Unfortunately for Nick, the fans wanted to see him chug!
Although, Nick managed to make slime look good!
Watch him chug (above) and get slimed (below)!
If it’s wrong or perhaps, too early to ship Nicariah Caraj, then we just don’t want to be right!
And Perezcious readers, if you missed it, it was all we could have ever hoped for… and MORE!
Between the fake strangling and fighting over who knows more about Mean Girls to who has the better accessories — we kinda sorta LOVE the girls together!
Check out some of the best Nicariah moments (above) from last night!
Oh, but that wasn’t all! They even agreed that they “gel well” with each other in a "weird, crazy way!"