Home Videos Photos Shop
PerezHilton CocoPerez Khloé Selena G. Meghan Markle T. Swift PerezTV

Jay-Z In Court Over Big Pimpin Sample

| Filed under: Legal MattersTimbalandJAY-Z

Jay Z In Court Over Egyptian Sample

Rappers apparently love their obscure foreign cinema so much that they can't stop themselves from sampling music from them.

A while ago, Timbaland narrowly avoided a lawsuit over sampling a 1967 Bollywood film.

Now it's Jay-Z's turn to wage a battle in the courts over an obscure 1960 Egyptian film called Fata Ahlami.

Apparently, Jay-Z's crew thought they had obtained the proper rights, but now the children who inherited the rights are claiming that it was only a reproduction right, not a sampling-turn-it-into-a-rap-song-right, so they're claiming a breach of Moral Rights under Egyptian law — something the judge here in the states isn't completely against hearing. Moral rights do exist in the states, but, are rarely used in copyright arguments.

Here's what's happening:

The plaintiff says that to the extent the defendants obtained a license of the song for the 2000 hit “Big Pimpin,” it was merely what Egyptians call “economic rights” and only pertained to reproduction, performance or distribution of the work “without alteration.”

Egyptian copyright law also confers to owners “moral rights” over copyrighted work, which, according to the plaintiff's experts, can’t be disposed of like “economic rights.” Basically, if Jay-Z wished to “mutilate” the original song by sampling it, looping it and adding his lyrics, the plaintiff argues he needed to get the express permission of each of Hamdy's four children.

The lawsuit was said to hold grounds, and it'll be looked into further.

Wow, it'll be interesting to see where all this goes!

What do U think? Do the kids have grounds?? Did Jay-Z butcher it immorally?

[Image via Ramey Pix.]

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

The Teen Mom Franchise: A Mugshot Collection!
Too Many Trump Scandals To Follow? Get The Breakdowns HERE!
Biggest Teen Mom Scandals!
20 Songs You Didn't Know Were Written By Bruno Mars!
Grammy Awards 2018: Performance Looks & Stage Pics
The Most Unique Celeb Baby Names!

3 comments to “Jay-Z In Court Over Big Pimpin Sample”

  1. @v@ says – reply to this


    It sounds like a misunderstanding involving some international law. He might have to pay them all some of that 'Big Pimpin' money.

  2. 2

    That is the most useless waste of legal time imaginable. Idiotic and benefiting no one.

  3. 3

    Hmm the song came out how long ago- and these people are just now getting around to suing him? seems like they finally realized they might possibly have a pay day on their hands…. Everyone is so sue happy now a days.