Justin Bieber VS Selena Gomez! Both Cover Cry Me A River: Who Did It Justice?

1/21/2013 11:41 AM ET | Filed under: Justin Timberlake • Music Minute • Love Line • Polls • Selena Gomez • Justin Bieber

Oh Jelena, Jelena Jelena…

How can young love end in such tragedy??

Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez have been off and on with their relationship over the past few months, most recently, reportedly splitting after a huge fight while on their Mexican vacay!

However, it seems like the two are both dealing with the break up the best way they know how — through song!

We previously showed you the video (above) of Selenita covering Justin Timberlake's Cry Me A River just this past weekend, and as you may remember, the Biebs covered it back in November, too!

Now we're curious to know…

Who Sang "Cry Me A River" Better?

Neither! Bring back Justin Timberlake! (49%)
Justin Bieber (20%)
Selena Gomez (31%)

Total Votes: 17,534

Vote

Loading …

Tags: break up, cover, cry me a river, justin bieber, justin timberlake, relationship, selena gomez, split

Email this »

See All 22 Comments

22 comments to “Justin Bieber VS Selena Gomez! Both Cover Cry Me A River: Who Did It Justice?”

jenn says – reply to this

1

both did good, but I like selena's version better. sounds better with a girls voice.
xxMaikexxx says – reply to this

2

I think you can really hear the emotion that fits with the song in Selena's version.
Cassie says – reply to this

3

I like Selena's version better. Her voice is sweet and easy on the ears. Justin… Idk, I'm not a fan of his voice. And listening to this song makes me missing JT. I'm so excited for his comeback this year.
oxygen says – reply to this

4

She can't sing (( very sad
sara says – reply to this

5

i like her version better but she really cant sing that well. i dunno if she was emotional or if she is just that bad. justin can sing he's just annoying
RB says – reply to this

6

Selena followed up her boy trouble cover songs with Britney Spears' "…Baby One More Time." This is a song about Britney screwing up with JT and wanted him to show her a sign that their love is still true. Why sing this song????
ekinna_ed says – reply to this

7

Selena better.
Yafa says – reply to this

8

Justin's vocals are amazing but Selena had more passion and she sang it wonderful. Selena wins!
crazylove says – reply to this

9

i think selena sang it better her voice is really nice and sweet
Just Passing Thro says – reply to this

10

Well, why not asked the guy behind Selena, he seemed to enjoy her singing. She might not be the greatest singer but she has room to improve. Must say she is looking good with the bohemian look.
Carli says – reply to this

11

Justin did it WAY better than Selena. And that is just the truth. You can't really compare their vocals. Lets be real with ourselves here.
RB says – reply to this

12

Selena! HELLO!!! You have had your BFF’s Vanessa Hudgens and Taylor Swift tell how to mend hour broken heart. You where with real men: Josh Hutcherson (20, caught dancing and flirting), Luke Bracey (23, holding hands), and now spotted with a mystery man in NY at your hotel, only to leave him behind in the car. You have had breakup songs. Is the Bieber fever that strong?? It looks like you’re standing on the bridge that you lit a match to, and is now on fire. Keep on going like you have, and you will be drowning in your own 'Cry Me a River', and Justin Bieber will have to pull you out.
sskiles says – reply to this

13

Soooo is Selena trying to tell us that Justin cheated? I wouldn't be surprised…
KStewannabe says – reply to this

14

This is so stupid why we should do Selena Vs Justin. I'm a belieber but i love selena too. They both are amazing but… Selena did it better ik. sounds so stupid cuz i said that and i'm a belieber but it's true i love Justin but i love him more when he makes crazy songs and not lyrics. Lyrics sounds better for Selly:) x
Yasmine says – reply to this

15

i liked Justins version better. Selena cant sing. Her voice is just annoying
Jessica says – reply to this

16

I liked Justin more. And he can sing and play an instrument. Selena can barley open her mouth and sing…
Yasmine says – reply to this

17

Re: Carli – i totally agree with you!
Taylor says – reply to this

18

I usually don't like selena's voice but she sounded nice. i hate justin bieber's voice. It's annoying.
Liyah says – reply to this

19

Re: Jessica – omg I so agree
Nia M says – reply to this

20

There was a lot of emotion in Selena's but honestly she can't sing..
fantasygirl says – reply to this

21

Justin clearly sang it better… Selena CANT SING!! Why on earth does she try?
Happy whore says – reply to this

22

They did welland so did justin timberlake