And the truth is finally REVEALED!!!
[Image via Kylie Jenner/Instagram.]
Jen and her studly fiance Justin Theroux were enjoying a friendly dinner with Drew Barrymore and Chelsea Handler at West Hollywood's Sunset Towers on Wednesday when none other than her estranged ex, John, walked in!
Fortunately the place was JUST big enough to seat John and his friend two tables away so they wouldn't have to interact with one another beyond making some uneasy eye contact.
In regard to their failed relationship, a source spilled:
"[John and Jen] weren't right for each other, but he is really a good guy. It really took him a long time to get over her. He really loved her a lot."
Well, duh! How can you NOT fall in love with Jen?!
You'd think they'd be over it 4 years later and would be able to at least exchange small talk, especially considering we ALL know Hollywood is a VERY small town.
Guess a broken heart can NEVER be truly mended!
[Image via WENN.]