Bad Idea!!

We just don't think he has the star power!
Bret Michaels is in talks to replace Simon Cowell on the next season of American Idol. He says:
"We have a meeting in L.A. in a couple weeks and we're going to sit down and talk. They did a poll and I think it was Madonna, P. Diddy, Howard Stern and myself, and I took 50 per cent or 60 per cent of the vote and that's tremendous. I would love to be a judge on American Idol. I think I would bring a lot to the table.
"I'm not built exactly like Simon Cowell, but, at the same time, I respect what he did. I would have to bring my own personality. I think if they have someone in there to try to imitate Simon, it would be a mistake; he's an original. Bring Bret Michaels in to be original… Bring someone who can bring a little grit, true grit, back to the show."
We think Bret's resurgence of fame is fleeting and while we're happy he's doing well, he's NOT the guy for this job!
PEREZ FOR IDOL!
[Image via WENN.]
Tags: american idol, bad idea, bret michaels, judge















































No way in hell Madonna would want this job. So beneath her
Re: SwedishSweetheart – STFU you ignorant troll. GaGa wouldn't exist if it wasn't for Madge and Madonna didn't release new music or tour non-stop this year you f-ing tool.
Re: poopooface – I vote you for President!
Re: jp1988 –
And why would being on that show be beneath Madonna? Because Paula Abdul did it? You're talking about the same woman with two failed marriages under her belt who did "The Marriage Ref." Madonna going on a show giving marriage advice (yeah, right), and you want to say AI is beneath her? Please….
your just jealous that you are not being considered for the job in the slightest…if you think it is important to have star power then you are definitely not in the running so stop being petty and pathetic. I would quit watching if I had to listen to you every week. Brett has more star power in his pinky then you have in your whole body.
Perez, you really need to get over yourself. I'm embarrassed for you! Bret Michaels may not have the star power to replace Simon, but you CERTAINLY don't have it either.
him over music mogul diddy? in a million years
perez stfu. u know nothin about music.
i think that p diddy would be the best for the seat
uh bret would get it over perez…
Diddy or Jay-Z or maybe Eminem…shake it up. Someone who,like Simon, could be kind of mean, but thruthful and sound like he/she knows what he/she is talking about.
and you think you have the star power? good luck you nasty fuck!
Re: killer_kupkakes – seriously….just because you are like 12 and don't know the impact he had on rock music and only know him from Rock of Love and his battle with diabetes, doesn't mean that is all he is known for….all that shows, is how ignorant you are about pop/music culture
Re: Misty_Vine – Perez needs to keep his job because he is good at it? What job is that? Shoving his head up gaga's ass as far as he possibly can? He'd be shit on Idol just like he's shit on every other thing he attempts! Well except when it comes to calling attention to kiddie porn, he's really good at that because he's a nasty ass pervert.
I think it's a bad idea. He's not intelligent enough. U need someone super smart for head judge. I think what might have worked is if Ellen had not been a part of this series and to replace Simon they introduced Brett and Ellen, but too late now. An option might be to get rid of Kara, and bring in another new judge there. Possibly J.Lo along with Brett. That could work. Then make Ellen head judge cos she's the smartest.
Ok sure, a guy who's been touring the world with his music the last 25 years doesn't have the "Star Power" but an Internet blogger does? Keep dreaming Perez!
Bret- yes he has the experience
Perez- stop your begging it is pathetic!!!!! You are NOT the most qualified!!!!!
OMG just saw someone mention Eminem. I think that's genius! Also I think he would be interested cos he mentioned something in the press before. I also think they should still get rid of Kara and replace her with J.Lo. J.Lo and Eminem would have good chemistry.
Re: KeeperOfEdwardsSexuality –
Creepiest username EVER!!!
Lets see, select someone that has been in the music business for a long time and knows what he is talking about or select someone that doesn't have a fucking clue what music is (see lame acts promoted by clueless Perez).
I'm going with the experienced musician over the piece of shit that would surely make Idol suck even more then it already does
end of idol.
You are so jealous! Bret Michaels is in the business. What can you possibly bring to the table? You just want your ugly face on TV.
Well of course you'd say that Perez.
They should replace Ellen with him and find someone else to replace Simon. But they can bring in anyone now because they did with Ellen - She didn't bring anything to the show and doesn't have anything to offer as advice - Just walk up to someone on the street and you could get the same advice hers was just an opinion who needs that - you need someone who gets the music industry Bret will know that.
If Bret Michaels is selected, it will be the end of American Idol. He is just not the one.
Re: killer_kupkakes – Are you kidding me the only thing he's known for is rock of love and his medical problems? Have you never heard of the band poison? Oh and wait that's right he was on celebrity apprentice. You've clearly been hiding under a rock for the past 20 years while he's been making his money in the music industry. He has the star power AND the experience to be an awesome judge!
LMFAO HAHA i cannot believe you say Bret Michaels doesnt have the star power for this position, but YOU do????!? Get fucking real assbag. I think i speak for a majority of the population when i say NO ONE would like to see YOU as a judge on IDOL. What the fuck kind of talent and experience in music do you have to judge???? please. they would NEVER consider you. Let it go already.
I would imagine someone who has actually had a career in a very successful band is far more qualified to judge singers/performers than someone who blogs about celebrity gossip. Just sayin.
I'd watch Bret Michaels on Idol.
Also, I wouldn't watch Madonna.. They already have too many girls whining up there. I wouldn't watch P. Diddy because he's annoying and already annoyed the hell out of me with his making the band craaappp and I wouldn't watch Howard Stern because he's annoying and my little sister would ask me why he's famous and there is no way i'm telling her.
I love the idea of Bret on Americal Idol!
Atleast they would be hiring someone with a real music background as opposed to Ellen Degeneres and that other stupid chick.
I agree w/Perez. Unless Bret can come up with another brain hemorrhage, his supreme popularity won't last. Also, he's too nice and polite. They need someone blunt and with out mercy. Martha Stewart fits the bill perfectly IF she has any musical sense. Or, David Spade? Any musical sense there? If he could lose the flab.