Did You Watch Idol???

Welcome to PerezHilton.com - Hollywood's Most-Hated Web Site!

E-mail Perez@PerezHilton.com

Report technical problems.
Perez Posse signup FAQ

Contact us to advertise on PerezHilton.com

Wear it, share it, give it, get it! Represent!

Articles by date

Filed under: American Idol

Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????
Thoughts???????

Posted: May 20, 2008 at 11:58 pm

Share |

Home >> American Idol >> Did You Watch Idol???

926 comments to “Did You Watch Idol???”

More comments: « 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »

Sarah says – reply to this

201

DAVID COOK!!!!!!!!!!! Archuleta looks like he is going to piss himself!
Diane says – reply to this

202

I think David Archuleta will win..since little screaming girls will vote, but David Cook will sell more albums and be a better recording artist in the long run. Plus, it's almost better that DC doesn't win…seems like the ones that win usually fall off the face of the erath.
brandi says – reply to this

203

Davvid Archulettta is great!
DC says – reply to this

204

DAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOKDAVID COOK
... says – reply to this

205

I love David Cook and I'm voting for him even though I admit David Archuleta did amazing tonight.
em says – reply to this

206

chyeah i looove david cook. he has so much more range. all archuleta has are damn ballads. how fucking boring right?
Jen says – reply to this

207

David Cook deserves to win because he is a true musician who can actually PLAY an instrument and is capable of writing his own songs. Unlike David A. he's just a good singer who will just sing songs people write for him which is LAME
kris says – reply to this

208

David A all the Way!
Kate says – reply to this

209

Someone said it earlier…Cook is a watered down Daughtry. I think Archuleta served him his balls on a silver platter tonight. NEVER let your balls get bigger than your underpants, Cookie. You should know that!

Plus the unfortunate exploitation of his brother really ruined him for me. Elliott Yamin's mom was (at the time of Idol) terminally ill with breast cancer. That she lived two years passed was a MIRACLE. Im glad Eliott didn't exploit her conditions!
Miguel says – reply to this

210

Today, I think David Archuletta did a better job than David Cook. I don't think David Archuletta was amazing tonight but he was good. David Cook was a little pitchy tonight.
POSH says – reply to this

211

I LOVE DAVID A! I CALLED IT! HE WILL WIN
Kali says – reply to this

212

David Cook is AMAZING. David A bothers me! I HATE how he licks his lips. ugh. Go DAVID COOK!
Natalie[Bold as Love] says – reply to this

213

I love both them. I can't favor one over the other, that's like favoring one of your kids more than the others!

I will be happy with whoever wins because they're both amazing.

Personally, I think David Cook should have gotten more recognition than Simon gave him. He definately has major talent and singing with that much power in your voice isn't easy.
shanfromCanada says – reply to this

214

David Archuleta rocked so hard that I actually kinda felt bad for Cook. Poor guy, ’cause Archuleta kicked his ASS!
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
melly says – reply to this

215

i think david archuleta has brain washed the young girls of america with his sickeningly cheesy sweet look and he will win…based purely on the fact that he makes them moist in their pre-teen panties. but in my own personal opinion, david cook is far more talented and will have a much better and longer career without winning this show. i predict he will release an album first and it will top the charts and be up there with the success of daughtry or carrie underwood. archuleta will put out an album and do well with it for awhile and then he'll kinda get forgotten about…like fantasia and jordan sparks…taylor hicks anyone? he's got a good voice but it's nothing special. enough with the fucking ballads already, take some damn risks and do something exciting. ahhhh. fucktard, i cant stand archuleta.
DALE says – reply to this

216

They both suck hard!, and no I didn't watch the shity kareoke show!.
Sarah says – reply to this

217

Cook was amazing. He will win. THey just feel back for David A becuase his dad is so crazy.
Darkhorse says – reply to this

218

DC DC DC DC DC DC DC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If David Cook doesn't win it…then it's fixed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RPS says – reply to this

219

Re: jim – no david a. didn cry but he looked likehe was going to after every song

and I dont think David C was crying to get votes .. I think and would bet he was crying causehis brother couldnt make it to the show, among other things
David Cook is a pud says – reply to this

220

Archuletta!!! He did an amazing song with Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me.

David Cook is good, but an arrogant ass.
JB says – reply to this

221

The last 17-year-old winner (Jordin Sparks, who isn't exactly burning up the charts…or doing anything but singing at like state fairs and malls at this point) didn't do shit once she won…and won't amount to anything…and neither will David Archuleta if he wins (much to the chagrin of his fking famewhore father, I'm sure).

David Cook is the real talent here, and if he doesn't win, it's a travesty along the lines of Ruben Studdard over Clay Aiken and that gray-haired freak, Taylor Hicks (also currently on the rodeo/ Wal-Mart grand opening tour circuit along with Sparks, Studdard and other never-were-and-never-will-be's) over the clearly more talented Chris Daughtry. David A. did better tonight, though I strongly disagree with the 'knockout' comment from Simon. However, Cook will and more importantly, SHOULD win.

Not only is he more charismatic, he's much more versatile–PLUS he's not saddled with the stage-dad beast from hell. The key to Cook's success is he is more MARKETABLE–which Idol sorely needs its winner to be at this point after the long string of sub-par winners listed above.

Anyone who votes for Archuleta is either 13 or a tone-deaf pedophile.

COOK FTW!!!
Marla says – reply to this

222

David Cook is AMAZING. I really hope he wins!

I can truly see David Cook becoming popular overnight, and making it big. David Archuleta is still young and has a ways to go before I think he'd even think about touring, etc., which would be like the past few winners that didn't do much with winning the title. David Cook's voice and music is what is HOT right now! I don't really think David Archuleta has a "genre" he likes to sing. And well, him solo in concert? It would be a bit boring and stiff. He needs to let loss a little!

So with that being said, David Cook better win and prove to the judges that there comments were way wrong tonight! DAVID was a knockout!
Tami says – reply to this

223

David Cook rules! David A is too young and his range is way too limited.. He's very talented, but not ready. David Cook could go out there tonight and fill a club!
chris says – reply to this

224

David A may be the better singer but he has noooo star quality. He'll never make it big. Another Ruben Studdard as far as Im concerned. David Cook has what it takes.
JOEY IN SAN JOSE says – reply to this

225

YEP, ARCHULETA NAILED IT. THE BOY WAS HOT, DEAD ON AND CREAMED COOKED IN THE FINALS. I WAS A COOK FAN, THAT WAS UNTIL TONIGHT. AN AMAZING JOURNEY FOR BOTH, BUT LETS FACE IT, ARCHULETA IS ONLY 17 FING YEAR OLD AND WILL BE AN AMAZING HEART FELT PERFORMER FOR YEARS TO COME….GREAT JOB LITTLE DAVIE! CHEERS TO YOUR SUCCESS, YOU DESERVE IT!
dumbnhung says – reply to this

226

David Archuleta owned the stage, destroying Cook easily. Archuleta will win.
RPS says – reply to this

227

It would actually be better for David C not to win cause then he will not be tied to AI , and he can write and sing whatever he wants , and not what they want him to ..
Favrerules says – reply to this

228

David A. looked like he was going to faint or pee his pants after the first song when he was being praised. Also, he sounds like Michael Jackson when he talks and gives me the creeps in general. He has no personality.
katie says – reply to this

229

ARCHULETA WILL WIN IT!!!
Overit! says – reply to this

230

I soooooooooo want David Archuleta to win! He's a great singer and a cute kid!
jane says – reply to this

231

Well, they tried to throw David Cook under the bus on this one, but secretly I think Simon knew what he was doing all along. All this week, he's been on talk shows saying he favors David Cook, and by saying Archuleta won the night tonight, he just inspired viewers to call in vigorously all night. So, I guess I should be thanking Simon when Cook wins tomorrow night!
kpl says – reply to this

232

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
But I
christina c (ccbloom) says – reply to this

233

david a all the way…vocally, personally, professionally.. no doubt. david cook is an egotistical albino with a broke down hollow voice.. going no where fast.. it got old quick watching him sing from the side of his mouth.

warm wishes to DA. you're going all the way!!
idol fan says – reply to this

234

david cook os the best out of the voth he deserves to win it all !!!!!!!!david a is good ………………..for broadway!!I voted thirty times for david c…
Tiff says – reply to this

235

David A played it way to safe….
DALE says – reply to this

236

You fuckin airheads who watch this shit, are the reason why music sucks today, yeah more dautrey, hicks, clarkson and manufactured hollywood music.
h says – reply to this

237

.
,
,
,
,
,

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
COOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tupac says – reply to this

238

david a is too too little to win!! he wouldn't have much of a career especially with poppa joe 2.0 as his dad. david cook had what it takes. david a had the voice of an angel but does not have what it takes to be a star. david cook just HAS it.
stephani3 says – reply to this

239

david cook will win, but david archuleta will become the next zac efron. disney will offer him a contract and he'll be huge. and david cook will follow in the footsteps of chris daughtry and become successful. and syesha will become a broadway star. michael johns will get a contract i'm sure, and he'll do well, but the rest of the idols' 15 minutes of fame will be over.
tali says – reply to this

240

david cooookkk
coook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
cook
coook
cook
cook
cook
cook
Anna says – reply to this

241

Cook was so-so at best, and completely off-key on his first song.
RYAN SECREAST says – reply to this

242

you all know its a curse to win idol…they own your ass for 5 years. I think david cook knows what he is doing by under singing tonight. He doesnt want to win….think about it. By being runner up hes free to sign with anyone he wants and he doesnt have to give idol 50% of his profits.
archie says – reply to this

243

david archuleta has the voice of an angel!!!
gnome says – reply to this

244

Cook annoys me so much. I couldn't believe Simon called him 'one of the most sincere' people that has been on the show. He appears so cocky and fake and I always get the feeling he's trying to get pity points and popularity votes. Besides that, Nickelback already has a mediocre singer, and one is more than enough!
dfgfg says – reply to this

245

COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK COOK
supermex says – reply to this

246

Archuleta killed it!
go cooksey says – reply to this

247

archuletta has the personality of a brick wall. he sucks a donkey dick.
gena says – reply to this

248

Monkey Boy to win A.I.

Cook to win in the real world… I'l buy his CD's….look at Chris Daughtry…. Never a dime spent for Monkey boy…..
Thea says – reply to this

249

everyone please vote for David Cook!!!!!!!!!
vote again and again and again….
Ken says – reply to this

250

Cook does the same thing over and over - totally derivative faux-alt rocker. What a phony.
HAZEL says – reply to this

251

WHAT THE $#%^
GuErA says – reply to this

252

David cook Rocked…! He's hot and has a great voice…Imagine him in bed…"Ahi Papi" jajajaja…I hope he wins…he really is original…not like Archuleta…his way to Pop…like every one else…PEREZ TE QUIERO PAPACITO CHULO…!!!
idol fan says – reply to this

253

Re: idol fan – I'm sorry i'm so tired i mispelled some word's i ment.
Natasha says – reply to this

254

David A!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Natalie [Bold as Love] says – reply to this

255

Re: maria –
I totally agree. David A was amazing tonight. I think David Cook held back a little bit, but I think he was just trying to enjoy the moment of being in the top 2.

I love both of them. They're both amazing. I will be happy with whoever wins.

However, I think David C deserves more recognition than what Simon gave him. I don't know what Simon was smoking, but anyone with ears knows that David C was great!
Tara says – reply to this

256

How sad this is what music has come to, two wannabe poseurs singing cheesy kareoke songs. MUSIC IS DEAD!
Kate says – reply to this

257

Um Jordin Sparks career has sky rocketed since her single with Chris Brown was released.
Cory says – reply to this

258

The recap clip of David's "Imagine" is completely different than the one that aired "live."
me the me says – reply to this

259

PEOPLE…PEOPLE

DC obviously held back because he doesnt want to be the AI winner and be held to their contract.

He knows he's gonna get the record deal anyway, without having to be AI's puppet.

He held back on purpose to go the DAUGHTRY ROUTE …DUH!

I HOPE COOK WINS though!
len says – reply to this

260

cook says in tv guide how sympathy votes leave a sour taste in his mouth. really? if that is so, then why exploit his brother over and over? phony/poseur.
Yeah you know says – reply to this

261

David A is one bizarre 17 year old. Who really listens to the music he has been singing at his age anyway? And the way he talks and acts, he's just weird and seems very awkward. Not sure who would buy his music other than some old granny types. David Cook at least chooses better songs and has a good voice. Just don't think David A is going to go anywhere but maybe to some musical on Broadway or something.
aubrie says – reply to this

262

D.A. fosho!!!
he rocked it
tinatru says – reply to this

263

DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK!
kt says – reply to this

264

COOK!
IDOL SUCKS HILTON'S BALLS says – reply to this

265

My sources tell me the two gay guys were fucking each other backstage.
Ermie Wormie says – reply to this

266

DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
me says – reply to this

267

DAVID all the way!
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>;)
mollie says – reply to this

268

ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
ARCHIE!
Barbie says – reply to this

269

:) David A. wins Idol & HILARY WINS KY! Vote HILARY GIRLS If the Democrats want a win in the Whitehouse , better go with HILARY She has the SUPPORT NEEDED
Amalia says – reply to this

270

Archuleta for idol!!!!!!
UK says – reply to this

271

Love David A…Hope he wins!!!!!
Kaylin says – reply to this

272

COOK FOR THE WIN, ARCHULETA IS NOT VERSATILE AT ALL!
DC FOR AI BABY!

oh, and Seacrest was on some shit tonight boyyy.
:]
Courtney says – reply to this

273

Davis Cook SHOULD win, but Archeletta WILL win. I think the producers told the judges to push David A.!!!!!
huh says – reply to this

274

my thought are the same as thy were when this shitfest started… Archulletta sucks! He ruined this whole season!
didi says – reply to this

275

DAVID COOK all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Glenny says – reply to this

276

David Cook all the way.
Melanie says – reply to this

277

well, i am not sure if you are immature children..you must not know what true talent and music is!!! David A. Definitly deserves to win!!! Cook is o.k. but the same as every other rocker…David A. has an amazing pure talent and he will win. thank you
me says – reply to this

278

Simon winked at David Cook. hahaha david c must be sleeping with him
Johnny says – reply to this

279

David A all the way!
helena says – reply to this

280

idk i like both of them but i think maybe David A. is going to win it.
Nathan says – reply to this

281

Archuleta obviously, eventhough Cook SHOULD win.
David Cook's GF says – reply to this

282

I think David Cook showed America the kind of album he is going to make and
did the best he could with the Idol selections that were forced upon
him. However, he strayed away from the "Idol winning formula" that the
lip licking leprechan followed to a T. Thus DC probably will lose the
competition. But win or lose, my BF DC will be a bigger success. He'll
sell more albums and be a staple on VH1 in a few months, and the lip
licker will be on some cheesy Mormon Christmas specials.
dani :) says – reply to this

283

david coooooooooookkk!!!!!!!! he needs to win! david a suck!!! he is the same everytime!!! goooo David COOK!!!!
cvs says – reply to this

284

You Rock Perez!!!!!!!!!! You got my vote…..(wink)

My AI vote is for David Cook!! Rock. Me. Baby.

David A is good, but I would not buy his album or buy a concert ticket to see him,.
kristi says – reply to this

285

even though archuleta always looks like he's gonna hyperventilate after simon's comments, I still think he did great tonight. archuleta for the win!!
cameron says – reply to this

286

cook!
Joseph says – reply to this

287

david cook should win Idol. He has a better personality a voice thats good with almost any songs he sings, and he can make it big. David A. has a great voice too but all i hear are slow songs he's not the type to sing a fast upbeat song, and he's only done it once with chris brown. and that songs not even fast. David A still has some growing up to do he's still young and VERY shy!!!
ashley says – reply to this

288

it doesnt matter how much you diss david archuleta. he's going to win.

suck it.
mike says – reply to this

289

David a is loser! I would rather see him win, and Cook get the better contract..see Daughtry!!!!!!
amanda says – reply to this

290

David Cook should win.
I think archuleta will though. I don't get him, I really don't. He's so boring, and weird… when Ryan interviews him, it makes me uncomfortable, his public speaking skills are so poor. But what really makes me angry is that fact that despite knowing how good he is (as he does hear it all the time) everytime they tell him hes safe, he gets all teary eyed like a little babe. ugh, gag me.
Really now, the best performer is Cook.
EVERYONE says – reply to this

291

VOTE FOR DAVID COOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Stephanie says – reply to this

292

I think the judges definitely made it so that people would vote for David A. I am so sick of his cookie cutter performances. It's sad that they tell every one to step out of their element yet he has sang the same dreary, weepy songs over and over again and nothing has been said. He is uninteresting while David C. is nothing but original. I actually think David C. will be better off not winning because he can go off and get his own contract without Idol.
pmr! says – reply to this

293

DAVID A!!! SOOO AMAZING!!!
monica says – reply to this

294

david cook is more of an overall artist & performer, it's not just about the vocals (although his vocals are stellar, as well).david archuleta has a good voice, however, his career is more broadway bound. david cook should be the winner.
DAVIDA! says – reply to this

295

duuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuude DAVID A IS SUCH A CUTIE
HE'S GONNA BE THE NEW TEEN HEART THROB AND AMERICAN IDOL
Lewis says – reply to this

296

DA for the win!
Jen says – reply to this

297

No, I motherfucking didn't. And everyone who does is beyond fucked.
Becky says – reply to this

298

I think it should be David A. He is a great singer, he is pretty much the whole package. David C. on the other hand always seems a lil smug and cocky. just fake. Like he is only doing this to be famous not because he really wants to win. David A. has his soul into this competion and he showed it today how bad he really wanted it.
COOK COOK COOK says – reply to this

299

Re: candie –

David A is a great singer but an awful performer.
DAVID COOK IS AMAZING ALL AROUND! WOOT WOOT!
dub1 says – reply to this

300

DC! DC!
Hope Simon said what he did to get more votes for David Cook.
I know he's only 17, but David Archuleta seems illiterate. Still hope his dad won't beat him with a coathanger if he loses.

More comments: « 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 »