Unfortunately for Nick, the fans wanted to see him chug!
Although, Nick managed to make slime look good!
Watch him chug (above) and get slimed (below)!
"Nobody's done this before, because it's stupid!"
This may be the first time in the history of TV that a host has had to interview his ex! Talk about awkward!
But you have to hand it to Jimmy and Sarah, who handled it with their famous humor and- no, you know what? It was still totes awkward!
Not only did Sarah bring her A-game (gurl is FLAUNTING those "big naturals" in that little black dress!), she also brought a box of Jimmy's old stuff!