Unfortunately for Nick, the fans wanted to see him chug!
Although, Nick managed to make slime look good!
Watch him chug (above) and get slimed (below)!
We say Amy Poehler was the real winner last night! LOLz!
Still, it's definitely not hard to believe that she was the life of the party even amongst such an A-list crowd! LOLz!
What we wouldn't do to fill in for bestie Tina Fey for the night! *SIGH*
[Image via Getty Images.]