After she couldn't make a decision between the contestant who had been in the bottom two three weeks in a row and Rachel, she left it up to America decide.
Surely, SURELY, she figured America's votes would send Marcus home but this was just a way to let him go without her having to be the bad guy.
But instead, Rachel ended up being the one to get the boot. And it was DEVASTATING!
The audience boo'd, audiences at home tweeted in fury… it's just been on big sh*tstorm! But she doesn't regret any of it, saying: