They fooled us all!
And it seems that they had a little secret they were keeping from everyone.
Baby Winnie was born via surrogate!
"My wife and I had been trying for a while to have a baby. We tried a bunch of things. So we had a surrogate. This time we just said we're not going to tell anybody. It'd be just more fun, just private between me and wife. When it happened we were shocked. … Who are we going to tell? Who's going to be mad at us? It's so emotional."
Hear Jimmy reveal some of the details himself (below) and share his excitement with his new bundle of joy!