Home Videos Photos

Kelly Clarkson Vs. Carrie Underwood In My Favorite Things! Which Country Cutie Sang It Better!? VOTE!

| Filed under: Kelly ClarksonMusic MinutePollsCarrie UnderwoodHolidaze

kelly carrie favorite things

It's a battle royal of Fräulein Maria's, y'all!

Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood both debuted their own ferosh versions of the Sound Of Music classic, My Favorite Things, in 2013!

Naturally, we've decided to compare the two renditions and put it to a vote - to see which female's "cream color ponies" reign supreme!

Viewers can remember Carrie's classic version featuring Audra McDonald during NBC's The Sound of Music LIVE!, while Kelly's delicious belt was placed on her own holiday special, Kelly Clarkson's Cautionary Christmas Tale!

Looks like the hills are alive with badass competition!

Whose version of My Favorite Things is your musical fav?

View Results

Whose version of My Favorite Things is your musical fav?

  • Carrie Underwood (29%)
  • Kelly Clarkson (71%)

Total Votes: 7,510

Loading ... Loading …

Ch-ch-check out both AH-Mazing performances head-to-head…AFTER THE JUMP!!!

[Image via NBC/Kelly Clarkson]

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Welcome back, !
or logout

Or, login or create a Perez Posse account!

27 comments to “Kelly Clarkson Vs. Carrie Underwood In My Favorite Things! Which Country Cutie Sang It Better!? VOTE!”



  1. 1

    I like Kelly's by far.

  2. Moi says – reply to this


    2

    I know she didn't sing it in 2013 but where is the Julie Andrews option? She is the only one who can sing it right and with heart.

  3. Makka says – reply to this


    3

    I like Carrie's version better, Kelly's is too far from the original and I don't like those crazy pitch variation thingies.

  4. Jen says – reply to this


    4

    Kelly. She's great.

  5. Vicki says – reply to this


    5

    C'mon..two different versions. One pure singing live with the actual arrangement. One having jazzy fun with a creative arrangement. Both are great in their two elements. Not one is better than the other.

  6. Mike says – reply to this


    6

    Only one "country cutie" sang the song. The other one is a fatass home wrecker pop singer.

  7. archibald says – reply to this


    7

    Kelly drags Carrie through the mud. There is such a gap between the talent of each it isn't even fair. KELLY FOR THE WIN!

  8. Melissa says – reply to this


    8

    Carrie sang it in the traditional way, while Kelly had some more liberties with the arrangement of the song. Both versions are completely different, and I honestly don't even know where to start trying to compare the two.

  9. James says – reply to this


    9

    Kelly Kelly Kelly

  10. Marcus says – reply to this


    10

    Re: Moi – I'm so sick of even hearing the name Julie Andrews. Even Julie Andrews said it was time for someone else to give it a go, so get over it. Plus, Julie Andrews had throat surgery a few years ago the ruined her vocal cords.

  11. MIckey says – reply to this


    11

    Carrie for the WIN. Kelly's version is hideous.

  12. Leo says – reply to this


    12

    Why is it that every time Carrie sings a song, Kelly does the same song and then we have the "who did it better" debate. Kelly was a bitch for doing a SOM song when the hoar knew Carrie would be doing those songs. That SOM song was totally out of place in Kelly's Christmas show. Which by the way, SUCKED. I think Kelly has gained about 100 pounds since she got married, pretty soon she will be fatter than the fat Judd and her husband will dump her and her kid just like he did his first wife and kids.

  13. lamchop says – reply to this


    13

    Carrie by a mile. While I commend Kelly for making it her own, I really don't like the jazzy blues version of it.

  14. Shelby says – reply to this


    14

    Re: Leo – Wow Leo, not only are you tone deaf but you have a mean bitter streak don't you. Kelly sings it the best.

  15. Dan says – reply to this


    15

    CARRIE UNDERWOOD most definitely!

  16. Ninjalillly says – reply to this


    16

    Kelly's version is the one I would listen to over and over. Carrie did fine, though.

  17. Jess says – reply to this


    17

    CARRIE UNDERWOOOOOOOODDDDD!

    The best.

  18. STEVEN says – reply to this


    18

    IT'S UNFAIR TO PUT CARRIE UNDERWOOD UP AGAINST KELLY CLARKSON. CARRIE IS A PRETTY GOOD ABOVE AVERAGE SINGER ALTHOUGH NASALLY, KELLY CLARKSON IS ONE OF THE BEST SINGERS IN THE WORLD. THERE IS NO COMPARISON. IF THEY BOTH SANG THE TRADITIONAL VERSION OR IF THEY BOTH SANG THE UPBEAT VERSION, KELLY'S WOULD BE BETTER BY A MILE

  19. John says – reply to this


    19

    Carrie Underwood by far.

  20. ROB says – reply to this


    20

    THERE IS NO COMPARISON!!!!!!!!! I love Carrie,voted for her til the end OM IDOL…… But kelly clarksons voice is the best of allll time….Kelly is a mariah or whitney …In fact kellys version of this song is my favorite version ever…HER VOICE IS TREMENDOUS

  21. ROB says – reply to this


    21

    Re: Mike – Get your facts straight, she not a home wrecker .he was single ??clueless………..and to call her fat is ridiculous go call someone in your own family fat ,see if they like it fool

  22. nick says – reply to this


    22

    Re: Leo – you know kelly pregnant and her version came out before carries…. #YouDumbShit



  23. 23

    I think both were good; but by using the classic Julie Andrews Sound of Music performance as a measure, Carrie hit it out of the park. Both Julie and Carrie are lyric sopranos. The main difference is Julie has a very defined "head voice", while Carrie uses her "chest voice" and a throaty approach showing off her country roots. Carrie was able to hit the same notes in the same key as Julie which is an amazing feat for any vocalist IMO.

  24. SallysSmart says – reply to this


    24

    Genesis104, where does it say that Julie Andrews rendition was the measure of comparison? It doesn't say that because this poll isn't about that. Kelly Clarkson is a far far better singer. She is winning this poll by a mile because she deserves to. Her rendition is the best.

  25. truth mcgee says – reply to this


    25

    Re: Mike – That made me laugh, thank you :D



  26. 26

    Kelly Clarkson is so much better than Carrie. Kelly is one of the best vocalists in the world. Carrie's voice is nasally and annoying. K.C. for the WIN every time!!!!!!

  27. Chris says – reply to this


    27

    Re: Leo
    Duuude, somebody has Kelly issues LOL…being that she's one of the most humble and most talented singers out there, I'm sure many of us don't know where this bitch fit came from!^^