Considering the starlet is one of E!'s main moneymakers, it almost seems like choice has been made!
BUT there's one other star who would like to join the contenders…
Emmy Rossum jetted to Mexico for the Beautiful Creatures premiere on Monday and she looked ravishing!
The actress posed with her co-stars on the black carpet in a red chiffon pleated Zuhair Murad dress that was accented with a gold belt to give her slim figure an exaggerated hourglass shape.
Nude snakeskin pumps, Katerina Maxine jewelry and fancy up-do completed her fiery Mexico City ensemble.
It's definitely a seductive look, but we can't say it's out favorite Emmy outfit of all time.
What about U???
[Image via AP Images.]