Home Videos Photos

Idol Contestant Performs 'Unreleased' GaGa Song, You & I!

| Filed under: American IdolLady GaGa

Look who took a real risk? Hopefully, it will pay off.

For the first time in American Idol history last night, a contestant performed a previously unreleased song by a major artist during the competition round. The ears of every little monster in the Idol audience perked up when Ryan Seacrest announced that Haley Reinhart would be singing a song by Lady GaGa that to date has not been made available to the public…unless you know how to use Youtube.

With GaGa's bless, Haley performed a rendition of You & I, a song not on any of GaGa's albums, but one she has been performing out on the road with the Monster Ball ever since she debuted it last June at Elton John's White Tie and Tiara Ball fundraiser in England.

So how did she do? See for yourself! Check out the video (above) to hear Haley croon out her version of GaGa's You & I!

Was it enough to make U vote for her last night???

Tags: , , , , , ,

Email this  »
MTV Video Music Awards' Worst Dressed Of ALL Time!
The Highest-Paid Women In Music 2013!
The Biggest On-Set Celebrity Feuds EVER!
On Stage Ouchies!
Huge Stars Who LOST On Reality Competition Shows
MTV Video Music Awards 2013: Worst Dressed

23 comments to “Idol Contestant Performs 'Unreleased' GaGa Song, You & I!”



  1. 1

    How can you leak your "best friend's" video? Haha I hope you get fined…

  2. M: says – reply to this


    2

    it sucks but it is better than gagaflop



  3. 3

    I didn't like the song at all!! even Randy said he doesnt think its even a good song!



  4. 4

    It wasn't perfect, but it was a good fit for her. I'm sure a lot of people watching who were unfamiliar with the song said, "Why don't they make songs like this anymore?"



  5. 5

    personnaly, i thought both her and the song sucked, i guess theres a reason Lady Shitho never realeased it.



  6. 6

    "unless you know how to use Youtube."

    How does that change the fact that it hasn't been released yet??? lol

    Song sucks and I really don't get how Haley has made it this far…



  7. 7

    heck to the freakin no. her performances were just terrible. im more of lauren alaina fan. lauren is so freakin talented. hayle's voice is too scratchy for my liking.



  8. 8

    I like her voice better then Gaga's on this track. This probably should have been on born this way as opposed to the awful songs we've heard so far (BTW, JUDAS, AMERICANO)



  9. 9

    dont like the song but Haley is AMAZING her second performance just blew me away



  10. 10

    The song was OK but Haley has an awesome voice, I just LOVE how people blindly follow the 3 blond mice judges. paleeeze



  11. 11

    That song sucks ass! and hopefully she won't go home because of it.



  12. 12

    I think Hayley did a great job! But unfortunately the producers have it out for her, because they had the judges give her complete bull shit comments. I hope she makes it through!



  13. 13

    Re: Megan Brittany – I totally agree! Her voice is a thousand times better than any of the other competitors, but the judges ALWAYS seem to pick on her for some inexplicable reason - and yet they praise Scotty and Lauren every week when they are as bland as saltine crackers. Haley has true raw talent - she's got genuine soul, and I truly hope America recognizes that and puts her through to the finale. But I have my doubts. Every one of her performances gives me chills.



  14. 14

    Dont like it. Dont know about her voice, cant really feel it with this horribad song.



  15. 15

    you idiots its about her voice not the song and her voice sounded amazing



  16. 16

    she should have been voted out weeks ago…..she has an annoying screechy singing voice



  17. 17

    she sucks! i heard drunk girls sing better



  18. 18

    Her singing is good but I don't care for her attitude. She is boring to watch on stage as well. Lauren and either James or Scotty will be finalists. Haley needs to get over herself, and quit standing there swinging her right arm all the time and do something with that hair.



  19. 19

    I love her but the song drives me nuts, grammatically it should be "You & Me".



  20. 20

    I prefer singing to yodeling.



  21. 21

    i must admit- i really dont like this girls voice!!!



  22. 22

    I give it a 10! :)



  23. 23

    Jimmy Iovine gave Haley bum advice by asking her to sing this song. Jimmy is so ridiculous, he's pushing 60 but always dresses like he's 19 years old. One of my guilty pleasures of American Idol is seeing what age inappropriate outfit "Jimmy" will wear in order to desperately appear to be young and hip.