Well, we can't say we're surprised!
In an interview with E! News, the Danity Kane alum shared:
And before the Canadian gave the song to the American Idol, she recorded her own version! And now after all these years Avril's original demo has finally hit the 'net!
At first we thought it was an "Avril Fools Day" prank, but it sounds like the real deal to us!
Ch-ch-check out the video (above) to hear what might have been, in some alternate world…