Home Videos Photos

Battle Of The Queens! Who Did It Better: Madonna Or Beyoncé? You Choose!

| Filed under: MadonnaBeyoncePolls

queen comparison madonna vs beyonce

All hail the queen!

Her Madgesty… Queen Bey… which of these ladiez donned the crown the best?

While Beyoncé just couldn’t seem to beat Madonna’s Super Bowl halftime ratings record, she did stun us with a majestic promo for her upcoming 2013 Mrs. Carter Show World Tour!

However, Madge will forever sit atop the throne in our hearts — she did it first with that epic promo poster (above) for her Re-Invention World Tour in 2004!!!

So we’ll just let you decide, royal, loyal Perezcious readers!

Who Reigns Supreme With Their Queen Theme?

View Results

Who Reigns Supreme With Their Queen Theme?

  • Beyoncé (44%)
  • Madonna (56%)

Total Votes: 36,191

Loading ... Loading …

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Celebrity Jobs Before Fame!
Wedding Crashers: Celebrity Edition!
Beyoncé's Best On Stage Looks: See The Evolution HERE!
Perez's Pics Of The Week: Sept. 5th-12th, 2014
Celebs Photoshopping Their Own Pictures: A Study Of Their Most Questionable Snaps!
This Week In Celebrity Twitpics And Instagrams!
Email this  »

136 comments to “Battle Of The Queens! Who Did It Better: Madonna Or Beyoncé? You Choose!”

More comments: [1] 2 »

  1. dangerwilrobinson says – reply to this


    1

    Jesus, really Perez? Madonna did do it first, but not for her Re-Invention Tour, but in like 1990 on the MTV Awards with the Vogue performance. That stuff for Re-Invention was Madonna once again rehashing everything she's already done. Whether it be this look, big crosses on stage, bashing Republicans during her show, swearing at her audience, resampling lyrics, etc. She claims she hates to repeat herself, but it's all she ever really does. MDNA record sounded like mash ups of her old songs.

  2. mlington says – reply to this


    2

    Madonna all the way. like Bey and they love each other but Madonna is Madonna

  3. mlington says – reply to this


    3

    Bey is way better than CACA …. but Maodnna is Madonna a legend

  4. Dawo says – reply to this


    4

    M.A.D.O.N.N.A 8)

  5. mlington says – reply to this


    5

    madonna all the way. she did it first in 1990 EPIC VMA omg i remember that. so freaking cool. Moadnna is amazing. we will never have an artist like her!!!!

  6. mlington says – reply to this


    6

    i would love to see them together. M fans love Bey too. Re: dangerwilrobinson – no madonna never claimed that… but re invents herself. mdna was clearly a re invention time. she told her story on her tour. was epic theatrical. GENIUS. but with other vision. thats why amdonna is so great. and M here was marie antoniette

  7. Cannon says – reply to this


    7

    Madonna will always be more talented and beautiful, no matter how much older she is.someone is messing up your voting, beyonce freaks are reclicking it, for god sakes you just put up the pole, there is no way 1400 have visited in the last 5 minutes.

  8. Angelo says – reply to this


    8

    Maddona is a legend rules the world…Bey did a good job but did not come close the show Madonna put on at the Bowl. Yes she has done over but it is with a new twist when you have been at the top of your game and made it for 30 years somethings may seem to be repeated but there are only so many things that she can do she is human. There is nothing that compares to the legend of the one and Only Madonna! she is the Queen and no one compares to the queen! Don't be haters!!!

  9. mlington says – reply to this


    9

    Maodnna is a genius

  10. Angelo says – reply to this


    10

    Re: Cannon – you are so correct Madonna will alwasy be beautiful, and the best and nothing or not one comes close…Madonna is #1. Thank you for your comments….

  11. ASIANS CAN READ MINDS! says – reply to this


    11

    ASIANS CAN ACTUALLY READ MINDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    they can hear, and see what your visually thinking
    this is the absolute complete truth!!!!!
    .
    The reason a lot of Asians have completely expressionless faces, segregate from everybody else-only associate with Asians and don't associate with non Asians that much, are very untalkative, and are very unfriendly in general is to avoid accidentally revealing that they can read minds by accidentally showing a facial expression or dirty look when someone thinks, or visually pictures something in their mind they don't like, find astonishing, or funny etc because those people might see that and really wonder what that was that just happened there and see the connection, and they might accidentally say something similar to what the person was just thinking and going to say. If they all associated with non Asians a lot more then there would be a lot more people around for them to accidentally show facial expressions when those people think things they don't like etc, so they segregate and only associate with Asians so there won't be anyone around for them to see that and have any accidents happen in the first place.
    .
    Try thinking, best yet visually picturing in your mind something absolutely wild as you possibly can when you are around Asians, and try looking for Asians who give people particular looks, especially dirty looks for what appears to be for completely no reason.
    .
    PLEASE SPREAD THE MESSAGE!!!!!!!



  12. 12

    Look at the eyes. Madonna's eyes are intense - Beyonce's, as usual, are blank.

  13. mlington says – reply to this


    13

    since the first day, all the photogaphers said madonna has an intensive eyes. shows her personality. strong, powerfull



  14. 14

    is that a joke? beeonça was shaking her hair like an indian from a tribe the whole time…. joke!!!

  15. Royalty says – reply to this


    15

    Obviously QUEEN B! She looks like a real queen. Her picture is so classy, Madonna looks old and ugly.

  16. mlington says – reply to this


    16

    Re: Royalty – old? i wanna see if beyonce will be like madonna at her age. everybody gets old. but some of them do it with style. Madonna is a genius, a hardworker… age means nothing. just go to her show and u will see

  17. Amelia says – reply to this


    17

    Perez honey don't even go there the world knows that BEYONCE snatched madonnas entire wig! Madonna is Queen, and Beyonce is next in line.

  18. LAME says – reply to this


    18

    Slow traffic Perez????

  19. Michael says – reply to this


    19

    Madonna is old and GROSS. She has never been beautiful and can't sing live to save herself. When she sings live it is painful and always off key. Beyonce is beautiful and CAN sing. Madonna is a legend only to her fans, the rest of us could not care less what she does and do not think of her as a legend.



  20. 20

    Beyonce wins. It would have been better if Madonna was in a standing pose and I could see her outfit. Beyonce wins because I can see her overall look.

  21. @v@ says – reply to this


    21

    Madge had a superior set, staging and costuming, and Bey had superior singing and dance.

  22. Monster says – reply to this


    22

    F———-R———–A———U———D———Y——0———N——-C——-E :D

  23. BEYWANCE says – reply to this


    23

    MADONNA QUEEN OF SUPERBOWL…….. !!!!!!!!!

  24. Truth tea says – reply to this


    24

    Beyonce..fake nose, fake breast…fake hair color…fake live performance :(

  25. Ririfan says – reply to this


    25

    Madonna- the best sellling female artist of all time. Bey who????

  26. GAGALOO says – reply to this


    26

    If it was Lady Gaga doing the Queen theme - Perez would have written something like: "LOOK AT COPYCAT GAGA!!" but now when it's Beyonce… not going there… shady shady

  27. R I P says – reply to this


    27

    Beyonce————————–> Janet —————> Grace Jones ! :D

  28. Sit Down says – reply to this


    28

    MADONNA- The highest selling tour for a solo artist…in the universe.

  29. YOLO says – reply to this


    29

    Even Beyonce 's daughter is fake. :(



  30. 30

    Madonna put on a better show, and Beyonce put on a better performance. Like, Madonna's was so cool and full of great performers.

    Beyonce, vocally, was fabulous. She, herself, did fabulously. But besides that, it was good!

    They both did amazingly in their respective areas!

  31. Osh Şarif says – reply to this


    31

    M A D O N N A <3

  32. JuPe says – reply to this


    32

    Beyonce did not break Madonna's Super Bowl 2012 record… Hahahahhaahahahahahaa

  33. mlington says – reply to this


    33

    but gaga is a copycat… bey isnt… and madonna is epic

  34. K Bye says – reply to this


    34

    Beyonce——————–> Ciara————————-> Fantasia Barrino :D

  35. Dion Robert says – reply to this


    35

    Madonna

  36. K Fixed says – reply to this


    36

    Beyonce———————-> Brandy———————> Paula Abdul :8

  37. Angelo says – reply to this


    37

    Re: trinigirl123 – let me tell you TRIN…I met her in person one time when she first started at her fist show and she looked amazing….and is still beautiful…wait until BEY gets older and some other young celebs everyone thinks is better…younger is not better….! There is grace, wisdom, elegance, strength, coming into your own and you will not understand until you are older. Modonn is and always will be the original Queen and don't forget it…! don't be rude stop hating!!!!! I thought there was all this talk about bullys what are you doing not putting down Bey…just saying she hits people with her hair big deal…entertain me like Madonna the real gorgeous beauty timeless that will live on forever!!!! MADONNA RULES!!

  38. FUGLY MUCH says – reply to this


    38

    PEREZ HILTON————————> ELTON JOHN———————-> PUBLIC TOILET :(

  39. Lady says – reply to this


    39

    Re: mlington

    Hey the RESULTS ARE WRONGGGG!! When you click on Madonna, the results appear backwards as if Beyonce is winning, when in fact its Madonna.

  40. VOTE NOW !!!! says – reply to this


    40

    Who is uglier?

    a) Perez Hilton
    b) Elton John
    c) Lady Gaga
    d) all of the above

  41. For Morons says – reply to this


    41

    What a f*cking stupid website……..such as waste of time !!!!!!!!!!



  42. 42

    Bouncie is MAGIC! Bouncie's voice was coming out of the speakers when she was holding the microphone at her side! She is magic!!! If it was a stomping contest Bouncie would win. I'm surprised she didn't cause an earthquake with those thunder thighs.

  43. Luis says – reply to this


    43

    I love Beyonce , but to be honest Madonna dit it faaaar better :) There is only one queen and that's Madonna Perez

  44. Patrick says – reply to this


    44

    THERE IS ONLY ONE QUEEN.
    AND THIS IS MADONNA, BITCHs!
    R.STone has said: MADONNA

  45. ALF says – reply to this


    45

    MADONNA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  46. Beyonce says – reply to this


    46

    Run the World like Lady GaGa! #SuperBowl2014

  47. SAMSAH says – reply to this


    47

    As usual Madonna did it first…this was the advert for her Re-invention tour……….the rest just follow………….

  48. JAPANERA says – reply to this


    48

    Well, Madonna is a legend while Beyonce is all fierce , all the day , ferociously fierce! They are all great individually! Nothing to compare

  49. LA GIRL says – reply to this


    49

    NO COMPARISON.. Beyonce was off the hook. It was pretty much a Beyonce Concert with a Football playing at break. haha

  50. zou zou says – reply to this


    50

    BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE

  51. ANGEL says – reply to this


    51

    BEYONCE OF COURSE ……LOL SO MANY MADONNA FANS ON HERE TRYING TO PROVE A POINT …LOL BEYONCE FANS REALLY DONT NEED TO FLOOD THE COMMENTS BECAUSE ITS OBVIOUS THAT BEYONCE IS THE WINNER ! IT'S SAD THAT SOME PEOPLE CANT ACCEPT THE NEW GENERATION QUEEN B ….SIGH !

  52. JOSH says – reply to this


    52

    MADONNA IS A MUMMY

  53. JAMES says – reply to this


    53

    MADONNA NEED TO HAVE A SEAT ….IM NOT EVEN A BEYONCE FAN ..BUT CLEARLY SHES THE NEW QUEEN B …FACTS PROVE IT

  54. W.SUMMERS says – reply to this


    54

    Madonna's performance was a joke ….M.i.a ruined her performance ..aaaahhh too bad …not to mention that horrible single she tried to make work but couldn't if her life depended on it lol…..her album suffered even with "114 million people" watching hhmmmmm thats weird .

  55. TeaShopMuse says – reply to this


    55

    Madonna is God. There is no comparison between Madge and BeYAWNce.

  56. june carly says – reply to this


    56

    Madonna couldn't pull her own weight ….had Lmfao ,Ceel lo ,Nicki Minaj AND M.i.a ???? While Beyonce didn't need all these names attached to her halftime show so of course more viewers watched Madonna's because it was more artists on the bill and they're fans watching as well duh…. Beyonce is still the queen and pulled her own weight with a few minutes of Destinys child :) that's all !!!!!!!!!!

  57. kelly says – reply to this


    57
  58. MAGIKKKK says – reply to this


    58

    Beyonce of course :)

  59. afd says – reply to this


    59

    the original is always best



  60. 60

    M.A.D.O.N.N.A. shes the FUCKING QUEEN OF THE WORLD!!

  61. FIXED says – reply to this


    61

    Beyonce was a joke of a stripper club performer :(

  62. truth says – reply to this


    62

    Madonna show was far more eventful entertaining and artistic and Madonna is better performer and artist musician song writer and much more creative..with a hell lot more input and hands on and creative control at what ever she dose… Beyonce is more a vocalist and diva super model her show was boring and uneventful and lack any real artistic message or vision..she did the same as s shaking in ur face routing and clumsy fast paced samples of her songs together it felt so rushed that u could not get into the songs..its like watching a fast paced interpersonal informercial of her songs

  63. David P says – reply to this


    63

    There's only one Queen and that's MADONNA

  64. Van Troy says – reply to this


    64

    When I cast my vote for Madonna, the results switch and puts Beyonce on top, what did u do Perez, I know you love both, don't be shady!!

  65. donnie g. says – reply to this


    65

    one word ……B.E.Y.O.N.C.E

  66. QUEEN KING says – reply to this


    66

    madonna is an old lady gaga

  67. real talk says – reply to this


    67

    Madonna : the queen of non singing and switching personality's over the years

  68. WTF says – reply to this


    68

    Re: Angelo – MADONNA CAN BARELY DANCE ….MORE LIKE YOGA PRACTICE

  69. BIZ says – reply to this


    69

    THE QUEEN OF FUCKING HERSELF TO THE TOP

  70. b. says – reply to this


    70

    Re: mlington – THIS IS 2013 NOT …….1990 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  71. jon says – reply to this


    71

    the warrior super hero performer mother wife sister daughter king and queen of show business = Beyonce !

  72. b.m.w says – reply to this


    72

    madonna is a bag of gay tranny bones

  73. bitch says – reply to this


    73

    Re: David P – Madonna is 54 years old and Beyonce is 31 and her third time doing the super bowl….so it really doesn't matter

  74. LOVE KING says – reply to this


    74

    MADONNA HAS A DUSTY COBWEB VAGINA AND ALL OF HER DANCERS HAVE BEEN INSIDE HER ……WHAT A GRANNY WHORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  75. G says – reply to this


    75

    MADONNA IS SOOOOOOOO UNPROFESSIONAL …..SLEEPS WITH HER DANCERS AND DISRESPECTS LADY GAGA PUBLICLY ON HER WORLD TOUR INTERVIEWS ETC ….LIKE WTF SHE IS TOO OLD TO BE ACTIN LIKE A HIGH SCHOOL CHEERLEADER ….BEYONCE WOULD NERVER !

  76. @v@ says – reply to this


    76

    Wish to add that Madonna singing was great…but Bey was on fire, and I lean toward soul.

  77. CAMMY says – reply to this


    77

    MADONNA TOOK 30 YEARS TO DO HER HALF TIME SHOW AND AND HAD CIRC DU SOLEIL, CEE LO, NICKI MINAJ. M.I.A, LMFAO, AND A CHOIR !

    BEYONCE HAD HER GROUP AND NOBODY ELSE TO HELP HER GIVE A SHOW… SO YOU DO THE MATH ….BEYONCE WINS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  78. BEVERLY says – reply to this


    78

    THIS IS VERY TRUE !!!!!!!!!!

    MADONNA TOOK 30 YEARS TO DO HER HALF TIME SHOW AND AND HAD CIRC DU SOLEIL, CEE LO, NICKI MINAJ. M.I.A, LMFAO, AND A CHOIR !

    BEYONCE HAD HER GROUP AND NOBODY ELSE TO HELP HER GIVE A SHOW… SO YOU DO THE MATH ….BEYONCE WINS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  79. BEYONCE says – reply to this


    79

    Re: @v@ – YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS BEYONCE

  80. KING B says – reply to this


    80

    Re: Patrick – YOU DONT LOVE BEYONCE ….SHUT UP YOU LIAR !

  81. BEYONCE MUGLER says – reply to this


    81

    HAHAHAHAHA SO TRUE ……..

    MADONNA TOOK 30 YEARS TO DO HER HALF TIME SHOW AND AND HAD CIRC DU SOLEIL, CEE LO, NICKI MINAJ. M.I.A, LMFAO, AND A CHOIR !

    BEYONCE HAD HER GROUP AND NOBODY ELSE TO HELP HER GIVE A SHOW… SO YOU DO THE MATH ….BEYONCE WINS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  82. BBBBBB says – reply to this


    82

    BEYONCE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  83. FUCK MADONNA says – reply to this


    83

    BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE

  84. ANGELS says – reply to this


    84

    Beyonce the beauty …..who is Madonna ??? oh yeah that old lady from the 80's and 90s ? hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

  85. blove says – reply to this


    85

    BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE BEYONCE

  86. OBAMA says – reply to this


    86

    THE BEST BEYONCE JOKE 2013 - "I SUNG LIVE" :D

  87. Gynna Kuntoria says – reply to this


    87

    Bey Toilet Bowl Halftime 2013 performance/ratings …as low as Black Eyed Peas. She and Fergie should duet soon….. lol

  88. Close Coffin says – reply to this


    88

    Beyonce—-> Janet——–> Fantasia Barrino

    *RIP*

  89. Yeah Right says – reply to this


    89

    Horrible show and why would anyone pay to watch the same songs and dance moves from 7 years ago from Fraudyonce?

    Just put her big bu++ on a pole and call it a stripper party. :(

  90. Tatayanna says – reply to this


    90

    Big legs, no class. That's Beyonce. :(

  91. Lamb says – reply to this


    91

    Madonna of course. Beyonce is the same level as Ciara and Nicki Minaj. She looked like a jobless stripper in the stadium.

  92. Fraud Lipped says – reply to this


    92

    Re: Tatayanna

    BEYONCE IS THE BIGGEST LIAR OF 2013 !!!!!!!!!!

  93. Bye Forever says – reply to this


    93

    Beyonce Super Bowl.. No classier than the Janet wardrobe malfunction. Hope you will retire soon.

  94. Sofeuh says – reply to this


    94

    Srsly? No comparison Madonna is Queen ..everyone else duplicates what Madonna originates.

  95. Tanisha says – reply to this


    95

    Re: Bye Forever

    Stupid hoes keep ruining the Half Time. Shame on them..



  96. 96

    Re: Angelo – Okay le me tell you somethin, I don't know what you're trying to say right now. I figure you're either drunk, high, or bi polar. But I was on here defending Madonna last year when all you bitches were saying she was too old and needed to stop. I am a fan and have never put her down. Now that she's up against Beyonce, you Mofos are kissing her ass and calling her the queen. I love them BOTH and I gave my honest opinion on the two posters. It's all about the poster and the poster only. Madonna's poster here, reminds me of the piece of art work where a celebrity was giving birth in the same position. Beyonce rocks it. HER POSTER IS BETTER. The votes yesterday says she is, the votes today says she is. WHAT?! Love her or not, you all know that's not a great pose. You have to bring up other stuff about her concert and this and that and blah blah blah blah because you know Bey damn well rocked it. And as a woman Miss/Mr thang, I will never put down another woman when it comes to age. Because I'll be rocking it Madonna/Beyonce style when I'm 90 BIIIIITCH!!!!

  97. Bubba Joe says – reply to this


    97

    Re: trinigirl123

    Beyonce is just a high priced studio singer with a stripper skill trying to sing! Without those hologram and pyrotechnique effect..she is nothing.

  98. Marsha Londoh says – reply to this


    98

    I used to hate Madonna but she wins. Beyonce was awful. Waste of time and money. How many times can you gyrate and throw your boobs around? Boring as fcuk :(

  99. Joe says – reply to this


    99

    Beyonce is a great entertainer, but Madonna is the Queen of Pop - no one can really ever top that.

  100. NoNoNoNo says – reply to this


    100

    Re: Joe

    I simply choose Madonna because she very sensitive towards her Super Bowl audiences.
    You can shake your booty 100 times but if you dont "know" your audience and behave like a 2nd class stripper from Vegas nightclub..it shows you are simply lack of IQ just like Beyonce.

More comments: [1] 2 »