We weren't even there and we were cheering, too!
And it sure seems like no one was complaining of the choice of Ben for Batman then!
Check it all out in the video (above) !!!
American Idol can't catch this Butterfly!
"I don't know if they [Idol] can afford Mariah Carey. That's a lot of money. If they gave J.Lo $20 million, they might have to double that!"
He's right though! $20 mil would hardly cover the rent on the couple's summer home.
Plus, MiMi has a new album coming out soon. She doesn't have time for a TV show!
Lucky for FOX, we know the perrrrfect replacement!
[Image via WENN.]