Well, nobody saw this coming!
Well... it's who he left the club with that's causing a stir:
They were spotted having dinner with their mutual friend Chelsea Handler earlier this month, and apparently they hit it off! Could Chelsea have been playing a little matchmaker? An eyewitness said of the initial meeting:
"Chelsea looked like the odd man out - Sandy and Chris were talking and joking with each other for much of the time.
Chelsea kept chiming in and they would include her but there seemed to be a connection between Chris and Sandy."
And that connection is reportedly staying open! A source says:
"They have been talking more than ever and they flirt anytime they spend time together. She's been his dream girl for most of his life, so it would be a fairy-tale ending for Chris."
It's true! He told Details magazine back in 2012 that Sandra was his first celeb crush! He said:
"I saw Speed when I was in seventh grade, and I was like, that's my lady."
Awwww! So cute!
So what's stopping them? Word is that ever since Sandy's rough public split from Jesse James, gurl has had trouble letting herself be vulnerable to a man.
But in this case, we hope she takes the plunge. We mean, this is Captain America we're talking about! If you can't trust him, who can you trust??
Plus, that butt! LOLz!
[Image via Pacific Coast News.]