electro…did gaga win GRAMMY WITH VOCAL????
i'm not hate gaga i like her music,but when i see the comment about gaga…OMG
look at the mirror and look at your self.
if you think xtina copy gaga….what ever but xtina is best for me its up 2 u copy or not copy,
xtina say on her song :i feel brandnew if you dont like FUCK U
getnaked says – reply to this

315

These gaga comparisons are seriously reaching, Perez.
Stop being an idiot. The only thing that's actually similar is the glasses and that's it.
wtf_perez says – reply to this

316

hahaha original?????from where??electro???how about the voice?did she win awards VOCAL WITH TALENT??????????? gaga only have 2 albums,x tina?????its ok for me if xtina want try to be madonna not GAGA because madonna is her senior
Claudiane says – reply to this

317

Oh my…. Get an identity Clonetina.
littlebit says – reply to this

318

Have you listened to the lyrics? I do not believe this was an accident, Their is also essence of Rihanna's 'Disturbia' in here, because that was very Un-Rihanna, Madonna's 'Human Nature', Britney Spears 'Circus' and their other references, that are very ovbious of out-of-character acts by other female pop-stars.

And besides, Xtina has ALWAYS had that 'dominatrix' feel ever since Dirrty, Have you seen her live? It's so intense, and she's been around for alot longer than gaga, if anything gaga's bad romance video, where she's a prostitute, Is inspired from Xtina and her very empowering acts.
littlebit says – reply to this

319

and once again, the title of the song is 'Not Myself Tonight!' Fuck. It's an ode, a commemoration to the other huge female pop-stars that have lasting power, this was ovbious released as the first single to express how she wants to be like them and last, she's paying them tribute

Ovbious tributes, Rihannas 'disturbia' with the sitting in a chair in chain outfit thingy, Lady gaga's bad romance, Britney spears 'circus' with the eye thing and the gold outfit and she even copied one of britneys moves from that vid, Madonna heaps, dont even need to point it out, maybe even a little pink
jnnfer22 says – reply to this

320

She definitely did it on purpose, she is surrounded by professional in the music industry, someone would have told her it was too similar of a video. She was obviously poking fun at her.
cintron jr says – reply to this

321

This video could have a better name then "Not my self tonight" well better yet it should be call called "Let me be gaga for tonight" This b**** needs a new life we were all better with out her!
pinkchik03 says – reply to this

322

Yes, Christina's video looks very similar to GaGa's video, and I know Gaga's video was released first, but both of their videos have the same style as Madonna's. It's a never ending process, someone is always going to imitate someone else's video/style. Just like Usher, Chris Brown, Ginuwine, and Justin Timberlake imitate Michael Jackson's style…
nycbill says – reply to this

323

i can't believe you don'[t get it…."not myself tonight"………she's got you all worked up……….she's genius and your not……..
thepaparazzi says – reply to this

324

Oh come on, Christina has been here ages before Lady gaga.
Gclyde says – reply to this

325

These "comparisons" really piss me off, Christina has been around a lot longer and has ALWAYS been this way, she's not copying anyone. She's always dressed this way!
dave_o says – reply to this

326

if christina had an original thought….
it was in another life time

stop copying the gaga!
scotty555britbrit says – reply to this

327

AT THE BEGINING WITH THE WITH SWIMSUIT AND THE DANCERS WITH THE BLACK ONE, IT LOOKED LIKE THE "3" VIDEO PART TO ME ASWELL. SHE WASN'T BEING HERSELF INDEED.
tori_fan1 says – reply to this

328

you know what i think is funny, that music is just music and why do we even need to argue like 15 year olds about who is better and who is not? they both bring things to the table and though i think christina can back her stuff up and has a voice that wont quit, (and i'm totally into the fetish gear), lady gaga is fun too. i've loved christina since she came out with stripped and gave me chills with her LYRICS, it was real, her words her feelings and thats how music should always be. sadly, it seems to be about competition (with fans and outside sources). i'm more of a fan of words and how music makes an individual FEEL, its not about surface, its about substance and speaking in a way that millions can relate. how about you all just sit back, relax and enjoy BOTH christina and gaga, and stop comparing and making it about WHO is better? this is not life my friends….music is beautiful, and if it makes you feel and react, then the job is done!
JOSHUAPERETS says – reply to this

329

i say she did it on purpose. the song is NOT MYSELF TONIGHT
so maybe she wanted to be Gaga "tonight"

but I prefer the "old" christina aguilera
and that video is not her best work. ugh
trashtalkinchick says – reply to this

330

She told LA Times in 2008 that she didn't know if Lady GaGa was a he or a she and also said that she didn't know anything about her since she didn't surf the web and she "lived under a rock". Pu-leeze! Even back then she was accused of ripping off GaGa's look (bangs and long straight hair) on her "Keeps Gettin' Better" video. I believe what comes out of her mouth like I believe JLO had twins without any "help" cuz that would be against her morals! PR people need to go into damage control PRONTO!
hudekzzo says – reply to this

331

amm noes lomismmo el temade xtina en el video es "BONDAGE" "SADO" todo lorelacionado en el video es a ese tema =) lo que pasa esq ue perez es fan de gaga por eso dicen estas cosas no veo lo mismo en el video sorry
jayceeb says – reply to this

332

gagtina™ isn't herself tonight! she is doing herself a bad night romance for sure!
madeleineforce says – reply to this

333

GaGa does it better.
madeleineforce says – reply to this

334

Re: Chelsea – Really? Your going to try and defend her using that pathetic argument?
Lady Gaga may be new, but everything about her is Original, and completely eccentric.
Christina's good too, but there is seriously no denying that she ripped off GaGa's video. And GaGa's is still hotter.
Stephaniie19 says – reply to this

335

Perez. idk why haters ,aid an account here??Their so retarded!!Go Perez!!love u!
mz.street says – reply to this

336

christina is a has been and will always be a has been.. aint no denying to that
musicitai says – reply to this

337

Actually the originals are a few of Madonna videos. Justify my love for one…
eskimo kisses says – reply to this

338

lmao. i hate her so much.
ohitsjessica says – reply to this

339

Hmmm…. Looks like Christina needs to get some of her own ideas.
tuffany says – reply to this

340

Who really cares who "copied" who here, there's no originality in music or fashion anymore, the market is flooded with images and artists, and if you wanna get attention, sometimes you gotta go big or go home. Which is sorta sad, because I think it really detracts from the real talent that some people have, and gives some people who lack talent waaaay too much success.
peachesgonebad says – reply to this

341

Re: PennyLane77 – Couldn't have said it better
lifeisasongloveisthemusic says – reply to this

342

She has to be doing it all on purpose. She is building the hype so people will watch her shit music video. If she wasn't looking like Gaga and trash talking Gaga….Xtina who?
Allie Sasha says – reply to this

343

X-Tina, or whatever she calls herself these days just can't make up her mind!
she was young and innocent
she was DIRRRTY
she was a rock chick
she was a 50's whatever
and now she's gone Gaga
Mmmirte says – reply to this

344

Surely all on purpose. The title of the song isn't 'Not Myself Tonight' for nothing.
qwen1981 says – reply to this

345

WELL IF CHRISTINA IS "DOING GAGA" SHE DID IT A HELL OF A LOT BETTER!!! HER NEW VIDEO KILLS LADY GAGA'S "BAD ROMANCE"(WHICH I LOVED AS WELL). I'M SORRY, BUT IF THIS IS ABOUT THE MUSIC(WHICH IT SHOULD BE) LADY GAGA'S MUSIC ISN'T ALL THAT CREATIVE OR DIFFERENT IF YOU REALLY LISTEN TO IT. CHRISTINA WINS THIS HANDS DOWN!! GAGA HAS A LONG WAY TO GO BEFORE SHE'S MUSICALLY WHERE CHRISTINA IS.
tr1ks says – reply to this

346

It's one thing to be inspired by Madonna or Gaga for that matter.. But to blatantly steal scenes and outfits and a whole idea/style is just.. desperation. I believe that "X-Tina" really has nothing left in her bag of tricks and to even be around now is somewhat.. surprising. Surprising that her career didn't die a long time ago. I'll be the first admit, she can sing; but not what she's been singing and it's time to hang it up. Her "ooohs" and "ahhhs" are just irritating and above all, played out. And even if she is doing this on purpose/intentional I doubt she'll stand 12 rounds with Gaga and Madonna. That's not even saying anything about Britney, who will wipe the floor with Miss Tina once her single hits let alone her album.

Do we even remember who the second girl was that Madonna kissed on stage..?
Or that Madonna even kissed another girl on stage during that VMA performance..
I didn't think so..
Im Mina says – reply to this

347

Probably intentional.
Shyeperez says – reply to this

348

FU perez, christinas been around a lot longer than gaga, and she keeps coming back, so what if gaga used fire? guys or red underwear in her video? that doesnt mean no one else can. ps, christina did the dirty, the red trademark and the candy floss hair first.
Sapsnap says – reply to this

349

Aguilera def not herself tonight shes LADY GAGA WANNABE

go fuck yourself xtina clonetina

Theres only 1 GaGalooo and it aint YOU!!!!!!!!!
Kateedid didn't says – reply to this

350

XTINA WAS ON THE SCENE WAYYY BEFORE YOUR JUNKIE GA GA WAS EVEN AROUND! SO ITS BLAH BLAH COPYING X-TINA, NOT THE OTHER WAY AROUND! AND XTINA DOESN'T HAVE TRACK MARKS ALL OVER HER BODY FROM SHOOTING DRUGS! GO CHRISTINA, YOUR THE ONE WITH THE REAL CLASS HERE! LADY GA GA IS NOT ORIGINAL IN THE LEAST, SHE HAS RIPPED OFF NUMEROUS PEOPLE, BUT THAT'S OKAY WHY? GIVE IT UP ASSHOLE!
Livin'Lovely says – reply to this

351

Wait who was the childish little girl who spread the rumor that Gaga was a hermaphrodite, which led to more people being interested in her? Uh yeah was Christina!! She is just doing this because she was influenced by Lady Gaga. Yea she was here longer, really who cares, its about who's in now. That is why Xtina had to copy her because she couldnt come up with anything herself. Plain 7 simple. She is clearly admitting that she is fake & isn't who she really wants to be or still doesn't know who she is. Where Gaga is in a different field from her.
Sambalam29 says – reply to this

352

There's no denying Christina is talented. There's definitely no denying that Gaga is talented. There is also no argument that these two are obviously inspired by Madonna. The big difference between the two is that when Gaga is compared to Christina she is gracious and polite. When Christina is compared to Gaga, she's a rude bitch…she knows she's been compared to Gaga in the past, so why the fuck would she deliberately do a video where she knows we're all gunna compare her again and call her a copy cat??
rrraquel says – reply to this

353

Alright, enough is enough. I'm a HUUUGE fan of BOTH these wonderful, talented ladies. NOT ONCE, did I fucking think of Gaga while watching this video. I think it's fucking ridiculous you're making a waaaay bigger deal than it really is. Really, you're you're creating a feud that is unesscesary, betwen both artists and the fans. And to the people saying Christina copies everyone, get your head out of your ass. Christina pushed the envelope first(excluding Madonna), so get bent.
getnaked says – reply to this

354

Ugh, y'know what? Eff you, perez. You're the worst Gaga stan of all. All of these comparisons are reaching, just like the Roisin/Gaga ones, too.
Gaga isn't original, and she knows and admits that. If she wanted to come off as original, she would've never cited her inspirations over and over and OVER.
She's open about where she got her ideas from. These two ladies don't have to deal with this. It sucks that Gaga has to deal with being called a copy cat when she never came out and said I'M AN ORIGINAL. It sucks for Christina, too. Some Gaga fans really are the worst, but I'm glad that there are LOGICAL ones out there. You not being one of them.
I hope these two join up on the stage together, belt out some notes, and get rid of you forever. I hate the fact that Gaga is a friend with a pig like you.
studhunk says – reply to this

355

none of these pictures are exactly the same and christina has worn similar things as in the pics years ago
Gav84 says – reply to this

356

This video has nothing to do with GaGa see Madonna Express yourself video from the men in the rain, to drinking the milk, to pouring the milk down her back!!!!
DWizle says – reply to this

357

Beauty on the right, Beast on the left. You can't stop making you and your besty look like bad players in the biz. Remind me of your talent again Perez? Crying when you get punched in the face like a fat school boy? Oh you, that's it.
DWizle says – reply to this

358

Xtina is perfection in many ways. Voice of our generation. Unparalleled vocal range. Mother. Wife. Beauty inside and out. Gaga wears weird clothes to stand out…. you tell me who's got it together and who is copying who.