Home Videos Photos

German Pop Singer Found Guilty In HIV Spreading Case

| Filed under: Legal Matters

web-nadja.jpg

Nadja Benaissa, a German pop singer who was part of the group “No Angels,” was found guilty of causing bodily harm to her ex-boyfriend by having unprotected sex with him with the full knowledge that she was HIV positive.

Despite committing this deplorable crime, she was not sentenced to any jail time, but instead a two-year suspended prison sentence and 300 hours of community service, which essentially means she’s on probation. The maximum jail time that she could have received was 10 years.

During the trial, Nadja made a formal apology:

"I'm sorry from the bottom of my heart…I wish I could turn back time and make everything undone. But I know that he will never forgive me."

Nadja refused to make any statements to reporters after the trial, but her attorney Oliver Wallasch said that she had admitted during the trial that she thought she deserved to be punished for her actions.

We agree. She does deserve to be punished and should feel lucky to have gotten off with only a two-year suspended sentence.

Do U think the punishment was fair?

Tags: , , , , ,

63 comments to “German Pop Singer Found Guilty In HIV Spreading Case”



  1. 1

    No!



  2. 2

    No shit he will never forgive you. No one deserves that! He now has alife sentece of AIDS therefore she should have gotten a life sentence in jail. What a deplorable human being she is!!!



  3. 3

    hell NO!!!

    That is like one of the WORST things you can do to someone you 'love'

    the ultimate betrayal….it is a death sentence. It changes someone's life forever.
    She should be jailed for this crime.

    How horrible can a person be to knowingly infect another with HIV?



  4. 4

    This just shows how biased courts are these days in favor of ""poor women" if it were a man in her place i bet you he would have gotten jail time.



  5. 5

    I'm sorry but this is much on him as her. We all know the dangers of unprotected sex weather with someone you're in a relationship or not. As adults it's your own respsonsibilty to ensure you're being safe. Knews flash! People lie and cheat on each other ALL THE TIME! So why put your life in someone else's hands that way. I could see if he did everyting he could to prevent this for example insist on STD tests before engaging in unprotected sex. And also anyone with any shred of human decency should not even THINK of having unprotected sex with someone knowing you are infected. That's just evil. Even if she didn't want to tell him she should have at least insisted on protection. Let this be a list to everyone out there. It's up to YOU to protect your body. There are cases everyday where people in so called commited relationships bring diseases to their partners. Don't be naive. This situation is a lot more common than you may think.Protect YOURSELF because noone else is going to!!!



  6. 6

    it's a two-way street. he didn't protect himself either. And unless he asked her outright if she were poz, and she lied to him, I think this is total BS that she was convicted of a crime. BS. All of you people need to be upfront with your sex partners!!!!!!



  7. 7

    im sorry

  8. Phaze says – reply to this


    8

    Awesome.



  9. 9

    What was the charge? Assault with a deadly weapon? Seriously?



  10. 10

    perez baby i hate to break this to ya this is old news, and she ruin alot of lives. This is why we must protect ourselves ladies and gentlemen, see how beautiful she is ……



  11. 11

    at least one year would be fair. i mean how naive was she? stupid . dumm



  12. 12

    She got off WAY TOO EASY!
    She just killed a man!!! HOPEFULLY no others were involved.



  13. 13

    I read a response that tried to shift the blame from her onto him. How could he be to blame. His girlfriend knowingly and maliciously lied to him, then infected him with a lethal disease. All because she was to immature to face the reality of her situation and give her partner a piece of information that could have saved his life. What she did is an ultimate act of cowardice that is inexcusable. She should have received at least the maximum sentence. A life sentence would be more fitting if not the death penalty. She has basically killed him. Any attempt to shift the blame from her is also a cowardly act.



  14. 14

    This news item does not say if the man contracted HIV or not. Did he? Female-to-male transmission is pretty rare (it's not easy to transmit HIV that way).



  15. 15

    this equals murder…she should be sentenced to life at least…



  16. 16

    Contemporary Germany has always been particularly light-handed in the sentences they pronounce. I remember Günther Parch, the nutjob that back-stabbed Monica Seles back then in 1993 to help Steffi Graf regain her top position in the wta rankings, got away with no jail time. Hard to fathom in America where a certain guy, if memory serves me well, had been sentenced to 42 years jail time for having stolen a pizza.



  17. 17

    it was wrong what she did. That´s right and she deserve her punishment. But you have to know the whole story before you judge about her. It isn´t an excuse, but she was drug addict at this time and underage. Because of that she can´t go to jail for life. The German Law is diffrent to the American.



  18. 18

    Unbelievable! How could someone do this? I feel bad for the guy honestly and NO I don't believe her punishment was fair. But then again I don't know the "Court System". [It seems like they've been doing a lot of unfair stuff now days. First a [famous] girl gets high when ever she wants and get less that 30 days, now another [famous] girl gives her boyfriend a uncurable [at the moment] disease and she doesn't even have to step foot in a jail cell.



  19. 19

    This is just deplorable. I don't understand how someone could do this to someone. It's so sad.



  20. 20

    bitch

  21. sas25 says – reply to this


    21

    First off, I also don't believe the punishment fair. Of course the guy could've worn a condom, but she knew she was positive and she consciously decided to not inform her partners about it. For that, there's just one word: Wrong! If she didn't want him to know about her being HIV positive, she could have made up an excuse like not being on the pill or whatever. Or not slept with him.
    The reason she got off with such a light sentence is that by the time she committed what she was accused of, she was under 21. In Germany, young adults until the age of 21 can be sentenced under juvenile laws (depends on level of maturity and such things). The maximum sentence in those cases would be 10 years (for capital crimes such as murder). What she was in court for was aggravated battery and aggravated assault.



  22. 22

    Re: Lulu101

    Fuuuuuuuuck you and knowing the whole story. Dont give me that underage and on drugs bullshit. How would you like it if your boyfriend whom your fucking has hiv and isnt telling you???? Would you sympathize with him? Probably not.

    20/20 did that story where all those "cougars" were fucking the same 30-40yr old dude at diff times and he had hiv and gave it to e-v-e-r-y single one of them. Hes in jail now.



  23. 23

    hell NO



  24. 24

    anyone who knowingly transmits HIV should recieve the same sentence as someone who shoots their bf/gf in the head, same thing really. I live in canada and there was a case here a couple years ago where a man did the same thing to SEVERAL gfs and he ended up being convicted on 2 counts of murder in the first degree, 10 counts of aggravated sexual assault, and 1 count of attempted aggravated sexual assault….needless to say the verdict got him sentenced to life imprisonment, i dont normally agree with the canadian legal system, but i think they got this one right :)

  25. eando says – reply to this


    25

    It's murder really. SO, no it's not a fair punishment at all.



  26. 26

    He had a choice as to whether or not he has unprotected sex. Yes, she did have an obligation to tell him she is HIV+ but he could have easily used a condom either way.

    They are both guilty of being reckless with their health.



  27. 27

    That's horrible and disgusting..How could a human being do that to another Human being? The bitch has no heart and even though she basically got off. She'll get hers eventually. That may sound mean of me but it's true. Fucking bitch!



  28. 28

    Did she actually infect him, or just expose him to HIV? You people don't seem to know much about HIV. In the western world where female circumcision in not widely practised the percentage of female to male infections through sexual intercourse are actually quite low. It is usually men who infect women. For a woman to infect a man through sexual intercourse she generally has to be bleeding and he has to have open sores that she is bleeding into.



  29. 29

    Dumb fucking skank. She deserves to be shot, in my opinion.



  30. 30

    Re: qwen1981

    lol, no you stupid fucking whore. Its not his fault that she knowingly gave him aids.



  31. 31

    Notice how all the females replying are somehow trying to make this his fault. Ridiculous.



  32. 32

    I think anyone who knows they have HIV & choses to have unprotected sex w/o telling the other person that they have the virus should be put to death. She's taken his life & should pay with hers.



  33. 33

    Fuck no. That bitch deserves to be in jail for the rest of her life, she's already serving a death sentence. I don't care how young she was or how turbulent her life is. Anyone with knowledge of that knows better. THAT is deplorable. What she did was inexcusable and unforgivable. I am shocked that the Prosecuting attorney said the sentence was fair. There aren't enough words to describe off of the top of my head how horrific what she did was. She's disgusting and should be on death row.



  34. 34

    She knew she had it, yes they have many treatments but in the end, an illness will kill him because he WILL get AIDs. I would feel guilty even having protected sex with someone if I was HIV positive, I couldn't do it.
    You take responsibility when you have a disease that is so scary and expensive to treat. That is his body… and he can't go back now.

    I agree with some people saying it was also his responsibility. I don't sleep with people unless I know them very well and make sure they are tested before we have any sort of sexual contact unprotected. It's too scary and you only have one body to live in!!!

    I feel sorry for him, and she deserves to be put away like anyone else would be. It's technically manslaughter.



  35. 35

    Re: jcrhode – What she did is horrible but she didn't kill a man. Nowadays people with HIV can have a relatively long and normal life. We shouldn't stigmatize this illnes and treat people with HIV as if they had a death sentence. You could die before.



  36. 36

    Re: Saosin – I agree she deserves to be shot, but that would also be giving her another easy way out. I don't think Qwen was wrong, she was exactly right, you protect yourself because no one else will! He should of been smarter with sex and this happens to a lot of people. Qwen also said that people cheat all the time…. and it's true. Someone can easily pick it up and not know… and pass it on and that's a lot of the cases probably. It's important to look out for YOURSELF.
    And I'm a woman, I'm putting FULL blame on this lady for doing that to another person. I just agree to being smarter when it comes to sex. Even if you trust someone.



  37. 37

    Re: contrarianchick

    The man in question IS HIV positive, but I read that her lawyer was going to try and disprove that it was definitely her that infected him.

    She also slept with 3 other men - all unprotected - over the course of 4 years. These men, as far as we know, are not HIV positive.

    I think it's unfortunately pretty common to have reckless and unprotected sex - but the fact that she'd had her status medically confirmed means that she knew she could be dealing that person a life-sentence of HIV.

    She's got to live with the knowledge that she did that for the rest of her life.



  38. 38

    I don't think it was fair at all. You should be criminally liable when you do something that disgusting to someone. They should have given her the 10 years.



  39. 39

    DA-YUM….



  40. 40

    Re: adnice – its not old news. they just said that yestersay. obviously im from germany and i know better



  41. 41

    Retards - she has to do that community ervice in an institution with HIV/AIDS infected people - that's a better punishment than prison you retards!



  42. 42

    PLUS she appeared in front of a "youth crime court" or whatever the right term for that is….so the punishment couldn't be this hard in the first place.



  43. 43

    to me this is the same as if she held a gun to his head.

    if she told him she was hiv positive and probably had aids. there is no way he would have sex with her not even with a condom..

    no one would have sex with a death sentence.

    she derserves a knife in her neck. a k.i.t.n



  44. 44

    OH YES AND KEEP ON BLAMING HER ONLY! ITS NOT LIKE THE GUY COULDVE WORN A FUCKING CONDOM! ITS ONLY HER FAULT RIGHT?!



  45. 45

    Re: qwen1981 – Learn how to spell. Re: estebanito – You sound ignorant because your entire statement contradicts yourself.



  46. 46

    she murdered him.

    she should face a murder charge and die



  47. 47

    she should die a painful death



  48. 48

    no angel, although she looks like one …
    it is a crime and it is sad for all the involved.
    she got infected when she was only 16 …
    i wonder if her daughter got the virus too?
    sad sad - & criminal, too.



  49. 49

    by the way: she has got to make a therapy, too - the court ordered that.



  50. 50

    This should at least be considered attempted murder, because the medicine they go on for this doesnt always help people, and even then, the length of their lives is often reduced, and they are plagued with illnesses all their lives due to the reduced immune system. just awful.



  51. 51

    Bitch is sick. Sorry just does not fucking cut it. She has ultimately (knowingly!!!) gave her ex a death sentence and she is fucking sorry?! She should rot in jail for what she has done. If she didn’t know that she had HIV then fair enough – it still would have sucked but at least she would have been unaware. This is one selfish bitch who knew EXACTLY what she was doing, she was old enough to understand her disease and the consequences of having unprotected sex but STILL did not tell her partner. She said the Doctor had told her it was more or less no chance she could pass it on to others, if that is the case then that Doctor is just as guilty as she is!

    Condoms people!!



  52. 52

    The men she slept with had an equal responsibility to use protection. There is a moral case that one should tell partners, but there should not be a legal responsibility - surely it will discourage people from regular testing so they cannot be accused of this 'crime.'



  53. 53

    Man or woman, if anyone did this, they should be executed.



  54. 54

    She was 17 at the time of offense



  55. 55

    they used criminal law relating to young offenders. Of course he has the virus. But due to the status of medicine today, he will not die



  56. 56

    Stupid of her but even more stupid of him!



  57. 57

    no she should fry



  58. 58

    She got off too lightly.



  59. 59

    selfish, thoughtless bitch



  60. 60

    Re: contrarianchick – 1 of the 3 men she slept with contracted it

  61. @v@ says – reply to this


    61

    Getting someone to forgive you kind of pales to the fact that they might not be alive to if they decided to. Stupid girl.



  62. 62

    Re: Saosin – First of all GROW UP! Name calling is for ignorant juveniles. I'm just saying people should get real and understand that OMG not everyone is honest. SHOCKER! Was she wrong in not telling him her status…yes!…did he do everything he could have done to ensure he was protected? NO! This is such an common issue that happens everyday and until people start taking responsibility for their own safety this disease will CONTINUE TO SREAD. I'm just saying…lets be realistic here. There are people out there who don' tknow they have it and i'm sure there are a lot more out there who know they do have it but choose to keep quiet. You can't MAKE them tell you but what you CAN do is use protection and if u decide to not use condoms at least insist that you and your partner get tested. This is real life not some damn fairytale where people always do the right thing.



  63. 63

    This is a crime in most jurisdictions with prison time. GBH.