The New Hilary & Haylie
Filed under: Disney > Ashley Tisdale > YOU Decide!
Disney star Ashley Tisdale took her actor sibling Jennifer to the premiere of High School Musical on ice this weekend in LA.
Ignore what they're wearing.
The real question is….
Which one is Hilary and which one is Haylie?????!!!
[Photo via Getty Images.]
Posted: October 6, 2007 at 10:26 pm
Jennifer Tisdale - Haylie
Ashley Tisdale - Hilary
DUH.
Re: MATN – Why do you comment if you dont care?
Why are you on this site if you dont care?
STFU!
God, if you dont care get off the computer and do something else you FucktaRD.
perez, you should do something on how it looks like ashley got a nose job
The real question is… When are they gonna show PINK? (& I ain't talkin' bout that douche singer thing).
They're both prettier than the Fugg, I mean, Duff sisters!!
Hmm neither one of them is as ugly as Haylie, they both are very cute. God Haylie is so ugly with her big ugly nose…..
Ashley is a wanna be A. Simpson.
eeew… i hate these american bottle-blonds with their black eyes trying to emulate northern europeans but just end up looking bizarre.
They're both horrible at what they do. Ignore these hacks.
ew that chick needs some dental work stat!
Two words….Crest Whitestrips!
WHAT THE FUCK iS WR0NG W/ ASHLEY TiSDALE'S FACE? JENNiFER'S iSN'T MUCH BETTER!
JENNiFER - HAYLiE
ASHLEY - HiLARY
Haylie is the unfamous sister just like Jennifer
Re: jbonz –
actually…shes a really innocent, mama's girl off camera. my bet is that shes still a virgin
Re: slammer – tru dat man!!!……
Ashley is Haylie and Jennifer is Hilary
They're both pretty girls. How old are they, 32?
I can't believe you people calling them fug,, and ugly and gross or calling them sluts,, that is just mean,,
what the hell did these girls do to you guys??
I think they are cute, I know the one is talented ,, saw her in that high school musical,, and watched her video online,,
so,, wow,,
talk about bitter and vile,,
just hate people just to hate people,, that is sad,,
I think they are cute,, and as far as I have NOT HEARD or SAW ,, they do not look to be slutty or mean or on drugs ,, or drunks,,
the Duff sisters are not bad girls either,, I think they are both sweet and talented girls,,
it's horrible to see people so mean and hateful over these girls and the Duff girls ,, when clearly they are not bad people
ashley is hilary!
ashley is hilary, the other girl is haylie.
ashley is more popular.
I don't know who these chicks are, but the short one on the right is giving me the "I wanna suck your cock" look. She looks like she has taken it down a few times….My kinda woman / girl.
Ashley = Hilary. Jennifer = Mariah Carey.
What has Jennifer been in? If there's nothing major to credit her with than I would consider her Haylie, especially because Ashley got her start on disney. Hopefully Jennifer and Ashley can produce edgier works. I would also suggest rhyming names. The Tisdale sisters are much better looking. I'd like to believe they have more acting potential, too.
Isn't the one on the left a Peldon?
THEY DO LOOK LIKE HAYLIE AND HILARY.
Whatever..like them two could ever replace the gorgeous Duff sisters
isnt ashley tisdale like 25 years old? that cunt is OLD shes not hailey duff shes definately not hilary duff SHE BEA ARTHUR. that old CUNT
ashley is hilary and jennifer is haylie! i like this duo of sisters better than hilary and haylie. haylie is fug, i think hilarys' career wouldn't of slowed down if she didnt make that ridiculous movie 'material girls' with her. the olsens are a good duo too! but i think the fact that they have chosen to work separately is a wise career move, twins working together over 20? i think not.
ASHLEY IS HILARY DUUUUUU
ASHLEY IS HILARY DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
It looks like Ashley got a boob job I guess she must have finally gotten tired of wearing bigger bra sizes to make her nipples look bigger I, I mean boobs.. lol!
i call that a definite nose job
Ashley isn't perfect but she's attractive, she's got that sumthin' sumthin' about her. Sister is bland, this is a rare instance where her sister looks almost as cute as her, usually she looks blah.
Ashley always has the Haylie (nose-nosenose) vibe. really.
first off, stfu perez, do not compare hil to these fugs!!
and second, what's up with their noses?!
first off, stfu perez, do not compare hil to these fugs!!
and second, what's up with their noses?!
Ashley is pretty freakin good in HS and in whateva she does . I dont know nething bout her sis. shes cute though. HSM on Ice was rele good. I saw the show with my 6 yr old daughter in SUNRISE FLORIDA. My daughter loved it. It was pretty entertaining for me as well. So many people out there r haters man lay back. There just friggin kids
ash is cuter than hil, hil's got a pinhead forehead.
I think that they are both cute girls. There is no Haylie. Come on, they are teenage girls. Let's not tear them apart!
ashley is hott the other it NOT
i am drunk
Jennifer is the ugly one so she's haylie.
not to mention loads more talented, i saw bits of HS Musical with my nieces and this girl can sing, dance, and act…hil can't do none of the above…when in the world did people start regarding hil as beautiful or talented anyways?
well, ashley is legitimately talented, which neither hil nor haylee are… so i'm going to have to go with her being neither.
ACTUALLY, THEY REMIND ME OF LC AND HEIDI…NOT SISTERS BUT YOU KNOW….LOOKS LIKE HEIDI W/ LC'S HAIR AND LC WITH HEIDI'S HAIR
The one on right actually looks like Haylie.
They're really cute and stylish!
Without knowing who they are, the one on the left looks very much like an Ashley type of a woman, while the one on the right looks very Jennifery.
The right one must be Hillary.
Ashley looks really pretty, thank god she ditched those horrible blonde hair extensions!!!
Thats just a bad photo of ashley, she genereally looks really pretty and yes her nose is REAL!!!!!! im glad she didnt get a nose job for that…shows what a true role model really is!!
Ashley could be compared to hilary on account of fame and haylie could be compared to jennifer.
oh shit. that's insane.
Hilary is the best! she's beautiful and talented ! and she's 19 !! ashley is 22 !!! Hilary is a star of the future! but ashley is a stupid and not talented girl! she's horrible girl! …Who is Jennifer ?!?!? xD
Hilary is perfect!!!! ashley likes a horse!!!!
Jennifer is Haylie cuz like Haylie she too needs a nose job. Ashley is a babe.
there can be NO comparison between them and hil&haylie..I love the duffs!
both haylie
Looks aside… Ashley has 2 huge movies, TV show, and an album under her belt! No contest!
they're both Haylies, the ugly sister
With that terrible shnoz and terrible dancing/singing/acting skills? Clearly, Ashley is the Haylie. Make NO mistake!
ashley is hilary
SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS ARE SHIT SPICS STINK!!
atleast jennifer isnt ugly like haylie! ash and jenn are the better pair!
Ashley is hilary, obviously, who has the bigger career? I've never even heard of jennifer.
Ashley looks like Haylie because her sister is wayy prettier! They both share that quality. HAHA!
They are both from my hometown of OT and they are so lame! Jen is riding her sisters coat-tails hardcore! Get your own career! Your in the backround of hsm2 and her new video… get a life Jen!
clearly ashley is hilary because she's more famous.
clearly ashley is hilary because she's more famous.
which ones Ashley? Im so old yalls.
i love ashley tisdale! i love her new Cd; Headstrong and i LOVE highschool musical 1 and 2 cant wait for number 3 hitting THEATRES next summer
.. and i like the suite life of zack and coddyy 
i dont think they look like either hilary or haylie, i think they're their own persons, let hilary and haylie be who they are and let ashley & jennifer be who they are, and btw they are not ugly! whoever writes that they are ugly must be ugly themselves! your just jealous cause they're famous and your a low life loser!
I wanna have a sexy ass orgy with Jennifer, Ashley & Haylie. Hilary can stay home. Those other three snowflakes are some some sexy motherfuckas…
Ashley has to be Hilary, because I've actually heard of her. =]
I'm trying to forget what they're wearing, but I just can't. It's burning my eyes!
ashleys hilary duhh. and did she like get a nose job?
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
the big one needs to whiten it's teeth
the little one is ugly as FUCK!
parts of her face are pointing in different directions!!!!!!!!!!!
_|_³³
What the hell are they wearing? It's looks like Ashley's wearing a dolls dress and put a vest over it… they're both ugly sluts if you ask me. Since when are they famous? Who fuckin CARES???
even though i hate them
people stop callin them little girls ashley is at least 23 now and her sister is older than her
ashley is hilary and the not so famous anther is haylie
Manufactured mall look: Plastic, plastic, plastic!!!!!!!!! They are essentially young woman who look older than their years: Plastic surgery-look at Ashley's nose, nose job!!!!!!!! Her honker was twice as big on The suite life of Zach and Cody, comparable to Ashlee Simpson's honker before the big nose bob. Less is best in the makeup and fashion - what they are wearing, that is fashion???????? It seems these days the pushers of consumerism toward young people are overtly sexualizing them - midriffs, belly rings, tight pants and makeup on a twelve year old??????? I have seen it and as a Mother, it is totally inappropriate. The J. Crew and Polo look: great clothes and fresh faces: not globs of makeup - now that is appropriate.
Ashley Tisdale has one of the most annoying faces I've ever seen.
Ashley is soo hilary, and jen is sooo haylie! it looks like jen is the older, loser, wanna be actor sister who cant get jobs without her younger more successful sister.
I think the Duff sisters are better
but Ashley=Hilary
Jennifer-Haylie most def
ashley is hilary because shes prettier..and everyone knows that haylie is the ugly bitch.
in order to be like the Duff sisters they have to be nice.. the Duff sisters are nice, smart & beautiful…and did we say have amazing carreers!
Re: Oceantownshit Highschool Student – I love that storyfrom our school! its one of my favorites! see ya at the reunion~!
omg!! cinderella's step sisters!! wow!!
p.s. i don't think being on 7th Heaven is a glorifying career moment and dating a 27 yearl old that dumps you for nicole rithchie makes u smart. and beautiful??!…….fill in the blank yourself____________________________!!!
EW THOSE TEETH!!!
It's Phoebe from Friends!
ashley is def. haylie because she is prettier :]
Ashley is Hilary, and Jennifer is Haylie. Although neither looks like a fug tranny so maybe they are both Hilary.
why is the ugly one famous?(ashley) and her sis is way hotter than her, with the Duff sisters that's not the case, the hotter one (hilary) is the famous…
Who the fuck are these two and why do we care???????
Re: EJROCKSU – YOU WRONG ASHLEY IS HILARY N SHE DOESNT LOOK LIKE A DOG >=( MAYBE YOUR MOMMY DOES!
jennifer is a media WHORE!!! she needs to stay out of ashleys spotlight!! lol she cant act or sing… she might as well throw in the towel!! =/
Re: What is with you haters? – Ok so Jen..dont pretend to be a fan sticking up for you guys. i am from ocean and can see right through you!! Get your own career!
ashley is haley because they both have big noses…and her sister is not hillary because hillary is way cuter and neither of these girls have any talent so who the fuck cares
They're just as fug as the Duff sisters.
They are fabulous!!!
Re: b – That is sooo funny!!! That's the exact first thought that I had when looking at this picture…. I was just scrolling down the comments to see if anyone else thought the same thing…. Ash should quit being so greedy will all that Disney money and get her sis to the dentist for some whitening…. Hell, she'll never make it big in Hollywood with yellow teeth like that… ha ha ha!!!!! And she's just smilin' for the camera like she has no clue… do you think she has a mirror???? Too funny… i needed a laugh today!!
Re: D Alexander –
no she wanna be jessica simpson
shes her idol
Lose Weight Now
Look at my space dzarbonne to learn more.
Re: kelly – Ashley is not a kid… hasn't been for many years since she is 23 years old. She may be successful on Disney and appeal to very young children, but the girl does not have enough talent to make it anywhere but there. Hilary Duff is the same… she was very popular with the little girls when she was on Disney. Since leaving her show and Disney, she has struggled to make it big. Sure, she's made a few movies and a few CD's, but none of them have been big hits… just mediocre. They each have the talent that only children can appreciate.
Ashley is Hilary
Jennifer is Haylie
Ashley and Hilary Rocks!