Welcome to PerezHilton.com
Welcome to PerezHilton.com - Hollywood's Most-Hated Web Site!
Celebrity Scoop Goes Here
E-mail Perez@PerezHilton.com

Report technical problems.
Perez Posse signup FAQ

Contact us to advertise on PerezHilton.com



Wear it, share it, give it, get it! Represent!

Jump to your favorite celebrity

Articles by date

Did You Watch Idol???

Filed under: American Idol

Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????

926 comments to “Did You Watch Idol???”

More comments: « 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »

  1. layla says – reply to this


    101

    what's with the first? i don't get it….please explain……
    DAVID A VOICE IS DIVINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. notsecondclass says – reply to this


    102

    what is idol?

  3. Josh says – reply to this


    103

    no i changed it.. it was very BORING like this whole season has been.

  4. noemi says – reply to this


    104

    OMGOMGOMGOGM!!!!

    i dont watch that shideous show..
    MCFLY!!! FTW!!! hahahahah
    ha

  5. bob says – reply to this


    105

    DANNY NORIEGA!!!!!!!!

  6. Brittany O says – reply to this


    106

    I think David Archuleta is blowing Randy Jackson. The kid can sing, but he can only sing slow ballads. Sure, the teeney boppers are eating his shit up, but who wants to see a confused teenage boy sing songs sung by 50 year old men? Not me. DAVID COOK IS THE AMERICAN IDOL.

  7. seio says – reply to this


    107

    girlchuleta has no personality
    and
    david cook is too over confident!

    fuckin Paula for the win!

  8. Cindy says – reply to this


    108

    David A. is such a cry baby!!!! David Cook clearly has more talent!!

  9. K says – reply to this


    109

    I was really surprised by simons comments.. David A What???????????/
    David Cook is soooooooo much better!!!

  10. Annie says – reply to this


    110

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

    DAVID ARCHULETA CLEARLY IS THE BEST

  11. JON says – reply to this


    111

    I WATCHED IDOL AND DAVID ARCHULETTA IS GOING TO WIN, HE SANG BEAUTIFULLY!!!SIMON SAID HE WON ALL THREE ROUNDS. DAVID ARCHULETTA HAS MORE RANGE VOCALLY THAN COOK AND HE IS JUST SO ADORABLE

  12. LINDAJ says – reply to this


    112

    DAVID COOK
    DAVID COOK
    DAVID COOK
    DAVID COOK
    DAVID COOK

  13. jannet says – reply to this


    113

    cook has so much talent… but he sings horrible songs that don't fit his personality. he sings terrible renditions of those songs… ugh

    archuletta deserves to win.. beautiful singer, natural talent.. he has personality — he's only 17 for christ sake.

  14. Dayna says – reply to this


    114

    Judges were on the David Cook bandwagon all season and now on the finale they favor Archuleta…PLEASE.

  15. ~*C*~ says – reply to this


    115

    I think David Cook should win.
    the judges were all trying to push David A. on everyone tonight! i think they want him to win for some odd reason. hes cute thats all he has going for him, i mean he didnt do that wonderful. he makes weird faces it bugs me.
    my votes are for Cook

  16. Jacquie says – reply to this


    116

    David Cook is absolutely wonderful!!!!!! I truly hope he takes the title.

  17. Beth says – reply to this


    117

    We had a "Fantasy Idol" pool at work so we watched the entire season. It has really been a boring year as far as idol goes. I really like David Cook but I am sure David A. will win. Don't get me wrong - he is good but I think David Cook is going to make an awesome rock star! I would buy his album today!

  18. Tori says – reply to this


    118

    David Cook for the win! He's great!

  19. Ally says – reply to this


    119

    I honestly cannot understand why people are so in love with freakin "Archie" . I find him so boring, with not a single bone of creativity in his body. For a 17 year old boy, he is really really old. Don't get me wrong, he has a great voice, but for the whole season, he didnt show any other side of him, except for that Chris Brown song, which was a disaster. David Cook deserves to win. He has material, he has charisma. The most talented idol contestant to this day.

  20. rudolph says – reply to this


    120

    cook deserves the win, and sang waaaaay better than the judges gave him credit for!! TEAM COOK!

  21. Michelle says – reply to this


    121

    Ahhhhh!!! After watching tonight, it is SO hard to tell! I wanted David Cook to win, but David Archuletta did so much better vocally…. I have no idea.

  22. WoopWoop says – reply to this


    122

    GO DAVID COOK!
    I HOPE EVERYONE VOTED FOR HIM.
    ARCHULETA'S A LIL' BITCH.

  23. BRITTANY!!(THE SANE ONE) says – reply to this


    123

    david cook!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  24. Kiira says – reply to this


    124

    Unfortunately the judges sided with Archuleta, but Cook has to win! He will win! I rarely voted, but tonight I think I might have voted 20 times. I really hope he wins! GO VOTE DAVID COOK!!!!

  25. Cook says – reply to this


    125

    DAVID COOK LOOKS LIKE A HOBBIT. His head is huge, his arms are short and he's a fata. every song he "reinterpreted" he stole from someone else.

  26. jason says – reply to this


    126

    archuletta can't even speak in complete sentences
    i think his singing and performance skills are so painfully mediocre

  27. Mae says – reply to this


    127

    Archie Baby!

  28. krista says – reply to this


    128

    i don't care. i just want to see the jonas brothers perform tomorrow on idol ;]

  29. THE WINNER: says – reply to this


    129

    ARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCHULETAARCH

  30. da4tw says – reply to this


    130

    david cook is horribly tone deaf

  31. Kayley says – reply to this


    131

    I'm voting for David Cook. David A is good, but I don't think he's ready for fame (he already gets so nervous and flustered just on AI. Think of all the media crap he'll have to do if he wins!)
    I think both will have successful careers, but David Cook is ready NOW and David A. could benefit from just growing up a bit more first.

  32. Jess says – reply to this


    132

    david coook!!! ♥

  33. sam says – reply to this


    133

    DAVID ARCHULETA ROCKS! He's absolutely flawless every single time….he deserves to win! LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  34. Crystal says – reply to this


    134

    I'm a David Cook fan, but Archuleta out preformed him tonight.

  35. jen says – reply to this


    135

    LOVE David Cook!!! xoxoox

  36. Kim says – reply to this


    136

    DAVID COOK ALL THE WAY. HE KICKS MAJOR ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  37. Missy Eyes says – reply to this


    137

    David A will win but David C. will out sell him.

  38. Jean says – reply to this


    138

    HOLD ON GIRLZ!
    More important than the performances tonight, did anyone notice how FROZEN Ryan Seacrest's forehead was?

    Ryan Seacrest wins the Nicole Kidman Award for BOTOX Excellence!

  39. HP says – reply to this


    139

    David cook is so much better than that pansy archuleta.

  40. Loni says – reply to this


    140

    DAVID ARCHULETA IS AMAZING!! HE HAS TO WIN!!
    -
    -
    -
    -DAVID ARCHULETA IS AMAZING!! HE HAS TO WIN!!
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -DAVID ARCHULETA IS AMAZING!! HE HAS TO WIN!!
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -DAVID ARCHULETA IS AMAZING!! HE HAS TO WIN!!
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -DAVID ARCHULETA IS AMAZING!! HE HAS TO WIN!!
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -
    -DAVID ARCHULETA IS AMAZING!! HE HAS TO WIN!!
    -
    -
    -
    -

  41. char says – reply to this


    141

    How can anyone say that they both suck? Something is wrong with that person. "It" probably can't carry a tune and wouldn't know good if it hit them in the face!!

  42. nicca says – reply to this


    142

    David Cook…he can sing different styles which means he can carry on a show. David Archuletta is really good but he has only one style, people will probably fall asleep after a few songs. He is kinda commercial too me, nothing is orriginal. Hope Cook will win.

  43. Ashley says – reply to this


    143

    I thought David Cook performed much better. Archuletta has zero personality and is not marketable.

  44. Jenn C says – reply to this


    144

    Idol has officially jumped the shark. Last season sucked and this season sucked!!! A.I. is dying a slow death.

  45. robynnn says – reply to this


    145

    COOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOKCOOK!!!

    he'll do better in the long run

  46. Just!n says – reply to this


    146

    Listen Raggedy Cunts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    ITS ARCHULETA FOR THE MOTHA FUCKIN WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  47. jess says – reply to this


    147

    I vote for David Cook but I think David A will win. Although it may be better for David Cook's career if he loses. Then he can get a record deal and won't have the Idol restrictions which could really put a damper on his career.

  48. Kate says – reply to this


    148

    David Cook is amazing.

    Nuff said.

  49. cg says – reply to this


    149

    David Cook is phenom. He's a star, Archuleta is just a little kid who sounds good for his age. Cook has it all.

  50. David Archuleta says – reply to this


    150

    Thanks for all you're support everyone, I really appreciate it! It means a lot, more than you know.

  51. simplyAng says – reply to this


    151

    I AM SOooOOoooOOooooooooooOoooOOOOOooooo OVER IDOL!!! I hope they both lose! And I hope Fox realizes the ratings are slipping because we are BORED of the staged show and all its FAKENESS!!!!!!! Fall off the stage!!! I hope Ryan and simon start making out. Ha ha. Okay enough. Die American Idol!!!!!!!

    -ang!

  52. allyk says – reply to this


    152

    Re: chow – yeah cause that's what matters, how they look you idiot. who gives a shit how they look, how you look or anyone for that matter. get over your shallow self.

  53. kim says – reply to this


    153

    david cook ftw!

  54. josh says – reply to this


    154

    David Cook is too arrogant. David A should win!

  55. Magdeil says – reply to this


    155

    David Cook has to win.

  56. kerry says – reply to this


    156

    David Cook…but that show was boring and flat

  57. NIC says – reply to this


    157

    Archuletta belongs singing in rent…
    COOK FOR THE WIN !!!!

  58. huh says – reply to this


    158

    of course it came down to a david david finale
    archie is a newborn. dcook is a star.

  59. carol says – reply to this


    159

    I almost hope that David Cook doesn't win, just because I would hate for that much talent to be bound by the "idol" title…I feel like if he had his own deal after this show that was separate from the franchise, he might be able to make a more creative/independent/edgy first album, as opposed to the generic, cookie-cutter fare the american idol winners usually put out
    (With that said, I still think he deserves the title more than the other David. Archuleta just needs a little more time to grow up and figure out his original voice and inspiration.)

  60. kp says – reply to this


    160

    david a has no range and only sticks to ballads. he plays it safe.
    however, david c has a nice range both vocally and musically (of course, david a has one vocally) and appeals to all ages, whereas david a only appeals to tweens…and that aint going to sell or last

    so, i hope david cook wins!

  61. ShayJea says – reply to this


    161

    DAIVD A IS GONNA WIN

  62. BoBo says – reply to this


    162

    JASON CASTRO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!——!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    or
    DANNY NORIEGA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!——!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    or
    DREW POPLRITER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!——-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  63. nathan says – reply to this


    163

    has anyone really cares about american idol since kelly clarkson won?? she is the only american idol that matters!!

  64. Laurie says – reply to this


    164

    Voted all night for David Cook (still voting) - know it is rigged for David A to win but DC is obviously the real star.

  65. brittany says – reply to this


    165

    they give david archuletta WAYYYYYY too much credit (especially randy)! he's a boring little boy and has NO versatility! everytime he speaks i want to shoot myself.

  66. I AM SMALL AND LOVE IT says – reply to this


    166

    IM FROM MURRAY UTAH AND I WAS THE FIRST TO SUCK D.A'S COCK… IT WAS SOOOOOO SMALL JUST LIKE HIS PERSONALITY!!….

    * UPDATE I HAVE THEN SINCE RECRUITED D.C TO MORMONISM TOO AND AM NOW HIS 2ND WIFE!! YEEEEEAY MEEE!!… D.C BIOTCHES!

  67. BrandyS says – reply to this


    167

    David Cook all the way!!!!

  68. rex says – reply to this


    168

    David A has more to offer hes still developing in every way I think well see much more of him ….. Go David A

  69. sunshine says – reply to this


    169

    David Cook is the best thing that has happened to american idol.
    he's proven he's an all around great artist.
    However, the teen vote will go to David A
    I look forward to buying David Cook album
    cheers!

  70. LIZZIE says – reply to this


    170

    DAVID A. ALL THE WAY!!!!!! :]

  71. Kisha Lee says – reply to this


    171

    I enjoyed tonight's show. I think both David C & Lil David are awesome! Lil David has such a powerful voice filled with compassion. Cook, I'd pay to see him in concert, he's the better performer/entertainer, Archuleta has the better vocals. I'm still wide awake voting for Archuleta as we speak. I love them both but would like to see Archuleta win. Cook will do just fine. He doesn't need to be stuck in the Idol contract. He needs to fly like a bird like Chris Daughtery. So my vote for the American Idol is DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!

  72. NIKKI says – reply to this


    172

    I THINK DAVID COOK IS MORE DIVERSE AND MULTI-TALENTED THEN DAVID A.! DAVID C. CAN SING A VARIETY OF MUSIC WHERE AS DAVID A. CAN SEEM TO ONLY SING SAPPY LOVE SONGS!!!! BORING!!! IF ONLY DAVID A. HAD MORE OF A PERSONALITY TO GO ALONG WITH THAT VOICE OF HIS HE MIGHT HAVE GOTTEN MY VOTE!!! =)

  73. Tara says – reply to this


    173

    COOK! COOK! COOK!

  74. Sydnee says – reply to this


    174

    DAVID COOK FOR THE WIN

  75. Julie says – reply to this


    175

    GO DAVID A., all the way!

  76. Anabanana says – reply to this


    176

    Who cares anymore? This show stopped being relevant after Season 2. After that, it only matters when it's on the air; the winner fails immediately after the season ends. The winners are irrelevant puppets that get the most votes because they're non-threatening and fit the mold, only to later fail for the exact same reason. Except Fantasia, who is awesome, but because she's black, she is only marketed as a ghetto sex-object, which insults her, her talent and black women in general.

  77. Bri says – reply to this


    177

    I have to say Archuleta was great tonight but I still want COOK to WIN!!!!

  78. Misti says – reply to this


    178

    David Cook needs to take it!!!

    I hate Archuleta. I hate that phony fake expression of shock on his face when anyone gives him a compliment. His face always says "Wow, you really think I can sing?? Me?? I can't believe it!!" Shut up!

    Cook has been the best all season. He is the most diverse and he puts on a show, he doesn't just get up there and sing. Acrchuleta can sing, but he can't perform.

  79. sasha says – reply to this


    179

    archuletta was vocally better, but DC ROX!!! way easier to listen to…

  80. lizziebaby says – reply to this


    180

    David Archuleta is going to win just based on fan votes, but David Cook is the better singer - I'm rooting for DAVID ARCHULETA - WOO, HOO!!!

  81. MG says – reply to this


    181

    Simon was Pro-Cook all the way until tonite. He spoke the truth. The Kid owned Cook. If you don't agree you are only lying to yourself and/or didn't watch the show.

  82. Canuck says – reply to this


    182

    what the bloody fuck was simon on tonight. he seemed to hate david cook. Cook by far outperformed Archuleta overall. Archie will put us all to sleep with his soft ballad album whereas Cook actually sings upbeat and the slower songs well.

    GO COOOOOOOOOOOOK

  83. Brian says – reply to this


    183

    First of All…. It doesn't matter!!!!! David Cook will sell more records that David A. I don't care if David A wins. I know that I won't be listening to his boring music on my ipod. I rather work out and be inspired by Cook. Why do I have this thought stuck in my head of David A singing and dancing to "My Boo!" That was horrible.

  84. carol says – reply to this


    184

    I almost hope David Cook doesn't win, so that he isn't hindered by the Idol title. There is no doubt he will be hugely successful, and will definitely get a record deal after the show, winner or not. I think he'd be more likely to put out a creative, original record with a label separate from the Idol franchise, which is highly preferable to a cheesy, predictible, safe, and cookie-cutter type album that is characteristic of almost all the previous Idol winners' first albums.
    That said, David Cook is stilll the better David, and ultimately deserves the title more.

  85. Archuleta or Cook says – reply to this


    185

    Cook is a wonderful performer. But Cook lacks humbleness. He is too cocky and seems to think he's already a platinum selling Grammy artist already. I caught the dig he threw out about why he didn't sing a song he's done before. You guys say Archuleta got too much credit tonight, well Cook has already been "crowned" the AI according to tons of online polls. But I wouldn't sit back and think he has it in the bag. Remember how people just knew Clay Aiken would beat out Ruben and he didn't. I agree with Cook's statement at the beginning saying they both are winners and tonight, they'd enjoy themselves. I think his tears at the end were forced and fake. As awesome as he is as a performer, he could use a slice of humble pie. ARCHULETA is the 2008 American Idol!!!

  86. cherry says – reply to this


    186

    it was ok (i am not jumping up and down though) …i would like david cook to win but…

  87. britt c. says – reply to this


    187

    DAVID COOK!!DACID COOK!!DAVID COOK!!
    omg

  88. sherry says – reply to this


    188

    david coo is a bitch. david a should win and if david c wins its only because his brother has cancer. he only gets smpathy votes. we all know his singing dident get him that far because he sucks ass im from kansas city missouri where he is from and i still cant stand the bitch david a all the way

  89. Heba says – reply to this


    189

    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA
    ARCHULETA

  90. meshell says – reply to this


    190

    david c should win… if david a wins come on who is really gonna buy his cd….ummmm no 1!!!!!! so dont waste votes on him!!!!

  91. Courtney says – reply to this


    191

    I would love fuck David Cook but as far as American Idol…David Archuleta owned tonight….but I'd still like to fuck David Cook. Man is that guy hot! When he smiles, I melt

  92. JTIZ says – reply to this


    192

    Oh you west coasters. Only the New Yorkers know whats good. Anyway, heres the scoop. Shit sucked, pretty much. DAVID COOK is a favorite; he is much more of an entertainer. Been doing it a while. DAVID A can be molded; he can make more money in the LONG RUN. Think Disney. Who SHOULD win? Probably cook. Who will? A.

  93. Katie says – reply to this


    193

    Does anyone know if the finale is still at the kodak theater?

  94. Megan says – reply to this


    194

    Cook!!!!!!!!!!!! He's so sexy!!!

  95. PJ says – reply to this


    195

    David A made my heart sink tonight. I voted for the very first time because he was so outstanding. Either guy really would be a great Idol.

  96. TT says – reply to this


    196

    Archie kicked ass! He DEFINITELY deserves the win!!

  97. YOUR MAMA'S DISCHARGE says – reply to this


    197

    I don't like AI because it is like they manufacture WHO they want to win. It's like watching Making of the Band… boring. Manufactured pop fluff is what people are tired of. People are catching on to the fact that it isn't real anymore. Brooke should have won…she was real. I can't say that for the rest of them.

  98. leslie says – reply to this


    198

    this has been the best season, hands down. i wanted these two in the finale from the beginning. i really love both, but i sway a little more towards david cook. he's way more versatile. he can sing ANYTHING and sound amazing. archuleta's voice is amazing though. especially for a 17 (!!) year old. it's a toss up. for the record, though, i voted for cook. :)

  99. Lala says – reply to this


    199

    Go David Archuleta!!!

  100. Hector says – reply to this


    200

    archuleta is going to win!!!!!

More comments: « 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »