Well, nobody saw this coming!
Well... it's who he left the club with that's causing a stir:
We just knew these two couldn't stay away from each other!
Well, it looks like he couldn't because the two were spotted TOGETHER - not just at the same place - during a night out in New York City!
John might have shown up at the Friars Foundation Annual Applause Awards Gala honoring Don Rickles alone, but our Katy Kat apparently secretly joined him during the night…
…and then…they left together!
And we must say, we've got a pretty good idea why John can't stay away from the sexalicious singer because she was looking like a dream in a satiny peach gown that hugged every curve just right!
"When John performed, Katy was enamored by his performance. He sang One for My Baby (and One More for the Road). When they were sitting down, she had her arm around John at one point. They shared kisses."
Round 3 is sounding pretty seksi!
Maybe they actually break up all the time because the making up is SO MUCH FUN!
[Image via FayesVision/WENN.]