Home Videos Photos Shop
PerezHilton CocoPerez Khloe K. Selena G. Kim K. Teen Mom PerezTV

Alexander Skarsgard Vs. Jamie Dornan: Who Will Dominate Producers' Pick For New Fifty Shades Of Grey Lead!?

| Filed under: Film FlickersBusiness BlitzAlexander Skarsgård50 Shades Of GreyOnce Upon A Time

fifty shades of grey alexander skarsgard jamie dornan

Here's an idea — hire 'em both!

Nothing like a lil' orgy to really up the sex bar! LOLz!!

Yes, friends, it seems as though our and your fantasies of Ian Somerhalder filling in the Fifty Shades of Grey bed that Charlie Hunnam left cold may never come to fruition.

Instead, we're now hearing two sexy gents are leading the producers' pack of desirable replacements: Alexander Skarsgard and Jamie Dornan.

We all know Alexander and his peen from True Blood. The hotness scale breaks past 10 every time he's around, so obviously we wouldn't mind him cuffing the coveted role!

But Jamie Dornan wouldn't be so bad, either! The former Once Upon A Time stud gave us chills every time he went to action in the fairytale series. Surely the same can be said of a hyper-sexualized film. ;)

Other hunks said to be among the running in producers' discussions are former contenders Theo James and Christian Cooke.

Out of these reported hopefuls, we wanna know who U vote for! Sound off in the comments (below)!!!

[Image via WENN.]

Tags: , , , , ,

Best Celebrity Movie Couples (Who Never Dated IRL)!
Stars Who Have Spoken Out About Working With Woody Allen!
Movies That Actually SHOULD Get Remade & Somehow Haven't Yet!
The Most Tragic Love Stories In TV/Film!
10 Horror Movies Netflix Says Are Too Scary To Finish!
Ripoff Artists! Stars Accused Of Plagiarism!

63 comments to “Alexander Skarsgard Vs. Jamie Dornan: Who Will Dominate Producers' Pick For New Fifty Shades Of Grey Lead!?”

  1. Brigitta says – reply to this



  2. Alessandra says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard <3

  3. 3

    As much as I like seeing Alexander getting his kit off, I think with how much of a joke these books were he could get himself a bad rep. I see the movie being a massive flop, but that's just me.

  4. Stepy67 says – reply to this


    ive said from the beginning it should be skarsgaard. he's perfect for this. i actually pictured him while i read the books.

  5. Lily says – reply to this


    Well I think since Charlie is not going to be Christian Grey that maybe Taylor Kinney is a very good choice ;)

  6. Hipsta Please says – reply to this


    lol is it a joke

    is there ANYBODY who will be against Skarsgard???

  7. Future says – reply to this


    Any of the above, but my first pick would be Alexander Skarsgard. He could definitely pull it off and I think that with his Swedish coolness he would be able to not make it too, how to say, porn-ish maybe…

  8. 8

    Alexander is way too old and frankly, not good looking enough for Christian Grey. Ian Sommerhalder, matt bomer or Henry Cavill are much better choices. Christian is supposed to be gorgeous!

  9. True Blood Alexander says – reply to this


    Alexander all the way baby! He is so hot and in a controlling dominating role much like our coveted Eric! How could you go wrong? You can't go wrong - Alexander is perfect! Stop looking at the others, of course unless he doesn't want to do it.

  10. Molly says – reply to this


    Sullivan Stapleton should be cast as Grey!

  11. fid says – reply to this


    So people have to endure another 9 months of "which celeb will win the covetted role" only to have them either decline the offer a month later with some lame schedule conflict excuse. No one wants to be a part of this project that already has a career in the industry.

  12. Robin says – reply to this


    Re: lalalla – a joke? a flop? This series of books were some of the most shared, talked about and sold books in over a decade! I would guess the movie will not be a flop, this is the best thing that could happen to him as far as breaking out from playing Eric, his other films have been massive flops!

  13. Laurel says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard is too good for this shit role. I really hope that he is smart enough not to ruin his career. Bleh.

  14. Elean says – reply to this


    Re: fid – So, we are just ignoring the fact that he very publicly said he would love to play the role a year ago?

  15. cati says – reply to this


    Is this a joke ?? I mean did anyone even read the bookS.. Neither would fit, they would ruin Christian. HOWEVER, they're both gorgeous men and great actors. I think Charlie would have killed it.. I just think we need someone that doesn't have Major fame to come in.. You see these guys and it's hard to separate the other work they've done and imagine them being Grey. Maybe that's just me.. If not Charlie, an unknown actor.

  16. JJ says – reply to this


    People get a grip! Christian's looks are really how you perceive the written word! Your given the description in the book and your mind forms the picture. He can be anyone you want him to be! Alexander would be fine! He's a formidable figure, but I also see any of the others as well. The books were poorly written. No argument there but it was what was beyond the poor grammar and sentence fragments! People it was the non verbalized fantasy of millions of women around the world that made that series of books skyrocket to the number 1 spot on so many lists! It gave us closet freaks a voice! I think the movie will do well. Look at Magic Mike. Story line sucked in that but the eye candy sent it soaring!

  17. 17

    At this point…who gives a crap? This casting has become ridiculous. What happened to the good old days when watching a movie meant seeing a preview commercial on TV to find out what actor/actresses are playing in a movie. Since when did it become reality casting? Real people casting movie actors in roles? Seriously people, unless you are getting paid to cast these actors, stay out of it and wait to see the movie when it comes out. I get all the hype around it, as I too am one of the millions of women who read these books, and I too fantasized about a person or two in the role…as a matter of fact, I fantasized myself in Anastasia's role…does that mean I have the right to throw myself into the casting? I was just fine with Charlie Hunnam in the role as Christian Grey, but you idiots out there (you know who you are), had to go and ruin it and make the guy back out. So from this point on who gives a crap. Whoever they pick will cause a media storm and sooner or later we will hear that the movie will not be made. If I were EL James, the director, casting agent, producers etc…I would keep in under wraps and let the world find out who Christian Grey is closer to the premier date. If turnout is what the movie people here are looking for, I doubt they will be dissatisfied any which way they do it.

  18. Livy says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard is walking sex!! Nuff said. >.<

  19. lisa says – reply to this


    Jamie Dornan!!!!!!

  20. lisa says – reply to this


    Jamie Dornan !!!

  21. Christine says – reply to this


    OMG Alexander Skarsgard all the way..No contest there

  22. Paris says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard has the looks AND the ability to play the mentally tormented character. just look at vampire Eric. Case closed.

  23. Kim says – reply to this


    Alexander can definitely pull off the suite and the red room look.

  24. Sam Jones says – reply to this



  25. Sam Jones says – reply to this



  26. Sam Jones says – reply to this



  27. Hannah says – reply to this


    They should go with Alexander. He isnt afraid to get nude and is perfect for the role, if he buffs up a bit and dyes his hair? Perfection. Ian still would be my top choice

  28. HotMessInAWalmartDress says – reply to this


    Jamie Dornan would be good!

  29. Emma says – reply to this


    If you've seen Alexander as the tormented hunk Johan in 'Vingar av glas'(*Wings of glass') you agree he would be perfect as Christian Grey! Perfect!!! Have known it since I first picked up the the 1st book

  30. opinionatrix says – reply to this


    Jamie Dornan was crazy intense in The Fall with Gillian Anderson - great actor. If he can make that character the least bit sympathetic he can do anything!!

  31. Ali says – reply to this



  32. d says – reply to this


    Alex of course. The other one looks like Pacey from Dawsons Creek, looks like a kid. He sure as hell does not give off any dom vibes lololol

  33. loveitalldaynight24 says – reply to this


    Jamie Dornan, why would you not chose anyone else. He is a beautiful man, and would make a great Christian Grey.

  34. Emma says – reply to this


    This must be a joke! None of these actors resemble the literary character. He was so specifically described that it would be a tragedy to cast an actor that looks nothing like him. Was James envisioning one thing and writing another? I'm so over this. It's ridiculous. No actor wants to do this movie. They should just cast a fame hungry unknown at this point. or scrap the project altogether.

  35. gatagorda says – reply to this


    James Scott, who plays EJ on Days of our Lives, would be great. Looks the part and has the intent reserve needed.

  36. 36

    I vote for Dornan. And who play the girl?

  37. henetn says – reply to this


    alexander scarsgard

  38. Julie says – reply to this


    Def Alexander Skarsgard. I was picturing him at Christian Grey while I was reading the books (WAY before talk of a movie).

  39. 39

    Those are two of the ugliest photographs of both actors. Why not actually use GOOD pictures. There are so many online. go to msn, type one's name in, and click on "images".

  40. 40

    Alexander S. has played very dominate AND very submissive characters. On True Blood, he played an alpa-male with a sex chamber and in the movie Melancholia, he played a submissive husband to a majorly depressed Kirsten Dunst (great movie, by the way). He knows both perspectives.

  41. Laura says – reply to this



  42. Sasha says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard pleaseeee!!!!!!

  43. Rumey Skarsgard says – reply to this



  44. otta says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard

  45. Jannie says – reply to this


    While I think ALexander Sharsgard is the hottest thing to hit the planet and has the acting chops to pull off the role, I'd hate for this project to taint his reputation.

  46. Marleneemm says – reply to this


    I'm older than most of you~ I'm 59.
    When I was a teenager,there was a book by Jacquline Susann, called "The Love Machine"
    now it was 1969's "Fifty Shades of Grey"~ I've just begun to reread this last night and beleive me 'Christian Grey's story) has been told before in that book!!!
    When I first began hearing about "FOSG" I immediately thought of "The Love Machine"
    The main character was a guy named "Robin Stone" and he was exactly like
    Christian Grey~ tall,dark,handsome,loved ice cold Vokda,kinky sex & WOMEN.
    He was played by the late actor John Phillip Law of "Barberella" fame
    Never thought of Ian Somerhalder,or any of the others mentioned.
    ONLY actor I thought about was ALEXANDER SKARSGARD!!!
    He's perfect for the role!!!!!
    The more of us who get the word out about him becoming "Christian Grey"
    the better~ give you opioion,write EL JAMES,write the director.
    DO ANYTHING YOU CAN THINK OF~ but let's get him hired as Christian!!

  47. Grace says – reply to this


    Oh it has to be Alexander Skarsgard, if anyone saw him in True Blood you would realize he can play any emotion besides looking sexy, tall and drop dead gorgeous and fits the description of Christian to a tee….

  48. gracie says – reply to this


    Re: Paris – you are so right, no one else can play that part better than Alex

  49. lmc1971 says – reply to this


    Jamie Dornan would be brilliant! I've read the books and as soon as I saw he was in the running to play Christian, I thought "Perfect"! He's done a British television thriller recently called The Fall (with Gillian Anderson) and he is amazing, very intense…he plays a serial killer and it's a great show. Check it out and tell me if you don't agree he has the chops to take on this role…

  50. Amber says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard was truly meant for this role!!! Hands down! I hope that he is in a position to accept the role IF they actually offered to him, and that he truly wants to do it. He is Christian Grey. Anyone who has read the books and watches True Blood knows what I am talking about.

  51. Angelika says – reply to this


    Alexander Skaarsgard! He would be the only way I would go see this movie. I haven't read the books and do not plan on seeing the movie unless he is cast as Christian Grey!

  52. ITBARBEE says – reply to this


    I agree - I have said from the beginning it should be Skarsgaard. He's perfect for the role of Christian Grey. I actually pictured him while I read the books. He has the looks, demeanor and can actually act. He is very sophisticated and very debonair!

  53. Shaylei says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgård all the way!!! When I first read the 50 Shades trilogy, and every time after, my mind automatically put him in as Christian. He is perfect for the part! He was born for the role. Just a very strong opinion from a loyal Skars-girl! ;) <3

  54. Ashleigh says – reply to this



  55. C says – reply to this


    Tom Welling. I know, he was too good as Kent Clark, but he is a little older now, and there is still something quite mysterious about him.

    Skarsgard is too old.

  56. Per says – reply to this


    Seriously? Am I the only person that thinks Alexander Skarsgard would be HORRIBLE for this role? He looks NOTHING like what was described in the book. I don't really care how good he is in the show he's on.

    To be honest, I think it was a horrible mistake for them to give a release date before the movie had even been cast. At this point, the movie will never be made. I think the best thing for them to do is just cast the movie with people no one knows, don't tell anyone and just be like, "Oh, we made the movie, here's the preview.". They aren't going to be able to make people happy no matter what they do.

  57. Genna says – reply to this


    As many have said, you can picture Alexander in the role. If you don't have HBO then you can't imagine how sexy he is in True Blood. If he doesn't get the part They won't get my money to see the film.

  58. ness says – reply to this


    I prefer Jamie Dornan, I could definitely see him as Christian Grey. He is pretty cute.

  59. Nikki says – reply to this


    Alexander Skarsgard is my pick!!!!

  60. KAnn says – reply to this


    Ya know, a lot are anticipating for this film to be a real flop. HOWEVER, with the right writing, acting and actors, it could be a real HIT. This movie wont sell with "D" list celebs like Jamie Dornan — I mean c'mon, they already cast Dakota Johnson (Who the fk is that). I'm not saying she isn't going to bring something great to the table, I'm just saying I - a long with MANY MANY others - have never even heard that name. When I found out Fifty was going to the big screen, I assumed they would have some real A List hotties in it. SKARSGARD is by FAR the most PERFECT Christian Grey. Hello, have you seen his intensity in True Blood and Straw Dogs! He is what would sell this movie and not make it a flop. Hell, the man has said himself he was born for the Christian Grey role! SO, EL James, if you are scavenging the internet to get public opinion — ASKARS is the only way to go with Grey! Otherwise, you're looking at an epic fail.

  61. nessa says – reply to this


    lols. Really Scarsgard ??? He looks nothing like Christian. I vote Jaime!! He looks very cute and he also has a bad boy quality to his looks. Very hot!!!

  62. JulesFromBrazil says – reply to this


    I'm rooting for JAMIE!!! JAMIE DORNAN ALL THE WAY!!! :)

  63. Tamara says – reply to this


    I Think Alexander was the best Choice of the two !