Home Videos Photos

YOU Decide! Whose Super Bowl Halftime Show Reigns Supreme?

| Filed under: Justin TimberlakeMadonnaJanet JacksonBritney SpearsBeyonceMichael JacksonYOU Decide!LMFAOSuper Bowl

super-bowl-halftime-show-beyonce madonna

We love watching sweaty dudes tackle one other, but our favorite part of the Super Bowl is always the halftime show!

From Justin Timberlake and Janet Jackson's booby debacle nearly a decade ago, to Madonna and LMFAO rocking our friggin' socks off just last year, the mid-game performances rarely disappoint!

As we prep our eardrums for Beyoncé mind-blowing show this weekend, we can't help but wonder…

Which Super Bowl spectacle was the most legendary?

U DECIDE…

Which Super Bowl halftime performance was most EPIC?

View Results

Which Super Bowl halftime performance was most EPIC?

  • Psh… Beyoncé will own all their asses this Sunday! (7%)
  • Michael Jackson (1993) (53%)
  • Britney Spears / 'N Sync / Aerosmith / Mary J. Blige (2001) (8%)
  • Justin Timberlake / Janet Jackson / Kid Rock / P. Diddy / Janet Jackson's boob (2004) (4%)
  • Madonna / LMFAO / Nicki Minaj / Cee-Lo Green (2012) (28%)

Total Votes: 96,234

Loading ... Loading …

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

185 comments to “YOU Decide! Whose Super Bowl Halftime Show Reigns Supreme?”

More comments: [1] 2 »

  1. Morisson says – reply to this


    1

    Beyonce will easily win this battle. Nobody works as hard as B! She will bring it.



  2. 2

    None of the above. How about U2, Paul McCartney, Springsteen or the Rolling Stones? I would take any of them over this list any day. But if you prefer glitz, glamour, and production then I can see why you would prefer Beyonce or Madonna.

  3. Jeff says – reply to this


    3

    Michael Jacksons Half Time was amazing. He had stunt doubles popping out of the boards. Altogether a much better show.

  4. fairmaiden says – reply to this


    4

    U2 U2 U2 U2



  5. 5

    The Who rocked it too.

  6. piazzasbutttplug says – reply to this


    6

    I think that they should show Three Stooges shorts during halftime. It would make quite an approvement.



  7. 7

    Re: piazzasbutttplug – improvement

  8. mlington says – reply to this


    8

    Madonna already won on rolling stone poll. biggest performance ever, with huge spetacle and huge ratings. madonna is a hard worker. noone does it better

  9. mlington says – reply to this


    9

    Madonna already won!!!! rolling stone said it… ppl voted !!!! bey is good but not WOWOW… Madonna is always WOWOWO and last year was surreal… never a star did that at superbowl!! huge stage, huge eprformance, huge opening act!! only QUEEN MADONNA

  10. samantha says – reply to this


    10

    lol M.I.A. is M.I.A., what happened? :p

  11. mlington says – reply to this


    11

    check rolling stone magazine. Madonna won. sorry but bey wont beat the ratings…. bey just ahs voice its too predictable. we already know what to expect!! madonna blowned the world…

  12. mlington says – reply to this


    12

    Madonna already won!! ppl voted at rolling stone and without a doubt madonna created a huge show in 10 minutes.

  13. mlington says – reply to this


    13

    MADONNA MADONNA MADONNA



  14. 14

    Le Boob wins.

  15. mlington says – reply to this


    15

    MADONNA WINS like rolling stone said. many M fans doesnt vote in here. Ratings proves it #1…. first artist bringing a shjow to a football game like the rpess said. bey has a huge voice but thats just that

  16. mlington says – reply to this


    16

    Bey performances are always the sme. shes not a performer



  17. 17

    I liked britney's, she was all wearing a football jersey and it was super fitting with the event and she did it in her prime. Madonna's just made me uncomfortable watching an old lady wearing things she shouldn't anymore and trying too hard to be sexual, it's really off putting.
    Oh and I only picked Britney over Michael cause I didn't see his…

  18. Britney S says – reply to this


    18

    MADONNA….WHO ELSE???? :(

  19. RiriFan says – reply to this


    19

    Beyonce will be booed…just wait !!!!!!!!!!!! hahahhahahaha

  20. The Rest Wannabe says – reply to this


    20

    ******Easily Madonna and her show has already in the Guinness World Records 2013******

  21. PrincePhreak says – reply to this


    21

    Uh…your list is incomplete. Prince, hands down, the best. ;) By the way, the moving pics on repeat is serious sensory overload. Just sayin'.



  22. 22

    how the fuck is madonna's performance good when she lip singed? idk but that isn't true talent, sure production looked awesome and stuff but idkkkkkkkk beyonce's will win because she said she won't lip sing and will put in a lot of work. have you seen the rehearsal video on youtube? i dont think shes playing around.



  23. 23

    Bruce

  24. xenedra says – reply to this


    24

    What the hell is wrong with you people. Michael Jackson had the best half time show that will ever be and you all know it. MJ forever!

  25. barb says – reply to this


    25

    Michael Jackson or The Who, either one was great ….but when you think about it, most people are going for a pee, a drink or food…so why do you need a half time show?????? Beyonce only works hard when it suits her purpose…she's no big deal. Destiny's Cild is so over.



  26. 26

    ZZ Top in 1997



  27. 27

    I really liked the year Diana Ross did the halftime show,then strapped herself to a helicopter and flew out of the stadium still sitting on the side !!!Now that's some showmanship!!!

  28. alanfeierstein says – reply to this


    28

    Re: Morisson – I hereby vote for Madonna; hands down….Only she can reign supreme, eternally…..She is Queen Of Pop…



  29. 29

    Re: mlington – No need to post the same story 3-4 times.
    Sorry but I voted for Michael Jackson, his show was amazing. Don't care for Madonna.

  30. Lucy says – reply to this


    30

    None of the above! Prince rocked the halftime show–far and away, the best!

  31. Lady Kaka says – reply to this


    31

    Re: artpop

    A typical response from a Lady Garbage fan. LOL!!!!! If Beyonce didnt record a duet with Gaga you would be hating her as well.

    P.S. Lady Gaga lip synchs as well

  32. mlington says – reply to this


    32

    Madonna all the way.

  33. Nicki says – reply to this


    33

    Madonna..easily !!!! ;)

  34. Artpoop says – reply to this


    34

    M———————A——————D——======—–O————–N————-N—————A

  35. The Edge Of Coffin says – reply to this


    35

    GaGa who?????? Hhahahaahahahahahahaa

  36. Allure says – reply to this


    36

    Michael Jackson! No doubt!

  37. Ane Hope says – reply to this


    37

    Michael Jackson



  38. 38

    your picks are crap. i'd go with the who or sir paul.

  39. Jaylie says – reply to this


    39

    Re: Morisson – You can watch the NFL Superbowl 2013 online for free and high quality at

  40. gigi says – reply to this


    40

    PRINCE

  41. Laia says – reply to this


    41

    Michael Jackson obviusluvy !!!!!!!!!!!! KING OF MUSIC, THE MEN OF THE RECORDS… hes the best <3

  42. Of Course says – reply to this


    42

    Madonna- the Queen of Pop !!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

  43. Gina says – reply to this


    43

    Madonna 101 %%%%%%

  44. Yulanda S says – reply to this


    44

    Madonna and MJ.

    Beyonce will be popping her ass with the same style and twerking. Boring…

  45. Michael says – reply to this


    45

    Re: rosebud99 – We watch the Puppy Bowl on Animal Planet. It may be silly, but after being bombarded with the Super Bowl's advertiser-driven, WAY WAY WAY over-the-top love affair with itself and it's commercials, watching a bunch of dogs run into each other is just a breath of fresh air. Maybe if they went back to marching bands it would become interesting again.

  46. Shaquanaya says – reply to this


    46

    Not too excited to see that fraud Beyawnce and Destiny's Child. Must be one of the worse lineup for Super Bowl after Black Eyed Peas :(

  47. Cocobutter Rihanna says – reply to this


    47

    Madonna = epicness !

  48. PinkyBell says – reply to this


    48

    Madonnaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  49. Dawo says – reply to this


    49

    M.A.D.O.N.N.A. 8)

  50. say says – reply to this


    50

    QUEEN MADGE OBIOUSLY! :)

  51. queen says – reply to this


    51

    MADONNA :)

  52. gessy says – reply to this


    52

    Michael Jackson

  53. Allie says – reply to this


    53

    Re: Morisson – You can watch the NFL Superbowl 2013 online for free and high quality at

  54. Vinny Bee says – reply to this


    54

    Who are the idots voting on this site, LOL. THere is no way Madonna or Britney's show is anywhere in the league of Janet and Justin's performance. janet's nipple has more talent in it than all the choices combines. Beyonce wont give us anything new. She'll shake her ass like she always does. THe JJ performance rules supreme!.

  55. twin1 says – reply to this


    55

    U2 U2 U2 U2 U2 U2

  56. deirdrelawlor says – reply to this


    56

    love michael jackson he did good job

  57. Liberty says – reply to this


    57

    DUH… MICHAEL JACKSON HANDS DOWN!!!

  58. @v@ says – reply to this


    58

    Michael Jackson, for his undeniable and limitless talent and artistry; and the excitement over his performance was palpable because he was just so good. I'll never forget that performance and him standing there with his hair and shirt blowing in that wind machine, while he performed right in the centre of the zone.
    His honed abilities put him on the zenith of performance. He rarely missed.

  59. Julie says – reply to this


    59

    How did Prince get left off the list? He also darn near killed himself playing an electric guitar in the rain.

  60. Tombi says – reply to this


    60

    Madonna is on my top list. She was original, creative, and artistic, e.g. choreography, stage presentation, technical production, and her singing. MJ cannot be ruled out …. For this SuperBowl, Beyonce's dance moves were expected. On some instances, her facial expression/look somehow mimicked J. Lo.

  61. Jocelyn says – reply to this


    61

    Michael Jackson had the best ever Superbowl……they should have gotten PitbulL to do it this year….he is amazing….

  62. Cynthia Kent says – reply to this


    62

    Michael Jackson hands down! You could 'feel the electricity' in the air, the crowd was going nuts!! The songs, not to mention his performance, outstanding! He had TOTAL command of the audience. I loved it, no one could match this mans talent OR his message.

  63. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    63

    TRUE DAT!!!!

  64. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    64

    YEAH WORD!!!!

  65. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    65

    Re: barb – to the 10th power!!!

  66. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    66

    Re: Britney S – MJ BURNED the dance floor baby 'n made the angels cry!!! Only reason the sluts got voted higher was cuz mostly men watch super bowl & voted for all the sluts!!!

  67. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    67

    Re: Britney S – MJ BURNED the dance floor baby 'n made the angels cry!!! Only reason the sluts got voted higher was cuz mostly men watch super bowl & voted for all the sluts!!!

  68. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    68

    Re: Britney S – MJ BURNED the dance floor baby 'n made the angels cry!!! Only reason the sluts got voted higher was cuz mostly men watch super bowl & voted for all the sluts!!!

  69. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    69

    Re: mzfunkythang – …ON MJ!

  70. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    70

    Re: mzfunkythang – …ON MJ!!!! THE GREATEST ENTERTAINER THAT EVER LIVED!!!!!!

  71. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    71

    Re: LaiaRe: mzfunkythang – ….On MJ hands down! GREATEST PERFORMER THE WORLD HAS EVER KNOWN!!!!

  72. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    72

    Re: mzfunkythang – … ON MJ WAS BEST-DUH!!!

  73. mzfunkythang says – reply to this


    73

    MJ- HANDS DOWN!!!

  74. Suni says – reply to this


    74

    Michael Jackson is the best and will always be, he didn't have backup artists to do the show, he sang and did it all himself, fuck you close-minded people who can't recognize greatness, all you like is crappy shit with 0 artistic value.

  75. mlington says – reply to this


    75

    ppl were expecting way more than Bey!!! everybody is saying Madonna was so much better. and she was. last year madonna changed half time show concept, created a huge performance… she fanced and all… bey crazy in love was fun but all the rest was boring… very poredictable!!!!! everybody is saying that. the numbers are 100 million for Bey and 114 million for Madonna. ppl are asking Madonna for 2014… but bey was cool too she should have created something huge for superbowl.. she just DANCED

  76. K Bye says – reply to this


    76

    Beyonce- The Worst Super Bowl Ever…. :(

  77. robertschulte says – reply to this


    77

    Madonna is a joke.

  78. Robert Schulte says – reply to this


    78

    Re: mlington – Madonna too

  79. Amanda says – reply to this


    79

    Defo michael jackson king of pop ❤❤❤



  80. 80

    Beyonce/Sasha can do some dancing now . Along with her troop, a lot better than Madonna, Justin Timberlake is getting older, I remember when he was the best, but I haven't seen him lately, so until then, I'll give it Beyonce. But I hope they don't have her every other song on the radio. Then you get B burn out.



  81. 81

    MJ was the first BIG-time star to do halftime Superbowl and no-one's done it better. MJ still reigns - King of Pop - King of Superbowl!!!!

  82. Beywance says – reply to this


    82

    Nice Try Beyonce but boring and repetitive. The whole fans thing was pathetic.. :(

  83. Zzzz says – reply to this


    83

    Her stripper image is getting TIRESOME.

  84. monster army says – reply to this


    84

    Beyonce's new album will flop…..just wait !!!!! Hahahhaahhahahaaa

  85. Tatayana says – reply to this


    85

    Beyonce, same dance..different venue and day. Boring :(

  86. Grow Up says – reply to this


    86

    This type of act is nothing but overproduced smoke and mirrors. Without all the flashing lights and smoke bombs there's really little to see.
    Young people are easily duped into believing that today's entertainment is high quality.
    Let's put the canned acts to rest. How about real musicians playing real music…live!

  87. Lolo says – reply to this


    87

    Beyonce- the most pathetic Super Bowl half time show of all time. What were the Super Bowl organizers thinking?

    That music is music to bore you to death with. :(

  88. SalsaGringo says – reply to this


    88

    Watching Beyone's half time show gave me a new appreciation for the Animal Planets "Puppy Bowl".

  89. wizkid says – reply to this


    89

    MDNA tour grossed the most. GO MADONNA. After all the negative things said about this "amazing force of nature", no one says "I'm better than you" than MADONNA. And she is!!!

  90. Luiza says – reply to this


    90

    Definitely Michael Jackson :)

  91. Heather Ruch says – reply to this


    91

    Anyone who voted for Madonna is an absolute MORON and clearly has no musical class

  92. Heather says – reply to this


    92

    It's a shame these are our voting choices as well, with the exception of Michael, although sadly, I don't remember his performance, so hopefully I can YouTube it. Why is Madonna's show last year even on the list?!?! She no longer entertaining, had used up her craft for longer then she should have & was SO obviously out of her element. EVERY SINGLE PERSON I spoke with last year about her performance, (mainly men), HATED whatever parts they did see…. And as a woman, I couldn't agree more. What a drag!! ;-)

  93. MartinP. (@Martin1987P says – reply to this


    93

    Who is Madonna? Cher, Grace Jones and Michael Jackson have all been victims of Madonna’s emulation, whether they know it or not.

  94. Nwvotes says – reply to this


    94

    Who really won at the Super Bowl? Beyonce or the Ravens? Vote at

  95. Yo Mama says – reply to this


    95

    Re: Heather Ruch – And you sound like an idiot!

  96. KC says – reply to this


    96

    What a biased poll. You could have at least listed every performer that performed during half-time. Instead, you choose the ones that appeal to the gayest fanbase.



  97. 97

    Lol. Still using MJ to bring the crowd in. This polls are rigged for just that. Anyways, his is the best Superbowl show thus far. What other one captivated the audience from when the doubles first jumped out the top of the stadium until the very end of his song Heal the World???? What other halftime spread a message so deep except for the 9/11 show???? no one. from when the doubles first came out, when MJ stood there for 1 1/2 -2 mins without moving, to his speech, to his involving the whole stadium on his message of heal the children, no one can beat that. His shows were always years ahead of other entertainers. Their is no other MJ. Until than these polls are just a way to make money for the sites. Bring up his name, and here comes the crowd.

  98. rd says – reply to this


    98

    Not one of those first four you listed would be in my top five halftime shows, nor in the top five of many people I know. As someone here mentioned, U2's was the best show ever and not just because of the Sept. 11 salute. They were smart in keeping it to just two songs instead of trying to do a sampling of several hits. Some of these shows remind me of being on iTunes listening to a snippet and trying to decide if we want to buy this song or not. Having said that, however, I would still put Beyonce/Destiny's Child in the top five for pure energy and choreography. It reminded me a bit of a Busby Berkeley scene from a 1930s musical.

  99. lourdes diaz says – reply to this


    99

    michael jackson the king of pop

  100. madara says – reply to this


    100

    MICHAEL JACKSON <3 … who else??

More comments: [1] 2 »