I don't think it was as horrible as other comments would lead you to believe. I mean come on "sounded like a drowning cat" where do you come up with that. I don't think it was all that great either, but still give her a fair try here.
i love this. shoegaze sound with delicate guitars.. she doesn't have a pop voice, but same goes for women like pj harvey, and they rock. video is beautiful too.
Wow. I was expecting her debut to be incredible and inspire jealousy in me. Maybe it was just the song choice but her voice sounded average to awful. Did I hear David Bowie? Did he help her? Why does everyone love Scarlett so much? She's no Natalie Portman! Natalie sings well, too. Her vocals seemed turned down so low. It was kind of hard to hear her. What I did her just sounded awful. It must be the song choice because I've heard the rumor she's a good singer. This was the wrong song to release first! I was really looking forward to the release. I love Tom Waits. I don't get the supporters on this one. I like weird music but her vocals just aren't good on this one.
It was not that bad of a song, the video is bad but I liked the singing. I think that is Bowie in the back ground. P leave her alone it is better than lots of other shit out there. I would like to hear more off of the album.
I like the song. The video is a bit self-indulgent, but the song is great.
I can see why Perez doesn't like it, though. He seems to be more into POP and this song is anything but. It [the song] would fit in very nicely with the mid-90s alterna-grrrl scene.
Okay, here's the deal. The song would be hot IF she could sing. Her voice isn't good but the song is. The video is boring. She's attractive but not interesting enough to look at for 4 minutes. I still think that she's better than Heidi!!!
i thought it was good. THRILLED that it was original and very unlike the other hollyhoes…video was a bit tedious, but it was appropriate for the tone of the song. you people are idiots…it is a great song…
it's indulgent, and she could have done better, but it isn't as terrible as most here would like to think. if she would have stuck to the simple shots (like the few in black and white) it would do tom waits more justice. however, i'm not sure if she is the one to cover him at all. i'm not sure if anyone should.
It sounds like a bad charoke rendition of the song. As if the guy singing background vocals is the one who actually sings the song and scarlett is drunk in a bar making a fool of herself. The song has the potential to be kind of cute but not with her voice. She is horrible at singing.
I like it. Not necessarily the video but the song and her voice is interesting and very NOt mainstream. She said in an interview regarding the album that it wouldn't be liked by all precisely because it wasn't going to be mainstream but music she liked herself. which is really nice when everything else you listen to on the radio is so cookie cutter. much like tom waits, who i also enjoy when in the mood.
this is so bad i didnt even finish watching it!
lol the random balloon flying.. it looks like a flying banana!!
lol since im a bad singer..
i'm gonna make a song that sucks..
think of all the money ill get!
well, I never thought she would choose tihs music as the first single… she is actually a good singer, you'll see it if you listen to summertime.
but this sucks, it's awful!!
okay, when they had that inflatable waving arm man that's when i stopped watching. it's like a dodgy home produced film clip for youtube. and she doesn't even sing! it's like sing talking. i can sing talk and make a crappy film clip of me getting my makeup done, where's my contract?
Um, wow. The video was embarassingly interesting, but the song was the shit of all shit. That voice.. what can any of us really say about that besides.. shit.
Maybe if she shows her bald beaver and hugh clappers I could stand her singing. I never in the world thought that I would rather lister to Jessica Simpson. Just got some good news from my doctor, I am going deaf.
I kinda loved it. I mean, she's covering Tom Waits (which is fucking awesome) and he sounds like a garbage disposal half the time. Hmm, I definitely loved it.
im horrified. i dont understand why people like lindsay lohan and paris and now scarlett johansson think they can sing. i just dont get it. its so horrible.
well…she can act ! and she's pretty? O GOOD GOD THAT WAS JUST BAD IT WAS BAD I DIDNT THINK IT WOULD EB THAT BAD BUT IT WAS i was trying to find beauty in it but no there is none sry i still like you scarlett
wow, that was hideous. That wasn't even singing, that was just one big montone-y, coma inducing, droning ass nonsense. Aaah, it needs to be about 4 minutes shorter.
I liked it a lot. the vid was compelling and the song was good kind of like a song that you would have on in the background it sounds like a song from a movie. i thought her voice was good for that song obviously you can't really tell if her voice is brilliant or not because the type of singing she does in this song is just like speaking loudly, nearly shouting.
OMG! That was horrible. I usually don't watch the videos but I was curious how bad it was since I don't think she had any talent. Take away her boobs and what do you have. A girl working in a regular job like everyone else. Why bother to create a music video if you do the same thing teh public sees you do everyday? Boring! No talent, no artistic ability- I can't wait until she goes away- or just poses for men magazines and stops trying to be an important actress.
How come no one told her that she doesn't have vocal skills? Her singing reminds me of Sinead O'Connor but Sinead was in key. Recording this track must have been hard for the producer and the very talented back up singers on this track used to mask her vocal ills.
In a weird sense, I feel this song and it's message. I also believe that this song will sound better to people during the winter months when everyone is forced inside and will listen. Remember, just because you look good (sometimes) doesn't mean that you can sing.
I actually dont think this video/song is that bad..the song def aint a party track or nething but im sure we'll hear it on a grey's anatomy episode or another pathetic heidi montag moment on the hills.
Loading...
OMG. I think I just threw up in my mouth…
WHAT THE HELL? ARE YOU SERIOUS??THIS HAS TO BE A JOKE.HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I CANNOT BELIEVE IT.
HAHAHAHAAHAAHAHAAAAAAAAA! that sucks ass. she needs to get over herself
sounds like sinead o'conner.
I can't believe she released that to the public. How humiliating.
I don't think it was as horrible as other comments would lead you to believe. I mean come on "sounded like a drowning cat" where do you come up with that. I don't think it was all that great either, but still give her a fair try here.
i love this. shoegaze sound with delicate guitars.. she doesn't have a pop voice, but same goes for women like pj harvey, and they rock. video is beautiful too.
I liked it. That was good
terrible!!!!!!! i guess anybody can make a video now.
I liked it.
Wow. I was expecting her debut to be incredible and inspire jealousy in me. Maybe it was just the song choice but her voice sounded average to awful. Did I hear David Bowie? Did he help her? Why does everyone love Scarlett so much? She's no Natalie Portman! Natalie sings well, too. Her vocals seemed turned down so low. It was kind of hard to hear her. What I did her just sounded awful. It must be the song choice because I've heard the rumor she's a good singer. This was the wrong song to release first! I was really looking forward to the release. I love Tom Waits. I don't get the supporters on this one. I like weird music but her vocals just aren't good on this one.
Tom Waits!
Oh my goodness…that singing was awful…
I think I threw up in my mouth.
Yeah, I definately did.
HORRIBLE!! Good thing she can act, is beautiful and has big boobs because people could easily forget her if all she tried to do was sing!!
OGM this is absolutly dreadful, where's simon when u need him?
parade of dying cats…still hot as hell
It was not that bad of a song, the video is bad but I liked the singing. I think that is Bowie in the back ground. P leave her alone it is better than lots of other shit out there. I would like to hear more off of the album.
I actually like it - better that most of the shit on this site
I don't think it was that bad.
it's really not bad. the video sucked but i liked her take on the song and any new bowie these days is appreciated.
Don't listen to the silverwear/Don't listen to the napkin…. These are lyrics from the song….. Need I say more?……… Shit on toast…..
terrible…………
wow, i really dont even know what to say about this except what is wrong with the world?
uhhhh what the hell is this??? her and heidi montag should make a duet and video together. absolute magic!!! hahah
just gave me a new reason not to like her!!!!
This isn't that bad…
I like the song. The video is a bit self-indulgent, but the song is great.
I can see why Perez doesn't like it, though. He seems to be more into POP and this song is anything but. It [the song] would fit in very nicely with the mid-90s alterna-grrrl scene.
Okay, here's the deal. The song would be hot IF she could sing. Her voice isn't good but the song is. The video is boring. She's attractive but not interesting enough to look at for 4 minutes. I still think that she's better than Heidi!!!
I liked it.
Can you say "Jesus and Mary Chain wannabe?" Song wasn't shabby, but I don't think I heard her actually SING once. Lots of slow talking and moaning.
i like the song, the vid sucks indeed.
I liked it.
i thought it was good. THRILLED that it was original and very unlike the other hollyhoes…video was a bit tedious, but it was appropriate for the tone of the song. you people are idiots…it is a great song…
it's indulgent, and she could have done better, but it isn't as terrible as most here would like to think. if she would have stuck to the simple shots (like the few in black and white) it would do tom waits more justice. however, i'm not sure if she is the one to cover him at all. i'm not sure if anyone should.
wow it really is bad
It sounds like a bad charoke rendition of the song. As if the guy singing background vocals is the one who actually sings the song and scarlett is drunk in a bar making a fool of herself. The song has the potential to be kind of cute but not with her voice. She is horrible at singing.
Horrific. Stick to acting.
I like it. Not necessarily the video but the song and her voice is interesting and very NOt mainstream. She said in an interview regarding the album that it wouldn't be liked by all precisely because it wasn't going to be mainstream but music she liked herself. which is really nice when everything else you listen to on the radio is so cookie cutter. much like tom waits, who i also enjoy when in the mood.
U really wanna puke? please listen and see if u can tolerate more than 10 seconds
this is so bad i didnt even finish watching it!
lol the random balloon flying.. it looks like a flying banana!!
lol since im a bad singer..
i'm gonna make a song that sucks..
think of all the money ill get!
Well, what can I say…
Very Tori Amos, very artistic…altough TA is MUCH better!
finally someone i'm better at singing than!! my day has come.
she actually sings worse than i do. i never thought it possible.
What the…????
Whaaaa?!
I love it.
herion addicts
AAARRRGGGHHHHH
…enough said
well, I never thought she would choose tihs music as the first single… she is actually a good singer, you'll see it if you listen to summertime.
but this sucks, it's awful!!
really!?!?!?! is she serious?
Oh my God she can NOT even carry a tune. That was fucking terrible.
oh, my sweet tap dancing jesus, that made me wanna curb stomp many babies. begining with hers.
ZOMG. THAT was HORRIBLE.
it was like nails to a blackboard.
hopefully, there wont be anymore.,
i thought she sounded like a man, it was horrible!
WHAT THE DEUCE..YOU BETTER PAY ME FOR LISTENING TO THIS ! & I LOVE MY WIFE & MY CAT JOJO YANG COMOT
Please tell me this is a joke… she can't be serious…..
I LIKE IT! YOU ALL ARE HATERS!
I love it…. I think she sings fine,
okay, when they had that inflatable waving arm man that's when i stopped watching. it's like a dodgy home produced film clip for youtube. and she doesn't even sing! it's like sing talking. i can sing talk and make a crappy film clip of me getting my makeup done, where's my contract?
Sure, it's not mainstream but I think it's really nice - reminded me of Bright Eyes and Nick Cave.
umm… is this some kind of sick joke?
Weird vid, love the song.
Whatever, I can dig it.
omg its so good! i cant believe it
she sounds like sinead o'connor with a sinus infection
WOW.
Poor Poor girl. She CANNOT i repeat CANNOT sing.
Love the song…anyone pick up on David Bowie singing back up. could have done better that a "day in the life of scarlett" video.
If Nails on a Chalkboard could Sing…THIS is what it would sound like in Slow Mo. Bahahhaaaa…It's like she's not even trying dude! Wtf?
Um, wow. The video was embarassingly interesting, but the song was the shit of all shit. That voice.. what can any of us really say about that besides.. shit.
wait, is that supposed to be her singing?
I really liked it. I thought it was original and folksy.
Maybe if she shows her bald beaver and hugh clappers I could stand her singing. I never in the world thought that I would rather lister to Jessica Simpson. Just got some good news from my doctor, I am going deaf.
FAIR GO COBBERS, I KNOW SHE IS A FAN OF THE VELVET UNDERGROUND, I THINK SHE IS TRYING TO PULL A "NICO" HERE.
is this a joke?
awful.
i can't believe she would feel good about releasing this.
hope the rest of the record isn't as shitty as this was.
i'm surprised i made it through the whole video. the video sucked balls. it's like WTF?
That is horrible…I got as far as "I came 500 miles to see you…" Hello tone deaf….
hola no estuvo tan mal peor es lindsay lohan y otras lo hacen pq ella no ademas i hate she is so pretty
X..O…X…O from monterrey mexico we love PEREZ
OMG. Terrible. She sounds like Yoko Ono on a bad night.
I always said ScarHO was a MAN, this just proves it. Love Ya Perezzle!!
alanis morresiette (spelling?) is laughing her ass off right about now… she should stick to acting
I kinda loved it. I mean, she's covering Tom Waits (which is fucking awesome) and he sounds like a garbage disposal half the time. Hmm, I definitely loved it.
what the f***?????????Is this for real???????Why is she doing this to her career?????
WOW, THAT WAS HER SINGING? SHE HAS A VERY DEEP VOICE, OR A VERY LIMITED RANGE BUT IT WASN'T TERRIBLE.. JUST STRANGE-SOUNDING FOR A FEMALE.
I LIKED THE VIDEO. VERY ART-Y.
i's say.. stick to acting. haha.
that sucked!
im horrified. i dont understand why people like lindsay lohan and paris and now scarlett johansson think they can sing. i just dont get it. its so horrible.
well…she can act ! and she's pretty? O GOOD GOD THAT WAS JUST BAD IT WAS BAD I DIDNT THINK IT WOULD EB THAT BAD BUT IT WAS i was trying to find beauty in it but no there is none sry i still like you scarlett
Fall down already! Sheesh! Scarlett is very hit or miss, but this is self-involved tripe (at best).
AWESOME song. Wow. Didn't know scarlett had it in her.
wow, that was hideous. That wasn't even singing, that was just one big montone-y, coma inducing, droning ass nonsense. Aaah, it needs to be about 4 minutes shorter.
awful… she needs to stick to watever she does… and thats looking pretty
I liked it a lot. the vid was compelling and the song was good kind of like a song that you would have on in the background it sounds like a song from a movie. i thought her voice was good for that song obviously you can't really tell if her voice is brilliant or not because the type of singing she does in this song is just like speaking loudly, nearly shouting.
Screw you Perez….this is much better than most of the shit that's out there…much more creative and doesn't sound like cheesy dance shit…
OMG! That was horrible. I usually don't watch the videos but I was curious how bad it was since I don't think she had any talent. Take away her boobs and what do you have. A girl working in a regular job like everyone else. Why bother to create a music video if you do the same thing teh public sees you do everyday? Boring! No talent, no artistic ability- I can't wait until she goes away- or just poses for men magazines and stops trying to be an important actress.
WOAH - SHITHOUSE!!!!!!
I'm usually a positive person but that was fucking Sucked HORRIBLE!!!!!
Bad Sinead O'Connor!!!! I am so dissapointed!
How come no one told her that she doesn't have vocal skills? Her singing reminds me of Sinead O'Connor but Sinead was in key. Recording this track must have been hard for the producer and the very talented back up singers on this track used to mask her vocal ills.
In a weird sense, I feel this song and it's message. I also believe that this song will sound better to people during the winter months when everyone is forced inside and will listen. Remember, just because you look good (sometimes) doesn't mean that you can sing.
i like it.
I actually dont think this video/song is that bad..the song def aint a party track or nething but im sure we'll hear it on a grey's anatomy episode or another pathetic heidi montag moment on the hills.
OMG
I
THINK
TINA
SINGS
BETTER
THAN
HER
How humiliating for her! Mind you with a name like Scarlet, she'd be used to humiliation by now
OMG that was fucking awful! i expected a little more. not so damn monotone! ugh! shut her ass up!